#nunmarie

[kmclaude]

Loving the AU where Annemarie is sent to wayward home and Fr.Tiefer meeting her again to "catch up" by repaying her the abuse she gave him. He doesn't believe this reform bit for one second, especially when he sees Ann teaching the children.

He remembers how well she would act the doting over worked older sister having to raise him in public, but out of sight she'd beat him or throw an empty whiskey bottle at him every time his crying got on her nerves. Until he catches sight of Ann alone with one of the kids when she thinks no one's around and she's actually sweet and nurturing. She's not yelling or smacking the brat when they're crying and clinging to her, she's actually comforting them, no inappropriate touching or anything either. Tiefer is shocked and furious. This can't be his sister, she's not a nurturing person! She can't be because if she was actually capable of it...if she could have really become patient and sweet with these kids why couldn't she have been like that with him? Next time he's alone with Annemarie he mocks and questions her about her being forced to take care of a bunch of bastard kids, and there's just something about his tone and expression that just chills Annemarie. He thinks he's right when he sees his sister genuinely scared, she really hasn't changed at all, until she starts pleading with him not to hurt any of the kids just to get back at her, she admits she deserves everything for what she did to Tiefer and she means it, for once in her miserable life Annemarie is actually worried about someone other than herself.

And Tiefer just snaps and he's extra vicious with Annemarie. He even accusing her of being a liar while he's fucking her ass so violently his cock is now slick with blood? Why she's acting like she cares about some snot nose brats?! Like she gave a damn about him when her boyfriends or their dad hurt and fucked him! Like she didn't do those same things to him! Maybe he's even crying afterwards while he's still buried inside of her asking why was she never that kind and sweet with him when he was little and needed her?

exquisite transcendent effervescent ~

and you know she doesn't have an answer -- not a satisfactory one, at least, not a single one that doesn't leave her hands clean -- and silence in the face of that question is just as damning, just as cutting.

"they're just kids..." she begs and tiefer has to laugh to keep from sobbing because she's still on about that -- she really doesn't care for him, she can't even face him, won't even look at him (and sure, he's had her face down on a work bench in an unused shed, splinters digging in her cheek, but she could at least try!), the awful realization settling in his chest that she could've cared, she could've, but apparently not for him.

"i was just a kid!"

"i know." and it's not cruel. it's not even sad. it's lifeless, a simple fact. "so was i."

later -- and maybe he helps clean her up, a rare gentleness (or possessiveness, an ownership, she's his), or maybe he chucks a damp cloth at her feet and tells her she reeks -- he asks whatever happened to...

and annemarie says he passed. premature. and there's something of a shakiness in her voice.

and neither of them can say their child. neither of them can bear the weight.

("i can make it up to you," she'd said, frantic, the way his tone twisted talking about the kid he'd found her with, sounding a little too like their daddy, "i can be sweet, i can be gentle, please, please, let me take care of you, just leave them out of it. they're just kids." and that fucking did it because so was he. so was she.)

[kmclaude]

OMG so you know how you said tiefer could put something else in annemarie's other hole while he fucks her ass... What if he shoves her prayer beads in there. And he slowly pulls them out one at a time... Or puts them in one at a time... And then at some point Yanks all of them out when he cums inside her ass and she's a squirting mess....

Anon you genius

You know, some orders have extra large rosaries--like fit in your palm beads--too...

And you know he can't help but comment on how easy they slip inside her, can't blame how loose she is all on the baby, what a little whore she is, and Annemarie is so quick to point out he'd know all about being a whore, probably only gets halfway through a nasty jab about at least one of his gang-rapes before she's paying for her prideful little mouth.

[kmclaude]

Both of them in their religious clothing, Tiefer pushing his sister's skirts up and bending her over like "we can't have you getting knocked up again, Sister" and screwing her ass (literally) raw, Annemarie sobbing and trying to be proud, demanding with a haughty little sniff once he's spilled inside of her and tugged her panties back up (just so she could feel him leaking out of her and into the cloth) that he should at least help her finish up too, its the least he could do... And Tiefer just laughs and tells her she'll have to earn it.

(And earning it means a lot of debasing herself for his kicks.)

I should continue the AU where Annemarie was sent to a wayward girls home/asylum and joined the nunnery solely because the thought of her baby brother Fr. Tiefer abusing her (yes in that way) in her novitiate habit is uhhhhhh hot

[kmclaude]

AND ADD TO IT you know some of the sisters comment on how often it seems Fr. Tiefer and her are together in private and it's no secret he's an attractive man even a blind woman could see that and given Annemarie's history rumors start flying until the Mother Superior takes him aside and Tiefer laughs, says he's so sorry for the trouble her wayward novitiate caused, but you see she's his sister, literally, he would never. He hadn't seen her since the pregnancy and, well, he missed her dearly...

And all is smoothed over and rumors stop but the next time the siblings are alone Tiefer is sure to make sure Annemarie is sorry for being such a slut that all the sisters start gossiping -- they're siblings, what sort of freak would sleep with their own sibling?

(He makes her say how much she loves her brother's cock inside her ass, how much she wants her brother to come in her, and absolutely mocks her for it and worst part is its not a lie)

I should continue the AU where Annemarie was sent to a wayward girls home/asylum and joined the nunnery solely because the thought of her baby brother Fr. Tiefer abusing her (yes in that way) in her novitiate habit is uhhhhhh hot