#newsies john tucker must die au

[1899-newsboy-strike]

Jack Kelly Must Die Pt. 3

part one part two

Requested: Jack Kelly must die part three

Warnings: none?

Summary: You may have regretted agreeing to Katherine’s plan, but now it was starting to look like the best decision you’d ever made.

———————————–

“Do you really feel that way?” Jack asked, still staring at you. “Yeah.” You admitted shyly, nodding your head. “Can I come in?” He asked, looking down at his feet. “Um… sure.” You said still trying to wrap your head around the fact that he was standing right in front of you. He silently walked in, closing the door behind him before awkwardly sitting down on your couch waiting for you. “Do you… want anything to drink?” You asked, your heart racing at the thought of sitting next to him. “No thank you.” He whispered shaking his head slightly.

When you sat down there was a tug on your heart, and you hoped that maybe this would work out after all. You didn’t really want to get your hopes up, the other part of you thinking he was there to talk it over to get closure. “Jack look. Before you say anything.” You started turning to face him. “I know I already said this in all of my voicemails, but I really did care for you. I don’t know why I ever said yes to Katherine about doing it. Maybe I just really wanted to have friends and also she could just be… convincing and intimidating?” You explained shaking your head earning a scoff from Jack. “Tell me about it.” He muttered to himself.

“That’s besides the point. She really painted you out to be some type of bad guy, but when I saw that you weren’t everything changed. You were really nice to me and you made me feel happy. I’ve never gotten attention from a guy like that before and I started to like you.” You explained, Jack staring intently at you to make sure he heard everything you said. “When I told you I thought I liked you that was the truth. Then you kissed me and it all felt right. I mean you were my first kiss and I wouldn’t have let that happen if I didn’t like you.” You explained earning a confused look from him. “I was your first kiss?” He asked, and you blushed nodding slightly.

“I’ve never felt so close to someone and never felt comfortable around them, but you make me feel different Jack. I’ve never felt like someone ever truly cared about me the way that you did, and I never expected to like you as much as I did… or still do… I’m really sorry that I had to ruin that and that I didn’t tell you about Katherine’s stupid plan when I should’ve just been honest with you, especially when you were honest with me.” You explained making Jack smiled slightly. “I still like you too.” He smiled his hand coming up to caress your cheek.

You couldn’t stop your eyes from fluttering closed. You had missed the feeling of Jack’s hands on you or wrapped around you in an embrace. When you opened your eyes you let out a small gasp, Jack’s face mere inches from yours. “Maybe we could start over?” He whispered, earning a small nod from you. “I’d like that.” You whispered softly, your eyes flickering to his lips then back up. You both started to lean in, your lips meeting in the middle. Your arms wrapped around Jack’s neck and his wrapped around your waist. There was no stopping the smile that was on your face, you didn’t expect to ever talk to Jack again, but here you both were kissing on your couch.

[1899-newsboy-strike]

Jack Kelly Must Die Pt. 1

part two part three 

Requested: Have you seen “John Tucker must die”? I have a suggestion for a fic inspired by it. You don’t need to see the movie, I’ll explain the req; So Jack is an ultimate playboy and a couple of his exes wants revenge. They take this new girl (reader) and transform her to fit all Jack’s standards so that once he falls in love with her, she can dump him and thereby teach him a lesson. But Reader end up falling for Jack too. However will it end? :0 You decide!

Warnings: none?

Summary: You couldn’t remember what made you say yes to these girls. Maybe it was because they were pretty convincing in the stories about Jack. You didn’t expect the outcome of what you had gotten yourself into.

———————————–

You’d only been at your new school for two weeks, trying to get adjusted, you kept to yourself watching everyone at your school trying to figure out who you’d be great friends with. It was no secret that Jack Kelly was the most popular guy at your school. You’d come across him in the hall, not taking much notice of the boy, but apparently he’d taken notice of you, or so you were currently being told. Now was one of the moments you regretted ever letting a noise leave your body.

You were trying to mind your own business, but the girls sitting next to you forgot whispering was a thing. “I can’t believe Jack really cheated on all of us with each other.” Katherine had groaned, and you had accidentally let the scoff leave your lips before realizing. You immediately regretted it when you felt the multiple pairs of eyes on you. “Sorry.” You apologized, looking away, but your heart began to race when their chairs scraped on the ground and they all sat around the table you were sitting at.

“Your name is Y/N right?” Sarah asked when your eyes landed on her. You gave a small nod, looking at the other girl that you couldn’t remember the name of. “Do you like Kelly, Y/N?” Katherine asked, and this time you were able to hold back the laugh. “I know he’s ‘popular’ but I don’t even know him.” You explained making Katherine laugh. “He always looks at you whenever I see both of you in the hall. I wouldn’t be surprised if he wants to be able to say he’s been with every girl in school.” Katherine explained, sarcasm dripping with every word, but that’s when a lightbulb seemed to go off above her head.

She only had to start explaining her plan for the other girl to leave because she wanted nothing to do with it. “Fake date him? How would that even work?” You asked, your eyebrows knitted together. “We’ll both help you through it. Jack isn’t picky apparently.” Sarah explained making you look at your hands trying to think about it. “Come on, do you want him to keep doing this to other girls? With our help Jack will finally feel so heartbroken he probably won’t date another girl ever again.” Katherine laughed making your face turn red. “I don’t know about going that far, but I guess I could help you.” You explained under the intimidating stare of Katherine.

Katherine and Sarah gave tips nonstop, your phone being filled with message after message from them about pointers for what Jack liked. You knew you were in too deep when Katherine shoved clothes in your grip pushing you toward the restroom so you could change. You were completely surprised that not even an hour later Jack had walked up to you to talk. “Hey, you look really beautiful.” He smiled down at you, your face immediately heating up. “Thanks, I guess.” You whispered looking down at your feet. “Hey, no need to be shy sweetheart.” He explained, grabbing your chin making you look back up to look at him.

You wouldn’t have guessed he was this captivating, but now you could see how he had gotten most of the girls in the school to be with him. “Are you free sometime?” He asked, making you snap out of it. “Yeah, definitely.” You smiled up at him, trying to keep your cool. “I’ll text you sometime.” He winked at you after putting his phone number in your phone, walking away. “That was quicker than I thought.” Katherine explained popping up behind you making you jump. “Is that a bad thing?” You asked, Sarah shaking her head from next to Katherine. “Just surprising, but it’s probably going to be that much easier for this to work.” She explained, a smirk forming on her face.

It was the day of your first ‘date’ and you couldn’t have been more nervous. You were terrified that you were going to mess this all up, especially since you knew both Katherine and Sarah would be lingering around somewhere watching the both of you. You were trying to calm your nerves, remembering it wasn’t a real date. You slipped into a shirt and a short skirt that Katherine gave you, wishing the skirt would have been just a bit longer but that’s what she insisted you wore. When the doorbell rang, your heartbeat picked up, all the nerves you tried to push away coming back all at once. 

When you opened the door Jack was patiently waiting, rocking back and forth with his hands in his pocket bored until you had opened the door. “Y/N hey, you look amazing.” He smiled, looking you up and down. “Thanks.” You whispered, tucking a piece of hair behind your ear looking at your feet. You were completely forgetting everything Katherine and Sarah told you about being confident, Jack leaving you flustered with attention you’d never received before. You couldn't help how shy you got when Jack wrapped his arm around your waist, opening the car door for you to get in. You almost couldn’t believe all the stories Katherine had told you about how Jack acted on dates. 

“How are you liking it here?” Jack asked once the waiter brought you both your drinks. “It’s fine… different.” You shrugged. “Have you lived here all your life?” You asked awkwardly shifting in your seat not having a clue of what to talk about. “Yeah, maybe I can give you a tour sometime, show you all the good hang outs.” Jack winked, his hand going to cover your own but you quickly pulled it away hoping picking up your drink would be a good excuse for pulling your hand away. You both started to get to know one another, when your phone started to buzz like crazy in your pocket. ‘Restroom now - Katherine’ was all you saw making you sigh before you excused yourself.

“Stop acting so shy! You’re going to make him think you aren’t into him. Calm down.” Katherine explained, her hands on your shoulders. “I’m sorry, I’m not used to this.” You explained tugging down at the skirt you were wearing. “Maybe he’s acted the way he has because he’s never been with anyone shy.” Sarah explained making both of you look at her. “Just open up a bit more, maybe if he gets what he feels is a real connection it’ll make him feel even worse once this is over.” She explained making Katherine smile at the thought. “Go out there, by shy I guess, but not too shy.” She pointed at you in an intimidating way before giving you a small shove out the restroom door.

The rest of the date you had tried to act more comfortable, finally letting Jack’s hand cover your own. Most of the night, butterflies filled your stomach, you were trying to remember that this wasn’t real. Jack walked you back to the car, his arm once again finding its way around your waist. The car ride was somewhat silent, most of the ride was spent playing with your thumbs or continuing to tell Jack about yourself when he asked questions. It was when you were about a few blocks away when you both stuck up a conversation.

“Beach or movies?” He asked making you look over at him. “Movies I guess… why?” You asked. “Trying to think about our next date. Unless you don’t want one?” He asked taking his eyes off the road for a few seconds to glance at you. “I’d love to. The movies sounds great.” You smiled softly to him. “Movies it is.” Jack nodded, already trying to think of the movies that were out at the moment. “We don’t have to go to the movies just because I said movies though, we can go to the beach if you want.” You explained but Jack shook his head. “Wouldn’t have asked if I wanted to pick.” He said pulling up to your house.

“Thanks.” You blushed when he helped you out of the car grabbing your hand to walk you to your front door. “I had fun, I’ll text you later about the movies.” Jack explained leaning down to kiss you but you pulled away. “I- um... it’s only the first date.” You explained completely flustered looking up at him. “Sorry, I’m getting ahead of myself.” He laughed softly. “Good night Y/N.” He smiled down at you kissing your cheek softly before making his way back to his car. When you walked into your house, leaning back against your door. You couldn’t believe you were helping Katherine and Sarah with their plan, but part of you was overly excited about getting to spend more time with Jack.

[1899-newsboy-strike]

Jack Kelly Must Die Pt. 2

part one part three 

Requested (continued): Have you seen “John Tucker must die”? I have a suggestion for a fic inspired by it. You don’t need to see the movie, I’ll explain the req; So Jack is an ultimate playboy and a couple of his exes wants revenge. They take this new girl (reader) and transform her to fit all Jack’s standards so that once he falls in love with her, she can dump him and thereby teach him a lesson. But Reader end up falling for Jack too. However will it end? :0 You decide! 

Warnings: none? angst?

Summary: You were never supposed to get feelings for Jack, but you couldn’t help but fall for him. You couldn’t stand lying to him, but you feared what might happen once he found the truth. What was worse was the thought of Katherine and Sarah finding out about your feelings for him.

———————————–

You were sat in your room, Katherine and Sarah both gawking at the story you told them about your date with Jack. “He never held the door open for me.” Katherine grumbled, Sarah agreeing from next to her. “He doesn’t seem that bad. He was really sweet throughout the whole date.” You explained making them laugh. “Aside from holding the door open for you don’t let that change your mind about him. The first date with him was pretty great, but wait for the next one I guarantee you he’ll try to get in your pants by the end of the night.” Katherine explained making you sigh.

“Don’t worry he won’t force you to do anything you don’t want to do. Just do what you did last time. This will be over before you know it, it’s going to be so much fun to see him heartbroken for once.” Katherine explained after seeing the concerned look on your face about her comment. “I wouldn’t go that far. We just want him to feel some of what we felt.” Sarah explained, and you couldn’t help but feel closer to Sarah than Katherine, but that didn’t mean that you agreed with what you were doing. You were starting to feel like you shouldn’t have agreed to this, but you were in too deep to get out now.

Jack was always around you at school, talking to you whenever he saw you walking in the hall. No matter how much you tried to convince yourself the feelings you felt toward him were just a ploy, there was a part of you that knew that wasn't true. “Guess who?” Someone whispered in your ear once their hands covered your eyes. “Hey Jack.” You laughed pulling his hands away from your eyes. “Are you free today after school? We can finally go catch a movie.” He explained, the smile on his face causing butterflies to erupt in your stomach. “Yeah, I’m free. I’ll meet you after the final bell.” You explained, your heart fluttering when he kissed your cheek. “See you then.” He said giving you a quick side hug.

When you were waiting in the front of the school, an arm wrapped around your shoulder making you jump. “Sorry, didn’t mean to scare you.” Jack laughed making you give him a small shove. “A warning would be nice.” You laughed along with him, your fingers intertwining with the hand that was draped over your shoulder, both of you walking in the direction of his car. “What movie are we going to see?” You asked, looking up at him. “We’ll see when we get there.” He kissed your forehead, only making you even more confused. You knew he did bad things, but the way he’d always acted with you contradicted everything Katherine and Sarah told you.

You both walked to your seats once you bought your tickets, both of you deciding that you didn’t want any snacks or drinks. Throughout the movie you were both intently watching, or at least you thought Jack had been watching the movie. He’d been staring at you for a while, and you hadn’t noticed. His hand slipped in yours and you glanced up at him, smiling before leaning against him. He let go of your hand, his arm wrapping around you to your hands reconnecting on your lap. “Y/N.” Jack whispered making you look back up at him. “Yeah?” You whispered back sitting up to hear him better. 

“I really like you.” He admitted making your heart clench at his words. “I think I really like you too.” You confessed, not only to him but to yourself making your eyes widen at the realization. Before you could think about it any further, Jack’s lips met yours. A small gasp left you, it wasn’t just your first kiss with Jack, but your first kiss. You couldn’t ignore the whole feeling you felt with Jack’s lips against yours. His hand came up to hold your face, deepening the kiss earning a content sigh from you. 

The rest of the movie, you couldn’t get your heart rate to slow down. You had a warm fuzzy feeling in you, your head resting on Jack’s chest, his head resting upon your own. The more he acted this way with you the more you forgot the whole reason behind why this had started. Jack wasn’t the person he was made out to be, and you were starting to see that. He was rubbing small circles in your arm, finally starting to enjoy the movie with you in his arms. You couldn’t help but snuggle up into him, feeling comfortable in his embrace.

You were walking hand in hand with Jack, one of you swinging your arms slightly. You both walked into a coffee shop, getting coffee as well as a pastry, both of you sitting near the back to be by yourselves. “Y/N, I’ve never really done this before. I don’t know if you’ve heard what some of the girls say about me at school. They’re all true. I used to be horrible, but before I even asked you out I would see you and hear about you. I’ve never felt this way with anyone before, and I just wanted to know if you wanted to be my girlfriend?” He asked, looking down at his hands the whole time. “I’ve never done this either, and I mean the whole boyfriend thing not what you said. Your past doesn’t define you Jack, especially when you’re trying to change and get better. I would love to be your girlfriend.” You smiled softly, holding his hand giving it a comforting squeeze.

“He asked you to be his girlfriend?” Sarah asked completely shocked at the news. “This is going to be fun! He’s whipped.” Katherine laughed, making your smile drop. “I’m not going to do that anymore. He isn’t who you say he is. He’s a person, and playing with his feelings isn’t going to undo what he did to you. He’s trying to change.” You explained earning a scoff from Katherine. “He just wants you to think he’s changed. He probably told you that in case you hadn’t heard anything bad about him yet.” She explained, only making you feel more frustrated with her. 

“I know he hurt you, and so many other girls at the school, but that doesn’t mean he’ll never change. He’s acted completely different from what you’ve told me and I mean completely different. You may want to get back at him, but it won’t change anything.” You explained making her glare at you. “He has you wrapped around his finger Y/N, and when he hurts you I won’t be around to help you through it when I’ve warned you multiple times.” She explained, storming out of your house. 

“She’s just mad that Jack’s acting different than she wanted him to. I wouldn’t worry about it, he sounds like he’s great. I hope you both will be happy, I’m really sorry we both dragged you into this.” Sarah apologized making you wave her off. “Hey.” You called out to her when she headed toward the door. “We’ll still be friends right?” You asked earning a smile from her. “Of course. Just because our friendship started off because of Katherine’s plan doesn’t mean that it has to end because the plan is over.” She explained with a small nod from her before she left.

You hadn’t talked to Katherine ever since she left your house a week ago, and just assumed that she had put the whole situation behind her. You were minding your own business near your locker, Jack leaning against the lockers near yours. “Are you almost done?” He whined, making you laugh. “Yes, almost.” You smiled going on your tippy toes to give him a small kiss. “Hey Jack.” You heard from behind you making you turn around to see Katherine. You were immediately on edge, your heart beginning to race.

“So I heard you guys got together. Did you tell him?” She asked you, earning a confused glance from Jack. “What is she talking about Y/N?” Jack asked making you shake your head at Katherine. “Your whole relationship was a lie. The only reason she ever dated you was because she was helping me and Sarah get revenge for what you did to us.” Katherine explained making tears blur your vision. You glanced over to Jack, a complete shocked look on his face. “Is that true?” He asked, sounding distraught. “Maybe it was originally, but I never meant to hurt you once I got to know you.” You explained, your voice cracking trying not to cry. 

“Well I guess it’s too late about hurting me.” Jack explained before walking away without another word. “Are you really that self centered that you have to get your way? Grow up Katherine.” You sniffed wiping the tears that began to fall down your face walking away. You left Jack countless voicemails on his phone explaining everything. You knew this would come back to haunt you, but you pushed it to the back of your head. You knew you shouldn’t have been as upset, knowing it was your fault that you ever agreed to this in the first place.

You still continued leaving messages, letting Jack know how you truly felt. You missed him, the way he talked to you everyday when you walked in the hall. Now you just awkwardly looked at each other in the hall anytime you passed by each other. Whether he counted the relationship as fake or real, it was real to you. Your feelings had been real ever since the beginning, and Jack had been your first kiss and you couldn’t take that back, refusing to call it fake. You had been moping around your house thinking about calling Jack again, when the doorbell rang. You groaned standing up to reluctantly answer the door. When you opened the door you stopped dead in your tracks when you saw Jack standing in front of you. “I listened to your voicemails.” He explained softly.