#natiannera

[cupidhaos]

Hi, ‘tis I, ya girl who thinks too much. Back with two theories! Okay, so I’m pretty sure both of them have holes in them, and I might’ve gotten the timeline wrong. Sorry about that. It was around 5 in the morning when I finished writing these, so they aren’t my best pieces. (Also, the layout is really bad, I know. I’m sorry.) Anyways. The first one is 1'163 words long, the second is 569 word long. So like last time get something to drink, get comfy, and most importantly: enjoy. 💜

Picture this: Senior year of Highschool. Y/N thinks Joshua doesn’t return her feelings, and instead of facing him, she just leaves for Japan, cutting everyone off she knew from Korea. Left behind are Chae, Joshua… and another friend. Let’s call her S. S was very attached to Y/N. Maybe S was a bit of a loner, or maybe S just liked Y/N a lot. It was more one-sided; S saw Y/N as her best friend, while Y/N saw Chae as her best friend and thought of S as just a regular friend. Someone she’d eat lunch with, have some classes with, sometimes hang out together with, but not much more. Either way, Y/N doesn’t think twice about leaving S behind, with no real explanation of why she left. She doesn’t even tell S she’s leaving herself, S finds out through other means. Maybe through social media, maybe through Chaeyoung, whom she met once or twice through Y/N. S doesn’t handle being abandoned like that well at all. She thought her and Y/N were great friends, best friends even! They knew each other since Kindergarten! Why did Y/N just abandon her like that?! Did their friendship mean nothing to Y/N? Did she care so little for S? Or maybe S did something wrong? Was S not a good friend? It drives S insane. And with the months passing, she goes from yearning for Y/N to hating Y/N. (When Y/N tries to reach out to her again close to her return to Korea, S ignores her. Y/N made it clear that she didn’t really care for her, so why should she bother with her again?) S enrolls in Pledis Uni, and because she’s lonely, becomes one of SVT’s clients. And here they are, 6 handsome men, caring for her, making her feel happy and appreciated. Their nice words and compliments charm her completely, and she quickly becomes attached to them. But then there’s Chaeyoung, getting along with all of them so well – especially Jeonghan, of whom S has grown extremely fond. She tries to figure out a way to separate Chaeyoung from SVT, and learns that Chae’s Dad is part of the schoolboard. And because Y/N, Chae and S probably hung out at one point together, she also knows Chae’s father can be a bit… controlling. Pair that with the fact that the school most likely would not want to lose a club which rakes in a lot of profit, she has the perfect plan. So, she complains to the schoolboard, making them aware of the fact that their profitable club could plummet if the members don’t stay focused on their ‘duty’, and simultaneously making Chaeyoung’s father aware that his daughter is spending a lot of time with Jeonghan. She’s mostly successful; SVT avoids Chaeyoung like the plague as soon as school starts again. Sure, Joshua leaves SVT for Chaeyoung, and S is incredibly angry, but she doesn’t have a way to force him back into SVT. Besides, she still has 5 of them left, and most importantly, still has Jeonghan. Everything is fine for a while. Then, Y/N returns. And at first, it’s… okay. Y/N probably won’t get close to SVT because she’s friends with Chaeyoung, so S doesn’t have to worry about that. S tries not to think too much of Y/N and her betrayal. But then, Y/N starts to get involved with SVT. Y/N starts to get closer to SVT. And S can’t have that. She can’t have Y/N take SVT away from her, can’t let her take away the only thing that makes her happy. She must separate her from SVT as well, preferably her AND Chaeyoung, who is close to SVT once again. But S knows she can’t complain to the schoolboard again, that didn’t work good enough. So, she keeps an eye on Y/N, trying to get any dirt on her. And just like called, Yuta shows up. S knows he holds a grudge against Y/N, and starts to talk to him, coaxing him into helping her. Together, they plan on bringing Y/N down, to get revenge on her. At first, they didn’t really know how to. They could release all the private pictures Yuta still has of her, but that would most likely get them into more trouble than it would hurt Y/N, even if S could hack the tea page to make it look like it was them (maybe she’s a computer science major, maybe she just takes a lot of computer science courses because she’s interested). Then, the whole confrontation happens by ‘accident’. (Okay, Yuta was stalking Y/N, and couldn’t control himself when he thought he saw a chance to humiliate Y/N. He wasn’t aware Wonwoo and Seungcheol knew each other. He doesn’t care about SVT.) And soon after, Y/N is nowhere to be found. It doesn’t take a lot to find out what is happening – the tea page posted that Y/N was on her way to Busan after all, and S knows Y/N has a tendency to run away. So, S sends them messages asking for information. They’re a tea page, she doesn’t expect them to have morals. When they don’t provide, S is forced to take a different route to get the information she wants. Once she knows that Y/N will leave for the summer, she sees the perfect opportunity to strike. So, Yuta and her devise a plan. They need to cause Y/N to not be reachable, either through stealing her phone or through causing the phone to be destroyed. Yuta follows them to Thailand, trying to somehow get to Y/N’s phone, but Seungkwan and Chaeyoung never leave Y/N’s side, making it impossible for him to get close to her. Turns out he doesn’t have to, because Y/N drops her phone into a river in Thailand on her own. Recognizing this as the perfect time to strike, Yuta texts S, and S hacks the tea page, posting the thread. Earlier, they also enlisted the help of someone else (Sohee – the sister/cousin/close friend of Sohye attending another Uni, who’s equally angry with Y/N for taking Wonwoo away from Sohye), since she knows none of SVT would take her word. They would write her off as a jealous client. But the words of someone they don’t know and who claims to be Y/N’s best friend? They’ll swallow that. And much to S’s delight, Chaeyoung and Seungkwan unintentionally help her! By preventing Y/N from getting a new phone, they make it so much easier for S, Yuta and Sohee. That, and the fact that S is preventing any messages from SVT to reach Chaeyoung and Seungkwan (except for Jihoon, since she knows that would make Chaeyoung suspicious, and she never really liked Jihoon anyway). SVT swallows everything Sohee tells them, as does a large populous of the school. S will stay in the background, pulling the strings from there. Those computer science courses now really come in handy. How lucky for her she took them.

Oh, but another cool theory. Sohee is from Japan (Move!8), if only partially. What if, and hear me out, what if everything she says is true? Or at least, she BELIEVES it’s true? Sohee was a friend of Y/N in Japan. (Y/N doesn’t know her because she has two names – a Japanese name and a Korean name. Like Joshua is called Joshua or Jisoo.) After the whole Yuta sitch happened and Y/N left Japan, Yuta started to turn the whole story around. Saying how Y/N manipulated him, forced him to sleep with others, that she actually cheated on him multiple times, making himself to be the victim. And Sohee falls for it, deeply hurt that Y/N didn’t tell her when she left. Yuta then convinces her that Y/N would try to do the same thing in Korea again, like she did here in Japan. She agrees to help Yuta with stopping Y/N. It takes them a while to track Y/N down completely and to save up the money (flights and hotels are /not/ cheap, after all), but once they do, Yuta goes over to ‘save the others from Y/N’. He’s not successful, and so they take more drastic measures. Yuta tells Sohee all about how Y/N has targeted many men, how Y/N has replaced her with another girl (which hurts Sohee even more), and how this other girl is helping Y/N with manipulating SVT. Yuta tells Sohee he was able to get others to help him (the truth: Yuta is the one who asked Jimin and Seokjin for info and Y/N, and also is the one to hack the tea account and post the thread – but Y/N dropped her phone on her own accord, she’s just that clumsy ha) and Sohee goes to Korea. Yuta convinces her to lie just a little bit, telling her SVT is too blind already to just believe her when she says she’s here to help them. So, Sohee lies. And she is especially motivated to lie once she sees a specific member of SVT – Seungcheol. You see, Sohee is Korean-Japanese (hence the two names). And she lived close to Seungcheol before she moved to Japan at age 8. Seungcheol doesn’t actively remember her, but he has this feeling about Sohee. She seems familiar to him, and he automatically trusts her a lot. So when Sohee tells them of Y/N’s ‘plan’ (the only part Sohee thinks is a lie is the part of Y/N sending her to Seoul to cover up for her), and Y/N, Chaeyoung or Seungkwan don’t respond to any of them except for Jihoon, who is – in their eyes – probably a henchman of Y/N or being manipulated by Chaeyoung, Seungcheol immediately believes Sohee. (Yuta is preventing the messages from the members of SVT to reach Seungkwan and Chaeyoung, and he would’ve prevented them from reaching Y/N’s new phone too, but luckily for him, Chaeyoung and Seungkwan help him unintentionally.) It doesn’t take long for the others to believe Sohee as well. And during those two/three summer months, Sohee becomes fond of SVT. It makes her resent Y/N even more, because Y/N already broke the hearts of such gentle and loving men by leading them on and then just leaving. (Which is why, once Y/N is back, she texts her from an unknown number.) So yeah, Theory that Sohee believes she’s saying the truth (partially) and is being manipulated by Yuta. (Sidenote: Seungcheol could be replaced by any other SVT member. It could very well also be Joshua, which would explain why he would teach Sohee guitar, and why he would abandon Y/N so quickly. I just chose Seungcheol because… well, he strongly believes Sohee. Strongly enough to kick out Jihoon. I think there’s a reason for that.)

[thankyoukhteam]

Hello, all who are tagged in this post!! I just wanted to get this one-month reminder to you at least in some form before the day of got any closer. 

I’ve been sending them out individually but have run into an unforeseen hiccup which is that Tumblr only allows me 50 new message conversations per day. With this handicap, it will take me another 8 days to send them to all of you. I will still be sending them to you over these next 8 days (which will prevent this from happening again with the 1 week left reminders), so, please keep an eye out for that! Dont hesitate to send me a message if you have any questions! 

@akizasakii @askbountyhunterjones @beldam-witch, @boof-hi-its-nigel, @candasaurus, @celestiaaaaaaaa, @coffeetime88, @cutegarbage, @dissolvingphoenixashes, @doggosandborks, @elli-mk, @ends-of-the-wayward-storm, @erachas-faithful, @fairytalenobodiesxvi, @gd-gone, @haveievermentioned, @hinataoc, @icing-on-the-icecream, @just-a-small-hobbit, @k-chanlovesanimexd, @khsupergeek1288, @kingdomsaurushearts, @kostecko27, @lazykrimzen99, @legendary-dork-of-the-universe, @lithium-banana, @little-mini-me-world, @liverpeps, @lollovovisossa, @lorastormbelle, @lostseraph45, @lotusflame14, @loveallanime, @loxli, @lozuuka, @lucky-im-terrified, @lucyrockbell, @lunami-cancro, @lunatroph, @luxordssearchhistory, @lycheeman, @madasthyhatter, @mafuyusatou, @magical-mistral, @magical-usaya, @m-agitek, @magneticdragon, @mahouoni, @maikusakabe, @marcigray, @marie-jaeger, @marshmallow-vulpes, @masteraqua, @maybe-not-a-robot, @melbelleroseart, @melodiousramblings2point0, @memorystormsanctuary, @mermaiddis, @mewhoismyself, @midnightcaffeinesstuff, @midnightpapllion, @mikayla-g, @mikumikubitch, @mikusaki39, @mishiali10, @mis-kitty, @misseymouse, @miss-r1418, @misstysea2, @mizurush, @mmysbathotw, @mollys-bullshit-blog, @momochiee, @mortellanarts, @msbluebell, @m-sid7, @mylvorytower, @mypaopu, @mysidianrabbit, @mzelle-lazuli, @n3k0c0, @nameless-stars, @natiannera, @nbgaymer, @ncrnpc, @nefarious-codex, @nekky-nek, @nerdykairi, @nesskyru, @nevilleswaltz, @nickiinator, @nidoarisato, @nightmarechirithys, @nobodiespoppet, @nozomirai, @nykamito-x, @nyxdoesedits, @oathkeeperandoblivion, @of-acorns-and-mithril, @office-of-eden, @ohsoroyal, @okamikawaiixd, @olivethebird, @onedestinytrio, @opulentwhimsy, @orcais, @oveliagirlhaditright, @ovesdominus, @owlymerlin, @oxen-nyx, @paintedmaple, @pandappuccino, @pandas-and-squirrels, @paopueater, @paopuisland, @passionateduelist, @patonigou, @paybackraid, @peachjuiiice, @pearlrose250, @phantom-donuts, @phantomknightgirl, @phoenix-downer, @phoenixiancrystallist, @pick-a-fig-and-pray, @pinkfoodkitty, @poisonmurderthot, @potitee, @preeteakeetea, @prince-astroace, @princegrinpayne, @princelier, @professional-fandom-jumper, @psychoparadox96, @pumpkinspice-cat, @purplesoultyphoon, @queendinosaur322, @rachelsrandomartwork, @radiofreekonoha, @raica-gp, @raindroppanda, @rainypurseprunetaco, @rakionex, @random-child666, @randomly-dreaming, @randomness-fandomness12, @rapis-razuri, @ratchetfan2006artsi, @realrobdog7, @redscornerposts, @reimisearchhistory, @remicon, @return2zero, @rhinefall, @rhuviel, @--riotknight--, @risingtea, @ritsu-x-tainaka, @robedingold, @roberjames92, @roko-kai, @rokosho-neo, @roksass, @rollinggirlrunahika, @rosequartzwrites, @rosieberry, @roxasinumiku, @roxas-uke, @rrutuvaduba, @rubydian, @run-run-runningman, @ryebread2003, @saaandyyvh, @sadisticunicorn666, @sakixhaise, @sakurawarfare. @salamemeder, @salsalahna, @salty-oranges, @sammi-eevee, @sassy-mami-tomoe, @scarfprincess, @scattereddream-faroffmemory, @schluesselschwert, @scrappedscript7, @sea-bea, @seasaltsouvenir, @sefiran, @sephyeol-aise, @sevenincubistolemyheart, @seven-sneaky-foxes, @shadowberrybinch, @shadowbearing, @sharlovesyou, @shellmilla, @shiba-exe, @shinemizuki, @shiro-the-fan-theorist. @shootingstarsora, @shorttulip, @shuradrawz, @shurareblog, @shutdownthenoise, @shygirl-00, @shyorchid, @silvaheart1995, @silverartistcat, @silverstararts, @simplyghosting, @simplynerdy, @sinfulpapillon, @sinfulseraph, @sir-cookienort, @sirikyu, @sisterkick2808, @skinwalkingxana, @sleepylightx, @snk25blr, @snoopthedrew, @socks-reblogs, @sojourntime, @solumwastaken, @somena-libra-dawn, @sorasearchhistory, @sornetteistired, @sorotheandroid, @spirit-of-creativity16, @spookysoupyy, @star-harvester, @star-shapedfruit, @steadycoffeecrusade, @stormflowyr, @stormy64, @summerdragoninc, @sunflova, @sunsetsacrifice, @supra-ana, @sushijjang, @swimmingmongersharkthing, @swoooonamis, @sxldierfirstclass, @symphoniesfatebell19, @synthiser-crypton, @syurreal, @taliaxlatia, @tcup-chipped, @teammomflynn, @tearfulfriend18, @thatonepansexualgirl, @thatrandompineappleinthecorner, @theangelicvampire08, @theartistinbed, @the-blueberrys-blog, @thedeliverygod, @thedustyleaves, @thefairywithfandoms, @thefinanic, @theflightlessphoenix, @the-genergy, @theheartstreasure, @the-questioning-dude, @thespellweaver, @thetolkienotaku-blog, @thetwilightroadtonightfall, @thewritingmusician, @thexiiithterra, @thirteenth-struggle, @timefrozen-waterstreams, @tina-nightray, @tiredofdumbass, @tobix-and-seraphim, @tofukitty, @tomboyjessie13, @triplegirl1, @trixie8264, @tsu9live, @tsumikim, @tsunamikaii, @tweltchy, @twilight-tracks, @twilighttwin, @ueeyasu, @user-unknow, @valkaaguilar, @valko-lapsus, @valor-winged-valkyrie, @vampiresque, @velvetroomattendant764, @ventusisgay, @ventusprotectionmom, @venvanitas, @veryclevermskitty, @violetstar264, @vividreminisce, @vnhelsing, @vocaloid-bananaboy, @waitwait, @walks-in-ink, @wayfinder-family-lover, @whereissora, @where-music-will-guide-us, @whotheheckisleanna, @wolfydusk, @woodlandcrowns, @worldofvaldis, @writer-chan97, @x-blade-master, @xiala-bexchan, @xionroxas, @xionshadow, @x-oath-x, @yacanchouseoabe, @yesmyjiin, @ygotas, @yoomsthefool, @youtubeallday, @yureid0ll, @yuusha-no-kibou, @zanzucchi, @zenmai--jikake--no--komoriuta

[cupidhaos]

(2nd attempt lol) So I went through Newsflash! and Move! with a fine-toothed comb...

This is structured into 4 parts to make it a bit easier to read. The first part is interesting information I 'found' again after reading through everything with watchful eyes again. The second part is a listing of everyone who could've done it, and what reasons they may have. The third part is not necessarily informative, but still interesting stuff I 'found' while reading through it again. And last are questions I had or things which didn't add up for me. This is extremely long (the Word document I have is 6 pages long RIP), so grab a drink and get comfy. Also, this is mostly just based on what is in Newsflash! and Move! itself. Hope you'll enjoy!

Interesting information:

“It’s crucial to the plot that you know” (DK in Newsflash! 5) implies there’s a hidden plot, one we don’t see

“You’re going to make plenty of friends soon enough y/n” (DK in Newsflash! 5) Did DK orchestrate Y/N becoming friends with SVT? Why? Does he want to tear SVT down? But why through Y/N?

Oh, remember that girl who told the schoolboard about Jeonghan and Chaeyoung, angry Jeonghan planned on resigning from SVT for Chaeyoung? The one who essentially was the cause for Jeonghan & SVT ghosting Chaeyoung in the beginning of Newsflash! because she got word to Chaeyoung’s father and he threatened to take away their scholarships? Maybe it has something to do with her… (Newsflash! 10)

Joshua said himself that the others give up easily (Newsflash! 10) as soon as the situation becomes a bit dire

Newsflash! 11 “I know what it feels like to just have someone slip away from you when you could’ve done more” (Y/N texting w/ Mingyu) Who?? Is she talking about?? COULD IT BE A REASON FOR SOMEONE TO BE A BITCH TO Y/N???? Adding to that the next text: “You have the chance to fix things before it’s too late” WHEN WAS Y/N TOO LATE?? FOR WHOM??

The Barista from Newsflash! 13 (I FORGOT HER NAME I’M NOT IN THE LOOP WITH GIRLGROUPS) could’ve heard everything SVT+Chaeyoung talked about when they were locked in that back room… maybe that started something? (Edit: okay in Newsflash! 22 several girls comment on Y/N’s tweet and one has the same profile picture as the Barista… so her name is something along the lines of Hyunie?)

Newsflash! 17 DK texting “He’s not the one for you trust me Y/N” makes DK all the more suspicious. How do you know that? Who are you trying to set us up with?

Newsflash! 21 DK knew before Y/N said anything at all that Y/N was out with Jeonghan and that Jeonghan had kissed her. How did he know?

Newsflash! 23 DK texting “Guess we’ll just have to wait and see” makes me think he didn’t actually plan all this… but the use of the emoji makes him still suspicious. But if he didn’t plan this – why does he know so much?! Is he stalking Y/N? Why? For what reason?

Newsflash! 29 Name of one of Jeonghan’s clients was dropped – Eunha. Was she the one who bitched to the schoolboard? Wonwoo calls her ‘VIP client ;)’, which Jeonghan doesn’t really appreciate (“how about u shut the fuck up :)” Has all the passive aggressive energy in the world)

Newsflash! 31 Okay, so Yuta: ex-bf from Japan; Y/N’s first love (what was Joshua then? Didn’t Y/N leave Korea because Joshua didn’t return her feelings in Senior year Highschool?); cheated on her (did he really?); showed her pictures/nudes to his friends;

Newsflash! 31 Am I… the only one who is kind of suspicious of Wonwoo? Like, why was he there? I don’t believe he was there by chance. And even if he was, why would he help Y/N? What does he gain from this? Yeah, SVT’s motto is ‘respect women and make them feel happy’, but… it still seems suspicious to me.

Newsflash! 33 DK texting “that?? wasn’t??? supposed to happen????” “where did he even COME FROM” confirms a suspicion of mine – it wasn’t an accident that Wonwoo was there. Or maybe it was? Ugh, I don’t know. All I know is that Wonwoo and DK are both suspicious as hell.

Newsflash! 34 HOLD ON A MF SECOND JEON WONWOO HAS A CLIENT WHO IS CALLED SOHYE. A CLINGY CLIENT. SOHYE AND SOHEE AREN’T TOO FAR APART. MAYBE SISTERS…? A SISTER WHO IS MAD THAT HER SISTER WASN’T TREATED ALL THAT NICELY BY WONWOO. THAT’S WHY SHE’S AFTER Y/N – BECAUSE SHE THINKS Y/N AND WONWOO ARE ACTUALLY DATING. IT WOULD MAKE SO MUCH SENSE THO BECAUSE CUPIDHAOS ALSO SAID ‘Sohee is connected to SVT but not in a way you think’ THAT WAY SHE’S CONNECTED TO SVT (HER SISTER IS WONWOO’S CLIENT) AND WE DEFINITELY WOULD’VE NEVER THOUGHT OF THAT. YOOOOO

Newsflash! 37 Jeonghan chewing Y/N out… and showing a possible motive.

Also Y/N is a dumbass for believing you can’t get phones in Thailand. HOW DUMB DO YOU HAVE TO BE??? Honestly. I mean, I get it if they were like, in a really rural part of Thailand, but somehow I doubt that

Move! 3 DK not be cryptic for 1 minute challenge: failed. BOI- “oh y/n this is where the story starts my dear friend” ???? Dear friend sounds so threatening. Like, what did Y/N do to you?

Move! 4 Why does Seungkwan want to keep Y/N away from SVT so desperately? Like, if Y/N can prove to them that the whole thread is a lie, she has 6 more people on her side. That would give her a lot more credibility, to be honest. Does Seungkwan have a reason for keeping Y/N away from SVT?

Move! 4 Chaeyoung is… surprisingly good… and QUICK… at getting Jimin’s and Seokjin’s number… even after they changed it… That’s suspicious. How good is Chaeyoung with tech?

Move! 4 Someone wanted Y/N info. And they were willing to pay for it. (This is before Y/N left, right after Jihoon posted the picture of being on the train to Busan with Y/N. So someone planned all this before Y/N even left.)

Move! 4 Jimin’s and Seokjin’s education and jobs have been threatened. (By whom exactly? Schoolboard? Or just a ‘random’ person? An anonymous person? They don’t know either – anonymous.) They were forbidden from talking to SVT (someone wants to prevent SVT from finding out the truth…) or explaining themselves.

Move! 5 Y/N mentions deleting all the photos she had of Yuta from her phone. But maybe Yuta still had some? Also (that happened to me) if you have a Google account and don’t adjust your setting, pictures taken on your phone will be saved on your Google Drive. As a backup. (I once deadass couldn’t get rid of 3 GB WORTH OF PICTURES BECAUSE OF THIS). Maybe that’s how someone got the pictures? Hacked Y/N’s email?

Move! 5 Soonyoung is very quick to point to Yuta. Then again, Yuta looks very suspicious. So… a ruse, probably.

Move! 5 DK “I trust no one and you shouldnt either” just… why should we trust YOU telling us not to trust anyone? Hm?

Move! 5 Vernon still hanging out with SVT (when did he even become friends with them? Nothing of that was mentioned during Newsflash! ? How did that happen??) is very suspicious. Like, isn’t there a conflict of interest? Or is he just stringing along either side? Making SVT believe he is on their side, or making Y/N believe he is on her side. Also, has Vernon met Sohee?? Or did he only hang out with SVT before the thread was posted? (But if that were the case… Minghao wouldn’t retweet it and Wonwoo wouldn’t say ‘we should do that again’.) Vernon, you’re very suspicious now.

Move! 5 Also interesting to note: Vernon practically pushes Y/N into Wonwoo’s direction. First saying that Mingaho isn’t a fan of Y/N anymore (true, I guess), but then leading her to Wonwoo? Did he know Wonwoo was the weakest link/the one who had doubts? Does he know Wonwoo still has feelings for Y/N, and is trying to push them together? Is Vernon playing something???

Move! 6 “You just disappearing out of nowhere was a bit weird” HOE YOU SAW EVERYTHING THAT HAPPENED??? SEUNGCHEOL, MINGYU, JEONGHAN AND Y/N WERE IN YOUR APARTMENT ON THAT EVENING??? YOU WITNESSED HOW JEONGHAN YELLED AT Y/N WHEN SHE WAS ALREADY A MESS?? AND YOU THINK IT’S WEIRD SHE RAN AWAY AND NEEDED SOME TIME? BOI-

Move! 6 One of Wonwoo’s answers indicated that he didn’t text Seungkwan or Chaeyoung and never asked for clarification, but just believed Sohee. He also never asked Vernon or Chan (again, why Vernon? And why is DK and Hoshi missing here??)

Move! 7 Jihoon mentions Y/N being pulled into things she didn’t do since Sohee appeared – is he talking about the thread saying Y/N manipulated Wonwoo (a whole lie, and SVT KNOWS THAT), or is there something more? Wasn’t there once the talk of rumors? What kind of rumors? More than what is written in the thread??? Ouf…

Move! 7 Mingyu outright says "Wonwoo I thought you liked Sohee…" Makes me suspicious. Did Sohee specifically target Wonwoo? Or is Wonwoo just pretending to be on Y/N's side? Hm...

Move! 8 DK clearly hinting towards Yuta being behind it all… but can we trust DK.

Suspects and why they would do it:

Chaeyoung:

Might still hold a massive grudge against SVT, and doesn’t want Y/N associate with them (Not logical – why would Jihoon and Wonwoo be okay? Why would she keep them around? They’re SVT too, and they ghosted her too, unlike Joshua.)

Might still hold a massive grudge against SVT and wants to get revenge (Once again – why are Jihoon and Wonwoo fine? They are/were SVT too.) (Thread/Rumors mainly hurt Y/N, not SVT.)

Holds a massive grudge against a specific member (don’t know who – maybe Jeonghan? Maybe one of the guys who overran Y/N?) and wants to ruin them. Orchestrated this whole thing and ‘leads’ the ‘investigation’ so it’ll lead to (a) certain member(s), in order to ruin them or keep them away from Y/N.

Got extremely jealous with how popular Y/N became with SVT. SVT is neglecting her once again, and Y/N is neglecting her as well, hanging out with her new friends instead. So, she wants to keep Y/N away from them, and hopes that this break of trust will cause Y/N to not be friends with SVT anymore, even if the situation gets cleared. She can be friends with Y/N again, Y/N will spend a lot of time with her again, and Chaeyoung’s happy again. (Might be psycho, but who knows…? Some people are crazy. And Chaeyoung seems very bossy with Y/N. (Granted Y/N needs it because DEAR LORD but still…))

General Reason for SVT members:

They feel betrayed and used by Y/N. She just left them, without even saying goodbye to them (she only texted Joshua before she left, as far as we know). They feel manipulated by her, and want to get revenge on her.

Or stereotypical ‘If I cannot have her, no one can have her’ or ‘If he cannot have her, no one can have her’. Y/N doesn’t want to be her girlfriend? (Or the girlfriend of one of their friends – JH and SC, for example.) Then you’ll be no one’s girlfriend. And I’ll drag you down.

Seungcheol:

Angry and hurt that Y/N immediately ran away after he got injured (for her, might I add), so he might feel like he was manipulated 

Jeonghan:

Angered at how Y/N treated Seungcheol and the rest of SVT, unknowingly strumming everyone along. Literally blamed Y/N for ‘everything going to shit’ into her face. Could be prone to enlisting the help of someone to tear Y/N down.

Joshua:

Extremely frustrated with Y/N. Feels betrayed by her and wants revenge. Finally snapped.

(Feels like he doesn’t know his friend anymore, which is why he believes so easily.)

Jun:

Deeply hurt that Y/N just went away without even saying anything. Wants to get revenge on her. Feels like she didn’t give him a chance, and now wants her to pay for it.

Soonyoung:

Frustrated that Y/N is only spending time with SVT now, wants to bring her back to her old circle of friends

Wonwoo:

Fell in love with Y/N, realized there’s too much competition and decided to get rid of them. (But why would he be hesitant when Y/N contacts him? Wouldn’t he want to be immediately on her side, to get into her good graces? But that could make him suspicious again… Hm…)

Fell in love with Y/N before the others did, before Jeonghan ever saw her in Communications class. Knows the others are competition, and wants to separate Y/N from them, hoping the break of trust will prevent Y/N from getting close to them.

Jihoon:

Knows all of the members. Knows they’re not good for Y/N. Wants to keep them away from Y/N. Hopes the massive break of trust will prevent Y/N from becoming friends with them again, even after the situation is cleared up. ’Leads’ the ‘investigation’ with Chaeyoung to lead it away from himself.

DK:

Homeboy knows too much. He said ‘and this is where the plot begins’ when Jeonghan sat next to Y/N at the beginning of Newsflash!. Always knew what was going on, even if it were unlikely for him to know. Could there be a reason for him orchestrating everything? Did Y/N wrong him at some point?

I feel like we all forget that in the first profile post, it’s stated that Mingyu and DK are close friends. Maybe he got über salty at Y/N not getting together with Mingyu, like he wanted to (?)?

Mingyu:

Feels abandoned by Y/N. Wants her to feel the same abandonment.

Minghao:

In the same class as Y/N – maybe a petty ass reason but she could’ve been too much competition? So he wanted to get rid of her? Essentially make her so disliked she’s forced to leave for her own sake.

Seungkwan:

Frustrated that Y/N spent so much time with her new friends, barely finding time for her old friends.

Vernon:

Maybe wanted to get into SVT, but got rejected. Tries to shake them up (Wonwoo and Jihoon left SVT already) so he maybe gets a chance to join SVT.

Seems to know an awful lot; pointed Y/N into Wonwoo’s direction. If not the culprit, then someone who helped? But why would he betray his friend? Well… has Y/N been a good friend?

Chan:

Same as Vernon possibly.

Mad that Y/N doesn’t hang out with him and the others as much anymore, and wants to bring her away from SVT.

Yuta:

Angry that Y/N won’t take him back, and that she humiliated him in public (she hit him and called him a dick)

First plan (just outright ask Y/N to come back to him) didn’t work. Now, next plan is set in motion.

(Most likely to be a red herring. He’s a bit too obvious.)

Yiren:

Y/N ‘stole’ Jun from her for a moment. He’s back with her now (both of them are Clownsssss), but still – hell hath no fury like a woman scorned. It could be a reason why she would want to harm Y/N, and make her stay away from Jun.

Sohye:

Clingy client of Wonwoo. Is not happy AT ALL that her favorite SVT member is spending so much time with another girl, someone who is not a client. Maybe wants to get rid of Y/N and keep Wonwoo to herself?

Sohee: Popular Theories:

Ex of Yuta who’s angry at Y/N because Yuta dumped her to get Y/N back. Wants to ruin her to get back at her.

Related to Seungcheol/Chaeyoung/Seungkwan/Anyone and either isn’t happy with how Y/N treated her (relative is not a dick in this route) or is the henchman of her relative, who holds a serious grudge against Y/N and wants to see her go down.

Ex-friend of Y/N who is angry that Y/N abandoned and forgot about her. (Maybe she was mentioned in Newsflash! 11?)

My theory:

Sister/Cousin/Very close friend of Sohye (clingy client of Wonwoo). Angered to see her sister/cousin/close friend being ignored by Wonwoo and not have his full attention anymore. Also think Wonwoo might be falling for Y/N, and doesn’t want her sister/cousin/close friend to experience heartbreak.

Chaeyoung’s Father:

Already has a history of being controlling over who interacts with his daughter

(Is he still part of the Schoolboard? And does the School still restrict SVT, or is that no more?)

What does he see: His daughter in distress, talking to SVT again, leaving for an entire summer… all because of who? Y/N.

Knows he can’t separate Chaeyoung from Y/N – childhood friends after all – but he can separate Y/N and Chaeyoung from SVT. Then he can start working on separating them.

‘Bitchy’ Client of Jeonghan (Eunha?):

Could be the one who bitched to the schoolboard when Jeonghan wanted to resign from SVT for Chaeyoung – or not.

Could be jealous of Y/N taking Jeonghan away from her, and wants to keep him away from Y/N

Jaehyun:

That one dude Chaeyoung dated for a hot second (were they really together??), best friends with Yuta (makes him suspicious!)

Could be in on the whole plot, planned to get to Y/N through Chaeyoung, but after that failed, they’re now doing Plan B

Unknown:

In Newsflash! 11 Y/N mentioned she once was too late in mending her relationship with someone. (She let someone slip away, as she said it.) Who was it? And could it be that the person is back, angry at Y/N for letting her slip away and wanting to get revenge?

Funny-informative things:

Seungcheol considered Joshua still a brother, even after Joshua left SVT and basically told them to get lost. So it’s extra ironic that he told Jihoon to leave because of a girl he just met ~2 months ago (Newsflash! 4)

You know, it’s really ironic – in Newsflash! 10 Joshua cites the fact that SVT just left Chaeyoung behind as his reason as to why he doesn’t tell Chaeyoung the truth. It’s very obvious he’s angry about them just leaving her. But look at what he’s doing now, leaving his friend of YEARS for… well, poor reasons. At least poorer reasons than SVT had to avoid Chaeyoung. Their education was at stake, while for him… what is at stake?

I like Jun calling Mingaho out on his bullshit in Newsflash! 22. First telling Jun that Y/N doesn’t like him that way and that he should go on a date with Yiren but then later on turn around and tell him ‘omg it was obvious she had feelings for you why did you play with her!!!’ Hao you just sank.

Newsflash! 26 Joshua’s whole tirade about “You should come to me when you need something, I should walk you home at night, it should be me, not Jun or Mingyu or Jeonghan” just rubs me in the wrong way. Like, dude – you weren’t there for her, but others were. So Y/N learned ‘oh, ok, can’t go to Joshua, I’ll go to someone else’. You can’t blame her for that. She went and found a different support system because you weren’t there for her. Stop being so controlling and demanding – even if you’re her friend since childhood, she doesn’t owe you shit. She doesn’t have to rely just on you, and doesn’t owe you a relationship. (Gosh, sorry went off on a tangent.)

Newsflash! 28 Jeonghan saying he’ll wait for Y/N until she’s ready (a whOLE LIE)

Newsflash! 36 Y/N doing the right thing and PUNCHING YUTA LIKE HE DESERVES GOODBYE HOE

THE MF IRONY OF JUN TEXTING “you don’t have any rights rn ur a dick” TO JEONGHAN IN Newsflash! 38 I’M DIEING XD HONEY, YOU ARE DICK YOURSELF. AND YOU’LL CONTINUE TO BE A DICK. GOSH YOU’RE MY BIAS WRECKER BUT HONESTLY SCREW Newsflash!/Move!Jun (Can we please get a moment where Jeonghan is convinced of Y/N's innocence but Jun doesn't believe her stubbornly, making Y/N cry, and then later when he sees he was wrong and tries to apologize Jeonghan pulls a "you don't have any right rn ur a dick" PLEASE???)

Also thank you Lee Jihoon for telling the guys they need to freaking CHILL. “throwing yourselves at her like DOGS” is exactly the phrase I would’ve used. 10/10 (Newsflash! 38)

Newsflash! 40 Joshua being a whole clown and texting “ill wait an eternity for you even if I get heartbroken in the end” like yeah, look at where you are now

Okay so to get this right: Y/N, Chaeyoung and Seungkwan have left for 1 week; Y/N drops her phone into a river in Thailand; that same week the thread was posted (but not on the exact same day?); very soon after that Sohee shows up and lies. That's… quick. How did no one of SVT think "wait, how come she showed up so soon after the thread was posted??" They really have -5 braincells, huh.

Questions I have/Things which don't add up for me:

Why was Chae’s Dad okay with Joshua still being friends with Chaeyoung? Is it because they didn’t have a thing for each other? Also, Chaeyoung's father still could've threatened Joshua. Either by threatening to take away his scholarship (if he has one) or by threatening to kick him out of university. Why was Joshua fine?

Why was it only Joshua who held to Chaeyoung when shit went down back then? I can understand Jeonghan, since his education was threatened, and Seungcheol, since he seems to be close with Jeonghan. But all the others? Did none of them, of all 12 (10) of them, care enough for Chaeyoung to say ‘I am resigning from SVT, I want to keep being friends with you’? My point is: it seems that SVT has a history of dropping people quite easily. Especially girls. Which is ironic, since SVT’s motto/theme is about respecting women and making them feel happy.

Then again - for how long have Joshua and Chaeyoung been friends? For how long have Chaeyoung and Y/N been friends? We know Joshua and Y/N are childhood friends (as far as I remember), but since Joshua said he met Chaeyoung during his time in SVT and only got close to her at that point, I don't think Y/N and Chaeyoung were childhood friends. But we also know Chaeyoung and Y/N were friends in Highschool, or else Chaeyoung wouldn't know about the reason why Y/N left for Japan. So... was Joshua just not aware of Chaeyoung, the best friend of his childhood friend? (How would that work??)

How did Y/N not know of SVT at the beginning of Newsflash! ? Like, she has to ask Chaeyoung who they are, even though Y/N has already been there for 2 Quarters. I get being a reclusive, I am too, but even I know about the very popular stuff going on around me. And SVT has to be popular. A host club/frat like theirs, not popular? They wouldn't bring in money if they weren't. And they do, as far as we know. So... is Y/N so unaware of her surroundings?

What also confuses me – we know Chaeyoung and Y/N have history. We know Y/N and Joshua have history. But Seungkwan and Y/N? We don’t know about them. We’re told he’s close friends with Y/N (Mingyu asking Seungkwan for help for getting Y/N and Seungcheol together, Seungkwan being the one to travel along Chaeyoung and Y/N), but we don’t see it. We see as much of their friendship – even less – than of Y/N’s friendship with Vernon, Dino, Hoshi and DK. I’m just- what’s their history? Why was he the one to travel alongside Chaeyoung and Y/N? Yeah, Chaeyoung said it’s because he’s not trying to get into Y/N’s pants, but… neither is Vernon or Dino. Or Seokmin. Hoshi is on shaky grounds, but I don’t think he wants to either. So, why Seungkwan?

Did DK and Y/N ever actually meet? Either during Newsflash! or Move! ? Because we know Y/N spent time with Vernon, Chan, Seungkwan, Soonyoung, Joshua and Chaeyoung on different occasions, but never was there any talk of DK. Speaking of which - how did DK and Y/N become friends? Was DK just an 'add-on' when Y/N started tutoring Chan and became friends with him? Does that really make them friends?

And... that's all I have. Sorry if I lost some things when I re-submitted them! And let's hope it'll work now!!

I really love what you do. Keep up the amazing work!!! 💕💕

[cupidhaos]

You know, it's interesting. Joshua's tweet heavily leans in on his romantic feelings, how he was jealous of Wonwoo (who is now close to Y/N). It centers on /his/ emotions, how /he/ feels. Mingyu's tweet is about how he wants to make Y/N happy. It's about /her/. Yes, it's about /him/ wanting to make her laugh, but the focus still is on /her/, not on him. Really shows who cares for Y/N, doesn't it?

you pick on context clues so fast and im just like omg ur GALAXY BRAIN like its so cool i just wnated to say but tru!! we’ve always known that mingyu would actually d!e for y/n since newsflash and it seems as if old feelings have been resurfaced once more 👀

[cupidhaos]

What’s sad is that Sohee could succeed in a way. What SVT did to Y/N, especially JiHanCheol, is a massive break of trust. While others (JunWonGyu) were bad as well, they got better. I think all of them need to earn back her trust and prove they’re good friends (minus Hoon/Hao). For me, forgiving JiHanCheol would be extremely difficult. I don’t think I’d want to be friends with them again immediately. (But knowing Y/N, she’ll probably forgive them quite quick… which isn’t healthy, tbh.) (3/3)

sohee honestly could succeed if she plays her cards right. you have to remember shes manipulative and if she manipulated the other guys, who says she won’t be able to do the same with y/n? and honestly who knows if y/n will actually forgive them this time i mean she shut out chaeyoung real quick but then again who knows!!

[cupidhaos]

For a hot second I thought I had ‘solved’ Sohee&MysteryPerson’s (MP) plan, but then a piece just didn’t slot in. What my ‘solved’ version of the plan was: Sohee&MP want to bully Y/N out of Pristin Uni, so Sohee can butter her up and replace Chae, while MP gets Chae back. But what Sohee texted to MP doesn’t fit in- ‘when can I come in’. Like, does she think she can become Y/N’s bf in Korea? When all of SVT knows what she looks like? How would that work? (1/3)

sohees kind of crazy if you couldn’t tell already lolz so she doesn’t realize that what shes doing is actually wrong. shes basically obsessed with y/n and all she focuses on is the end conclusion that she would become her best friend and doesn’t realize its damaging y/n in the long run so basically shes a sociopath

[cupidhaos]

Yeah, Sohee told SVT she idolizes Y/N, but she also made Y/N out to be a manipulative jerk. And since she has/had SVT whipped (*cough*Seungcheol*cough*), wouldn’t they try to protect her from Y/N, preventing her from getting close to her again? Besides: no way in hell will Mingaho, Wonwoo, Mingyu or Jihoon (has he met her?) let Sohee close to Y/N now. Then again… does Sohee know she lost some SVT guys? I'm just- it doesn't add up! (2/3)

jihoon has met y/n since he as in svt during the summer! her main goal is to just separate SVT and who knows what else shes capable of! sohee doesn’t know she lost some of the guys other than jihoon and wonwoo but with mingyu and minghao she doesn’t know

[cupidhaos]

Okay wow a lot went down- lemme process. (Warning: a lot incoming.) 1. Didn't Jun/Yiren happen again after the whole thread was posted? Or did Jun immediately go to Yiren after Y/N left? (If he did… low, dude.) 2. Y/N, Jin and Jimin were outside. Sohee went outside. Two different places, or did they cross each other? 3. 'Sohee went outside with someone'- who is that someone? Jaehyun? Does Mingyu know Jaehyun? 4. Where is Seungcheol? Did he hear Yiren and Eunha essentially exposing Sohee? (1/2)

okay i saw all your asks and i am READY *cracks knuckles* okay lets GO

1. jun and yiren happened after the whole thread was posted because jun was all like omg noo y/n :( then was like haha hey yiren... and yiren was like mmm maybe i HAVE a chance but she knows damn well he won’t like her back the way she wants him too

2. jackson’s house is big and their paths didn’t cross so they were in different ends of the house

3. you’ll find out who she was with soon enough ;) also mingyu does know who jaehyun is but they aren’t friends but they are classmates

4. seungcheol was actually in the kitchen because he saw wonwoo punch jihoon so he did hear the exposing of them

[cupidhaos]

Hoshi: 'This is just how I am deal with it' Me: *has violent flashbacks to goth/emo-phase from early teenage years* (I am so sorry, I just couldn't take anything 'Soonyoung' said serious because of that. He literally went 'shut up mom this is not a phase it's who I really am' on us. Help, I'm crying from laughter 😂😂)

PLEASEKRKE ME IN THE SEVENTH GRADE 😭 soonyoung isnt like other boys

[cupidhaos]

You know what makes me suspicious? Chaeyoung said no one texted her and Seungkwan. Wonwoo said he was there when they did it. I feel like that's gonna be important at some point... Like, did Sohe (or however tf you spell her name, idc for this girl) swipe all their phones and block SVT's numbers in them? Did she replace all the phones? Oh, what if she pushed y/n to drop her phone into the river in Thailand? Argh, questions!! (1/2)

SOMEONE FINALLY BROUGHT IT UP!!! even tho it was just a small line it holds a big importance!!! like seok said small things can be big or summ like that i honestly cant remember wht he said but u know where im coming from

[cupidhaos]

Look at Minghao, gaining braincells and calling SVT out for their back-and-forth idiocy! So proud of him. Also, I'm getting the feeling Sohee is connected to Seungcheol or Jeonghan. It would explain why Jeonghan is so aggressive (Jihoon and Mingyu), and why only Seungcheol knows that Sohee hasn't enrolled yet. (Really? Girl was there for two months but hasn't enrolled yet? She probably won't until the situation gets dire and she needs to confront Y/N in front of a large audience.)

minghao said: braincells now loading

and tru sohee wilding out here like damn what are u even DOING

[cupidhaos]

I'm so sorry, but I just had to laugh at this 'Unknown' person. "ill ruin you. dont test me. i have the power" "i can destroy you" like... they sound so much like a cartoon villain I just can't. Also, props to Y/N. "so if u can like maybe threaten me later??" iconic. I'm almost surprised she didn't text "Do it, don't be a pussy" 😂😂

OKAY RIGHTKSKFMD like theyre trying so hard its so cliche but y/n truly couldve given less than two fucks 😭😭 she deadass mightve called them a pussy if they didnt block her so quickly afterwards

[cupidhaos]

Ayeee Y/N read Joshua to FILTH!! Love that 😃 but I'll say it right now - now that Josh knows he was her choice, I bet he'll do everything in his power to 'get y/n back', even if she doesn't want that. Even if Y/N would want to move on with someone else, like Wonwoo. I already feel tired just thinking about that. (I really hope I'm wrong and Shua pulls a 'imma be a good friend again first' card.)

SHE REALLY DID!!  but lets hope that joshua has some hidden braincells and thinks with his head and not his heart (or dick either one is applicable)

[cupidhaos]

I'm sorry but when you said DK's role is obvious (👀) my brain went straight to crack like "DK is Y/N's fairy godmother (like animated Cinderella's) but Y/N fcks up all of DK's plans for her happy endings, so DK is left with fixing her messes and creating new happy endings for her while going 'gdi, I'm not paid enough to deal with this blind idiot' and being 0.05 seconds away from screaming at Y/N for being like that" and I just can't-

HONESTLY... UR NOT THAT FAR OFF ! but imagine being y/ns fairy god mother.... god the stress that would come with that

[cupidhaos]

5. Were Jeonghan and Eunha actually dating? Did I miss that?? When was that said??? 6. Y/N’s reaction confuses me. Why is she in disbelief? Shouldn’t she be glad? People behind thread exposed, and they literally said ‘[Sohee] helped us create that shit for the thread’. Can’t she believe that Eunha/Yiren would do it for a ‘petty’ reason? (Also, I just realized I’m not on your tag list. WTF. Can I be added?) (2/2)

5. jeonghan and eunha are not actually dating she’s just a client of his

6. you have to remember that y/ns ass is drunk as fuck and she doesn’t really know how to comprehend anything atm lmaoo so all she understood from the situation was that everyone was talking about her and there was drama happening. also she likes to believe in the best of everyone for some reason so i don’t think she even realized that they would do something like that to her (also of course u can i’ve always had the urge to tag you but i didn’t in case you didn’t like that) 

[cupidhaos]

Help. I read the lines “just go away! i know you’re pretty good at leaving” and my mind went overboard. I have just, and I kid you not, written out two different theories. 1700+ words. One reads like a poorly written short-story. What have I done. (You wanna hear them?)

HELL YEAH I WANNA HEAR THEM HIT ME WITH IT RIGHT NOW