#mcs (we): a:tla elements

[the-ravenclaw-werewolf]

Which of the four nations do you think each of the 40 (excluding Zuko and Korra) would be part of and which ones could bend?

Remember! List is subject to change!

Indented: Character

Bullet point: Explanation

When writing my answer, I had thought of a A:TLA AU with these characters, with the exception of Korra, but let me know if anyone is interested in hearing it!

MCS (WE): A:TLA Elements

I came up with this list back with the mind set of all of them to be benders, but if I had to chose some of them to be non-benders to would be:

Spike Spiegel

He isn't rich or socially powerful as some of the other characters from his anime, but he's always quick on his feet and has a few tricks up his sleeves.

Mako Mankanshoku

She's already weaker in a sense compared to the cast of her anime, but I can see her being supportive and learning chi-blocking, even if she executes in a weird way.

Chika Fujiwara

She is definitely the opposite of Spike when it comes to wealth and social standing, but I could imagine her more in a role of where she is a non-bender but is very manipulative, kind of playing mind games with her opponent.

Tohru Honda

She didn't need special powers in order to help the Sohma family, so a non-bender role would fit with her.

Izuku Midoriya

I don't think I need to say it.

Senku Ishigami

HE WILL USE SCIENCE TO DECIMATE ANY BENDERS WHO WISH HIM OR HIS LOVED ONES HARM! CHANGE MY MIND!

Iruma Suzuki

He's isn't a fighter, but we have seen him train and fight when faced against the odds, even though he is just a human in the Netherworld full of demons.

Nagisa Shiota

Naturally adaptable and can easily fool his opponents into dropping their guard because of his unassuming appearance.

Ciel Phantomhive

It's in a similar vain to Chika, but he would be pulling more strings in the background to combat any benders.

But regardless, here is my take on your question!

Fire:

Heine Wittgenstein

Earth would be a good element for him as he endured so much from both versions of his backstory. However, because he was a leader in both stories and he was driven to make changes to the kingdom/lives of those who lived in the lower class better, I put him with fire.

Satoru Gojo

He wants to change how the jujutsu system is and has an insane amount of drive, even if it seems he’s just kickback. Not to mention he already has such powerful and destructive technique, what could possibly go wrong? (Answer: Everything).

Kusuo Saiki

Even in the most ridiculous of situations, he has the drive and energy to achieve his goals and or a quiet life.

Rin Okumura

Driven, determined, stubborn, wants to be the best exorcist and defeat Satan, definitely a firebender.

Soma Yukihira

His biggest drive is to beat his father and to become the best chef in the world, making his perfect element fire.

Ciel Phantomhive

Ironic that he’s fire, but I chose this element as he is a leader who takes charge of his life, even if it means to make a contract with a demon. He knows what he wants and he doesn’t care what it takes to get it.

Killua Zoldyck

Fire, and not just for his lighting. He has the strength and determination to fight for what he believes, even if it means fighting against his family or powerful enemies. He will even use everything in his arsenal to see that Alluka, his friends, and Gon are safe and sound.

Emma

Definitely fire as she is driven to get the kids of the orphanage out of there and safe all the while doing everything in her power so they can get to the human world safely. I could see her as earth too, but she isn't afraid to challenge the system.

Earth:

Levi Ackerman

Is a firm leader who doesn't bend (ha!) to anyone and keeps marching forward even in the hardest of times.

Kobayashi

Blunt, stubborn, but determined and headstrong, I can see her as a powerful earthbender who knows how to keep others in line.

Edward Elric

Even though he has a short temper, he would make a perfect earthbender as he already works with so many elements from the earth and is stubborn to a fault.

Senku Ishigami

He has conviction and drive, but also when he sets his mind to a goal, there is no talking him out of it. For better or for worse, he take on any challenge he comes across and sweeps everyone else along for the ride.

(Plus I can imagine him using his bending and science to creating Octo-Arms just like Doc Ock.)

Air:

Saitama

While indifferent, he still has a heart and fights for the right thing. He can come off as rude or cynical, but that’s only because his indifference affects his social interactions. I first thought fire or earth would be his forte, but then I thought of how he usually fights in the defense of others. Sure he wants to find a fight that he can go all out in, but more often than not, get involved in a fight when civilians or an area is in danger. So I thought air would fit him.

Naegi Makoto

He tries to keep the peace and finds a resolution, and absolutely hates the idea of killing. But he brings a sense of community to the group he leads.

Legoshi

He is quite humble as he purely uses his strength for the sake of others and to protect them, so he would be a prefect airbender

Mako Mankanshoku

Full of life, cheer, and loves her family and friends to the very core, even through the hardest time, she has such high spirits that it’s hard to not get swept up in it.

Ryota Suzui

He doesn’t like to take risks, but is shown to pull through when the stakes are high. Smart, yet thoughtful. Careful, but determined. But above all else, he is grounded.

Tetsuya Kuroko

As you know, he works best in the shadows and as a support. And since air can be used to support the other elements, this is perfect for him.

Izuku Midoriya

He deeply cares for those he loves and stands up for what is right. While some go with fire, I see air bending as more of his style.

Shoyo Hinata

He doesn't like to be shackled by his own limitations, which is why he strives to break them so he can go higher.

Shigeo Kageyama

He can be naive at times, but he has a deep understanding of people and emotions, and plus his esper abilities already deals with spirits, so this is a good choice for him.

Iruma Suzuki

He doesn't have material desires, he just wants to live his life with his family and friends. He may be a gentle soul, but when push comes to shove, he can pull off amazing feats.

Hanako

Because of his playful nature and that he strives to protect the spirit world and those he cares deeply for.

Water:

Italy

One of his famous landmark is the Grand Canal, but I see that he is a peacekeeper, but also a fighter if need be, (i.e. Turkey). I considered him as an Airbender, but he has earthly attachments so water I found was a better fit as he also cares for his family and friends and can adapt pretty much everywhere, even in the wackiest of ways.

Spike Spiegel

Like his philosophy, he goes with the flow of life and adapts to anything life throws at him. He also has a heart, even if he doesn’t show it.

Satoru Fujinuma

When he has to constantly live through Revival, he has to adapt and be quick to find the oddity. And even if he doesn’t show it or says he doesn’t have the capacity to care about others, he constantly puts himself in harm's way for their sake.

L Lawliet

He is adaptable in so many ways that he always has a contingency plan. Even if one plan fails, he’s quick to come up with another and is always strategizing, like his mind games with Light.

Yuuri Katsuki

He has a deep love for his family, friends, and later on Victor. His entire program centers around the concept of love and during his training he learns how to adapt both physically and mentally.

U-1146

Definitely determined and hardworking, for his ultimate goal is to protect the body and the cells that live in it, making him the perfect waterbender.

Haruka Nanase

Do I even need to say it?

Kae Serinuma

Throughout the changes of her life, she adapts and finds ways to conquer through them. And she wishes for the others to get along, even if she’s oblivious to their feelings for her.

Langa Hasegawa

Adapts from snowboarding to skateboarding in a matter of seconds and deeply cares towards his new found family.

Chika Fujiwara

As a politician's daughter, she needs to be ready for anything. With all her skill sets and to be able to switch the situation to her advantage, this is her element. (But now I’m terrified that she will try to learn blood bending.)

Mafuyu Sato

Despite being soft spoken and most of the time expressionless, he has a big heart and cares for those he loves, especially when he is afraid of saying the wrong thing. He found a place within the band and could definitely call it home.

Tohru Honda

Gentle, thoughtful, sometimes stubborn, has adapted to the worse, and a healer to all, this is her element.

Haruhi Fujioka

Often blunt and lacking tack at times, she has shown to be understanding and quite motherly at times, which makes her caring but brings about a tough love.

Tanjiro Kamado

He is entirely devoted to his family and those he cares about and strives not only to find a cure for his sister, but to rid Muzan from the world so that innocent people can live out their lives in peace.

Nagisa Shiota

He mostly puts others in front of himself, but he is ready to fight for his classmates and teachers, as they all become this weird, but wonderful family.

[the-ravenclaw-werewolf]

Well, about the Avatar ask I sent you, maybe a few things could help.

I think Legoshi would not be a bender or from any of the four bation, but be a spirit.

Izuku would be a nonbender and be from the Fire Nation. He would be part of Zuko's crew.

Levi would be from the Earth Kingdom. I don't know about bending, but I think he should be at the wall of Ba Sing Se. (Get it? Lol)

Nanase and Katsuki should be Water Tribe as they are swimmers and ice skaters, respectively.

That's all I got for now.

I'm still trying to write down the roles for my A:TLA au, but here what I have!

Synopsis: Each one of the 40, except for Korra, live as normal citizens within the Avatar world. But what the Fire Nation doesn’t know was that not all of the air benders were killed, some went into hiding after hearing the whispers of the Fire Nation planning to kill them all. This resulted in a few more air benders being born, leading to a chain of events where more people, and spirits alike, are much more involved with the story of the Avatar

Where They Live: Fire Nation Heine Wittgenstein Satoru Gojo Spike Spiegel Chika Fujiwara (Was born in the Southern Water Tribe) Zuko Izuku Midoriya Soma Yukihira Ciel Phantomhive Killua Zoldyck Emma

Earth Kingdom Saitama Kusuo Saiki Naegi Makoto Mako Mankanshoku Rin Okumura Ryota Suzui Tetsuya Kuroko Edward Elric Haruhi Fujioka Senku Ishigami Shoyo Hinata Shigeo Kageyama

Southern Water Tribe Haruka Nanase Kae Serinuma Iruma Suzuki Nagisa Shiota

Northern Water Tribe L Lawliet Langa Hasegawa Mafuyu Sato Tohru Honda Tanjiro Kamado

Kyoshi Island Satoru Fujinuma (Was born in the Southern Water Tribe) Kobayashi (Was born in the Earth Kingdom) Yuuri Katsuki (Was born in the Northern Water Tribe)

Ba Sing Se Levi Ackerman (The Outer Ring)

Spirit World Italy (Lives in the Fire Nation) U-1146 (Lives in the Earth Kingdom) Legoshi (Lives in the Southern Water Tribe) Hanako-kun (Lives in the Southern Air Temple)

Benders: Fire Killua Zoldyck Emma Heine Wittgenstein Satoru Gojo Kusuo Saiki Rin Okumura Soma Yukihira

Earth Levi Ackerman Kobayashi Edward Elric

Air Saitama Naegi Makoto Ryota Suzui Tetsuya Kuroko Shoyo Hinata Shigeo Kageyama

Water Satoru Fujinuma L Lawliet Yuuri Katsuki Haruka Nanase Kae Serinuma Langa Hasegawa Chika Fujiwara Mafuyu Sato Haruhi Fujioka Tanjiro Kamado

Non-benders Spike Spiegel Mako Mankanshoku Tohru Honda Izuku Midoriya Senku Ishigami Iruma Suzuki Nagisa Shiota Ciel Phantomhive

Spirits Italy U-1146 Legoshi Hanako-kun