#like. i find the depictions of MEN in stuff like shoujo and fanfcition interest where its like
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Note
God your post about how people treat masculine women in media and irl hit the nail exactly on the head. I also keep seeing these people rejoice when a masc woman is forced to present femininely bc it's now "genderfluid rep" or whatever which makes me feel kinda sick ngl bc it's so clear that they think being a butch dyke is a shallow uncomplicated gender experience but being forced to be feminine is more moral/attractive/complex. Haruka Sailormoon is like one of my favorite fictional characters ever but the amount of tepidly queer sm fans who openly hate butches while championing heterosexuality and gender conformity under a thin veneer of progressive language make me want to lose my mind
YES to everything!!! the weird delight when a masc woman does something feminine is actually so uncomfortable and it's like... they've literally BEEN being gnc every day of their life but it's not enough for you until its watered down to just like a generic androgyny its so weird anddd i think combined with the belief that butch women are doing that as some kind of statement and denying them the understanding thats afforded to other women that like they sometimes just do the stuff they do because they enjoy it and it feels natural. thats actually my favourite thing about haruka (and i liked it about utena too which actually comes out n SAYS it when wakaba is like "but this IS what's normal for you", and that still went massively over ppls heads) like she is so casually masculine and like she's just like that. not only is butchdykery so much more complex than whatever tepid futch androgyny people would prefer, even if it wasn't its like literally just how people are helloooo like butch lesbians arent there to be controversial and make a statement ... you should not be responding to the denigration of the gendered boundaries someone has set for themselves like ever in any context anywayyy. but let alone in the group whose boundaries people are probably the most determined to deny (not that people don't do this with all gender nonconformity but theres nothing like the desperation with which people want an unapologetically masculine women to make just one concession to femininity). the whole 'compensating for short hair with big earrings and winged eyeliner' girlboss in menswear industrial complex is why butchness is uniquely predicated on not JUST the embrace of masculinity but also the exclusion of coercive femininity completely at the same time like it's really hand in hand and its to do with a wider social labyrinth of coercion that every woman navigates so you can't just brush it off with choice feminism type platitudes because ummm we live in a society
#ask#anon#butchfemme#also um i know haruka is like super unrealistic but its actually so interesting to see like#masc women for the gaze of. other women#so it is like exaggerated and unattainable in the way feminine women usually are for men's gaze etc etc#but at the same time it feels extremely refreshing because itslike#literally a portrayal boiling over with attraction between women#like. i find the depictions of MEN in stuff like shoujo and fanfcition interest where its like#a fake man made up by women for other women#because it doesnt at all translate as just a mirror flipped version of The Male Gaze#but taking it another level and having a masc woman thats designed to feel attractive to other women is like#yes there are kind of stereotypes and issues but also something about that feels insanely liberating dhfgdfg#anyway idt i would trust anyone that describes themselves as a sailor moon fan because if you can watch interactions between usagi &mamoru#without physically cringing you have something wrong with you
18 notes
·
View notes