A Dream Worth Chasing
Part two to ‘You’ve Always Been My Dream’
~~
~~
Okay, so I’m fucking annoyed because I just spent an hour editing all of this, just so Tumblr could fuck me over. ANYWAY, this is part two to ‘You’ve Always Been My Dream’. Thank you @fuckingbye for making such an amazing mood board, but also being an amazing wedding planner, and an amazing friend. I love you so much. Thank you all so much for your patience, there's so much going on right now. Okay, I hope you all enjoy it!!
Word Count: 35,640 (be proud of me please)
Warnings: SMUT (so much), MINORS DNI, Angst, Swearing, Age kink, Family drama, lying, drinking, FLUFF, Arguing, Drinking, Oral (m/ receiving) (f/ receiving), Degrade kink, Daddy kink, Unprotected sex (reader is on birth control but it’s nit mentioned), Anxiety, Lying, Cheating (I guess), and more shit I’m sure I forgot
Song(s) That Inspired This Chapter: Whatever you do, don’t tell anyone
Summary: You and Andy just can’t quit one another, so you’re both done trying. However, your new found love means that you now have friction with your best friend. How the hell are you two supposed to tell Jacob that you’re in love with one another?
I do not give consent/permission for my stories/works to be posted elsewhere. I do not condone this type of behavior, this is for entertainment purposes only.
Part 1
~~
“Why didn’t you answer me?” Laurie asks as she makes her into the bedroom.
“I think it’s pretty obvious that I was sleeping,” Andy scoffs and you hear his feet shuffling around the bedroom.
After quickly making sure you had everything (except the panties Andy ripped off of you because he refuses to give them back), you ran into Jacob’s room just in time. Now, you have the privilege of hearing them going back and forth.
“I called you-”
“Laurie, my phone is downstairs. I don’t feel like going back and forth with you, especially when I’m just waking up, so I’m not fucking going to.”
“You spent the night with her and expect-”
“Her being in the same house as me while sleeping doesn’t mean we fucking spent the night together.”
“You had no problem telling her to stay!”
“Would you have preferred that she drive in that shit and crash into a fucking pole? You saw the same fucking storm I did, it was a shit show! It’s not her fault that Jacob didn’t show up, so leave her alone!”
“Andy-”
“She means nothing to me, Laurie. I barely fucking know her, so just drop it!” he snaps.
You know why he’s saying it, but it doesn’t stop it from hurting any less. It doesn’t help that, less than 24 hours ago, you gave yourself to him completely.
You don’t want to be mad, but you’re fucking pissed.
“I don’t mean to start an argument, Andy. I just wasn’t expecting...I did something for us,” Laurie beams.
“What?”
What?
“I booked us two tickets-”
“Don’t even finish that statement. You know I can’t just randomly take off from work-”
“We used to go on spontaneous trips all the time!”
“Things change and I can’t-”
“Hello!?” Jacob calls from downstairs, reminding you that you need to finish getting dressed.
“Hey bud!” Andy responds and you roll your eyes.
You’ve been awake for all of 20 minutes and you already have a fucking headache.
“Y/N, are you up?” Jacob asks as he knocks on the door to his bedroom, “I’ve-we’ve got news for you!”
“Jesus, are you two pregnant?” you laugh awkwardly as you open the bedroom door.
“No, not yet,” Jacob laughs “we got the place! Took longer than we wanted, but we got the place we wanted!”
“That’s amazing! Jake, I’m so damn happy for you!” you smile as you wrap him in a hug. “You too, Sarah!” you beam as you let go of him and wrap her in a hug just as tight.
As you two break apart, you can tell by the look on her face that she knows something is wrong.
“Hey, what is this I hear about you getting a place?” Andy bellows as he walks out of his bedroom with just his pajama pants on.
Gorgeous asshole.
“Yeah, we got the call last night at around...7? Sarah’s parents knew before you guys,” Jacob laughs as he goes to give Andy a hug.
“I’m so happy for the both of you!”
“Jesus Andy, what the hell happened to your back?” Laurie questions as she lightly traces her hand over his back.
It’s taking all the strength you have to not face palm yourself.
“What do you mean?” Andy asks, avoiding looking at you as if his life depends on it.
“Your back is covered in marks!”
“I mean I used that back scratch thing you got me-”
“If these are the results, never use it again,” she mutters.
“We should all go out to celebrate,” Jacob suggests and it’s obvious he just wants to get the fuck out of the house.
“Oh, I at least need to shower,” you laugh awkwardly as rub you the back of your neck.
“You can shower here!”
“I don’t wanna wear the same clothes two days in a row. How about we do dinner? That gives everyone time to get ready,” you suggest, thinking it’s the best way to end the most cringe worthy conversation you’ve ever had in your life.
“Dinner is actually a great idea! It gives your father and I enough time to set a reservation and everything,” Laurie squeals, and it pisses you off that you’ve done something to make her happy.
“Sushi?” Sarah smiles, noticing your anxious state.
“If we’re not paying, I don’t care,” Jacob laughs as he wraps his arms around her.
“Tonight is on us, I promise,” Laurie laughs as she takes Andy’s hand in hers.
You want to throw up.
“How does six sound?” you ask as you step into your Vans.
“Six is perfect!”
“Six it is,” you smile at everyone “I’m gonna head out!”
You take your time going down the steps, but the minute you’re outside, you’re practically running to your car.
What the fuck?!
How the hell did everything go so wrong so fast? One minute you’re in heaven with the man of your dreams, the next you’re listening to him lie to his wife about how you mean nothing to him.
Fucking alcohol.
The entire drive back to your place, your phone won’t stop buzzing and you know it’s Andy. You know you shouldn’t be mad at him, and you know he didn’t mean it, but that doesn’t stop the stinging those words left. By the time you’re back at your place, your headache has evolved into a migraine. You finally look at your phone and you have eight unread texts from Andy and two from Sarah.
Babydoll: Okay, what the fuck was that about?
Babydoll: I knew it! I fucking knew it! I knew you two were gonna fuck last night!
Y/N: Please don’t say anything to Jake.
Babydoll: What the fuck happened?!
Y/N: Sleepover tonight? I need a minute to fucking decompress because what the fuck?!
Babydoll: WHAT THE FUCK?!
Y/N: Ugh, we’ll talk about it tonight, just...idk, act normal.
Babydoll: I swear to fuck, you two.
Y/N: Imagine how the fuck I feel.
You take a deep breath before getting out of your conversation with Sarah, and tapping on the text conversation between you and Andy.
My Heart: I am so fucking sorry, sweetheart.
My Heart: It hurt me to say it, but you know I didn’t mean it.
My Heart: Nothing has changed. I love you so much and I want nothing more than to be with you. I will be with you, I promise.
My Heart: Honey, please don’t be mad at me. I just fucking panicked.
My Heart: Just call me when you’re home, okay? Or let me know, and I’ll come over.
My Heart: I just don’t want this to be over as quickly as it started.
My Heart: You know you mean the world to me, please don’t take it to heart.
My Heart: I love you.
Y/N: I can’t talk to you right now, Andy.
My Heart: Please, just call me or let me see you. I don’t want our first argument to be about this.
Y/N: Andy, I can’t fucking do this right now.
My Heart: Well, when can you?
Y/N: I don’t fucking know, Andy! I’m not the one who said that you mean nothing to me!
My Heart: Please, even if it’s just for a moment, just let me plead my case in person!
Y/N: I really just can’t fucking do this right now. I need to lay down and I need to think.
My Heart: Please don’t change your mind, sweetheart. There’s so much that you still just don’t know yet.
Y/N: I’ll see you later, Andy.
You plop down on your bed and try to calm your emotions, but you can’t. You really shouldn’t be mad at him, because what else was he supposed to do? If Jacob wasn’t in the picture, you’re more than sure he would’ve been fine with telling Laurie the truth, but the fact of the matter is that you both would never want for Jacob to find out that way.
Still, he didn’t have to say that.
You know he feels terrible and he probably felt guilty right after he said it, but it still hurt. The one person who means the world to you and made you feel like the center of his universe, said out loud that you mean nothing to him. Yeah, it was a lie, but it still hurt like a bitch. In that moment, it felt like he was treating you like everyone else in your life had. Your parents, your so called “friends”, all of the guys you had dated...trauma is a son of a bitch.
As you toss and turn, trying to find some peace of mind and get some rest, your mind can’t stop going over last night. The more you keep trying to tell yourself that it was just sex, the more you know it’s all bullshit. No, it wasn’t traditional love making, but you felt his passion in every thrust. You felt his desire in every kiss, you saw the love in his eyes, and you felt care in his every touch.
Andy wasn’t trying to play you for a fool, and you know that in your heart of hearts, Andy’s love for you is just as genuine as yours is for his. So why can’t you just get the fuck over it? You know he didn’t mean it, so why isn’t it enough to just let it go and pretend you didn’t hear it?
Because he’s everything to you.
Nonetheless, by the time five o’clock rolls around, you’re dragging your feet about getting ready. You take the longest shower you’ve probably ever taken in your life, and you take your time picking out your outfit. Yeah, Andy’s sorry and feels like shit, but you still decide that torturing him all through dinner is your best move. It’s getting closer to summer, so the weather is nice enough that you can dress in something that’ll make him salivate.
You decide on one of your more flirty white crop tops, and your light blue denim jean shorts that hug your ass perfectly. Seeing as you just got a mani and a pedi last week, it’s only fair that you wear your favorite pair of open toed white sandals. Yes, it’s petty and unnecessary, but if he’s going to pretend that you mean nothing to him, why shouldn’t you pretend that he means nothing to you?
It’s childish, but fuck all if you aren’t tired of being made to feel like shit by those who mean the most to you.
You park right next to Laurie’s car when you pull up to the restaurant and fight the urge to key her car when you get out, telling yourself that would be taking it too far and she isn’t worth it.
“I love that shirt!” Sarah beams as you make your way over to the table where everyone is seated.
Andy looks up at you and almost chokes on his drink.
Good.
“I figured I’d finally pull something out of my closet that’s appropriate for the season. The weather is finally nice enough,” you chuckle as you take a seat, “did I miss anything?”
“The waitress took drink orders, so I got you a whiskey neat,” Jake shrugs, not even bothering to look up from his menu.
“You know me so well. So, tell me all about the new place!”
“It’s gorgeous!” Sarah squeals. “It’s a two bedroom, it’s not far from where Jacob is gonna start working after graduation, it’s only 20 minutes from my job, it’s not far from you at all, and it feels like home as soon as you step inside! You’re gonna help us move in, right?”
“Of course, I wouldn’t miss it!”
“You sure you won’t get cold in that shirt?” Laurie asks with a small laugh, but the look in her eyes lets you know that she’s pissed.
“Well, it’s 72 degrees outside, so I think I’ll be okay,” you smile softly.
“Leave her alone, Laurie. She’s a gorgeous young woman, let her take advantage of the nice weather. Especially after that shit show of a storm we had last night.”
Now it was Sarah’s the one chocking on her drink.
“Yeah, what the hell was that? That was insane!” Jacob laughs incredulously, completely oblivious to the tension.
As usual.
“I owe you a new bottle of whiskey,” you laugh, looking down at your menu, realizing that you don’t have a clue as to what you’re gonna eat.
“No, it’s my fault. I’m so sorry.”
“It’s really not a big deal. You didn’t know it was gonna happen. Besides, I had fun,” you smirk, and you see Sarah’s eyes go wide from the corner of your eye.
“What did you get into?” Laurie questions, trying to hide the alarm in her tone.
“Played some of Jacob’s games, watched some movies on TCM, and had small talk with Mr. Barber when I went downstairs to get myself another drink.”
“Oh? What about?”
“What it’s like to be satisfied after living a life where you haven’t been.”
“What are you satisfied about?”
“Work is finally going the way I want it to,” you lie with a pleasant smile, before looking up at Laurie.
“Has anyone been able to figure out what they want? Everything sounds amazing and I love sushi too much,” Sarah laughs awkwardly, and the look on Andy’s face lets you know that he’s trying his best to contain his amused his smirk.
“I’m pretty sure I know what I’m getting. Y/N?” Jacob questions looking over to you.
“Well, I’m definitely gonna have the pork goyza for for my appetizer, but I’m on the fence about what I want as my main course.”
“What are you stuck between?” Andy asks with a smile that makes you weak.
“The spicy salmon maki and the tempura maki.”
“I’m having the same issue,” he chuckles.
“How about I get the spicy salmon, you get the tempura maki, and we’ll split it?”
“Sounds good.”
“Hey, hey, hey,” Jacob interrupts “you’re my splitting food buddy!”
“We can still split fried handmade spring rolls.”
“Alright, then you and my dad can split whatever, I don’t care,” he smiles as he closes the menu and you shake your head. “How about you mom?”
“How about me what?” she smiles, finally turning her attention from you to Jacob.
“What are you gonna get?”
“Oh, pad thai. As always,” she shrugs.
As the evening goes on, you truly wonder how Jacob has no clue what’s going on. Laurie glares at you on and off, Andy is doing all he can not to look at you, Sarah is doing her best to pretend she doesn’t have a clue as to why there’s so much tension, you barely look at Andy or Laurie, and then there’s Jacob.
So completely ignorant to everything that’s going on, and you envy him so much. They really weren’t lying when they said that ignorance is bliss. However, this also makes you wonder how the hell you’re gonna tell him about you and Andy.
Is there even anything to tell?
Of course there is. It’s one argument and Andy didn’t even mean it. But still. Can he handle it? Can you handle it? Your heart has never burned for anyone before, and Andy is all you’ve ever wanted and more, but will he still want you once everything comes out? Will he be willing and ready to to handle the shit show that’s bound to take place when Laurie loses her shit? Is he ready to argue with Jacob? Handle Jacob not wanting to talk to him?
Will he still truly love you?
By the time everyone is finished with dinner, you have a migraine.
“Can we get separate checks?” you ask the waitress as she comes to collect the empty plates.
“Oh no! This is on Andy and myself!” Laurie exclaims with a false smile.
The last thing you want is a fucking handout from Laurie Barber.
God, it fucking sucks that they still share a last name.
“No, it’s perfectly fine. This was to celebrate Sarah and Jacob. I’m fine to cover my end,” you smile at her before turning your attention to the waitress, “my drinks and what I ordered can go on a separate bill.”
She only smiles and nods before walking off.
“I feel awful,” Laurie chuckles.
“It’s perfectly fine. I got a raise, so it’s actually affordable.”
“You got a raise?!” Jacob exclaims.
“It’s a recent development.”
“Why do I feel like I never know what’s going on in your life?”
“Because I never know what’s going in my life.”
“Anything else I should know about?” he asks with a small laugh.
Oh Jacob, there’s so much more you need to know.
“I think we’re all caught up,” you lie with a plastic smile as the waitress returns with the checks.
You’ve never been more excited to get out a place so fast.
“Alright, we’re moving the beginning of next month, you sure you’ll be able to help out?” Jacob asks as all of you stand in front of your car.
“I don’t care if I just have to pull a no-call/no-show, I’m going to be there. This is a huge step and I’m more than happy to be there for you!”
“You’re the best friend I could ever ask for,” Jacob smiles as he engulfs you in a tight hug.
You hate keeping all of this a secret from him.
“I’ll text you all of the information later, okay?”
“Sounds good to me,” you smile at him as you force yourself to hold back tears.
You’ve never lied to Jacob, and a lie this big feels like the worst betrayal in the world. But how do you tell him? How do you make him understand?
You get into your car and quickly start it before almost speeding off. The entire drive you’re at war with yourself, because for as terrible as you feel, it’s not enough to make you want to stop. It’s not enough to pull you away from Andy. It’s not enough to convince you that all of this is a bad idea. In fact, you’re not sure if anything is capable of making you feel that way. Andy has been the center of your universe since you two spent that night eating ice cream on the hood of his car, and it’s only grown over time. For as much as you’re terrified of what’s to come, it’s not enough to make you quit on the both of you.
It’s not enough to make you stop loving him.
The second you step foot back inside your apartment, you kick off your shoes and make yourself a drink.Yes, they’re better ways to handle the situation, but you aren’t interested in any of that right now. You just want Andy and you want to be numb.
You’re alone for an hour before you hear, “bitch, open up! We gotta talk!”
You can’t help but giggle as you make your way over to the door and open it, “took you long enough.”
“What the fuck was that?!” Sarah exclaims as she makes her way inside your apartment. “You two are insanely cute, but in front of Laurie?! What the fuck?!”
“I don’t understand what the hell that was either.”
“Okay, lets rewind. What the hell happened last night?” Sarah asks as she makes her own drink.
“Well, when I got there yesterday, I saw Andy’s car but no one answered when I called out, so I assumed I was alone. When I woke up and discovered that not only was I not seeing you and Jacob, but also wouldn’t be able to leave, I put on Jacob’s hoodie, and finished off his whiskey. I wanted to get drunk so I could go to bed, so I went downstairs, without pants, to steal a bottle.”
“Ah shit.”
“And guess who was sitting in the dark, drunk, and watching the Turner Classic Movies channel?”
“Jacob said Mr. Barber’s been into black and white films a lot lately. Wait, why weren’t you wearing pants?”
“I thought I was alone and don’t like sleeping in pants when I’m alone.”
“That’s fair, so what happened?”
“He asked why I came downstairs and I told him that I was gonna grab a glass and a bottle of something to drink, and he told me to grab a glass and have a seat with him.”
“You didn’t think to put on pants?”
“When I said I would, he told me it’s nothing he hasn’t seen before.”
“Come again?!”
You sigh as you get up, going into your bedroom and grabbing the picture he gifted you on Christmas,
“He came by on Christmas and left this and a key chain gifted in front of my door. When he was back in his car, he called me and we talked for a bit. I sat in my window sill,” you nod over to the window, “and I wasn’t wearing any pants. Nothing had happened at that point.”
“When did you two take this photo? You both look so happy,” she smiles softly.
“We used to go on late night drives together. When he couldn’t sleep, he would pick me up and we’d hangout. Sometimes we’d just drive around and talk, other times we’d get food. That was a selfie I took of us the first time we hung out. We got ice cream at 2am and stayed up till the sun came up. That was the night I realized that I’m in love with him,” you finish in almost a whisper as you tear a little.
“Y/N-”
“Anyway,” you interrupt as you clear your throat “that’s what he meant. I grabbed a glass and sat down next to him and he vented. Apparently, Laurie had a full blown affair the first time she cheated. The guy would buy her flowers, take her on dates, get them hotel rooms, they fucked quite a lot...it was a whole thing. However, when she came clean to Andy, he forgave her cause he wanted to make it work. Then, a few months ago, maybe a year at this point I’m not too sure, she cheated again because he didn’t answer his phone and she got all pissy. So, that’s why he started yelling about a divorce that night you told me Jacob told you about-”
“Hold the fuck up! She did what?! And she’s treating you like shit?! You and Mr. Barber?! JACOB DOESN’T EVEN KNOW ABOUT THIS BECAUSE BOTH OF YOU ARE WAY NICER THAN SHE DESERVES, BUT SHE’S GONNA GIVE YOU BOTH A HARD TIME?! WHAT THE FUCK?!”
“Yeah, that’s only part of what I’m feeling,” you scoff, finishing off your drink and pouring yourself another. “So, I started to tell him that I was sorry and he told me I had no reason to be sorry. He told me how much he loves me, how much he wants to be with me and he doesn’t understand why we can’t be...when I went to tell me to stop, he told me to get on his lap...I couldn’t have stayed away if I had tried. It doesn’t help that I’ve craved nothing but his touch since the last time we made out-”
“Back the fuck up, you two did what now?!”
“The night I bailed on you guys because I was fed up with my day, I went to a club and Andy was there with his friends, because Laurie wanted him out of the house since I was supposed to be there. He begged me to let him take me home, because he couldn’t stand to see me leave with another man. We got to my place, things were said, he brought me upstairs and as he was about to leave, I grabbed him and kissed him. We made out for all of 5 minutes before he stopped it. He felt bad because I was drunk and he said it felt like he was taking advantage of me.”
“You kissed him!”
“That’s what I said, but he said it didn’t matter. Anyway, last night...we fucked around a little on the sofa, then we went upstairs and into his bedroom and...,” you trail off and a small smile comes to your face at the memory.
“Okay, I know I shouldn’t ask because he’s my boyfriend’s dad, but you gotta tell me,” she giggles and you burst out laughing.
“Not exaggerating, the best I’ve ever had. I swear to God, that man worked my body like a fucking fiddle! He’s not selfish, he’s skilled with every part of his body, he takes his time....last night was a fucking dream, and after...he was so fucking sweet and gentle. He was reassuring and held me so close, like he was afraid I wouldn’t be there in the morning.”
“That’s so fucking sweet,” Sarah smiles, curling her legs up on the sofa.
“It was, then morning came,” you scowled.
“What happened this morning?”
“Well, he woke me up and got me all worked up, and we had just started when Laurie came home. I’ve never gotten of bed so fucking fast in my life. I ran across the hall naked, holding onto Jacob’s hoodie and my bra as if my life depended on it and-”
“What about your panties?!”
“I didn’t get those back,” you chuckle with a smirk.
“I swear to God, you two are meant for each other,” she laughs and you laugh softly with her.
“So, I get to Jacob’s room and start getting dressed fast as fuck, because for whatever reason, I was afraid she’d walk in. Anyway, she gets upstairs and starts laying into Andy about why he didn’t answer his phone, why did he let me stay over, why he’s naked, and she wouldn’t let up. Eventually, Andy got fed up and said that I mean nothing to him and she needs to drop it.”
“I mean, I get why he said it, but he definitely could’ve said something else.”
“My fucking sentiments exactly. I guess tonight he was trying to show me how sorry he truly was, and of course, Jacob was completely oblivious to all of it. I just don’t know.”
“Babe, I know it hurt, but we both know he didn’t mean it.”
“It’s just triggering, because it’s always me that ends up getting hurt. I know Andy isn’t a bad guy, and I know he’d never purposely hurt me, but the fear is still there and hearing him say that...it just triggered all of my insecurities and fears. Will he love me enough to stay if Jacob gets mad about us? Will he stay when Laurie gets mad and turns the town against us? Will he be ashamed when the town turns up their noses up at us? Yeah, he says no, but a lot of people have told me a lot of things,” you sniffle as you dry your eyes.
“Oh sweetie,” Sarah sighs as she moves closer to you and wraps you in a tight hug, “this isn’t anything like those other times. He’s not your parents, he’s not Mr. Fucking Matthews, and he isn’t like any of those other assholes you dated.”
“I just don’t know,” you sob.
“It’s gonna be okay, babe. You’ll see,” she promises gently as she strokes your back.
Sarah’s words roll around in your head as she tries to calm you down, and you know she’s making perfectly good sense, but everything happened so fast today...you just can’t quiet the fear.
As you cry into Sarah’s shoulder, you wonder if the fear will ever pass or if it’ll live loudly inside of you forever.
You wonder if you’ll ever feel like you’re good enough for Andy Barber.
Andy’s P.O.V
“She’s gorgeous, Andy? Really? You didn’t even try and hide the fact that you were flirting with her!” Laurie barks as I take some clothes out of my drawer.
“You believe whatever you want, I truly don’t give a damn.”
“And you said nothing happened last night! I wouldn’t count a fucking conversation as nothing!”
“I suppose I could’ve taken her to a hotel, fucked her all night, come creeping back in early in the morning, then lie to your face about where I’ve been all night!”
“Andy, it’s like you two were on your own little date!”
“I can’t help the fact that you hate her, Laurie. That’s something you need to work out in your own time,” I sigh, fed up with lying.
I don’t want to hide you, or us. I don’t want to say things that’ll hurt you or draw attention to us, I sure as shit don’t wanna sneak around, and I don’t ever want to make you feel less than.
How could I fucking say that?
‘She means nothing to me.’
Of all the fucking things to say, I had to go and say that. You’re good at masking your facial features, but your eyes said it all: my words cut you right to your core. You didn’t even want to talk to me, and I can’t find any fault with that. After so many other people have said one thing and done another, I had to go and sound like another asshole.
Fuck, everything was so perfect, then fucked up almost instantly. Fucked up because of my inability to think fast, which is saying something, cause I’m a fucking lawyer.
“Are you even listening to me, Andy?” Laurie sighs, putting her hands on her hips.
“No. Listen, I don’t feel like doing this tonight, so I’m not going to.”
“Andy, please-”
“Laurie, I’m gonna be out late and I’ll be sleeping on the sofa when I get back. I’m gonna start packing tomorrow. Make this easier for the both of us and just sign the damn papers. I don’t know how much longer I can keep doing this with you.”
“There’s still so much more-”
“There’s nothing left for us, Laurie. Do whatever you need to, to deal with that, but you do need to finally accept and deal with it.”
I hear her breakdown and start to cry as I turn to leave, and while I feel bad for being so blunt with her, I don’t know how else to approach this anymore. I’m through with keeping you on the sidelines, and I’m done trying to keep Laurie happy.
You are my main concern now. You are the only one I’m concerned with keeping happy, and I’m ready to do whatever I need to do to prove it to you.
Y/N’s P.O.V.
“How have I never heard this album before?” Sarah asks, drink in hand, as she drunkenly dances around to ‘Tony Adams’ by Joe Strummer and the Mescaleros.
“You can’t always be cooler than me,” you tease before getting up, grabbing your cup, and making your way into your kitchen, “do we wanna eat?”
“When don’t we wanna eat?” she laughs.
“That’s a very good point,” you murmur, opening the door and seeing what you have available to you. “How about-”
You’re interrupted by a knock on door.
“Probably Jacob feeling left out,” you giggle to yourself as you open your door. “Oh.”
Andy doesn’t say a word, he just wraps his arms around you, pulls you close, and kisses you like he hasn’t seen you in decades. Your only response is to wrap your arms around his neck and kiss him back.
For as hurt as you are, you’ll never turn down a soul stirring kiss from Andy. Whether that’s a good or bad thing, you’re not sure yet, but right now, you just don’t care.
“You’re drunk again,” Andy breathes once you two break apart.
“I told you I have a tendency to drink too much at times,” you mumble, still in a daze from his kiss.
“I don’t like you drinking to solve your problems. Especially when you’re alone.”
“Oh, I’m not alone,” you laugh softly, moving your head to the side so he can see Sarah standing in your living area.
“Hey there, Mr. Barber,” she chuckles.
“Oh...hey, Sarah,” he greets awkwardly and you can’t help but laugh.
“Don’t worry, I’ll go watch YouTube videos in Y/N’s room. You two lovebirds workout whatever is wrong,” she hums before practically running to your bedroom and closing the door behind her.
“I’m sorry.”
“Andy-”
“No, you don’t know how much I regretted it as soon as I said it. I didn’t mean a word of it. You mean everything and I’m so sorry I hurt you like that.”
“It’s fine.”
“No it’s not, so don’t pretend that it is. Don’t lie to me.”
“She’s your wife,” you scoff as you let him go.
“Don’t. Don’t act like it’s something I want.”
“She still hasn’t signed. Lets move you out of the doorway, I don’t need anyone seeing me be a man stealing whore,” you mutter, breaking out of his hold and stepping to the side so he can come in.
“Should I just come back when you’re sober?”
“You should come back when you’re divorced.”
“Honey, there’s just so much more you don’t know.”
“Did she sign the papers?”
“Honey-”
“Did she sign the fucking papers, Andy?!” you snap, slamming your hand down on the kitchen island.
“I’m trying.”
“Okay.”
“I want to be with you! I want to be out in the open with you! Give me the okay and I’ll go back to that house right now and tell her everything! I’ll tell her that I’ve been in love with you since I helped you move into this loft, I’ll tell her that we made love last night, I’ll tell her that I’ve never felt so strongly as for anyone as I do for you! Give me the okay and I’ll do it!”
“You can just do that to Jacob?”
“He’s an adult-”
“He’s your son!”
“He’ll get over it!”
“Why are you here?!”
“Because I love you! I am so in love with you and I...last night, I wasn’t saying a bunch of words to get you into bed. I meant everything-”
“But your first thought to respond with was ‘she means nothing to me’?”
“I panicked!”
“Andy, I love you, but I really don’t have the energy to jerked around-”
“We can do this. It’s messy and it’s fucked up, but we’ll figure out a way to tell Jacob and we’ll be together. I told you, I don’t give a fuck about what anyone in this town has to say and I don’t give a fuck how Laurie feels. I just want you, sweetheart. I told you that you’ve always been my dream and that wasn’t bullshit. You’re a dream worth chasing and I’m gonna chase you until we’re a reality.”
“Andy...”
“I love you, Y/N. I’ll do everything in my power to prove to you that this is real.”
“You can’t stay here tonight,” you sniffle, trying to hide your tears, “Sarah’s staying here.”
“I had a feeling,” he laughs “lets do lunch tomorrow?”
“We’ll figure-”
“Y/N, I know you and Sarah are having girl’s night or whatever, but I need to talk to you!” Jacob calls from the other side of your door.
“For fucks sake, is my place just the place to be tonight?!” you mutter furiously as Andy chuckles softly and Sarah runs out of your bedroom.
“Time for us to trade places, bud,” Sarah awkwardly smiles as she ushers Andy into your bedroom.
“Where’s your key?” you question, trying to sound as normal as possible, getting yourself together.
“I don’t know, it was on my nightstand and now it isn’t, can you open up?”
“Babe, give us a second, you’re catching us mid-concert,” Sarah responds with a faux laugh, looking at you with concerned eyes.
You give her a small nod as she draws a deep breath before opening the door.
“Someone’s impatient,” she chuckles as she steps aside, letting him in.
“I don’t mean to be a dick, and I tried to wait, but I just needed to talk about it. Was tonight weird to anyone besides me?”
“Weird how?” you ask while making him a drink.
“My parents were more socially awkward than usual. My dad calling you gorgeous? What the fuck was that?”
“Why was that weird?”
“Don’t start that. You know you looked great, but my dad isn’t like every other old pervert in this town.”
“Your dad isn’t old, Jacob,” you scowl as you grab your glass, pouring yourself a drink.
“I know guys his age are more your style, but to me, he’s old. Plus, he and my mom got into a pretty loud screaming match before he stormed out.”
“What about?”
“I don’t know, I sat out on the porch and drank a beer. I think all of this is starting to take a toll on my him,” he huffs as he takes a seat at the kitchen island, sipping on his drink.
“I’m sure he’s doing his best to sort things out,” you sigh as you sit across from him.
“Should I say something to him?”
“Have you spoken to him at all about how you feel?”
“No. He’s been so calm and collected about all of this, but he went out of his way to hurt my mom tonight and that’s not him at all. I’ll talk to both of them separately.”
“How did he go out of his way to hurt her?”
“The comment about you being gorgeous, you two bonding over fucking food, the little jokes.”
“Why does that mean he went out of his way to hurt her? Andy and I just have a lot in common!”
“Andy?”
“Jacob, it’s late and I’ve been drinking. I’m not about to be formal every five seconds, it’s just us three.”
“You don’t think it was a little weird?”
“I mean, I think your dad is hot, so no,” you shrug as Sarah chokes on her drink.
“You know what you don’t need to tell me?”
“You asked.”
“That’s the last thing I need; my dad having a mental fucking breakdown and start dating someone my age.”
“I’ll drop off an application.”
“Please stop,” he groans as he lays his head on the table.
“Well Jacob, what exactly are you expecting him to do? Get divorced and be alone for the rest of his life?”
“No, I just...I’ve been thinking about it a lot these past few days. I want them to divorce, it’ll be best for him, but I don’t...it’s always been the three of us. Whether it was healthy or not, it’s the only family I’ve known, and we’ve been through hell and back. I don’t know if I’ll ever accept either of them having anyone else in their lives, but I want him to be happy. I want them both to be happy,” he finishes with a heavy sigh.
How the hell are you and Andy supposed to tell him now?
“If he settled down with someone younger, would it really be so bad?” you ask timidly, terrified of the answer.
“It wouldn’t be my first or second choice, but it wouldn’t be awful. If he’s truly happy, I won’t care,” he mutters softly with a frustrated sigh, finishing off his drink.
You force yourself to swallow down the lump in your throat. You blink away tears trying to accept that if you pursue a relationship with Andy, it may be the end of your friendship with Jacob.
“Guess we’ll just have to see how it all plays out,” you shrug with a meager smile.
“What should I even start off with?”
“Just tell them how you feel, separately, of course.Yeah, you’re moving out, but they’re still your parents, and it’s taking a toll on you. You can tell it’s taking a toll on them. You need them to get it together.”
“Yeah, I guess.”
He takes a deep breath before rubbing the back of his neck and standing up. You can feel the heaviness he’s trying to ignore, and you’re torn because you don’t want to cause him anymore stress and frustration; but you just love Andy so damn much.
Why does all of this have to be so damn complicated?
“I’ll let you guys get back to your night, keep an eye on her,” Jacob chuckles with a nod towards Sarah, who flips him off in return. “I love you both, talk to you later.”
You start crying the second he’s out the door.
“He’ll come around,” Andy coos softly as he steps out of your room.
“He’s gonna fucking hate me!”
“No, he’s really not,” Sarah tries to reassure you, occupying the seat that Jacob was in. “He’ll throw a hissy fit, probably won’t talk to you for a month or two, and then he’ll apologize and ask to talk it out. He’s emotional, not a complete idiot.”
“You both heard him! He said-”
“He said as long as I’m truly happy, he’ll accept it. Listen to me, honey,” Andy starts, gently pulling you out of your seat and wrapping his arms around you, pulling you close. “This isn’t a breakdown or some sort of crisis. I love you. I am so insanely in love with you to the point that it terrifies me because I’ve never felt this way about anyone. I don’t want to fuck this up, I don’t want you to get hurt, and I don’t want you to quit on us. We both did our best to avoid this, but it was pointless because look where we are. I’m so happy when I’m with you, and for once, life makes sense. You are worth everything to me and I will be with you. It won’t be a secret and it’ll work out fine.”
“Jacob-”
“I’ll deal with Jake, don’t worry about it. I’ll figure out a way to get Laurie to sign those damn papers, and then I’ll tell him-”
“We’re in this together, Andy. We’ll tell him together. If we’re gonna do this, really do this, we should do it together.”
“Are you sure?”
“I can’t leave you to face all the hard shit alone. That’s not how relationships work, well not how a healthy one works. I wanna be all in with you. Even the hard stuff.”
“You two,” Sarah whispers with a grin as her eyes start to water.
“Shut up,” you scoff, drying your own eyes.
“Sarah, I’m sorry you’re in the middle of all this-”
“It’s fine, Mr. Barber. You both deserve a win and I’m happy you two have each other. I’m more than happy to keep my mouth shut until you guys figure it out.”
“Thank you,” Andy smiles with a nod before turning his attention to you. “Are you okay?”
“No.”
“Honey-”
“It’s just going to take some adjusting. All of this is about to get a lot harder before it gets easier and...not every day is going to be amazing. It is what it is, whatever.”
“Don’t make plans next weekend, okay?”
“What? Why not?”
“Just trust me. Please don’t make any plans.”
“Well...okay then.”
“I’m gonna get out of here, I love you, Y/N. I love you so much. Please...don’t change your mind, okay?”
“We’re in it now, so where else is there to go?” you chuckle softly. “I love you too, Andy. Let me know when you’re safe.”
“I always do,” he smiles before kissing your forehead.
He nods towards Sarah before turning and making his way out. Just like that, you feel alone all over again.
“I know I probably shouldn’t be rooting for you two, but you two are just so fucking cute!”
“Sarah,” you scowl and laugh as you get up to make yourself another drink.
“Okay, I gotta ask, what’s the draw? Obviously, it’s not lost on anyone that he’s fucking fine, but what makes him worth...everything?”
“I’m safe with him,” you shrug. “When I’m with Andy, I’m home. My brain never shuts off and it’s always so fucking loud, but with Andy...I’m so calm. Nothing is scary, stressful, or tiring. When I’m with him, I just feel light. Yeah, the one time we had sex was amazing, but it’s so much more than a physical desire. It always has been. We’ve been on so many car rides, had so many conversations, helped each other cope with so much...he just knows me. He gets me, ya know? He’s my home.”
“God, I’m so fucking jealous of you,” she scoffs as she scarfs down her drink.
“What? Why?”
“I want Jacob to feel the same way about me. I want us to have what you and Andy have.”
“Sarah, stop it. You know Jacob is head over heels-”
“I own half his heart, babe,” she smiles softly, getting up and making her way over to the counter to make another drink.
“What do you mean?”
“Oh, come on. You can’t tell me that you don’t know.”
“Sarah, what the fuck are you talking about?”
“Jacob is in love with you.”
“Stop it! That’s horseshit and you know it!”
“Do you know how many times I’ve tried to talk myself into believing that? It’s infuriating at times, because I know you have no interest in him, but I see it in him. I see it, how he looks at you, the way he always comes to you for council; like he did tonight-”
“Sarah, there is no one on this planet that Jacob loves more than you. Jacob loves me, but he’s not in love with me.”
“You really are as pure they come,” she chuckles softly, shaking her head.
“What are you talking about?”
“Y/N, I don’t blame you or like, hate you. There was a point in time when I abandoned Jacob, and we basically broke up. Then, when you came into his life, you just trusted him completely. You were always there for him.”
“Sarah-”
“It’s fine,” she smiles sheepishly, trying to ignore her tears, “you don’t want him at all, so why should I be mad?
“Sarah, you’re drunk and-”
“Trust me, I’ve thought about this a lot,” she laughs humorlessly, “this has nothing to do with me drinking.”
“Is this why you want me with Andy so bad?”
“God no,” she scoffs before taking a sip of her drink, “if anything, it’ll make it worse, but you’ll be happy. You’ll be happy and so will Andy. I don’t tell you that you’re my best friend to make you smile, I say it because you really are my best friend. I want you to succeed, I want you to be happy, and I want things to work out in your favor. I’ve seen all the hurt you’ve gone through and I want better for you.”
“Sarah...why do you-”
“Stay with Jacob? Because I love him,” she states as if it’s the most obvious thing in the world. “He’s never going to cheat on me with you and you’d never let him. He’ll get over it at some point.”
“This isn’t fair or right. I’m ruining everyone’s life.”
“You’re not ruining shit. What’s wrong between Andy and Laurie is on her, and there’s nothing wrong between Jake and I. In all honesty, I don’t even think he knows. That’s part of the reason I didn’t want to meet you in high school,” she laughs, taking a long sip of her drink. “I knew he had a thing for you, but we were trying to work things out. We always joked about being the old couple that were once childhood sweethearts. I was terrified of meeting you, because I was terrified of seeing the person who would take him away from me, but then I met you,” she laughs. “It was so evident how much you weren’t into him.You made it so easy to love you and get to know you, and honestly? I get it. The way you describe Andy? That’s how you make everyone else feel. You don’t understand how much of yourself you give to people. Even if it’s just for a moment, you make people feel like they’re safe, like they have a home. It’s not hard at all too see why Andy is so in love with you.”
You’re thoughtful before you speak: “Sarah, can I ask you something?”
“You can ask me anything.”
“What did you and Andy talk about at the Christmas party?”
“I was wondering if you’d ever ask,” she chuckles. “We talked about you and the relationship you two could have. He’s so fucking in love with you. He said that the only reason he hadn’t made a move was because he wanted you to be as happy as you made him. I told him that he can do that by being with you, but he shook his head. He insisted that you two being together would only complicate your life more, but he wanted nothing more than to be with you. I told him that he’s the piece of your life that’s been missing and he said you’d be happier with someone else, that he didn’t want to weigh you down. So, I asked him why he was willing to suffer if he knew you felt the same way he did.”
“And?”
“He said he’d be willing to take on all of the pain and suffering in the world if it meant you’d be happy,” she smiles softly.
“Fuck!”
“Y/N-”
“Sarah...you don’t get it. Before I met Andy, I didn’t even feel like I could breathe. Last night, it was all so simple because there was no Laurie and Jacob. No thought of them.We were in our own little world and we were happy. It was peaceful, full of love, happiness, and for once, my life wasn’t a complete shit show. He’s been trying so hard to get her to sign the fucking papers...there were times I completely forgot about Jake. How shitty does that make me? I didn’t think about my own best fucking friend!”
“Babe, you’ve spent the better part of your young adult life looking out for Jake. When it comes to love, you’re allowed to be selfish.”
“Sarah, what the fuck am I gonna do?” you sob as your phone buzzes.
You’re quick to take it out and check, and a smile is instantly painted on your face when you see that it’s Andy.
My Heart: Had to stop to pick up a few things for this weekend, but I’m safe. I love you so much, honey. Counting down the seconds until I can see you again, because I miss the fuck out of you. The day we start living together is gonna be the best fucking day. Please don’t drink too much, okay? We’re gonna figure all this shit out. I love you.
“Sarah, I can’t quit him and I don’t want to.”
“Then don’t,” she smiles at you reassuringly, “fight like hell to make it work.”
As you and Sarah go back to drinking and dancing the night away, one thought is clearer in your mind than it’s ever been: you and Andy are meant to be with one another. By no means will any of it be easy, but you’re more than ready to fight like hell for the love of your life.
You’re more than ready to fight like hell for Andy Barber.
**
Laurie’s P.O.V.
“Andy, can you stop packing for five fucking minutes?!” I sob as he continues to load his clothes into his duffle bag.
“Laurie, I’ve told you multiple times that I’m done, and you won’t fucking hear it. I don’t know what else to do,” he shrugs, a look of pure indifference on his face.
“Andy-”
“You’re the one that cheated. Without saying it out loud, you decided that you don’t want this anymore. You don’t want us. So, I’m moving on. I’ve moved on!”
“Andy, no. You think you’ve moved on, but you’re just-”
“Laurie, I don’t love you. I have no desire to work this out, and I never will again. Please, just let it go and sign the goddamn papers!”
“You just need time,” I sob as he throws up his hands and scowls.
That’s what he used to say to me all the time, and it always worked like a charm; he could always bring me back. However, now? It seems like a lie. I’ve been using the same line for practically a year, and for what? The more I say it, the less he wants me.
Maybe that’s the difference. He was fighting for someone who he truly loved, and somewhere deep inside, I loved him back. Now? I’ve pushed him away so much that he truly is finished with all of this, but now I finally wanna come back.
I finally see what’s worth fighting for.
“Where are you even living now?”
“It doesn’t matter. What matters is that I’m gone for good, and you need to sign the damn papers.”
“You don’t need to be so cold!”
“That seems to be the only way that you’ll respond,” he huffs before closing his bag. “Laurie, at one point, we were lovers and best friends. We have Jacob. I don’t want this to get ugly, so please don’t let it get to that point. He’s moving out, we both know he���s gonna propose to Sarah sooner or later, and you and I both know that we’ve run our course. You can have the house, the cars, you can paint me as the bad guy. I truly don’t care. Please, just let me go.”
“Andy, please, lets just go away-”
“I don’t want to go away!” he finally snaps, causing me to jump just a bit.
Hes never been this way with me.
“Laurie,” he sighs dropping his bag, clearly frustrated and worn out “don’t make me be this guy. The angry husband who has to be an asshole. I don’t want to hurt you, I don’t want to upset you, and I don’t want either of us to hate each other. After all is said and done, I still want us to at least be able to have some sort of healthy relationship. It doesn’t have to be something fueled by hate and anger, it can be amicable. I don’t hate you, Laurie, I just don’t love you anymore,” he sighs before picking up his bag. “Think about it, I’ll see you in a few days.”
As he walks away I can’t help but think back to college. Was this all my fault? He never pursued me, I always wanted him.
He never looked for me, I always looked for him.
“You came!” I beamed as the handsome brunette came walking into my dorm room.
“You made it sound like I’d be missing out on something big if I show up,” he chuckled with a bright smile.
I’d been daydreaming about the smile since I first saw it two weeks ago in the campus library.
“You didn’t bring anyone?” I asked, hopeful that I wasn’t about to make myself look like a complete fool.
“No one to bring. I spend most of my time studying or working. That’s why I decided maybe it would be nice to go to a party. Thanks for invitin’ me.”
“Thanks for showing up,” I replied, and I could tell my cheeks were burning red.
From that day on, I looked for him, I waited for him, and I tried to come up with any reason to talk to him, until he finally asked me out. At first, it was exciting and I was enamored with him. Then, after about five months, I started to get lazy and he took notice. It’s not even that I stopped loving him, but I realized I wanted to be young and experience college as a single woman. Neither of us said a thing about it, but I could tell he knew and that I’d hurt him.
Then I started seeing him hanging around with some girl and it made my blood boil.
He was mine.
So, I showed up at his dorm one day and when he opened the door, I practically pounced on him, and of course he didn’t say no. Of course, my little impulsive act ended up with me pregnant, and he was a saint about it. Why wouldn’t he be?
Andy is the sweetest soul on earth; he always has been.
Everything was perfect for a while. Even with school being as demanding as it was, Andy was a loving and doting father. I wasn’t surprised that he proposed, and I was more than happy to say yes. I wanted nothing more than to devote myself to him forever.
For a while, it was perfect. We had the perfect life. Sure, I looked at other men sometimes, just wondering what it would be like to have the freedom to do whatever I wanted, but I never acted on anything. I had a good life, why mess it up?
Then, Jacob’s trial.
Even after everything that happened; the arguments, the trial, the sleeping in separate rooms...the accident...he still treated me like I was the center of his universe, and loved me unconditionally.
But I felt betrayed.
How could he not tell me about his father? Yeah, it’s his life and he’s allowed his secrets, but I’m his wife! So, after all was said and done, even with him being as amazing as he was, I still cheated. I cheated because I wanted him to feel as betrayed as I did. I seduced his best friend, best man at our wedding, and fucked him in the backseat of our car. It should’ve been quick and dirty, but I fucked up and let it turn into something that it should’ve never been.
It was nice to feel like I was a priority, to feel beautiful, and just get away from the weight that now comes with being a Barber. The flowers, gifts, the sneaking...it all felt new and exciting. I felt young again.
Andy started to notice of how distant I was becoming and offered to take me on a trip, or pay for me to go on my own trip, and that’s when the guilt set in. I was out being the world’s worst wife, and he was still trying to take care of me. So, I broke off the relationship and came clean to Andy.
He didn’t even say a word, and to be honest, he didn’t need to. The look in his eyes told me everything. I had crushed him and instantly felt terrible. I was so ready for him to demand a divorce, and a small part of me wanted him to, but he just stormed out and spent the rest of the night driving around. Of course, Andy being the amazing man he is, came back in the morning and told me he loved me and wanted to work it out.
That should’ve been enough for me and I should’ve been happy, but of course I wasn’t. I dug my nails in and did my best to make sure that no one would ever be able to steal him from me, including making sure he never met Y/N. Yes I’m the one that made the mess, and it was obvious that she’d done nothing wrong, but still. Enough people talk and word gets around. It was irrational, mean, and dumb, but I wasn’t going to take any chances.
All my hard work and it did nothing.
I messed everything up out of pure fear and jealousy, but it was nowhere near as bad as the last time. I knew it pushed him to his wits end, but it’s something I know we can make our way back from it.
But now? After that dinner for Jacob and Sarah?
God, the way he looked at Y/N that night? Is she the one he’s in love with? No, she can’t be. It’s just not possible. He wouldn’t do that to Jacob, and she’s so damn young. 24? 25? He’d never go for someone her age.
No, whoever has his attention...I can fix it. I can make it right and do better this time. I know it took me forever to realize it, but I truly do love Andy, and I’ll do anything I can to prove that to him.
I can fix this.
Y/N’s P.O.V
“What?!” you snap as you answer your phone, making your way into your loft.
“What did I do? I’m sorry,” Andy starts and you instantly feel bad.
“I didn’t check my phone before I answered. I’m sorry, what’s up?”
“What’s wrong, sweetheart?”
“Don’t worry about it.”
“Sweetheart, talk to me.”
“I’m just fucking fed up.”
“With what?”
“With everything!”
“Baby, what happened?”
“Fucking...Andy, I miss you,” you sigh as you sit down on your bed, kicking off your shoes before taking your hair out of a ponytail and laying down.
“I miss you too, honey. Talk to me, what happened?”
“I don’t want to talk about it right now.”
“How can I help?”
“Come over.”
“I can’t, I’m gonna see you tomorrow though.”
“Why not now?”
“You’ll know tomorrow.”
“I need you now.”
“What do you need?”
“For you to make me feel better.”
Andy chuckles before responding,” how can I make you feel better right now?”
“I wanna see you.”
In just a matter of moments your phone is buzzing and you know it’s Andy FaceTiming you.
“Where are you?” he asks, looking over you as much as he can as you unbutton the top two buttons on your blouse.
“I’m home, in bed.”
“Now, how am I supposed to make you feel better if you’re in bed?”
“I think you know, daddy,” you pout as you continue to unbutton your blouse.
“It hasn’t even been a full week, sweetheart,” he chuckles, but his gaze is intense.
“You made me feel so good.”
“Only once and you’re already so desperate?”
“Please come over, daddy.”
“No, but I’ll watch you get yourself off,” he states with an authoritative voice.
And just like that, your pussy is more than desperate for him.
“Daddy-”
“Lick two fingers then rub your clit.”
“Please-”
“Don’t be a brat. Do what daddy told you to.”
“Fuck,” you sigh, bringing one of your hands to your mouth, licking and sucking two of your fingers, then hiking up your skirt and pushing your panties to the side and playing with your clit. “Daddy,” you moan pathetically.
“What do you want me to do to you?”
“I want...I want you to eat my pussy so bad! It felt so good having your tongue on me!”
“Yeah? What else, baby?”
“Daddy, please just come over. I haven’t seen or felt you all week and I’m going crazy! I miss you so much,” you whine pathetically.
“I feel the same, honey, but if I come over, I won’t leave. Just gotta wait, sweetheart,” he broods as you hear him undo his belt buckle and unzip his pants. “Now, tell daddy what else you want him to do to you.”
“I need to feel your lips on me. I need you to kiss me like you did when you were carrying me up the steps, I need to feel just how much you love me before you’re mean to me!”
“Mean to you how?”
“Make me choke on your fat cock, daddy! Make me take every inch of it, then fuck me like a slut, please!”
“Jesus Y/N,” he growls, “lick your fingers then tell me how you taste,” he demands, voice rough and coarse.
“Mmm, so fucking good!”
“Shit, I can only fucking imagine! Now, be a good girl and start fucking yourself with those fingers, baby. Fuck yourself and cum hard for daddy.”
“Shit, I miss you so much, daddy!”
“I miss you too, baby. Can’t fucking wait...can’t wait to see you and bend you over tomorrow!”
“Jesus daddy!”
“Gonna spread those fucking legs and eat that pussy so good, then I’m gonna taste that ass...fuck!”
“Shit!” you cry out, cumming hard, and almost dropping your phone.
“Fuck, sweetheart!” Andy groans softly as you see bits of his cum landing on a desk.
“Where...where are you, daddy?”
He takes his time, collecting himself and regulating his breathing, before he answers, “at work.”
“Andy!”
“It’s alright,” he laughs softly, “no one’s here and the door is closed.”
“You can’t do that, daddy.”
“Well, I can’t exactly do this where I live.”
“You could’ve come over.”
“I told you, sweetheart; if I would’ve come over, I wouldn’t have been able to leave.”
“It’s not like that’s a bad thing,” you sigh, finally meeting his warm and loving gaze.
“What’s wrong, baby?”
“Nothing.”
“You’ve had an attitude all week, you’ve been distant, and I know you were crying before you answered the phone last night.”
“Andy-”
“What’s wrong?”
“I just hate this fucking week.”
“Why?”
“I haven’t seen you, my mother is in one of her rage moods; which is apparently my fault cause I don’t go and see her, my fucking heel broke the other day and I stepped in a fucking puddle, my boss actually fucking put his hand on my upper thigh today-”
“I’m sorry, he did what?”
“It’s fine-”
“It’s not fucking fine!”
“Andy, calm down. It’s fine, I told him it made me uncomfortable and-”
“We’re finding you a new job.”
“You’re sweet,” you chuckle softly, sitting up and taking off your blouse, “I have bills to pay.”
“We’ll live together soon enough, it won’t matter.”
“Yeah okay,” you scoff. “Don’t you have to get home to your wife?”
“Don’t. That’s not fair and you know it.”
“Yeah, that’s not fair,” you mutter, rolling your eyes before getting up.
“Sweetheart-”
“Do you fuck her?”
“You know I don’t, I don’t even sleep in the same bed as her!”
“You still live in the same fucking house.”
“Honey, what’s going on?”
“I’m lonely, Andy!” you finally snap as you grab a glass. “It’s been a fucking week and I...I heard you say what you said, I haven’t seen you since, Jacob’s been telling me that he secretly wants you two to work it out, and...what the fuck am I doing?!”
Andy lets out a heavy sigh and it only makes you feel worse. “Do you just wanna break this off now?”
“No,” you sniffle, trying to control your emotions, “I love you. I love you so much, and I just want to be with you, but all of this-”
“It’s not always going to be like this, honey.”
“Andy, are you sure you want this? Are you sure you want me?”
“I’m coming over.”
“Andy-”
“No, I’m on way. I’ll see you in a bit, I love you.”
With that, he hung up and you’re left to wonder what the fuck is going on. For as much as Andy wants to be divorced, he isn’t. For as much as Andy loves you, he still isn’t with you completely. For as good of a mam Andy Barber is, he still isn’t only yours.
But God, does he want to be.
Why are you picking a fight with him? Why are you trying to hurt him? It’s more than obvious that he just wants to love and be with you. Hes spent the entire week staying late in his office, listening to you bitch and complain about your week (at least what you were willing to tell him), and he promised constantly that it would get better. He promised that this wouldn’t be how it’ll always go. He promised that you two would be openly together, and he’d have no issue being with you in front of everyone who has something negative to say.
He told you a million times that he loves you and just how much.
However, there’s still fear, worry, and guilt. Fear that he’ll decide you’re not enough and leave, worry that you’ll fuck it up because you’ve never actually been in a good or healthy relationship, and guilt because you’re sneaking around and lying to Jacob. Yes, Andy was unhappy and trying to get out of his marriage before he met you, but he wasn’t fully committed to it until he met you.
What if Jacob thinks that you’re the one who broke up his family? What if he lashes out at you? What if your best friend decides that he wants to walk out of your life for good? Could you really handle that? Would Andy be able to handle his son being that furious? Would he still choose you?
Yeah, he says that he’s all in and wants nothing more than forever with you, but what happens-
The sharp knock on your door pulls you out of your thoughts.
The second you open the door, Andy’s lips are on yours and he’s picking you up. His grip on you is tight as you wrap your legs around him, finally feeling some relief at simply the feel of him.
“Am I sure that I want you? Am I sure that I want us? Honey, I’m never changing my mind,” he whispers, showering soft kisses all along your neck.
“Andy,” you whisper, running your hands through his hair, not caring if anyone sees the two of you.
“You are my whole world now, sweetheart,” he husks as he kicks your door closed. “I desire you. I burn for you. I crave you.”
“Baby please,” you whimper, letting your hands travel down and unbuttoning the first few buttons of his shirt.
“I want you by my side every second of every day,” he confesses softly, as one hand reaches around and unclasps your bra.
“I...I missed you so much, Andy.”
“I missed you too, baby,” he coos and lays you down, looking you over as he pulls off your bra. “You’re so perfect, sweetheart.”
“You think so, baby?” you moan as you unbutton the rest of his shirt, gripping him tighter with your legs as he takes it off.
“Mhm, I think you were made just for me,” he husks as he unbuckles his belt and unzips his pants. “I think you’re the most perfect woman I’ve ever known and most beautiful woman I’ve ever seen.”
“Then show me, Andy. Take your time and show me,” you beg, unzipping your skirt, right before he pulls it and your panties down.
“I’ll take all night if I have to.”
He dips down and kisses you gently, but there’s an urgency to it, and you instantly know he understands. He knows that this isn’t just about sex; it’s about intimacy and vulnerability. It’s about understanding and honesty.
It’s about trust and love.
“Fuck,” you softly sigh as he thrusts himself inside of you, “I missed you.”
“Finally fucking home, baby,” he groans as he moves slowly and deeper within you.
You cup his face and keep his focus on you, softly stroking the side of it as you try and hold on for the ride. He keeps hitting that spot in you that makes you feel everything all at once, but you’re not ready to reach that euphoric moment. Yeah, it’s only been a week, but Andy was right: you finally feel like you’re home.
“You don’t think I’ve been thinking about you all week? You don’t think I’ve wanted anything more than to be with you?”
“Andy...baby, I just...I needed you here!”
“We’ll be together soon, my love,” he coos as he starts to pick up his pace, “why are you denying me what I want?”
“Want...wanna make it last,” you whine as you arch your back a little, trying to feel as much of him as possible.
“We’ve got all night, baby. Please...give it to me,” he begs earnestly as he rests his head in the crook of your neck. “Let me feel you, I’ve needed it all fucking week!”
“Oh God!”
“I want every part of you, every day, forever, baby!”
“Andy...oh God, Andy YES!” you whimper as you claw at his back. “I can’t...fuck, I can’t...fuck!” you sob as you clench around him.
“The way you squeeze me...honey, you are so perfect!”
“Shit!” you cry out, squirting hard on his cock as you grip him tight.
“So fucking good for me,” he husks as his seed spills into you.
You both stay that way for a moment; lost in each other’s embrace, no sound except each other’s labored breathing, and taking each other in.
This is what you needed. You needed him, his love, and his touch. Sure, you’ve only had his embrace only once before, but all it takes is once. Andy makes you feel everything at once, and it’s something you’ll always need and never tire of. When he loves you like this, kisses you endlessly, and holds you close, you know exactly why you’ll never be able to give him up.
Why you’ll never want to.
“I love you,” he breathes after a moment. “I love you so much, Y/N, and I’m all in. I’m all in for as long as you want me.”
“What if I want you forever?”
“Then I’m in this forever. You’re not gonna scare me off, Laurie isn’t going to scare me into staying, the town can go to hell...I love you. I’m madly in love with you, and nothing’s ever going to change that.”
“Show me.”
“Like I said, baby; we’ve got all night.”
You and Andy spend the next few hours tangled up in your sheets, and getting lost in one another. He doesn’t even bother to answer his phone as it constantly goes off; determined to show you just how in love and dedicated he is to you. Every kiss awakens something in you, every touch sets your skin alight, and every thrust is filled with passion.
Andy is yours just as much you’re his, and no matter how messy things may get, that’s never going to change.
When the both of you finally tire each other out, you both lay back on your bed, and Andy holds you close while you lay your head on his chest.
“You have to go back tonight?” you ask as you make little circles on his chest.
“Unfortunately,” he sighs before kissing the top of your head, “but I promise tomorrow will make you extremely happy.”
“Why can’t you just tell me?”
“Because that’ll ruin the shocked look on your face tomorrow, and I’ve dreaming of seeing it,” he chuckles and you smile to yourself. “We should order dinner.”
“More like we should make dinner.”
“It can’t be that late.”
“Babe, look at my alarm clock. It’s 9:30,” you laugh and Andy chuckles before pressing a soft kiss into your hair.
“Guess I got carried away, I’m sorry.”
“I’m not,” you giggle, “what do you wanna eat?”
“Well, I already had my favorite meal-”
“Andy!” you laugh as you playfully hit his chest.
“So, I’m fine with whatever.”
“Freezer food okay? I haven’t gone grocery shopping yet.”
“Is it stupid that I’m excited about going grocery shopping with you?”
“Why is that something you’re excited about?” you laugh.
“I don’t even know. It feels so normal? I want every experience with you, because I want to spend the rest of my life with you. Something as mundane as grocery shopping feels like it would be an adventure with you,” he chuckles. “Maybe I’m just crazy-”
“Andrew Stephen Barber, I am so in love with you. I can’t wait to do everything with you too,” you smile up at him.
“Lets eat something,” he smirks before dipping down and kissing you passionately.
This man is gonna be the death of you. Andy pulls on his boxer briefs as you pull on the AC/DC crew neck he got you, and you both make your way into the kitchen.
“Okay, I have lasagna, hot pockets, anytizers-”
“What do you want?” he asks, wrapping his arms around you as he presses soft kisses along the column of your neck.
“It’s really hard to think when you kiss me like that,” you moan as you lull your head back.
“I’m sure my good girl can think of something,” he presses before lightly licking the side of your neck with the tip of his tongue.
“Daddy...please,” you whimper, getting all worked up again. “We’ve gotta eat.”
“I know what I wanna eat, baby, and it’s nothing that’s in your freezer,” he husks as he hoists you up and places you on the counter top, quickly getting on his knees.
“Daddy-”
“Let daddy enjoy his favorite meal,” he smirks up at you before pushing the bottom of your crew neck up and licking your clit.
“Daddy, we have to...shit, just like that,” you whimper as grip his hair tight, the feeling of his tongue fucking you while he massages your clit with his thumb driving you insane. “You eat my pussy so good, daddy.”
“My perfect, desperate little girl,” he murmurs before sucking on your clit and sliding two fingers into your weeping cunt.
“Oh...daddy,” you moan as you lull your head back against one of your kitchen cabinets.
Needless to say, you two end up back in bed.
Andy loves you until you’re barely able to stand, telling you just how much he loves you and can’t wait to be with you like he really wants to. As he holds close while you drift off, there’s only one thought that runs through your mind:
Andrew Stephen Barber will never stop being the love of your life.
Andy’s P.O.V
“You’re home late,” Laurie mutters with a slight slur as I make my way into the house.
“This isn’t my home anymore, Laurie,” I sigh, taking off my suit jacket and heading to the kitchen.
“You reek of sex.”
“That’s because I just had sex, Laurie.”
“So, you’re cheating now?”
“Cheating would imply that we have some sort of a functioning marriage, which we don’t,” I scowl as pull a package of bread out of the cabinet.
“So, who is it? Who are you so in love with that you don’t want to try anymore? Is it her?” she asks, folding her arms across her chest, losing her balance a little.
“Her who?”
“Andy, don’t be an asshole. Y/N.”
I want to say yes so fucking bad, but I can’t do that to you. I won’t say anything until you’re ready.
“What is your obsession with her?” I scoff, taking ham and cheese out of the fridge.
“You seem to be in love with her, and Jacob is in love with her-”
“I barely know her and Jacob’s in love with Sarah.”
“Well, who is it?”
“Why on earth would I tell you that? So you can go and harass her?”
“Andy, you used to-”
“Laurie, you cheated on me twice, you treat Jacob like shit-”
“I do not!”
“Yeah, alright,” I scoff, putting my sandwich together, wishing I had taken you up on your lasagna offer.
“She’s so fucking great, but she can’t feed you?”
I open my mouth to tell her that my favorite meal today was that perfect little pussy between your legs, but stop short and just scoff and shake my head instead.
‘That’ll be taking it too far, Andy,’ I think to myself.
“I’ve had a long day and I don’t feel like arguing with you, Laurie. That and you’re drunk, so there’s really no point. I’m going to sleep.”
“When are you telling, Jacob, huh? When are you going to tell him that you’re moving out? That you’re fine with breaking up our family?”
“Laurie, you broke up this family when you purposely drove your truck into a wall, trying to kill our son, and when you spread your legs for my best friend.”
“You know that accident was just that! An accident!”
“Whatever you need to tell yourself to get through the day. Listen, I told you, you can paint me as the bad guy to everyone, you can keep everything, I don’t care. All I want is for you to sign the damn papers. There’s no sense in arguing about this anymore, I’m done. I’ve moved on and I’m happier than I’ve ever been. If you ever truly loved me, if you claim to love me now, then please just sign the damn papers,” I practically beg, feeling a little pain at the tears welling up in her eyes.
I don’t know how else to get through to her.
“Andy, whoever this new woman is that you’re in love with...it’s not going to work out. She’s just gonna hurt you.”
“You say that like you haven’t a thousand times already.”
“I didn’t get it before and I’m sorry. I made mistakes and I know I hurt you, but I can do better now. I will do better!”
“Laurie-”
“Andy please,” she sobs, slowly making her way over to me, “let me show you how much I’ve changed. Give me a month-”
“Laurie, please don’t make this harder than it already is. I just don’t want this anymore...I don’t want you. I don’t want to hurt you, but I just can’t do this anymore. Please, just let this-”
“You loved me before, I know you can love me again,” she whispers before standing on her tiptoes and kissing me.
Nothing. I feel absolutely nothing. It breaks my heart, because there once was a time when I lived for her kisses, but now? Now, nothing. If I’m being honest, I’m almost repulsed. She’s not the woman I fell in love with, but to be fair, I’m not the man she fell in love with.
I’m not sure if I ever really was.
“Sleep in our room tonight, please,” she pleads softly as she takes a step back.
“I’ll be in the spare room downstairs,” I sigh, looking away as her tears start to fall, “I’ll be gone by the time you wake up. I’m moving the last bit of my stuff, and I’ll do my best not to wake you.”
“Andy, please-”
“Goodnight Laurie.”
I quickly make my way downstairs, throwing out the sandwich I made, no longer having an appetite, before getting undressed and stepping into the shower.
This isn’t how I wanted any of this to go, but I don’t know why I expected any of this to go easy. Once Laurie sinks her claws in and sets her sights on something, she doesn’t give up easily. Still, this shouldn’t be the shit show that it is. It shouldn’t be this hard to get some damn closure and just move on. Laurie and I have run our course and I’m so damn tired of this shit.
Tonight with you? It was perfect, but fuck if I don’t hate myself for making you question everything. Question me. I never wanted to be a person in your life that makes you question whether or not love is real, or if it actually even matters. How could I say something that made you feel so horrible less than 24 hours after you completely gave yourself to me? After you told me you trust me completely?
I want everything and every day with you, forever.
If Jacob end up hating me, then so be it. If Laurie rains down all hell fire on my head, then I’ll just deal with it. Nothing and no one is gonna stop me from being with you. Grocery shopping, picking out furniture for our home, taking trips, coming home to you daily...all of these things and more make my heart burst with excitement and pure love.
It’s not lost on me that people are going to see me with you and think that I’m obsessed with someone who’s younger than me, and I’m not gonna lie and say it doesn’t boost my ego a bit, but it’s so much more than that. You are the most selfless and thoughtful person I’ve ever known. The way you would stick up for Jacob in high school to the point that you would get into fist fights, you would go out of your way to make sure he always felt included, the fact that you got a job to help out with the bills even though it wasn’t on you to fix the damage your father had done, how you took care of your mother after your father abandoned the both of you...
Even now, you’re just taking all of this in stride. Keeping secrets you shouldn’t have to, being so much nicer to Laurie than you should be, keeping Jacob’s feelings in mind, being patient with me while I figure all of this out...you’re so fucking gracious, sweet, and thoughtful. It honestly infuriates me that everyone else just constantly lets you down, over some shit you didn’t even do.
I refuse to be another person that hurts you. I’m gonna stick by you and I’m not leaving your side, come hell or high water, I will be with you and we’ll make it work.
Y/N’s P.O.V
You don’t make much of a fuss about getting out of bed, since you’re a bit sore from your long night with Andy. You’d hoped he’d be good in bed, but you didn’t think he’d be that amazing in bed.
It’s not like you have any complaints. Andy can do whatever he wants to you, and in the end, all you’ll do is thank him and beg for more. No, it’s not necessarily a healthy concept, but there’s comfort in knowing that Andy feels the same way you do. Somehow, the second time around was better than the first.
Probably because you two were both sober this time.
As you roll around in bed, trying to decide if you have the energy to actually start your day, your mind plays over everything Andy said last night; both when he was inside of you and when he wasn’t.
It’s hard not to give into the fear of it all, but how can you not trust him? The way he looks at you, the way he holds you, the way he smiles at you, the way he loves you...it’s all so damn genuine, you know that he means it. He’s not telling you what you want to hear so he can keep getting access to your pussy; it’s obvious that he means every word.
You just have to find the strength to believe everything he’s saying is true.
You’re finally ready to get out of bed when your phone buzzes. The smile that comes to your face almost hurts when you see that it’s Andy. However, you’re completely confused when you open it and see that hes sent you an address.
Y/N: Huh?
My Heart: Meet me here as fast as you can, and bring clothes for the weekend.
Y/N: What’s going on?
My Heart: You’ll see when you get here, so don’t take too long. I love you and I’ll see you soon.
Well, now you’re wide awake and full of energy.
You quickly get out of bed and make your way to your shower, doing your best to ignore all of the anxiety that you feel. They’re not exactly bats in your stomach, but they sure as shit aren’t butterflies. By the time you’re dressed and ready to go , you feel like you’re gonna lose your mind.
Just an address? What the hell does that mean? Yeah, hes talked about you two moving in together all the time, but so soon? When Laurie hasn’t even signed the papers yet?
That’s another thing; how the hell is going to get to her to sign the papers? He’s entirely too kind to actually pressure her into signing the papers, but he’s also fed up with everything. What the hell does he have up his sleeve?
When you finally reach the destination, you’re in pure shock and awe.
What the hell?
“Andy...what is this?” you question as you get out of the car.
“I’ve officially moved out,” he smiles as he wraps his arms around you and dips down to kiss you.
“Someone could see,” you smile sheepishly as you turn your head away from him.
“Who cares?”
“Andy-”
“I told you that I told her I’m in love with someone else, and when she told me I reeked of sex last night, I told her it was because I had sex. I’m not hiding anything from her, because I truly don’t care. No, I haven’t told her that I’m with you, but the second you give me the okay, I’m telling her. I love you, Y/N. I want this. I want us.”
“Andy...,” you start to tear “is this house...?”
“It’s a condo I got for me, but when you’re ready, I would love for it to be ours. There’s no pressure, and we’ll take this at whatever pace you want, but I’m all in,\. I know they’re things you need to figure out on your end, and I’m perfectly fine waiting while you figure it out-”
“How will we tell Jacob?” you interrupt, trying to suppress every emotion you’re feeling as you keep looking over the gorgeous house.
“I was thinking we’d talk about that today,” he smiles at you.
“Is Laurie any closer to signing the papers?”
“I can tell that she’s starting to realize that I’m serious.”
“Andy...are you sure-”
“I love you and I’ve never been more sure of anything. If you don’t want this, I’ll completely understand and I won’t be mad in the slightest, but if you really do want to do this-”
“I know I can’t move in right away, but I’d like to keep some of my stuff here. I’d like to have...I’d like to have my own key,” you almost whisper, trying to convince yourself that all of this actually happening.
“You’re in luck,” he chuckles as he takes a key out from his pocket, “I already had one made for you. This is your home too, sweetheart.”
“Andy-”
“I genuinely want everything with you. I love you, Y/N. I love you, I love you, I love you. I will say it every day until you believe it.”
“It’s not that I don’t believe it, Andy, it’s just...this is a lot...it’s everything. I love you so much and I just don’t want to get myself all wrapped up in someone who isn’t-”
“Honey, this is as real as it gets. I love you and want forever with you. That’s never going to change. The moment I laid eyes on you, I was already thinking of ways to see you again. Then, when I helped you move in, seeing just how thoughtful and kind you are...I’ve been in love with you ever since. I know that this is moving kind of fast, but if only you could understand just how deeply and how much I love you...my heart rate speeds up whenever I see you, your smile alone is enough to calm me down and make me come alive at the same time, and your laugh...honey, I could listen to you laugh and talk all day and still want more. I love you, Y/N. I’m madly and truly in love with you,” he finishes with a warm smile as he wipes your tears away.
You don’t know what to say. How can all of this be real? How can he choose you so easily? How is he choosing you at all? And how the hell is he so calm about all of this?
Are you sure you’re awake? Is this actually real?
“This is really happening, it’s not all in your head or some dream,” he chuckles softly as he practically reads your mind.
“Can we go inside and take a look around?” you sniffle after a moment, wiping your eyes.
“Anything you want, honey.”
You don’t mean to gasp when you go inside, but the place is gorgeous and spacious.
How much money does Andy have exactly?
“Now, I had to get some furniture, I didn’t want you coming home to a completely empty house. I figured we’d go shopping for the rest of it together. Out of town, so you don’t have to worry about being seen. I figured we could go tomorrow.”
“Andy, this is gorgeous!”
“Yeah, you really like it?”
“I love it!” you beam, turning around wrapping your arms around him tight. “Give me the full tour,” you smile up at him.
Andy is more than happy to show you around, very clearly excited and happy that you didn’t go running off in the other direction. It all seems so unreal, especially when he shows you the little art studio he set up for you.
“Andy-”
“You told me that you loved to paint when you were younger, but had to stop between work and school. I’m obviously not going to push you, but I want you to feel free to start again. Maybe you’ll fall back in love with it, and if you don’t, this will still be your space to do whatever you want in.”
“You didn’t have to do this for me, Andy. Any of it. I just...how can you love me this much?”
“How can I not love you this much?” he chuckles as he wraps an arm around your waist. “Come on, there’s still the upstairs.”
“Somehow I forgot all about the upstairs,” you laugh along with Andy.
“So,” Andy starts as you both start up the stairs, “there are three bedrooms. I’ve started setting up what I think you’ll want to be our room, but just tell me-”
“Say that again,” you smile up at him once you two reach the top step.
“Hmm? Say what?”
“Our room.”
Andy smiles down at you before cupping your face and giving a soul stirring kiss, “our room,”
“I love you, Andy.”
“I love you too, sweetheart.”
As he shows you each room and leads you down the hallway, you can’t help but wonder why he got a place with three rooms. Yeah, a two bedroom would make sense, a spare room form Jake and Sarah if they ever sleep over, but why three?
“And this is ours,” he smiles at you as he pushes the door open.
It’s amazing how well Andy knows you.
“I know the furniture is a little bland and we can get something else, if you want. There’s a 30 day warranty on everything,” he laughs softly. “I know you prefer then left side, so I set up all my stuff on the right. If you want, I’ll-”
You cut him off by crashing your lips into his and pulling him impossibly closer to you. “You are incredible,” you breathe once you two break apart. “You are so incredible and I am so in love with you.”
“You’re happy?”
“I’m so far past happy, daddy,” you whisper before you start to kiss down his body, “you did really good.”
“Sweetheart, we don’t have to-”
“But I want to, daddy. I really want to,” you plead as you look up at him with your most innocent eyes.
He tries to hide it, but you can see lust and desire in his eyes, and you know he’s about to give you what you want. “Get on the bed,” he demands with a low growl.
“But daddy-”
“You always wanna argue with daddy, and we have to put a stop to that,” he scowls before gripping your hair roughly, “I think that’s exactly what we’re gonna do now.”
“I’m so sorry, daddy,” you whimper, getting more and more desperate for him by the second.
“Oh, you will be, now strip and get on the bed. Don’t make me tell you again.”
And just like that, you’re up on your feet and undressing yourself. Soon enough, you’re naked and in the middle of the bed, waiting for instruction as Andy looks you over.
“Such a gorgeous little girl, but such a dumb little slut. Open those pretty little legs and start playing with your clit.”
All you can do is whine like the bitch in heat that you are as you follow his instructions, trying to hold his burning gaze.
“Daddy,” you moan, closing your eyes and lulling your head back, fighting off a release he hasn’t given you permission for.
“Eyes on me,” he demands hotly, unbuttoning and unzipping his jeans.
When you focus your attention back on him, he’s stroking his angry red cock that’s leaking with pre-cum. “Daddy, please let me-”
“You don’t cum until I say so, little slut. You understand me?”
“Please-”
“Tsk, tsk, tsk, really such a dumb little girl,” he smirks mischievously, “and to think, I was about to eat that perfect little cunt of yours.”
“Daddy please!”
“Guess I’m just gonna teach you how to obey,” he sighs before taking off his shirt and stepping out of his jeans. “What has daddy told you about begging?”
“No-not to,” you breathe, still trying to hold his intense gaze as you watch him take a seat on the edge of the bed.
“So, why do you keep being a whiny little brat?”
“Just want you so...so bad all the time.”
“Is that so? Well, come and sit on daddy’s lap. We’re gonna have a little talk about why you should be a good little girl,” he coaxes, starting to stroke himself again.
You’re quick to make your way over to him, ready to straddle him, before he stops you.
“You’re gonna face that mirror, so you can see how much better it is when you’re a good girl.”
“Daddy-”
“You’re just making it harder for yourself. Now, face the mirror, and take daddy’s cock until you learn how to behave.”
How the hell are you supposed to last? You have no idea.
“Oh God, daddy,” you moan as you slide yourself down on his cock, lulling your head back at the way he still pulls you apart.
“Look at yourself in the mirror, sweet girl,” he coos against your neck, licking it lightly.
“Daddy!”
“I said look!” he snaps before slapping your clit.
“Fuck!” you cry out, looking straight ahead as you start to bounce up and down on his cock.
“That’s a good girl,” he smirks against your neck, “see how your greedy little cunt takes my cock so well?”
All you can do is nod.
“You know daddy doesn’t like it when you don’t use your words,” he scolds before slapping your clit again.
“Fuck daddy! I’m...I-I’m sorry!”
“Now, I’ll ask you again,” he husks as you pick up your pace, “do you see how well your greedy little cunt takes my fat cock so well?”
“Y-yes daddy!”
“All I wanna do is spoil you and make you feel so fucking good,” he groans in a condescending tone, “but you just love to act up. Doesn’t it feel so much better when I don’t have to punish you?”
“Everything you do feels amazing, daddy,” you sob as he starts to massage your tits, pinching your nipples hard.
“Oh, so that’s what it is? My little girl just needs to be treated like a little fucking slut?”
“Daddy please!” you whine, clenching around him, knowing you won’t be able to hold off your release much longer.
“That’s not being a good girl,” he sighs against your neck, slapping your clit again, causing you to yelp; you try and close your legs. “If daddy lets you cum, you’ve gotta watch yourself the whole time. Watch how beautiful you look when you explode for me. You understand?”
“Anything you want! Just please!” you whine, knowing you sound pathetic, but you’re so far beyond blissed out that you don’t fucking care.
“So fucking needy,” he laughs as he starts to massage your clit with two of his fingers, “alright, be a good little whore and cum for daddy.”
In no time at all, you’re screaming out in pleasure, squirting all over his cock and the floor, not feeling an ounce of shame as you see how wrecked you are. Andy’s grip tightens on you, and you’re sure he’s about to cum until he stills you.
“Sweet girl, you made a mess all over my cock,” he chides as you clench around him, knowing he’s going to be just as mean about cleanup.
“I didn’t...I didn’t mean to,” you breathe, trying to come down from your high.
“But you did, and what do good girls do when they make a mess?”
“Clean it up, daddy.”
“Exactly.Get on your knees and clean daddy’s cock.”
“Please-”
“Tsk, tsk, tsk, there you go again,” he sighs, slapping your clit again.
He’s going to fucking ruin you.
You slowly stand up, your legs still unstable, but you’re quick to get on your knees in the little puddle you created. A whimper escapes your lips at the sight of Andy’s cock in front of you, happy to finally be able to take it into your mouth. You lick it softly and moan in satisfaction at the taste of yourself on him.
“Take it, sweet girl,” he husks, gripping your hair as he bucks his hips slightly, “take every fucking inch of it.”
You’re quick to get your mouth on him, desperate to make him feel an ounce of the pleasure he’s made you feel. You soon find that just because you’re eager to do something doesn’t mean it’ll get done.
“C’mon sweet girl, I know can take all of it. Relax your throat for me,” he coos, guiding your head down.
It’s not like it hadn’t dawned on you until now that Andy’s cock is the biggest you’ve ever experienced, but you’re still annoyed with yourself for not prepping for it.
“That’s it...fuck, that’s it! Such a good girl,” he groans as you take him more and more.
You both moan in satisfaction when he finally reaches the back of your throat. He starts guiding you slowly, but the second you start whimpering, he’s rough, picking up the pace.
“Fuck, you’re such a good little whore, baby,” he grunts, his grip white knuckling, “wish you could see how well you’re taking daddy’s cock. Fuck!”
When you start gagging, he pulls you off and you whine in protest.
“What did daddy say about being a whiny little brat?”
“I wanna taste you so bad.”
“Another time, sweet girl. For now, get on the bed and on your hands and knees.”
Once again, it takes you a moment to get yourself together, completely blissed out, but determined not to throw in the towel in until he does.
The bed shifts behind you almost instantly, and you whimper when you feel one of Andy’s hands smooth over your ass cheek.
“Daddy!” you scream out when he smacks it hard.
“Are gonna start behaving?”
“Mhm!”
“Use your words!” he reprimands, slapping your ass harder.
“I’ll be such a good girl, daddy! I promise!” you cry out.
“That’s what I wanna hear,” he praises.
You prepare yourself to feel him thrust inside of you, but are completely caught off guard when you feel his tongue against your folds.
“Holy fuck!”
“Told you, rewards feel so much better than punishments,” he smirks before starting to fuck you with his tongue.
Between the lewd slurping sounds between your legs, and Andy’s groans of approval, you lull your head back and get lost in that blissful state only he can bring you to. You’re right on the edge when Andy replaces his tongue with his fingers, and before you can protest, you feel his tongue licking your asshole, and you arch your back, gripping the sheets to keep yourself upright.
“Y-you make me feel so fucking good! I swear to fuck!”
All Andy does is slap your ass in approval and it makes you clench tighter around his fingers.
Never in a million years did you ever think Andy would or could be this dominant or controlling. The same man who loves late night ice cream drives and is insanely romantic to you: the quiet and shy guy, the loving father. He cuddles you close during movie night while also the same guy who dominates the fuck out of you, making you feel like the dirty little slut you secretly are.
“You ever been fucked in this perfect little hole, sweet girl?” Andy asks, making little circles around your asshole with his finger.
“N-no daddy!”
“At some point this weekend, we should fix that,” he husks before removing his fingers from your weeping cunt, “but for now, I’m gonna use you as my little cum dump.”
“Fuck, please daddy!” you sob as he thrusts himself inside of you.
“Are those pretty little tears for me?” he coos condescendingly, reaching down between your legs and rubbing little circles on your overstimulated clit.
“Never felt so fu...so fucking good!”
“Yeah? Show me just how much by cumming for me right now,” he demands with a throaty grunt as his movements become erratic.
“Fu...fu...FUCK!” you shout with a sob, squirting all over all his cock and the bed.
“Sweet girl,” he growls, dipping down and resting his forehead on your back as he coats your inner walls with his seed. “Such a good fucking girl.”
Andy rides out both your highs before letting you down gently and collapsing next to you. He instantly pulls you close, and you cuddle up against him; feeling loved, full, happy, and content.
“Was I too rough with you?” he asks after a moment, softly making little circles on the small of your back.
“No baby,” you all but mumble, trying to stay awake.
“You promise?”
“I swear.”
“I love you so much, honey.”
“You are my world, Andy. I still can’t believe you did all of this for us. It’s so...I’ve never felt so loved or cared for in my life, and I’m trying to accept that all of this is real, it’s just gonna take a bit. I’m so afraid you’re gonna wake up one day and decide I’m not worth all of this and walk away. Everyone always walks away.”
“Honey, I told you I’m all in and I mean that. This isn’t a phase and I’m not looking to fuck around. I’m in love with you, so fucking in love. That’s not changing.”
Now you’re crying for a completely different reason.
“I’m so happy, Andy. Thank you.”
“Get some rest, sweetheart.”
As you drift off to sleep, feeling safe and secure in Andy’s arms, you slowly feel your fears and insecurities fall away.
Maybe this all can work out.
**
When you wake up, the sun is setting, the TV is on, and you’re alone in bed. You grab your phone, (ignoring all of your notifications) and see that it’s 5:30.
You would sleep the day away.
You’re slow to get out of bed and make your way over to his drawers, quickly grabbing one of his sweaters since your clothes are still in the car. A smile comes to your as the memories of what took place earlier play in your head.
It wasn’t a dream.
You quietly make your way down the steps, listening for Andy, but when you hear him the backyard, your smile quickly fades.
“Laurie, I’m not having this talk when you’re drunk...Jacob took Sarah away this weekend and when he comes back, he’s moving out. You know that’s why I did it this way...he’s not going to notice anything, he’ll be too busy taking out all of his packed boxes...I’ll tell him when I finish helping him and Sarah move into their new place....I would imagine Y/N is gonna be there, she is their best friend...don’t start that shit again....I’ll tell him about her when we’re both ready...well, we wouldn’t still be married if you’d sign the damn papers, now would we?...God, don’t start with the tears...listen, I’m gonna go. Please don’t call me again, unless it’s to tell me you’ve signed the papers,” he finishes with a frustrated sigh before hanging up and tossing his phone down and taking a seat on one of the lawn chairs.
“I’m guessing she’s not taking the move well,” you practically whisper.
“Hey,” he smiles at you, but his eyes show just how frustrated he is.
“Andy-”
“Don’t start, honey. Come here.”
You slowly walk over to him and pulls you down into his lap and holds you close.
“Do not worry about Laurie, I can handle her.”
“You wouldn’t have to if I hadn’t-”
“Stop that, you didn’t do anything.”
“I kissed you.”
“I was in love with you long before that kiss, sweetheart. Besides, I was the one who begged you to let me take you home.”
“Baby-”
“You said it yourself; this is gonna get harder before it gets easier. Laurie can cry and complain all she wants to, it’s not going to change anything.”
“What about Jacob?” you mumble, cuddling up and curling in to him.
“That’s up to you. I told you; you set the pace.”
You’re thoughtful before you speak, “after graduation and the proposal. Those are both really special days, and I know that this will ruin it for him,” you softly sigh.
“Babe, he’s gonna get over it.”
“Will he, Andy? Sarah and Laurie are convinced that he’s in love with me-”
“Because he is.”
“Oh, not you too!”
“You can’t tell me that you don’t see it.”
“I don’t because he’s not!”
Andy just sighs and presses kiss to your forehead, “okay, honey.”
“Besides, if that is true, he’s probably never going to talk to me again.”
“He’ll get over it. Yes, he is going to be upset and overreact, but he’ll get over it. You’re his best friend and, at some point, he’ll get over it.”
“Andy-”
“Listen, if it’s too much for you-”
“It’s not,” you quickly interject, “you’re worth all of this and more. I just...I have to prepare myself.”
“We’re this together, sweetheart,” he promises, pressing a soft kiss into your hair.
“ ‘Roman Holiday’ was on when I got up.”
“I planned that perfectly,” he laughs softly.
“I think I’d like for us to do that one day. Have our own Roman Holiday.”
“Yeah?”
“Mhm,” you nod as a small smile comes to your face, “I think it would be a lot of fun. Plus, we’ve never actually been away together, obviously. When I have some more money saved up, we should go. Would you like that?”
“Anything I get to do with you is something I’d love.”
“I love you, Andy.”
“I love you, sweetheart.”
You two spend the rest of evening cooking dinner, planning when to move some of your stuff in, and deciding what time you both wanted to get up to go and look at furniture.
After almost falling asleep in bed, twice, you both decide it’s time to shower and call it a night. It’s the best shower you’ve ever had with another person, because there was nothing sexual about it. You both washed each other, made each other laugh, and at the end; he just holds you tight and kisses the top of your head.
You never knew love could feel this good.
“You’re not wearing your ring,” you yawn as you two settle under the covers and turn out the lights.
“Why should I?”
“You’re still married.”
“As far as I’m concerned, I’m not. I signed the papers and the only person I’m with is you.”
“Andy, people will notice.”
“Good,” is all he says before wrapping his arm around you and pulling you close. “That way, when they see us together, there won’t be anything to question.”
“I love you.”
“I love you, honey. Goodnight.”
You’re almost asleep when you remember, “babe?”
“Hmm?”
“Why did you get a place with three rooms.”
“Oh,” he comments softly and you feel him stiffen a little. “Well, ya know, for when Jacob and Sarah sleepover.”
“You’re gonna make them sleep in separate rooms?”
“Well, if they want options.”
“What are you not telling me?”
“Just...maybe one day...if you wanted to have a kid or kids with me...we have the space,” he confesses sheepishly.
You turn over in his hold, wide eyed and in complete disbelief, “what?”
“You obviously don’t need to think about it now, or even at all, it was just...just in case it is something you want.”
“You want a family with me?”
“I keep telling you that I want everything with you.”
“Even kids?”
“Marriage, kids, sharing an AARP membership,” he laughs, “all of it.”
“If we have kids, you’ll be like Atticus Finch.”
“Only in the sense that I’ll be an old lawyer. We won’t be poor and their mother won’t be dead.”
“That’s a good way to look at it,” you laugh.
“We’ll talk about it more in the morning. I love you, Y/N,” he smirks before kissing your forehead.
“I love you too, Atticus.”
As you drift into dream land, secure in Andy’s hold, you’re finally certain of at least one thing; this isn’t made up at all.
**
Its been a constant roller coaster for you and Andy in the following months after he first shows you the condo he got for you both. After helping Jacob and Sarah move into their new place, Andy told him that he had moved out while he was away, and of course Jacob wanted to go and see it instantly.
“Have you seen the my dad’s new place?” Jacob asks you two sit in your apartment two weeks later.
“Why would I have seen it?” you scoffed before you took a sip of your whiskey neat, trying to burn away the guilt.
“I don’t know, I figured he might’ve asked you for help or something. The place has an essence of you,” he chuckled.
“What does that even mean?”
“Like...some of the sheets in the bedroom, some of the kitchenware, the pillows...hell, even some of the paintings he got. I don’t know, it feels very you,” he shrugged as he grabbed the remote and turned on the TV.
All of the things you picked out.
“He seems happier though. Maybe this is just what they needed, time apart.”
“Meaning?”
“I don’t know...maybe there’s a chance they’ll get back together.”
“Is that what you want?”
“I don’t know,” he sighed, running a hand through his hair. “I mean, doesn’t every kid want their parents to work out their shit out?”
“Not when they’re toxic.”
“I don’t know, I guess with us going to look for rings soon, I’m looking for something to believe in. Believe that love lasts and that its real.”
“Stop it. You and Sarah are different.”
“How would you know?”
“I just do. Besides, maybe the person your father finds next will be the one.”
“I don’t wanna think about that,” Jacob scowled and it only made you feel worse.
“So, when are you gonna propose?” you asked before you downed the rest of your drink, trying to think of anything to make yourself feel a little less worse.
“December.”
“W-why December?”
“One, I just feel crazy right now. Graduation, the new job, adjusting to living with Sarah and paying bills, and all this shit with my parents...it’ll just be too much at once, ya know? Second, I think she’ll really love it if I propose to her at the ‘Festival of Lights’. It’s already the number one thing she looks forward to all year long, so why not propose then?”
“That’s a good point,” you muttered before you downed the rest of your drink.
Jacob spent the next few hours telling you about how torn he is about his parents, how he’s not sure how he’ll handle his parents moving on and his family splitting up, and how he wishes things were like they were before Ben’s murder.
It also didn’t help that Laurie still hadn’t signed the fucking papers.
“Sweetheart, when are you coming home?” Andy asked once you finally answered his call.
“I’m not coming over tonight,” you sobbed, curled up underneath your favorite blanket.
“What’s wrong, baby? What happened?”
“He’s gonna hate me, Andy, He’s never gonna talk to me again,” you cried.
“I’m on my way, sweetheart,” is all he said before hanging up.
Andy was at your place in 10 minutes.
“Sweetheart?” Andy called out, once he entered using the key you had made for him.
“In here,” you croaked out, not even bothering to move.
“Oh honey,” Andy cooed once he made his way into your bedroom. “Do you wanna talk about it?
All you could do was shake your head ‘no’ as you sniffled.
“Then we won’t talk about it,” he agreed as he kicked off his shoes before getting into bed with you, “I’ll just hold you until you feel better,” he cooed as he wrapped his arms around you kissed your forehead.
In moments like those, you were more than happy that you had Andy in your life. He gave you your space, he let you feel what you needed to feel, he never pressured you into telling him what the issue was, and whenever you were ready to tell him, he was patient and understanding.
However, it doesn’t go without saying that you two had your fair share of arguments about the situation you found yourself in.
“Why are you mad at me?!” Andy snapped as the two you got ready for bed.
“I don’t wanna talk about it, Andy.”
“Y/N-”
“I just had to stand there like a fucking idiot while you all took family pictures!”
“It was his graduation!”
“I should’ve just stayed home.”
“Stop it, Y/N.”
“Don’t you dare catch an attitude with me, Barber! You’re not in my position! You don’t know how this feels!”
“She’s his mother! What do you want me to do?!”
“I’m sleeping in the other room.”
“Can we please work this out? Don’t go to bed angry.”
“Andy, I’m tired and-”
“What do you want me to do? You’ve heard the phone calls, I’ve offered her everything and she still won’t sign the papers. I’ve threatened legal action and she still won’t sign the papers. You want us to go to her right now and tell her about us? Lets go. You wanna call Jacob right now? We can. I love you. I want to be with you. I am with you!”
In that moment, you felt embarrassingly small.
“Can we just get away?” you questioned as you covered your face with your hands. “Lets just go on a trip. It doesn’t have to be some big to-do, but lets just get the fuck out of here for a while. I feel like I’m split in two and since Jacob is dead set on a December proposal, the feeling isn’t going to go away any time soon.”
“We’ll go away soon, sweetheart. I promise,” he sighed as he rubbed the back of his neck. “Please sleep in here tonight.”
“Yeah, fine.”
“Baby-”
“I’m just...I’m just tired, Andy. Lets just go to bed,” you muttered as you got into bed.
Andy sighed heavily in response before he got into bed and pulled you close.
“I love you, sweetheart. You set the pace for all of this. I just want to be with you. Only you,” he whispered before he kissed the back of your neck.
It’s very rare that you ever find yourself truly angry with Andy. No, he’s not perfect, but he does his best to be perfect for you. Overall, you both are extremely happy, even with things as fucked up as they are.
Your anger is mainly fueled by your frustration. You know that if you leave it up to Andy, he’ll tell everyone everything in an instant.
However, you’re about to railroad Jacob’s whole life, and he deserves better than you fucking up his ideal proposal. Which is why, when he wanted you to spend your birthday with him and Sarah, you didn’t put up a fuss. You spent your morning and afternoon with them, and you spent your night with Andy; him taking you out to dinner and you finishing the night bouncing up and down on his cock.
When Jacob wanted you to go over to his place to hangout, you went without fuss or complaint. When it came to your home with Andy, you accepted with grace that you couldn’t have pictures of the two of you up, just because Jacob liked to frequent his dad’s place. You constantly talk yourself into accepting how things are, because after Christmas, things are about to change drastically.
“Laurie, what do you want me to do? If Jacob wants her at the propsal, he wants her at the proposal,” Andy sighs, plopping down on the sofa next to you, and wrapping an arm around you. “They’re best friends, Laurie. If you’re gonna be this crazy about it, talk to Jacob. This isn’t my proposal...alright, I’m not getting into this, I’m going. Bye,” he snaps before hanging up. “She won’t be my wife forever, she won’t be my wife forever,” he mutters to himself as he pulls you close.
“I can say that I’m sick and not show up-”
“No,” he instantly cuts you off, “you’re going to be there and she’s going to deal with it. She doesn’t even know we’re together, so it’s just her being paranoid.”
“I don’t want her to keep giving you a hard time.”
“She’s hellbent on always giving me a hard time. Don’t worry about it.”
“Andy-”
“Don’t worry about it, honey,” he repeats in a firmer yet gentle tone.
You sigh before straddling him, “how can I make you feel better?”
“It’s not fair when you ask that question and you’re in this position,” he whines.
You dip down and whisper seductively in his ear, “you know I’m yours to use however you want, daddy.”
“Y/N,” he growls, gripping hips tight.
“Take what’s yours, daddy,” you moan, grinding yourself against him.
“Sweet girl,” he husks.
“Tell me what you want.”
“I want you to sit on my face, sweet girl. Ride my face until I’m drowning in cum from that sweet pussy.”
“Oh daddy,” you whimper, picking up your pace.
“Then, I’m gonna abuse both your holes because daddy needs to relieve some stress.”
“I’ve missed having you in my ass, daddy!”
“Yeah, well get ready for a long-”
“Dad!” Jacob calls from the other side of the door, knocking a little aggressively.
“Fuck,” Andy breathes into the crook of your neck.
“I’ll make myself scarce-”
“No no, I’ll think of something to tell him by the time I’m at the front door. Fuck, we’re picking this up the second he leaves.”
“I’m betting on it,” you giggle softly.
You moan as you get off of him, the friction of your panties rubbing against your now extremely sensitive clit only making you more desperate, and Andy’s quick to give you that look.
“I know, daddy: I can’t cum until you say so.”
“There’s a good girl,” he smirks at you before getting up, readjusting his pants, and slowly making his way to the front door.
You quickly turn on the TV (happy that it’s Turner Classic Movies) before heading into the kitchen and making drinks for you and Andy.
“Hey bud, what’s up?”
“I need to talk to you,” Jacob mutters, pushing right past Andy. “Should I propose-”
“Hey Jake,” you smile, popping out from the kitchen and holding a glass out to Andy, which he happily takes.
“What are you doing here?”
“I had a few legal questions for Andy about my parents, because they’ve been driving me crazy. The more I talked about it, the more I got upset, so we turned on Turner Classic Movies, and I just made us some drinks. I figured we’d dive back in soon.”
“You could’ve just come to me, ya know.”
“Are you a lawyer?”
“Don’t be an asshole-”
“Jacob!” Andy snaps.
“You know what I mean,” he rolls his eyes, “you could’ve talked to me.”
“You’ve been so stressed lately, I didn’t want to add on anymore.”
“I wouldn’t have-”
“Yes, you would have. Whenever I bring up how upset my parents make me, you get pissed off and worked up.”
“You don’t tell me anything anymore!”
“It’s one thing, Jake.”
“Whatever.”
“Jake, you didn’t come here to argue with me, I’ll go-”
“We’ll go into my office, you sit down and calm down,” Andy tells you softly.
You want to say something, but you know there’s no use. As Andy leads Jacob to his office, you resume your seat on the sofa and do your best to focus on the movie on the screen, but now you’re irritated.
For the last few months, when you tell either Sarah or Andy something before you tell him, he catches an attitude. The only thing that you’ve purposely kept a secret from him is your relationship with Andy, and it’s obvious why. Hell, he was pissy with you for being secretive about his birthday until the actual surprise. Even then, he gave you a half-ass apology. You don’t know when he started getting so selfish with you, but you’re really growing tired of it.
Until he starts hating you for being with Andy, Jacob is still your best friend, and you’ve done your best to show him that. By the time both men come out of the office, you can tell that Jacob is more at ease, but it’s also clear (to you at least) that Andy is trying his best to hide his frustration.
“Y/N, you’re gonna be there tomorrow, right?” Jacob asks, standing in the doorway.
“Are you done being a dick?”
“You know I’m sorry-”
“That would be something hard to know since you never fucking said it.”
“I really am sorry, Y/N. I don’t know whats gotten into me lately, but I don’t mean any of it. I’m just frustrated and I took it out on you. I’m sorry.”
“It’s fine, Jake. Just don’t make a habit of taking your anger out on me, please. I’ll see you tomorrow,” you smile softly.
Jacob just nods before practically running out.
“He should be wearing a jacket,” you mutter as Andy closes the door.
You’re about to ask him what’s going on, when he suddenly throws you over his shoulder, “unbutton your jeans,” is all he said as he starts on his way up the stairs.
Maybe you won’t make it tomorrow.
“Take them off,” he demands, tossing you down on the bed before taking off his shirt and undoing his pants, “and take your fucking shirt and bra off too.”
You want to tell him to calm down and ask him what happened, but you’ve never seen him this angry before, and your hormones are winning the battle.
He lays down next and motions for you to come over, “come take a ride on daddy’s face, sweet girl.”
And just like that, you’re doing any and everything he wants.
You were already expecting Andy to be rough with you, but you didn’t think he’d be as rough as he is. It’s not like you mind or that it hurts, in fact you’ll probably ask him to act like this more often, but pleasure aside: something is wrong.
“Come on, sweet girl, give it to me,” he grunts, fucking you hard from behind, pushing you to your limit for the third time.
“Daddy,” you mindlessly moan, clawing at the sheets that you’re more than sure are ruined.
“This cunt is amazing, sweetheart! You’re being such a good little girl for me!” he praises, slapping your ass hard.
“Fuck!”
“There she is! The way this pussy clenches me!”
“Fuck! Daddy!” you cry out, squirting on his cock for what feels like the millionth time, as your body gets lost in another mind-numbing orgasm.
“Good girl,” he grunts, coating your inner walls with his desire.
He hovers for a moment, panting above you before he pulls out, and you think he’s finally spent.
“Get on your back, sweet girl,” he husks, pinning you down.
Alright, what the fuck is going on?
“Andy, baby...wait.”
“What’s wrong? Are you okay? Did I hurt you?”
“Baby, I’m perfect, but you...you aren’t,” you breathe, trying to get your thoughts together, “what’s wrong?”
“I don’t want to talk about it,” he mutters before dipping down to kiss you, but you turn your head away just in time. “Sweet girl-”
“No Andy. We can go all night if you want to, just like this, but you gotta talk to me, baby, please. What happened?”
“Please-”
“Andy, this doesn’t work if we don’t talk to each other.”
He lets out an exasperated sigh before collapsing next you on the bed and staring up at the ceiling, “Laurie told Jacob I started seeing someone.”
“I’m sorry, she did what?!”
“He obviously doesn’t know it’s you, but he did have questions about you...us. I obviously lied and he bought it, but it’s only gonna make everything worse in the long run.”
“Did he say anything about it?”
“Well, he wants to meet her,” he scoffs, running one of his frustrated hands through damp his hair, “he’s a little upset because he was holding out hope, but he understands.”
“Do you want to just tell him now?”
“No, because you’re right; him finding out before proposing would ruin everything. Everything is tied into one, sweetheart,” he sighs heavily.
“What are you not telling me, baby?”
“The reason he came over initially...he was having cold feet about proposing to Sarah, because...he figured out that he has feelings for you.”
“Jesus Christ,” you groan into your hands.
You can’t catch a fucking break.
“I asked him if he could see himself having a real future with you if he broke it off with Sarah, and he said no. He said that he isn’t in love, but he didn’t realize just how much he was used to being the only one in your life until he stopped being the only person you spend your time with. He swears it’s just a crush and that he’ll get over it. That’s when he asked if anything was going on between us and I told him that we’re just friends. I know for a fact that this is why Laurie said anything, because she wants her suspicions confirmed. To pull this shit now though? The day before he’s supposed to propose? That’s a fucking low blow, even for her.”
“We’ll just...we’ll deal with it after Christmas, okay baby?”
“Sweetheart, you don’t have to-”
“Hey, we are in this together. This is something we both decided to do and I’m all in. Whatever we have to face, we’ll face it together. Good or bad.”
“You know this means we’re gonna have to be even more discreet, right?”
“Yeah, I know,” you sigh, finally turning on your side to look at him, “but it won’t always be like this,” you smile weakly.
Andy raises himself up on his elbow and looks you over, before cupping your face and giving you one of the most passionate kisses hes ever given you, “I love you.”
“I love you.”
“Ya know, you did say that we can go all night just like we were...”
“We can do whatever you wanna do, daddy,” you smirk as he chuckles before kissing you again.
You both go for another two rounds before deciding that you need it to call it a night. However, neither of you actually goes to sleep. Andy just holds you close while leaning against the headboard, stroking your arm gently, while you lay your head on his chest. Not a word is spoken as you two lookout the window; up at the moon, it’s just a silent understanding that very soon, things are going to become very hectic and chaotic.
**
“Why aren’t you coming to the ‘Festival of Lights’?!” Sarah whines into the phone and you laugh.
“I have some things I need to take care of.”
“You better not be putting Andy before me.”
“I’m not!” you laugh, coming up to a red light, “Christmas is a week away and I’ve got some last minute things to do.”
“Y/N!”
“Listen, it’s not my fault they choose the worst time to do this every year. A lot’s been going on.”
“Is everything okay?”
“I mean, yes and no.”
“Uh oh, what happened? What did the Wicked Witch do now?”
“Don’t worry-”
“No no, talk to me. Tell me what’s going on.”
“Laurie told Jacob that Andy has started seeing someone.”
“Shut the fuck up!”
“To make matters worse,” you start as the light turns green and you pull off, “I was over when Jacob came over last night, and of course he asked Andy about it.”
“Oh no.”
“And of course, Andy lied.”
“Fuck.”
“So, thanks for that, Laurie.”
“Why not just tell him?”
“And ruin his Christmas? No thanks.”
“That’s a fair point. He’s actually so excited this year. Christmas morning with you, lunch with Andy and my parents, then dinner with Laurie. He’s planned the shit out of it,” she laughs softly. “What about you and Andy?”
“He’s coming to get me as soon as you two leave for dinner,” you chuckle.
“Ugh, I’m so happy for you two. You’ve been so much happier these last few months, and the fact that he got a home for you both? Y/N, I’m so damn happy for you.”
“Thanks, babe.”
“Oh, I hear footsteps approaching, we’ll talk about this more later, okay?”
“Sounds good,” you smile as you pull up to the town square, “I love you.”
“I love you,” she beams before hanging up.
As you park your car, you see Laurie standing next to Andy, and you mentally prepare yourself not to punch her face in on site.
“Oh thank God you’re here!” Sarah’s mom laughs, as you get out and open your trunk. “You know how everything is supposed to look and Jacob was a nervous wreck when he was here earlier.”
“He wasn’t that bad,” Laurie laughs following behind her.
“Sorry sorry, things ran a little late at work, but I’m here now and we’ve got...2 hours to get this done! We can-”
“Hour and a half,” Andy interjects with a laugh. “Jacob is a little too excited for Christmas this year, so Sarah wants to show up early.”
“Well...shit, okay then,” you laugh awkwardly. “I guess we should get to work.
As everyone gets to work on setting up the “proposal area”, you can’t help but notice how much Laurie is clinging to Andy, and how much Andy is trying to keep his distance. The whole thing wants to make you scream, but what can you do? What can you say? As far as everyone knows, you and Andy are nothing more than acquaintances.
So, you have no other option but to sit and watch?
An hour into setting up, your phone buzzes and you assume it’s Jacob, but a small smile comes to your face when you read the name on your phone.
My Heart: I know we said we won’t see each other again until Christmas, but I really want to see you tonight.
Y/N: Baby, you know we can’t.
My Heart: Laurie is driving me insane, all I wanna do is kiss you, and I hate sleeping alone.
Y/N: Christmas will be here before you know it, baby. Besides, we’ll find other alternatives while we wait. As for Laurie, I’m ready wring her fucking neck if she puts her hands on you one more time. What the fuck is she even talking about?
My Heart: How excited she is and reminiscing about how we used to talk about this day all the time.
Y/N: Of course she fucking is, because I guarantee you she doesn’t think that Jacob talked to you about what she fucking said.
My Heart: I wanna say something so bad, but this isn’t the fucking time or place, and I’m not gonna argue with her before Christmas.
Y/N: We’ll sort all of this soon. Today isn’t about any of this. Jacob and Sarah have been through a lot and I just want this to be perfect for them.
My Heart: I am so in love with you, did you know that?
Y/N: That’s good to hear, because the feeling is mutual :)
You look up and over at him for just a split second, and see the biggest smile on his face, and a small one comes to yours. God, you can’t to truly be with him. When your phone buzzes again, you know who it is before even checking it.
The Dark Lord: We’re on our way!
“Alright everyone, they’re on their way, so finish up and get to your spots,” you happily announce, tying up your last bow.
Everything is perfect, it’s even snowing, but you’re still annoyed. You completely understand why Laurie and Andy’s hiding spot is together, but it’s painfully clear that Laurie isn’t going down without a fight. Yeah, Andy will turn down all of her advances, but she shouldn’t be trying anything anyway. Whether or not you’re with Andy, he’s made it perfectly clear that he just wants to move on, and she refuses to accept that.
Also, yes, he’s your boyfriend so everyone needs to back off.
However, you can’t focus on that right now. Jacob and Sarah will be arriving any moment, and you’re the one in charge of recording everything.
Thank God you finally hear Sarah’s voice.
“Jacob, c’mon! I wanna do the maze while it’s still snowing!” she calls and you force yourself not to giggle.
“I had to grab something from the car, take a walk with me really quick though.”
“Babe-”
“I have a surprise for you,” he laughs softly as he takes her hand and starts to walk towards the spot that’s been set up for them. “Now, I know nothing about this relationship has really been normal or easy, for fucks sake, we started talking because you wanted to tip me off about what Derick said over a murder case,” he shakes his head in disbelief. “Yet, here we are all these years later, still in love and making it work. There’s no one else I can see myself having a future with and there’s no one else I want a future with.”
“Jacob-”
“I am moody, messy, argumentative, and I always forget to clean the coffee grinds out of the sink, but Sarah...I love you. I have always loved you and I will always love you. So,” he starts as he gets down on one knee and ‘Reflecting Light’ by Sam Phillips starts playing, “will you do me the honor of being my wife?”
Sarah doesn’t hesitate for a second.
“Of course!” she squeals, almost knocking him over with a hug.
Everyone soon erupts into cheers and applause as they come out of their hiding spots, and you finally stop recording.
“You sneaky little bitch!” Sarah exclaims when she sees you. “I love you so much!”
“I love you too,” you laugh as she almost knocks you over.
“You know you’re my maid of honor right?!”
“You sure about that?” you laugh as you two break apart, cocking an eyebrow.
“I’ve never been so sure of anything,” she promises with a nod.
Thank God for loyal friends.
Soon enough, it was time for photos and you do your best to mask the pain you feel when you Laurie hanging all over Andy. You know she’s doing it for show, but that doesn’t make it hurt any less. You want so badly to be in those photos and not some secret. You want so badly to just feel like it’s really real.
When she kisses Andy on the cheek, you’re not sure how you’re able to hold yourself back from smacking the shit out of her.
‘This isn’t about you or Andy. Control yourself,’ you tell yourself mentally.
“Y/N, you should get in some of these pictures,” Andy calls, giving you a small smile.
So much for being more discreet.
“What? Why?” Laurie questions, very obviously upset.
“She’s their best friend and has been there for them almost as long as their relationship, She’s practically apart of the family. Besides, she’s also the one came up with the design for all of this and got the decorations.”
“That’s a fair point,” Laurie begrudgingly agrees.
Well. Shit.
You’re about to stand on the other side of Laurie when Andy says, “here, stand between Laurie and I.”
“What? Why?”
“She can’t stand between Jacob and me or between Jacob or Sarah. She obviously stand between Sarah and her parents.”
“But why between us?”
“Why does it matter? It’s not like we’re together anymore.”
Fuck.
“It’s not a big deal, Mr. Barber, I can stand on the other side of-”
“No, that’s okay,” Laurie smiles the best she can, trying and failing to mask her pain, anger, and embarrassment. “You can stand between Andy and I.”
You and Sarah exchange a quick look before you stand between Andy and Laurie, and the smile that comes to your face is genuine. Not only is Andy going out of his way to make sure you’re included, but he’s also taking a stand.
He’s standing up to Laurie.
Yes, Andy’s a good man and you’re more than sure it hurt him to hurt and embarrass her, but it’s not like she didn’t draw first blood. From the look on Laurie’s face, she could tell that he really isn’t coming back.
He isn’t going to and he doesn’t want to.
You can’t stop yourself when he comes over later that night. Yeah, you two agreed to be more discreet, but after the massive display of affection he showed, waiting till Christmas feels a little more impossible.
However, that night was the only slip up you two had. From then until Christmas Eve, it was only texts, phone calls, and FaceTime. The only reason you went home (his place) on Christmas Eve was because he invited Sarah and Jacob over to decorate the Christmas tree, and Jacob invited you.
You both tried to hide how happy you were about doing something so simple together, but the look on Sarah’s let you know that she could see right through it. All she did was offer a small and subtle smile.
As silly as it seems, it was one of the best nights of your life.
You can’t think about that right now, though. You can’t even think about Andy, because you’ll get too excited and Jacob will start asking questions. In a few hours, you’ll be having the best Christmas ever, but for now, you need to focus.
“So, have you met my dad’s new girlfriend?” Jacob asks as you all finish up breakfast.
“Leave her alone, babe,” Sarah coos, collecting the plates and taking them all to your kitchen.
“It’s just a simple question.”
“Why do you think I’ve met her?” you ask sheepishly, quickly grabbing your coffee and taking sip; doing your best to hide your face.
“You two just seem pretty friendly-”
“You saw me at his house once and it was just to ask legal advice. There’s no reason for me to know anything else about his personal life, Jake.”
Lie.
“Speaking of that, how the hell are you gonna handle Christmas with your parents?”
“In and out for both. I’ll pop in, drop off gifts, and come back here, make dinner, and watch Christmas movies.”
Another lie.
“That sounds lonely, you wanna come with us to have dinner with my mom?”
“Nah, I’m pretty sure she just wants to spend time with you two.”
Truth.
“Lunch with my dad and Sarah’s family?”
“I have gifts to give,” you laugh humorlessly.
Another fucking lie.
“I just know that Christmas is your favorite and I feel bad about you spending it all alone.”
“It’s really okay, Jake. I’m fine with it. Being alone isn’t so bad. I’ll have ice cream, booze, and my favorite holiday movies. I’ll be fine.”
Lie, lie, lie.
“If you say so,” he sighs as he gets up, “but we gotta get going. We’re meeting my dad at Sarah’s parents’ house, then it’s off to my mother’s. This would be a lot simpler if they could’ve just stayed together,” he grumbles.
Ah, yes. There it is: guilt.
“We’ve had this talk, Jake: it’s for the better.”
“I know, I know, but still.”
“Just do your best to enjoy the day, okay?”
“I guess. I love you and I hope you enjoy your gifts,” he smiles as you both stand up and he engulfs you in a huge hug.
“I love you too, Jake. Merry Christmas.”
“We’ll see you after New Year?” Sarah asks as she makes her way over to you.
“Yeah, lets all do lunch on the 14th. Sound good?”
“It’s perfect,” she smiles as she wraps you in a tight hug. “Enjoy your time with him, you both love each other so much. I left the food you asked for in the fridge and Jake has no idea,” she whispers.
“Thank you, Sarah. For everything. I love you,” you whisper back, hugging her just a little bit tighter, before breaking away.
“I guess we’re off,” she sighs as she makes her way over to Jacob.
“You just gotta get through today then you two are on vacation,” you laugh.
“Thank God.”
The second they’re out the door, you’re pulling out Andy’s gifts and wrapping them. It would’ve been done earlier, but with Andy soaking up every single free moment you have since you two can’t see each other, it wasn’t going to happen.
You both agreed to small gifts, but you knew Andy was bullshitting, so you went a little over your budget (nothing you couldn’t make up with overtime), and got him a couple of pricey gifts you knew he’d love and find useful.
You take your time showering, feeling both anxious and excited about spending an almost normal Christmas Andy. The fact that, soon enough, you two will be able to have a real relationship and not have to hide in the shadows. You’ll live together, shop together, fall asleep together, talk about your days in person, have dinner together...all of it. So many things that are done in private, will finally be able to happen freely in the public.
Soon, you and Andy will finally have the life you’ve both been desperately seeking for over a year.
You decide on dressing in your favorite Christmas leggings and pull on the AC/DC crew neck he’s always happy to see you in. Just as you finish brushing out your hair, your phone buzzes and the butterflies appear all over again.
My Heart: On my way, sweetheart.
The squeal that leaves your mouth even causes you to laugh.
You gather all your groceries for dinner, as well as, gifts and a few more clothes you want to move into your home with Andy, before checking that everything is off and away as it should be. Then, you quickly making your way downstairs to the parking garage and waiting for him.
When he pulls in a few minutes later, you can tell he’s laughing without the window even being open.
“I would’ve come up to get you,” he laughs as you get into his car.
“I was too excited! Merry Christmas!” you beam, wrapping your arms around him and engulfing him in a tight hug.
“Merry Christmas, baby,” he chuckles softly, “you ready to go home?”
“Always.”
The entire time Andy is driving, you sing all of your favorite Christmas songs loud and off key.
And he’s begging you to stop.
“Okay, now I know that for next Christmas, I need to hide all things that provide music,” Andy sighs as you two make your way inside the house.
“You loved every second of it, I don’t care what you say,” you smirk as set up your presents up underneath the tree.
“Yeah yeah, which present do you wanna open-”
“No no, there’s an art to this. For starters, you should be wearing something Christmas-y, not jeans and a sweater.”
“I don’t have anything Christmas-y,” he chuckles and you shake your head.
“I thought you’d say that, that’s why I got you this!”
“I’m not wearing that.”
“Andy, you can’t break Christmas rules.”
“Since when is wearing a ridiculous sweater a Christmas rule?”
“Since you decided you’re in love with me. Now, put this on, along with some sweatpants, and I’ll make the drinks.”
“I’m about to have the longest Christmas ever, aren’t I?”
“You bet your ass, now change,” you giggle as you make your way into the kitchen.
You hear Andy huff before he starts on his way upstairs, and giggle a little as you get to work on the hot chocolates. Once the stove is hot enough, you start mixing everything together before grabbing a few of the appetizers you asked Andy to get out of the freezer, and preheating the oven.
“I’m not coming downstairs,” Andy calls from the top of the stairs.
“Oh, stop it! It’s not the bunny outfit from ‘A Christmas Story’, it’s just an ugly sweater.”
“It’s the ugliest sweater.”
“C’mon, Christmas grump.”
“I’m not a Christmas grump,” he mumbles as he starts making his down the steps. The second you see him, you burst out laughing and he rolls his eyes. “I’m not wearing this ever again.”
“It’s okay to look ridiculous, babe,” you giggle, “I do it every day.”
“You’ve never looked ridiculous a day in your life,” he smirks as he makes his way over to you, snaking his arms around your waist.
“You’re sweet. How was lunch?”
“How was breakfast?”
“That bad, huh?”
“Sarah’s dad was telling me about all the women he could set me up with and Jacob kept asking me about my new girlfriend.”
“He tried to ask me about your new girlfriend too.”
“I could scream at Laurie.”
“It’s Christmas, babe. Don’t think about it,” you sigh as pour the hot chocolate into two mugs. “We’re gonna have a shit show to deal with after New Year, so lets just enjoy today.”
“Why is the oven on?”
“So I can heat up the appetizers?”
“Don’t tell me you’re gonna start making dinner before we open gifts,” he groans, resting his head in the crook of your neck as you start laughing.
“Babe, it’s late! I should’ve started making dinner a while ago!”
“Who needs dinner?”
“Andy.”
“I wanna know what you got me!”
“I didn’t know that I’m in love with a child.”
“According to the town, I am.”
“Fuck you!” you laugh as you feel him smirk against your shoulder. “One gift, Andy.”
“That means you have to open one too.”
“I wanna wait.”
“You’re difficult, you know that?”
“You’re one to talk,” you grin.
“Fine, I’ll wait to open my gift,” he huffs and you can’t stop yourself from giggling. “What’s for dinner tonight?”
“You’ll just have to wait and see.”
“Are you gonna be like this every Christmas?”
“Uh huh,” you smile, pouring Baileys into his hot chocolate then yours, “and you’re gonna love it.”
Andy takes a seat at the kitchen island and starts telling you about the traditions him and his mom had up until she passed away, while you get the appetizers together and put them in the oven. Just as you close the oven door, ‘The Christmas Song’ starts playing and you don’t even notice that he’s standing right behind you.
“Andy-”
“I think we should dance, don’t you?”
“You never fail to surprise me,” you laugh softly.
He pulls you close and you two slowly dance to one of your absolute favorite songs, and it feels like a dream.
Being with Andy is a dream come true.
When the song comes to and end, Andy continues to hold you close and rests his head on top of yours.
“I just want to stay in this moment for a minute,” he states softly, “I’ve waited for you for so long, and I’ve loved you...I just want us to stay like this for a moment. We finally got here, babe, and I just want to live in the moment that has made me the happiest I’ve ever been.”
“I love you, Andy.”
“I love you, Y/N.”
You both just stand there and hold each other until the timer goes off on the stove.
You place a soft kiss on his chest before letting go of him and opening the stove, “alright, I made a few different things, because options are always a good thing.”
“That and you’re terrible at making decisions.”
“Both can be true,” you huff before sticking your tongue out at him and he chuckles. “What Christmas movie would you like to watch?”
“I don’t really have a favorite. I guess, ‘The Shop Around The Corner’? That was my mom’s favorite.”
“She had great taste,” you smile at him as you finish set up the plate, before you both head into the living room.
For the first hour, everything is perfect and Andy teases you for being able quote the movie line for line.
However, dreams do have their bumps from time to time.
“Fuck,” you mutter as your phone starts going off.
“What’s wrong?”
“I know who it is and I don’t wanna talk to her.”
“You don’t have to answer, sweetheart.”
“Yeah I do, or she’ll just keep calling,” you mutter, sitting up and grabbing your phone. “Hello?”
“Well, merry Christmas to you too,” your mother laughs and you roll your eyes. “When are you coming over? David and I are waiting.”
“Who the hell is David?”
“My boyfriend.”
“What the hell happened to Eric?”
“Oh, we broke up months ago.”
“Of course you did. Anyway, I told you last night that I’m not coming over.”
“Y/N-”
“I’m not arguing about this with you again. I don’t want to see you and I don’t wanna see dad. I don’t need either of you ruining my favorite holiday.”
“Y/N, I know we’ve had our differences but this used to be our-”
“Don’t. This was our holiday until you deiced that I don’t matter anymore. I did one Christmas without you both and it was almost near perfect. I think I’ll survive another one just fine without you two.”
“If you don’t see your dad-”
“You ruined it when you decided that I don’t matter. It doesn’t matter if I see him or not, you’ll always talk shit about him, and he’ll always talk shit about you. Now, I’m actually enjoying my day and I’m not about to ruin it by arguing with you. I love you and Merry Christmas,” you finish with an exasperated sigh before hanging up.
You feel your tears coming on and you know you shouldn’t be, but you’re upset with yourself. Why let her get to you? Why let either of them get to you? They chose to make it this way and you’ve made your peace with that, so why are you so worked up now?
“Talk to me, honey. What’s going on?” Andy questions, pausing the movie and pulling you close.
“It’s so fucking stupid,” you sob, wiping your eyes, “I’m ruining everything.”
“Hey, no you aren’t. What’s going on?”
“Christmas was such a big deal when I was child because we didn’t have any money. We made ornaments, stayed up on Christmas Eve to decorate our shitty tree and watch movies, then on Christmas Day my mom would make a big breakfast,” you chuckle softly, sniffling a little. “We’d eat, sing and dance around to Christmas songs, watch more movies, have a small lunch, and we’d get around to presents late in the afternoon. I never cared about them much, because I knew they couldn’t afford a lot. The only thing I cared about was that we were happy. For two days out of the year, we were all really happy and we were happy together.
Then as I got older, and they started arguing more, Christmas became a day for just my mom and I. She knew how much it meant to me and she wanted me to still have that feeling. She wanted me to know that even though things were changing, some things would always stay the same. It was alright for a while, but after the divorce...it just got so nasty. I would split my day with them, which would be an argument on its own, because the both them wanted me for the day. I would spend the morning and evening with her, then finish the day with him. Yeah, they had money at that point so they showered me with gifts, but they would just talk shit about each other to me. The whole spirit and idea of it was ruined. Last year was the first Christmas I spent alone and it was the first time that I loved it again since I was 15. There was no arguing, no feelings of guilt that I could letting one of them down, and no anger. It was me, my TV, ice cream, wine, and a quiet dinner.
Now, I get to spend it with you and I’m so fucking happy, because even without the gifts, this is the best. I have you and I really couldn’t ask for anything else,” you smile at him as more tears start to come.
“But?”
“Jacob doesn’t understand how lucky he is at times. Even with you and Laurie split up, he still got to see the both of you today. You’re a gentleman, so I know you didn’t say anything awful about Laurie, and for as awful as Laurie is, she knows how much Jacob worships the ground you walk on, so she’s not going to say anything terrible about you. Even if it’s not together, he still gets to see the both of you and enjoy it. He gets to bring Sarah with him and know he won’t be embarrassed or have to apologize for the actions of his parents. My parents fucking hate each other and that’s never going to change, and I know for a fact that if I were to ever bring you on the holidays, it’ll be a shit show.
They’ll spend the whole time just tearing each other down. I’m so fucking mad at them for doing this. For just tearing apart something that meant so much to me. That means something to me. Christmas was such a special time for us and it was everything, and now I’ll never enjoy it with them again. The one thing that would bring us together is now one of the many things that keeps us apart,” you cry.
“Sweetheart,” Andy coos, pulling onto his lap and you lay your head on his shoulder, “that’s not stupid at all. It’s okay to be upset about something that’s upsetting. Your parents have had more than enough time to get their shit together, and the fact that they refuse to is utter bullshit. You told your mother last night that you weren’t coming over, and she still called and tried to act like it was something that hadn’t been discussed. That’s fucked up, and no matter what’s happened over time, she knows how much today means to you. It’s fucked up and it’s selfish. Don’t feel like you’re ruining anything by being rightfully upset, because you’re not.”
“I should start on dinner,” you sniff, wiping your eyes as you go to get up, but Andy’s hold on you is strong.
“Hey, I love you, Y/N,” he tells you as he softly forces your gaze on him with his free hand. “It’s okay to open up to me about your past, you know that.”
“I don’t want you to go away, Andy.”
“I’ve told you I’m not and I mean that, why don’t you trust that?”
“Because you’re too good to be true,” you laugh humorlessly, “I keep waiting for you to go, because all of this is a lot. I’m a lot to deal with.”
“Babe, I got us a home,” he chuckles, “what else do you need me to do? You want me to propose?”
“Andy.”
“Listen, I think about it every single day. I want everything with you forever. I’ll propose to and marry you today if that’s what it takes for you to believe me.”
You don’t even think about it; you just cup his face and kiss him passionately. As always, you want to get lost in Andrew Steven Barber and every emotion he makes you feel. Even if it all crashes and burns, everything he makes you feel lets you know that all of this is worth it.
He truly is the love of your life.
“I should start on dinner,” you breathe once you two break apart.
“After the movie?”
“It’s getting late and-”
“Please?”
You’ll never tell him no.
“Right after.”
“Sounds good to me,” he smiles at you before pressing play on the movie.
You two barely watch the movie, because neither of you can keep your hands off of each other, but the second it comes to an end, you’re practically pushing Andy off of you.
“Just a little bit longer,” he begs breathlessly.
“Judging by what I just felt on my inner thigh, we won’t get anything else done tonight,” you laugh.
“Tonight?”
“I’ll make you so happy tonight, daddy,” you promise in the innocent tone that makes him insanely feral.
“Don’t start,” he warns with a low growl as he gets off of you.
“Punish me for it later,” you wink, getting up and letting up a little yelp when he slaps your ass. “Don’t get ahead of yourself, daddy.”
“I swear to God, you’re gonna ruin me,” he groans and you laugh. “What am I supposed to do while you’re cooking?”
“Watch ‘A Charlie Brown Christmas’,” you shrug before walking out of the room, and you hear him scoff.
You start going over everything that you two discussed over in your head as you start on dinner and it feels as if your heart is about to burst open.
Yes, hes told you he wants everything with you multiple times, but the fact that he’s so ready to marry you? It’s not something he said just put you at ease, and you could tell by the look in his eyes.
You know that he’s happy to wait and you’re so happy he’s so patient with you, because the reality of someone genuinely loving and wanting you is something you still aren’t able to able to believe.
However, that’s not something you wanna focus on right now. It’s Christmas and you’ve got a dinner to prepare.
You notice that the water is finally boiling and you frown. You hate this part.
You sigh as you open the fridge and take out the stapled plastic bag. “Sorry buddy, I really don’t wanna do this.”
You take the lobster out of the bag, place it on the cutting board, and look at it. You wanna call Andy in and ask him to kill it, but it’s supposed to be a surprise, so that would defeat the purpose. Sure, you can close your eyes, but knowing you, that’ll more than likely make things worse. Usually, you can get Sarah or Jacob to do it, but that’s obviously not an option right now.
You’ve just got to do it.
You pick up the knife and hold it directly over the lobster’s head, “I’m so sorry!” you exclaim before stabbing it.
You’re quick to remove the rubber bands on its claws and throw it into the pot, before throwing the knife into the sink.
You’re a murderer.
“What’s going on in here?” Andy asks as he makes his way into the kitchen.
“Nothing nothing,” you smile as you quickly cover the lid.
“Who were you apologizing to?” he asks as he cocks an eyebrow.
“Dinner.”
“What the hell are you making?” he laughs.
“You just wait and see. Now, out of the kitchen!”
“I want a drink,” he says with a coy smile as he makes his way over to the cabinet and grabs a glass.
“Don’t try and get slick with me, Barber,” you laugh.
“I’m not trying anything,” he shrugs as he pours himself a drink, but you see the smile playing on his lips.
“Out of the kitchen.”
“I miss you.”
“You’re nosey.”
“Both can be true.”
“Andy!” you laugh, pushing him playfully.
“I’ll leave you alone...for now,” his tone foreboding as he starts to walk away, “but I’ll be back.”
“Out of the kitchen!” you laugh before sticking your tongue out at him.
From that moment on, Andy won’t give you a moment of peace. He’s either trying to call you out of the kitchen or he pops in to bother you.
“You’re making steak? Now we’re getting somewhere!” he beams as he pops up behind you, causing you to jump.
“You’re honestly the worst person to make dinner for,” you giggle as he wraps his arms around you.
“In my defense, we usually make dinner together.”
“That’s a shitty defense. I’m appalled, District Attorney Barber.”
“I can’t really make a good case when you look this good,” he mumbles against your neck before kissing it. “What was in the pot earlier?”
“Food.”
“Why won’t you tell me?”
“Because dinner is almost ready!”
“Did you make this salad yourself? A homemade chicken ceasar salad?”
“Andrew Steven Barber, go away!”
“How much longer do I have to wait?”
“Keep it up and I’ll send you to bed without supper.”
“You’re mean on Christmas,” he mutters and you laugh. “Jacob’s been calling and texting you.”
“What did he say?”
“I don’t know, I didn’t go through your phone.”
“I don’t care. You know my passcode, just check it and tell me.”
“So, I have permission to leave and come back into the kitchen?”
“I’m going to fight you,” you giggle.
“I just wanna make sure I’m not breaking any rules. I don’t wanna get banished from our home.”
“You are such a pain in the ass,” you chuckle as he leaves the room.
It’s quiet for only a few moments before you hear, “well, it seems like he had an eventful dinner.”
“Uh oh.”
“By the time they arrived, Laurie was drunk and Sarah had to help her finish dinner.”
“Fuck.”
“Do you want me to read the rest?”
“Might as well.”
“She cried over me moving on and away and said that if I give her another chance, she’ll be better.”
“Jesus, she didn’t say this in front of Sarah, did she?”
“He doesn’t say.”
“Fuck.”
“What do you want me to say?”
You’re thoughtful before you speak. “Just say, in the middle of making myself dinner, but that sounds like a fucking shit show. My phone was in the other and that’s why I missed your call. I promise to talk to you before you go on vacation, but for the time being, just enjoy the rest of your night with Sarah. I love you.”
“How do you know how to handle him so well?”
“Years of practice, Barber. Now, out of the kitchen.”
“So damn bossy,” he sighs before kissing your cheek. “How much longer?”
“Soon! Now out!” you giggle.
It’s not that you don’t want to talk to Jacob, but for right now, you just want to focus on you and Andy. Thankfully, a few moments later, you hear Andy answer his phone with ‘hey bud’, and you know it’s Jacob.
You’re more than happy for the welcomed distraction as you finish up dinner and start to put everything together on plates.
‘It’s dinner time,’ you mouth to Andy as he paces back and forth while talking on the phone.
“Bud, we’ll talk about all of it when you get back from vacation, okay? I wouldn’t stress too much about it, because your mother is just being...your mother. It’s all gonna be fine, okay? Don’t worry....I love you too, Jake...Merry Christmas to you and Sarah too,” he smiles before hanging up.
“Everything okay?”
“One way or another it will be,” he smiles weakly, “now, show me what’s for dinner.”
“Only if you ask nicely.”
“Please feed me,” he whines and you laugh.
“I guess, come on,” you smile as you make your way back into the kitchen.
“Sweetheart, all of this looks amazing. It smells fantastic!” Andy marvels as he looks over the table.
“I made the sauce that you love for the fettuccine and-”
“Is that lobster in the pasta? Oh no,” he starts laughing, “you had to kill it didn’t you? That’s why you were apologizing?”
“I’m a murderer! I stabbed it in the head!”
“Why didn’t you just put in the pot?” he laughs, wrapping you in a tight hug,
“I was told that it’s more humane to kill it first! I usually get Sarah or Jake to do it, but that obviously wasn’t an option.”
“You could’ve asked me.”
“It was supposed to be a surprise!”
“You really are the sweetest thing,” he chuckles, “I love you.”
“I love you, I hope you enjoy everything.”
“There’s so much food.”
“Leftovers, my friend. Leftovers,” you smirk as you two break apart. “I seasoned the broccoli just the you like, but there’s very little butter because I put a good amount on the lobster.”
“Have you thought about going to cooking school?”
“Don’t suggest anything until you try it,” you laugh as you pour yourself a glass of wine.
Dinner is perfect (according to Andy), and you can’t help but feel a little silly about crying earlier. Yes, your feelings were valid but, for the most part, the day has been everything you’ve ever wanted and more. You’re with the love of your life, you’re both happy, it’s snowing, and you honestly don’t think there’s ever been a time in your life where you’ve felt this content.
This is how it should be.
“It’s finally time to open presents!” Andy yells after he puts away the last of the leftovers, running into the living room.
“You’re giant child,” you laugh, following behind with a bottle of bourbon for him, and you freshly refilled glass of wine.
“I wanna see your face when you open your gifts!”
“You go first, cause you were the one who wanted to open gifts first.”
“How about we both pick a gift?”
“Fine,” you giggle as you sit on the floor next to him.
“Alright, open this one and I’ll open-”
“Why do you get to pick your own gift and I don’t get to pick mine?!”
“Because I bought that gift 7months ago and have been desperate to give it to you since I purchased it.”
“What did you do?”
“Just take it,” he laughs as he passes you the small long box. “I’ll take this one...why is it heavy?”
“I don’t know,” you shrug, sipping on your wine.
“We had an agreement-”
“I have a feeling that whatever is in this box breaks our agreement.”
“Y/N.”
“Just open it!”
“Fuck,” he sighs, putting his drink down before tearing off the paper. “No.”
“You needed it!”
“Sweetheart-”
“Andy, your old laptop is shit, and you were never going to get yourself a new one.”
“An Apple?!”
“It’s what you’re used to!”
“It’s too much!”
“Just say ‘thank you’ and give me a kiss.”
“You are something else, ya know that?” he chuckles in disbelief as he leans over and gives you a kiss. “The most selfless person I know.”
“Do you like it?”
“I love it. Now you.”
“I’m afraid.”
“If I had to open yours, you have to open mine.”
“We’re the worst,” you mutter and he laughs. “Andy...jewelry definitely breaks our agreement.”
“After the gift I just opened from you, I don’t wanna hear it.”
“Andy-”
“Open it.”
You’re slow to rip of the paper and glance at Andy before opening the box. “Andy...”
“Do you remember the talk we had that night we went for ice cream? The first time we hung out?”
“You didn’t...oh Andy!”
“You said that, after dogs, butterflies make you the happiest. They’re so delicate, but also so strong, and they’re so light but also leave you with a good feeling. A butterfly is something so fleeting, but so everlasting.”
“Andy, this gorgeous, but it’s too much.”
“No it isn’t.”
“A diamond encrusted bracelet of butterflies-”
“Stop, you’re worth it. I know it makes you happy.”
“You didn’t have to-”
“I wanted to. I love you.”
“Andy, this is too much.”
“Do you like it?”
“I love it.’
“Then its not. Put it on, lets see it.”
You’re hesitant at first, but the second it’s on your wrist, there’s a smile painted on your face.
“Andy...”
“It looks great on you.”
“This had to cost-”
“Don’t worry about the cost. I saw it, thought of you, and decided you needed it. I’m not returning it, so just enjoy it.”
“You’re too good to me.”
“I’m not good enough,” he smirks before kissing you.
How is this real life?
As you suspected, all of Andy’s gifts are much more than you two agreed upon, and you feel foolish for not getting him more lavish gifts.
“You didn’t stick to the agreement at all,” you laugh as you open up your last gift from him; a brand new kitchen knife set.
“Listen, you you said your blades were getting dull and-”
“You didn’t have to put yourself into debt to get me new ones! I was gonna buy some soon, anyway!”
“I didn’t put myself into debt and now you don’t have to spend the money. Besides, the new briefcase that has ‘Attiucs Finch’ engraved in it? I don’t wanna hear it.”
“You’re annoying.”
“So are you,” he laughs before kissing your temple.
“Let me take my stuff upstairs and we’ll watch another movie,” you giggle as you get up and grab your bag.
“I’ll clean up while you do that. Do you liken your gifts?”
“I adore them almost as much as In adore you.”
“I really love making you happy.”
“Same here,” you smile before making your way out of the living room.
You get upstairs and take a deep breath as you get yourself ready for your next and final gift. Yeah, you know Andy thinks you’re beautiful, but you’ve never presented yourself to him like this. He’s usually ripping your clothes off or making you strip, but there’s always clothes on your body. And now? You’re going down there in just velvet red ribbon underwear, hoping he thinks you’re sexy as hell.
“You okay up there?” he calls with a small laugh as you put your Santa hat on.
“Yeah, I’m just getting your last gift together,” you respond, making your way down the steps.
“Funny you should say that, because I have...fuck,” he sighs as he looks you over.
“You’ve been a really good boy this year, daddy.”
“Sweetheart...holy shit.”
“I think you should be rewarded, don’t you?” you innocently ask as you straddle him.
“Baby-”
“Because I really think you should,” you moan, grinding your hips against his.
“Santa’s little whore, huh?” he grunts, gripping your hips and starting to move with you.
“I’m whatever you want me to be,” you promise with breathy sigh as he moans. “You like it, daddy? Your cock...it’s so hard! It feels like you do!”
“Jesus, sweet girl!”
“Wanna feel you,” you whimper, raising yourself just a little as you pull his sweatpants down just enough that you see him, stroking him a bit before lightly tracing the tip of his cock with your fingers. You smirk, getting just a bit of pre-cum on your fingers, bringing them to your lips as licking them softly.
“Sweet girl,” he growls with a warning tone.
“Just wanted a taste, daddy...oh fuck!” you mewl as you lower yourself down on his cock. “You fucking fill me so good, daddy!”
“Look at you,” he moans as you start to ride, “you look so beautiful when you take daddy’s fat cock!”
“Shit!”
“Daddy’s gonna destroy this perfect little cunt, but you gotta cum for me first.”
“F...fuck, you promise?”
“You’ve been such a good little girl today, it’s only fair that I-”
“Andy!” Laurie yells as she bangs on the door.
Andy’s quickly turns his head, but you force his attention back on you, “focus, daddy,” you coo softly as you pick up your pace.
“Andy!” Laurie calls again, a little louder and longer this time.
“Just focus, you wanna make me cum, don’t you daddy?”
“Fuck,” he groans as you take his hand and place it around your throat.
“You know what I need, daddy,” you whimper, “be a good boy and make me cum, please!”
“Sweet girl,” he grunts as his grip on your neck tightens.
“Andy, please!” Laurie begs pathetically.
“That’s it, daddy! Ri...right there! Oh God!” you mewl as squirt all over his cock.
“Fuck!” he broods as he fills you with his desire.
You both just sit there for a moment, breathing heavy and embracing each other, as Laurie continues banging on the door.
“Hands and knees. On the floor,” he demands hotly, looking up at you with lust filled eyes.
You don’t hesitate at all as Laurie’s banging finally settles down a little.
“Just can’t stop yourself from making a mess, can you?” Andy taunts as he thrusts himself inside you.
“Daddy!”
“And we just got that sofa, sweet girl.”
“ ‘m so sorry, daddy! Just felt so good! Fuck!”
“ ‘ts okay, baby. You look so fucking pretty under these fucking Christmas lights,” he huffs, slapping your ass hard, “cause you’re daddy’s gift, right?”
“Y...yes!” you sob, feeling your orgasm building up again.
“Andy, please just talk to me!” Laurie begs from the other side of the door.
“Feels too good, daddy! I need to-”
“Tsk tsk tsk, you know you only cum when daddy says so,” he chides, gripping your hair tight.
“Oh my God!”
“Jesus, I always forget how pathetic you get when you’re desperate to cum,” he chuckles darkly before dipping down and biting your neck.
“Daddy please!”
“I want her to hear you,” he husks against the shell of your ear as he starts to massage your clit.
“Fuck!”
“Makeher hear how much you love me.”
“Daddy!”
“Make her hear how much we love each other, because I love you so fucking much, sweet girl.”
“OH FUCK!” you cry out, squirting hard all over his cock, and you’re more than certain you’ve made a mess on the carpet.
“Such a good little whore,” he praises before pulling out and flipping you on your back.
“Daddy!”
“I know, sweet girl, I know,” he coos, gripping your hips and adjusting you a little before thrusting himself inside you again. “Daddy’s gonna take such good care of you.”
“You...you always, fuck! You always do,” you sob, pulling at the ends of his sweater. “Wanna see all of you, please!”
“Anything for you, sweet girl.”
If Laurie is still out there you can’t hear her.
Andy quickly discards his sweater before dipping down and pressing soft kisses to your collar bone.
“Oh God, please don’t stop, daddy!”
“You’re so fucking perfect, baby! Everything about you...”
“Fuck!”
“C’mere,” he broods before pulling you upright with him. “So fucking gorgeous.”
You look down at him as your hair falls in front of your face, taking in every bit of his hard, beautiful body. You’re sure that you’ll never see a more gorgeous man in your life, and you’re also sure that no one will ever make you feel as good.
His hand travels down between your bodies, and his fingers find your most sensitive spot and you know that everything happening tonight is real. He chooses you, he loves you, and he wants you.
He needs you.
“Too full, daddy! Too...oh God!”
“You can take a little bit more, babygirl,” he husks as he starts rubbing your clit faster.
“Daddy...please! I need it!”
“Gonna make you so fucking happy, sweet girl! Never gonna...fuck, never gonna be brokenhearted again!”
“Fuck! I’m gonna...fuck!” you mewl while clawing at his back.
“Jesus, sweet girl! Let go! Let go right now!”
You scream Andy’s name as your orgasm washes over you, clenching around him tighter when you feel his release filling you up.
Neither of you say anything. You just hold on to him tightly, trying to come down from your euphoria as well as trying to stay awake.
“You okay, babe?” he asks after a moment.
“Mhm.”
“Was I too rough?”
“No daddy.”
His phone buzzes and you whine in protest. “Just rest, sweetheart.”
“You said...you said you have another gift for me,” you breathe as his phone buzzes again. “You may as well answer her.”
“She can wait.”
“Clearly not.”
“Hey, come back to me,” he coos softly. “Don’t get upset over her. Not now, not tonight.”
“She’s just never gonna go away. She’ll always be around.”
“But that has nothing to do with us.”
“Andy-”
“Y/N, I love you. Whatever bullshit Laurie is dealing with is just that: her bullshit. It’s just you and me now.”
“You feel that way now-”
“I’ll always feel that way.”
You sigh and rest your forehead against his, “today was perfect. I love you, thank you.”
“I’d do anything for you.”
“What’s my other gift?”
“Oh,” he chuckles, “that. You’re gonna freak out, but don’t.”
“Andy, what did you do?”
“Well, you said you wanted us to go away together.”
“And?”
“You said wanted us to have our own ‘Roman Holiday’.”
“You didn’t!”
“Before you start yelling, it isn’t as expensive as you think it is and-”
“Andy! I said I would save up money!”
“You wanted it, so I wanted you to have it,” he says simply with a shrug.
You cup his face in your hands and kiss him like you’re afraid he’s about to leave you. His hold on you tightens, he deepens the kiss, and you feel him coming back to life.
“Andy,” you moan, grinding yourself against him as his phone buzzes again. “For fucks sake!”
“I’ll answer her and then I swear I’ll take care of you,” he groans, pulling out of you as you settle yourself underneath the Christmas tree.
Andy’s quickly gets his phone, and you undress yourself, deciding that clothes are no longer necessary for the rest of the night.
“What the fuck?” he mumbles as he starts making his way to the front door.
“What’s wrong?”
“More like, what’s right,” he counters as he opens the door. “There’s no fucking way...”
“Andy, what’s going on?”
“Holy shit!” he exclaims, grabbing something out of the mailbox before closing the door, turning to face you. “She signed the papers.”
“Are you serious? What did she say in the texts? Are you fucking serious?”
“A few choice words about you-”
“I can handle it.”
“Sweetheart-”
“Just read it, Andy.”
He sighs before unlocking his phone. “You and that little whore are disgusting, I hope you know that. Also, the whole block can probably hear you two, so that’s a nice gift for everyone on Christmas. I hope whoever the fuck she is that she’s worth all the hell you’re wreaking on our family. I just want you to know that when she walks away, I’ll be ready to take you back. I love you. Merry Christmas.”
“How did she even find our home?”
“Probably Jacob, cause she still doesn’t know that I’m with you.”
“I feel like there’s a catch. Laurie being selfless? It doesn’t add up.”
“Her signature is everywhere it needs to be, sweetheart. It’s finally fucking official,” he smiles at you.
Without giving it another thought, you’re on your feet, running over to him and jumping on him as soon as your arms are around him.
“This is real?”
“As real as it gets, sweetheart.”
“You still want me?”
“Ya know, I think I’ll use the next few hours to show you just how much I still want you. How much I’ll always want you,” he smirks before starting to run up the stairs as you start laughing.
In the back of your mind, you know this isn’t as simple as Laurie is making it seem, but for right now, you don’t care. You belong to Andy completely and he finally belongs to only you. Yes, he’s been telling you how you’re the only one for him, but this is different. It’s so much more. Yeah, you’re one step closer to pure and utter chaos, but you’re also one step closer an actual real relationship that’s truly worth all of the energy and stress you’ve put into it.
Merry Christmas indeed.
**
“I don’t wanna go back to my loft tomorrow,” you sigh as you rest your head on Andy’s chest, intertwining your fingers with his.
“Then just move in. This your home.”
“I know, but we haven’t told Jacob yet and...it’s gonna be hard, but we need to do it. We need to have that talk with him before we officially do anything.”
“He comes back tomorrow, so lets-”
“I’ve been thinking about that too,” you practically mumble as you make little circles on his chest with your pointer finger.
“Y/N.”
“Just hear me out. I’m not backing out of anything, or asking for more time. I just don’t want our vacation to be filled with me crying because Jacob hates me.”
“He won’t-”
“Don’t, Andy. Just don’t. He’s going to be furious with the both of us. I don’t want out first trip away together to be clouded by that.”
“Sweetheart, the trip isn’t until May.”
“I know, I know. So, if you still want to tell him when he gets back tomorrow, I’m fine with that.”
“No, you have a point,” he sighs. “He is gonna be furious and you’re gonna be beside yourself, and that’s something I don’t want. Especially during our very first trip together. I just don’t like keeping it from him.”
“Trust me, I feel the same, but the timing wasn’t right. It didn’t help that it took Laurie for-fucking-ever to sign the damn papers,”
“At least she signed them though, and that’s something to smile about,” he reassures you with a gentle squeeze.
“Yeah, you have a point. What did she agree to in the end?”
“She keeps the house, her car, we split our Savings and I keep whatever is in mine, she gets the furniture, and she gets to keep the timeshare we got in California.”
“You have a timeshare?”
“Had a timeshare,” he laughs, but he can sense your uneasiness. “Uh oh, what’s wrong, sweetheart?”
“It’s stupid.”
“Talk to me.”
“There’s just so much...I don’t want you to feel like you have get me things because you have more than me.”
“Y/N-”
“And it’s not like I think you’re rich or anything, it’s just very obvious that you have more money than me and-”
“Hey, stop,” he chuckles softly. “I don’t buy you things because I think of you as some charity case. I do it because I love you and I love making you happy.”
“I’m just not used to being loved, Andy. I’m not used to being the girl that someone picks.”
“Well, take as much time as you need to get used to it,” he reassures you before kissing the top of your head.
“You really wanna face the world with me when all of this comes out?”
“I wanna face the world with you no matter what.”
“I love you, Andy.”
“I love you, Y/N. I love you more than you’ll ever know,” he whispers before pressing a soft kiss into your hair.
As you both lay in bed, looking up at the moon, you wonder just how well you both will handle the hell that’s about to come your way. You believe in the love that Andy has for you, and you know it’s stronger than anything you’ve ever felt, but the fear is still there, because who the hell ever chooses you? You’re terrified of pushing him away, but you don’t have a fucking clue in hell how to keep him close when it all becomes too much.
God, you really hope you don’t fuck this up.
Jacob’s P.O.V.
“What do you mean you’re going away?” I ask as you continue to pack.
“I just need to get out of here. I feel like I’m gonna lose my fucking my mind,” you huff, slamming a drawer shut.
It’s not like I haven’t noticed the changes in you since Sarah and I got back from vacation, but this just seems drastic.
Then again, your moods have been too.
You’re either extremely happy or severely distant. You either wanna be left alone or are desperate to hangout. You’re not you and for as much as I wanna ask you about it, Sarah keeps telling me that you’ll talk about it when you’re ready, and I know she’s right, but lately it feels like you’re a million miles away and I can’t reel you back in, no matter how hard I try. I hate that.
I hate feeling like it’s no longer me and you against the world.
“It’s just for a few weeks,” you mutter, throwing more close into your suitcase.
“It’s just my dad and now you-”
“What’s going on with your dad?”
“He told me that he got tickets for a vacation last week. Between work and all the shit with my mom, he just needs a break.”
“That makes sense.”
“Y/N, can you please just take a break and tell me what’s going on?”
“We’ll talk when I get back.”
“Y/N-”
“Jacob, its been a hell of a few months...a hell of a few years. I just need to finally do something for me.”
What aren’t you telling me?
“Y/N, what’s going on with you? I know you say that nothing’s changed between us, but it feels like it has. I don’t feel close to you anymore.”
“Jake-”
“You can’t tell me that you haven’t noticed a change in our friendship.”
“Of course there is! Both of our lives are changing! You’re planning a wedding!”
“And what about your life? What’s going on? Please talk to me!”
You’re hesitant before you answer me, “I might be moving when I get back. I don’t know, nothing’s been decided yet.”
“Moving? Where? Why?”
“It’s just time for a change. I feel like I need to uproot and start over. I’m not gonna be far, I’m just-”
“Are you moving in with someone?”
You’re hesitant again. “Why does it matter?”
“Why won’t you tell me?”
“Jake, whether I am or I’m not doesn’t concern you.”
“Why won’t you tell me?”
“Jake-”
“Is it my dad?”
“What the...why would you say that?”
“My mom’s been saying-”
“Don’t finish that statement,” you warn before walking over to your dresser and grabbing more clothes.
“What’s that supposed to mean?”
“We’ll talk about of it when I get back.”
“Why not now?”
“Because I don’t wanna fucking talk about it right now!” you snap, throwing your things down.
I’ve clearly hit some nerve, because you’ve never acted this way with me before.
“Y/N-”
“I just can’t do this right now. That’s all there is to it. There’s a lot going on that I don’t know how to deal with and I don’t know how to put them into words, so I just don’t feel like doing it now.”
“There was a time when you were okay with telling me everything, and now-”
“How are things with Sarah?’ you counter.
“What do you mean-we’re fine?”
“Then why aren’t off planning a wedding with her?”
“One, everything is on hold till you get back; not my decision, hers. Two, my best friend is icing me out-”
“I’m not icing you out, Jacob!”
“Listen, if you’re just over this friendship, just have the fucking decency to say it, because-”
“Jacob, just stop! Please...stop,” you sob.
Great, now I feel like an asshole.
“Y/N-”
“When I get back, okay? We’ll talk about everything when I get back, okay?”
“You could always talk to me before-”
“And I know I can now,” you interrupt with a heavy sigh, “I’m just tired of talking and planning right now. I need a break and then I’ll be back to myself.”
I can’t fault you for that. You’ve spent your whole life arguing and planning, it only make sense that you’re fed up.
But still.
“When you get back?”
“I promise, Jake.”
“I love you.”
“I love you too, Jacob. Just go home and rest, okay?”
Something is off, but there’s no use in pushing. Not when you’re like this.
All I can do is give you a kiss on the cheek before making my way out of your place. I guess I made it our home, which was fucked up on my part.
It’s not like I lied to my dad when I said that my feelings for you aren’t stronger than the love I have for Sarah, it’s just that you’ve always made me feel normal. Being my friend has never been easy, but you’ve never left my side. You’ve always defended me, gotten into actual fights, and have always believed me. Believed in me. Sarah and I separated at one point, and it’s not like I can blame her, but you...you’ve always been there. From the day that we met, you’ve never let my side.
I know that you’ll eventually meet someone and they’ll become the love of your life, and they’ll more than likely be older, but the way that my mother is going on about it being my father...you wouldn’t do that, would you?
I’m your best friend.
However, you didn’t deny it and that has me on edge. You probably haven’t noticed, but I see the way he looks at you, and I know you think he’s insanely attractive (like every other woman in this dumb little town). I can handle you being with someone else, but my dad?
What does he have that I don’t?
“Is everything okay?” Sarah asks as I make my way into our home; bridal magazines everywhere.
“She says so.”
“Baby, I’m sure whatever is going on, she’ll tell you when she gets back.”
“Her and my dad leaving on the same day? Even you have to notice that it’s a bit strange.”
“Babe-”
“Plus, every time I ask him about his girlfriend, he changes the subject, which is fucking weird since they’ve been dating for months.”
“Well, what did she say when you asked her?”
“She didn’t confirm it.”
“There ya go.”
“She also didn’t deny it.”
“If there’s anything to tell you, she will.”
“Why are you so calm about this?”
“Because I don’t care,” she scoffs with a shrug.
“Well, why not?!”
“Honey, they’re both adults. If they want to date, just let them, it’s really not a big deal.”
“So, you don’t care that Y/N might be the reason that my dad left my mom?”
“No, because you and I both know that the problems in your parents’ marriage didn’t start with y/n. I think that there’s a bigger issue here.”
“Not that shit again!”
“Jacob, just tell me-”
“I just want you, babe. I only want you.”
“Are you sure?”
“Sarah, you’ve been the one ever since I met you, and that’s not changing any time soon,” I promise with a smile.
It’s not like it’s a lie. Sarah is the only person I want to be with...I just need you to be with anyone but my dad. That’s not asking too much...is it?
Y/N’s P.O.V.
“We have to go to the Mouth of Truth before leave!” you whine as Andy picks you up and carries you into the villa you’ve both been staying at for a week and a half.
“We’re gonna go, I promise,” he laughs, “we’ve got two more days.”
“No, lets just stay here. Here is so much better.”
“I wish we could, sweetheart,” he sighs as his phone goes off. “For fucks sake.”
“Just ignore it.”
“You know I can’t,” he mutters as he sets you down before taking out his phone and answering it. “Hey bud, what’s up?”
For the most part, the vacation has been amazing. The villa Andy got you both is beautiful, you’ve been to almost every place you’ve seen in ‘Roman Holiday’ along with a few places that Andy’s always wanted to visit, the dinners you two have made for each other have perfect, and the sex has been remarkable.
That doesn’t mean it’s been smooth sailing.
Every day, Jacob calls you and Andy, looking for cracks in either of your stories, Laurie texts him non-stop, and Sarah has told you multiple times that she’s getting tired of Jacob’s obsession over the whole.
If things are this bad, you can’t even begin to imagine how much worse they’ll be when you two get home and tell everyone. However, you’re not home yet, and you’re determined to make the best of the last few days you two have left. You quickly slip into the blue lace lingerie you were saving for the last day of the trip, your skinny black heels, and let your hair done. You do a quick look over in the mirror before making your way downstairs.
“I’m sure she’ just taking a break from...,” Andy trails off once his eyes land on you, jaw dropping just a little.
Mission accomplished.
“I’m sorry, I got distracted,” he almost stutters as he clears his throat, “I’m sure she’s just taking a break...she is on vacation, Jake.”
“Hang up,” you mouth as you straddle him, starting to undo the button on his jeans.
“You said she seemed pretty stressed and frustrated when she was packing, so I would imagine....she has a lot going on. I’m sure she’ll tell you everything when she gets back...I’ve been working non-stop for 4 years, Jake. I just-” he gasps as you slide yourself down on him, “I-I needed a break. Your mother and I talked about gong away a lot, but....but we never did it.”
“Hang up,” you mouth again as you start to pick your pace, hitting that spot deep within that makes you come alive for him.
“Listen, when...when I get back home, you and I will have a lunch or dinner, and we’ll talk about everything...y-yes...yes, we can go to the diner,” he breathes as he grips your throat tight, “I’ll talk to you later and I’ll be home soon.”
“Daddy please,” you mouth, gripping his shoulders as your climax starts to build. “Need you so much.”
Andy’s eyes go wide as he watches you, memorized by the way you move your hips as you take your bra off, your mouth agape as you try to hold on.
“I gotta...I gotta go, okay? Yes Jacob, we’ll talk soon...I really gotta go...I love you too,” he grunts before finally fucking hanging up.
“Daddy!” you cry out come undone, leaning your forehead against his.
“Now, who told you to be a whore and pull that little stunt, huh?”
“I want all of your attention, daddy. This is our trip, isn’t it?”
“You don’t feel important?” he taunts as he wraps his arms around before getting up, “you don’t think you’re my main focus?”
“No,” you moan, wrapping your legs around him as the feel of him deeper inside of you starts driving you insane as he heads for up the stairs.
“I thought I was doing a good idea of that night after night.”
“Shit,” you moan, grinding yourself against him.
“And every morning when I wake you up by eating this perfect little pussy.”
“I just need...need you! Didn’t feel important,” you whine.
“Let daddy fix that,” he smirks, laying you down on the bed before fucking into you relentlessly. “Let daddy make you feel better!”
“Fuck!”
“My sweet, sweet girl.”
“Oh my God!”
“You’re so fucking beautiful, baby. God, I never get tired at looking you...at this perfect little body.”
“Fuck, I’m so...so close!”
“Yeah? You gonna be a good girl and cream on daddy’s cock?”
All you can do is nod.
“Use your words,” he growls, slapping your clit.
“Fuck! Yes...YES!” you cry out, gripping the sheets as your body trembles.
“Such a good girl,” he praises as he pulls out, “I want you to tell me how good you taste,” he coos as he slides two fingers inside of you.
“Fuck, daddy!”
“Tell me, baby,” he encourages as he smears your lips with your cum. “Daddy really wants to know.”
“So good,” you moan as you lick your lips.
“Yeah? I think I’ll find out for myself,” he smirks before getting on his knees.
“Fuck, you make...make me feel...shit!” you cry out, gripping his hair as uses three of his fingers fuck you, while he sucks and licks your clit. “So fucking good to me,” you moan.
You prop up yourself using one of your elbows and look down, meeting Andy’s intense gaze on you.
“I...I love you so much, Andy,” you brood, feeling that knot in your core tighten. “I only...only need...you!” you cry out, coating his fingers (and you’re sure his face) with your release.
Andy takes his time cleaning you up, keeping his eyes on you, before slowly peppering you body with the most soft and delicate kisses hes ever given you, as he makes his way up your body.
“Never been this in love with anyone,” he groans he pushes himself inside of you. “Never knew I could be this in love.”
“Andy!”
“You are everything to me. I’m gonna love you until...until my dying breath,” his promises as his movements start to become erratic.
Between your juices still glistening on his beard, his words, and the fact that he keeps hitting that spot inside of you that makes your whole body ignite, you feel yourself ready to come apart for the final part.
“Can’t...need to let go!”
“Do it, sweet girl! Give me everything!”
“Andy!” you sob, squirting all over his cock as you dig your nails into his back.
“Fuck!”
You both just stay there for a moment, living in the moment, and trying to commit to memory how perfect this moment is.
“I’m just tired of hiding, baby,” you breathe after a moment.
“I know sweetheart, I can’t wait to tell Jacob about us.”
“Do you mean that?”
“Sweetheart, it’s not going to be ideal, and I know we’ll have hell to pay, but I just want to be with you. That’s all I care about at this point. Hell or high water, we’ll finally be together for real. I’m in love with you and I want to finally express that the right way. Not just in private.”
“He’s gonna be so hurt, Andy.”
“I know, sweetheart, but he’ll get over it.”
“Can we just ignore our phones for the next few days? The trip is almost over and I don’t wanna deal with anything that’ll make us unhappy until we get back.”
“Sounds good to me, sweet girl. Come here,” he coaxes softly.
You move closer to him and lay your head on his chest, sighing in content as he wraps his arms around you.
There will never be a better feeling than being in Andy’s arms.
“Lets just do it when we get back. We can do dinner at our house and we’ll just...we’ll deal with it,” Andy suggests with a heavy sigh. “Our flight lands at 3:30...it’s time to get it over with. Tell Jacob then tell Laurie.”
“Oh God, Laurie.”
“Yeah, that’ll more than likely go worse than everything with Jacob.”
“What the fuck did we get ourselves into?” you laugh humorlessly.
“Love. We got ourselves into love.”
“You’re damn right we did,” you smile up at him.
For the rest of the trip, you and Andy ignore your phones and just focus on each other. You go site seeing, dancing, make love, watch ‘Roman Holiday’, make dinners, go out to the best restaurants, and just live in the moment. There’s no sense in pretending that going home won’t be chaotic, so you both decide that it’s best to just live in the moment until it’s time to go back.
Until it’s time to deal with the consequences of your actions.
“Andy, are you sure-”
“Honey, I know all of this is scary, but I’m not changing my mind. It’s gonna be rough, it’s gonna suck, but we’ll get through it,” he interrupts as you both lay in bed and stare up at the ceiling.
“I just want you to be sure that you want this. Want us. Want me.”
“I’m never gonna change my mind, sweetheart. I’m all in forever. Are you?”
“You’re the only one for me. Always have been and you always will be.”
“Just don’t forget that we have each other, okay? No matter how chaotic it may seem, you have me and I have you.”
“You don’t forget either.”
“It’s you and me,” he smiles down at you. “It’s me and you until the end.”
As you both lay in bed, trying to calm your nerves about heading back tomorrow, you know that you both have the same question on your mind: how the fuck do we approach this?
“Lets do dinner at the loft,” you suggest, catching yourself as you’re about to fall asleep.
“Hm?”
“I think it’ll soften the blow. Us telling him that we’re together and that we’re living together? It’s gonna be too much at once.”
“But you’re moving in-”
“No, I know, but lets just take it one thing at a time. If we tell him we went on vacation together, have been dating for a while, and live together, he’s gonna lose his shit.”
“You’re making a more than good point and that’s annoying.”
“Trust me, I don’t like it either. He knows that I’m moving and I’m sure that he’ll put two and two together once we tell him, but I think the visualization will be too much for him.”
“Alright, we’ll tell him at the loft and you’ll finally move home the next day?”
“I promise.”
“Then we better get some sleep. We have an early flight.”
“Sounds good...I love you, Andy.”
“I love you, Y/N.”
As you both settle into bed, anxiety at an all time high, you hope and pray that telling Jacob won’t be as bad as you think it will be.
Yeah, he’ll be hurt and annoyed, but he’ll hopefully get over it quick...right?
You drift off to sleep with that thought leading and you can only pray to God that you’re right.
Please, just this once, let things not be painful.
**
“What time are they coming over?” Andy yawns as gets out of the bathroom with a towel wrapped around his waist, sitting next to you on the sofa.
“One, get dressed,” you laugh, “two, you need a damn nap.”
“I’m fine.”
“You know I can see you, right? That’s bullshit, you need rest.”
“It’ll just fuck up me adjusting to the time change. Lets watch something that’ll keep me awake.”
“Or, you can take a nap and store up your energy.”
“There is never going to be enough sleep in the world for me to tell my son that I’m in love with his best friend.”
“That’s fair.”
“What are you watching?”
“ ‘Chicago’”
“Of course you are,” he laughs as he wraps an arm around you. “What time will they be here?”
“In two hours.”
“Shit, okay.”
“Just take a deep breath, baby. At least we’ll tell him and have it out of the way. Like you said last week, he won’t be angry with you forever.”
“He won’t be angry with you forever, either.”
“I’m not worried about me. I can handle him hating me, I just want you two to be okay.”
“Sweetheart-”
“I mean it, Andy. Your relationship with him is more important than mine.”
Andy says nothing. He just cups your face and kisses you passionately, and you let yourself get lost in it.
Lost in him.
It’s not like you two mean to get carried away, but it’s so hard for you two to contain yourselves. Soon enough, the kiss leads to you two making out, making out leads to you straddling him and grinding yourself against him, which leads to you on your knees and blowing him, which is why your clothes and the towel he was wearing are now on the floor and he’s fucking you senseless.
“Oh my God!’ you whimper as Andy picks up his pace as he sits up.
“You take my fucking cock so well, sweet girl!”
“Daddy!”
“No one has ever been take me as well as you do, not even her,” he grunts and smirks when you clench around him.
You’ll never admit it outloud but you love it when he tells you how much better you are at pleasing than Laurie ever was. Yes, it’s mean petty, and a bit sick, but fuck all if it doesn’t make you feel all that much more special and important to him.
“You got so fucking wet just from sucking daddy’s cock! Should’ve tasted this perfect little pussy before I started fucking it!”
“Oh my...fuck!’
“Got your fucking cream all over my fucking cock! God, wish you could see...shit, you I could stay in this fucking cunt all day!”
“Daddy!’
“I should film me fucking you, just so you can see just how well this greedy little cunt takes my cock!”
“Please!” you mindlessly beg, with one hand clawing at the bed and the other clawing at his chest.
“Of course my good little whore wants to me film me filling up this pretty little pussy,” he smirks devilishly before slapping your clit.
“Jesus...fuck!”
“I’ll fill this pussy then, while I fuck your ass, you can watch how wrecked you looked while I fucked this sweet little cunt. You want that, sweet girl?”
You’re too blissed out to answer. Andy spits on your on your already soaked and sticky cunt, before starting to massage your clit.
“Can’t...can’t...daddy please!”
“You don’t cum until you answer me,” he husks. “Do you want to record us? Do you wanna watch how well you take daddy’s fat cock while I fuck your perfect little ass?”
“Yes! Yes, I wanna see how well...how I take your cock, daddy! How good I am at pleasing you!”
“Fuck, and the way your perfect tits bounce with every thrust! You’re so fucking perfect, sweet girl! Ya know, daddy thinks he’ll record you soaking the bed,” he chuckles before grabbing his phone off your nightstand.
You two always take it too far.
“Look at the camera, baby. Fuck, those tears! Feel too good sweet girl?” “Yes daddy! I need to...I need to let go!”
“Such a good little whore, keep your eyes on the camera as you cum, sweet-”
“WHAT THE FUCK?!” Jacob exclaims as he bursts through the door.
And busted.
“Jacob, get out!” Andy yells, instantly covering you as you cum hard and squirt all over Andy’s cock and the bed.
This is definitely in the top three moments you never want relieve or remember in your life.
“You fucking said-”
“Go wait in the kitchen! Get out!” Andy yells as you bury your face in the crook of his neck in an attempt to hide.
Jacob huffs before slamming your bedroom door shut. This wasn’t how things were supposed to go at all.
“Looks like someone found his key to my place,” you mutter as you fight off your tears.
“Are you okay, sweetheart?”
“Why? Why the fuck did we have to get carried away now?!”
“I’ll go out there and-”
“No, we’ll go together. I just...I need a moment.”
“I’m so fucking sorry, sweetheart.”
“This isn’t on you. You didn’t force me into anything; I wanted you. I always want you. I knew they were coming and I still...fuck!”
“We can do this another-”
“No, he’s already seen...we may as well just deal with this now.”
“Are you sure, sweetheart?”
“I’m all in,” you smile up at him weakly.
Andy cleans you up and the both take your time getting dressed, not sure how the hell you’re going to approach the current situation at hand. You pull on the AC/DC sweatshirt Andy got you and the Boston College sweatpants Jacob got you, while Andy opts to only wear a pair of black sweatpants.
If the situation weren’t what it is, you would drag him back to bed, but there’s obviously no time for that.
“Does anyone want a drink?” you ask as you two finally make your way out of your room.
“I’ll take one,” Sarah mumbles as she leans against the kitchen island.
“We need to talk about-”
“We’re definitely gonna talk about it. Do you want a drink?” you interrupt Jacob as you pull two glasses out of the cabinet.
“You’re acting like-”
“I’m not acting like anything, Jacob. You and I are about to have a talk about how I’ve been dating your father and in love with him for a while. I’m gonna have a fucking drink. How about you? Do you want something that’ll help the sting or do you wanna have this talk completely sober?” you ask, finally turning your attention to him.
He’s thoughtful before he speaks, “yeah, I guess I’ll take that drink.”
“You?” you ask as you turn to Andy.
“Yeah, I think I will, sweetheart.”
You pour the four of you a tall glass of bourbon, before handing them all out and standing at Andy’s side.
“So...lets have it out. Lets talk about...your father and your best friend,” you mutter before taking a sip of your drink. “Lets talk about your father and your best friend being in love.”
~~
taglist: @maroonsunrise83, @emerald-evans, @fuckingbye, @whxre4cevans, @autumnrose40, @greeneyedblondie44, @whiskeytangofoxtrot555, @pono-pura-vida, @nomadstucky, @sapphire-rogers, @jamneuromain
247 notes
·
View notes
i was an angel, looking to get f*cked hard. like a groupie incognito posing as a real singer
summary: a disaster.
warnings: like, everything. threesomes mmf and ffm. anal, like extreme anal too. oral. vaginal, and also extreme vaginal bc yikes that got crazy there for a moment. slight bondage. steve being the b e s t (imo that’s a logical warning)
word count: around 9,250
relationships: steve rogers x reader (main), andy barber x reader, mike weiss x reader, ransom drysdale x reader, robert pronge x reader, ari levinson x reader, colin shea x reader, nick vaughan x reader, frank adler, wanda maximoff x reader
a/n: i’m just discreetly dropping this mess in the cover of night lol. literally will never understand why my mind came up with this idea. but if you see this fic, who was your favorite power duo?
To you, it was just another normal day. You were on Steve’s lap, your legs draped over his, his knees pressed hard against your inner thighs to keep you open, your ass grinding down on his hard cock. With two fingers buried in your overworked pussy and a thumb rounding your clit, you couldn’t sit up on your own. You were leaned back against his chest, babbling all the while your cunt made a mess on his pants and the bed.
To Steve, well, he had other plans. “What do you think your weirdest fantasy is, doll?”
He was only asking because you were so distracted, so weak-minded in that moment to feel anything even close to shame. But the last thing you ever wanted was to hurt Steve, didn’t matter how fucked out you were.
“I don’t know,” you mumbled.
“You know you can tell me anything, right? I know you’re a beautiful woman who gets a lot of attention. It’s all right…”
“Steve?” you prompted. Why this question? Why now? And what did he mean by attention?
His mouth was at your ear when he spoke next. “You were talking in your sleep again.”
You immediately felt hot all over, and it was not because of your impending orgasm. “What did I say?”
“Some very interesting things. But I wanna hear it again. I wanna hear it now that you’re wide awake.”
You turned your head up, shivering when he didn’t stop moving his fingers. “I love you.”
“I know you do, my gorgeous girl. I always know. But I love you, too, and I want to make sure I give you everything you want. You can tell me, I would never betray your trust.”
“Well,” you squeaked, feeling like your throat was about to close, “lately…”
He curled his fingers up just right and you cried out. “It’s okay, baby, I’ve got all day. I’ll get it out of you one way or another.”
“It’s just…um, lately…I’ve kind of been thinking about, like, being fucked…”
He hummed.
“By, like, a lot of people. Like…in one night.”
He scoffed. “People or men?”
“Well…”
“It’s okay,” he assured. “You want to be fucked by a lot of different cocks, yeah?”
All you could do was nod.
“That’s okay, baby. I was just curious is all. Just like you are. It’s not wrong to fantasize about that.”
“But I don’t need it, okay? I only need you.”
“I know,” he assured. “I know how much you love my cock.”
“And you.”
He nodded, smirking. “Yes, and me.”
When Steve had come home from his run several days later, you had felt him watching you. You craved him immediately because even after all these years, all the nights he had fucked you senseless, the missions the two of you couldn’t go without being connected, you still ached to be wrapped around him because you loved him so much.
He kissed you slowly, pointedly before he went to take a shower. You went to his bedroom several minutes later and waited for him on his bed. You stripped down to nothing but your bra and panties.
You knew he heard you come in and he heard you drop your clothing, he heard you climb on the bed, and he could hear you breathing. You were certain he could smell you, too. You were drenched just thinking about fucking him. It was unnatural how badly you wanted Steve sometimes.
He came out without a towel, water dripping onto the floor.
You scoffed. “Baby, stop making a mess.”
“Don’t be hypocritical, doll. You’re about to make a mess of the bed.”
You arched an eyebrow. “Am I?”
Still soaking wet, he approached the bed carefully. He showed zero hesitation as he laid himself on top of you.
You laughed. “Steve, you’re getting water everywhere!”
He didn’t care, he just kissed you, filthy, all tongue, moaning into your open mouth. His hands slid up and down your torso, your hips, your thighs, never touching you quite where you wanted him to.
You felt his cock between your bodies, already hard. You attempted to reach down to move your underwear aside, but he caught both of your hands and pinned them to the mattress over your head.
He broke the kiss to stare down at you.
“Well, are you going to make me make a mess, or what?”
“I have something new I wanna try, doll.”
You scoffed. “New? Is there anything you haven’t done to me yet?”
He looked excited to answer the question, but knew if he started to think about it, this situation would quickly spiral out of his control. “Well, remember how Wanda took an entire town hostage?”
Your mouth dropped. “I don’t think we’re supposed to talk about that.”
“Oh, she’s fine now. That’s what therapy is for.”
“Okay, but your point is?”
“She’s gotten much better at using those powers.”
“Like…the mental stuff? Like…” You hated to use these negative terms because you hardly blamed Wanda for everything that went down, but until Bruce had come up with the sensitive script, you were all just going in blind. “Like, mind control?”
“Yeah.”
“Tell me how that’s relevant right now, Steven.”
“Better at mind control, better at…creating worlds. It doesn’t even have to be out here anymore, she could get inside your mind and make you think you were living a life that she completely made up.”
You narrowed your eyes. “What are you saying?”
“I asked her for a little help. You remember what we talked about the other day? How you want to get fucked by different men?”
“That is not what I said because I definitely do not want that.”
“You don’t want to get fucked by other men, in reality. In a world created by Wanda, however…”
“Steve, I don’t—”
“Just try it with me. She’s gonna come in here, you’re going to let her in that gorgeous head of yours. I’ll be there with you the entire time.”
“How will I know it’s really you?”
“I promise, baby. That’s what she said. She can do that, she can put us both in one little world that no one can interrupt us in.”
“So…who’s fucking me? Because if it’s Bucky, that is so weak, Steve. We can have a threesome in real life, grow up.”
“Nope. No one on the team.”
You were immeasurably confused then. “Do you even know other people?”
“I know you inside and out, and I know who you want to fuck.”
“You think there’s anyone in this world that I think compares to you?”
“In this world? Oh, no. Hang on, I’m gonna get dressed and then I’ll get Wanda.”
It was clear then that he wasn’t going to tell you a thing. Steve could be elaborate when he wanted to and his “in this world” comment was starting to scare you. If not this world, what world?
You watched him finally dry off and slip into a simple t-shirt and jeans. Shamelessly, your eyes moved over his body, thighs rubbing together when he tucked his cock into his pants.
“You touch yourself and this isn’t going to be as pleasant as I wanted it to be.”
You lifted both hands to the headboard. “They won’t move, I promise.”
He moved over you again, kissing your forehead. “You know how much I enjoy rewarding you when you’re a good girl.”
“Mhm.”
“I’ll be right back.”
When he returned with Wanda, you were trying not to think about how weird this was. You loved Wanda and yes, you were both comfortable enough that you’d been naked together. But in a sexual way? Never happened. This was obviously sexual. How did he talk her into this? Probably an early birthday present.
“Lie down next to her,” she directed.
You moved over a little, finally placing your arms back down to your sides. He got on the bed next to you, turning his head to kiss your cheek. You couldn’t help but smile, some of those twisting nervous feelings were starting to get quieter now that he was so close to you.
Wanda sat down next to you. “Are you calm?”
“Not really,” you admitted.
“You need to be calm,” she instructed. “Just close your eyes.”
You did so, mindful of your breathing and trying not to let your thoughts get ahead of you.
“You should probably tell her who she’s going to see,” Wanda recommended. “She’s going to panic there and ruin this whole thing.”
“I wanted it to be a surprise, but she is the worst about this stuff. I can never manage it.” He took one of your hands in his, his fingers sliding between yours. “Baby, remain calm.”
“Okay…”
“You know that actor you’re so in love with?”
You immediately sat up, staring at him with wide eyes. “What?!”
He sighed at you and reminded, “Calm.”
“How does anyone stay calm after that, Steve?”
“Lie back down now,” he directed, and you did so with a sigh. “Now, you made me watch many of his movies and that one show... who else would I let fuck my girlfriend?”
“This is weird.”
“No, this is fictional, meaning that it’s not real. Meaning that yes, you’re going to feel like you’re getting fucked by different men, but you’re not going to be. This is the only way I can accept this fantasy of yours.”
You looked at Wanda. “How is this even going to work?”
“So, your thoughts and opinions about these characters will influence their behavior. Think of it like I’m a spider, spinning a web with your thoughts.”
“And you’re the prey caught in the web,” Steve tried.
Wanda gave him a flat look. “No.”
You snorted. “Okay, so…it’s all just what I think they would do?”
She nodded.
“And you promise Steve will really be there with me?”
“I promise.”
“Like, it will really be Steve? Not just some imaginary Steve of my mind?”
“Honey, I brought my boyfriend back from the dead and kept him with me in a town for a very long time. I think I can manage you and Steve for a few hours.”
Steve lifted your joined hands and kissed the back of your palm.
You turned to look at him.
“I promise I’ll be there the entire time. No one, not even a fictional man will touch you without my permission.”
You snorted. “And mine?”
He smiled. “Right. That was what I meant.”
“Oh, I’m sure.”
“Mostly, what you will experience will be based on your mind. But Steve will be there too, equally part of this, so I can also take feedback from him. If he wants someone to do something to you, I’ll know, and I can make it happen. You’ll know it’s really him then, won’t you?”
Yes, more than likely. Steve certainly had a very specific style in the bedroom.
“Okay, so just relax for me,” Wanda tried again.
Steve kissed your hand again and you settled back down on your pillow. You once more paid special attention to the steadiness of your breathing and tried to quiet your racing mind.
“Okay, just focus on my voice,” Wanda said. “I’m going to count down.” She pressed her fingers to your temple lightly and began at 10.
The next thing you knew, you were in a dimly lit room, naked and lying on a leather surface. Your legs were open, ankles bound, and your hands were tied together over your head, also wrapped around something you could not see. You were spread out and on display, incapable of even moving an inch on your own.
“You good, baby?”
You looked up where Steve’s voice sounded. He was naked as well; you could see all that muscle you always enjoyed even with the dull lights. “I’m good.”
“You okay with being tied up?”
“I think so.”
“At any point, you want to stop, just say my name.”
“Just your name?”
“You want me to stop, yes, say my name.” He started walking along the table, his hand coming out to trail down the side of your body. “But if you want me to keep going, you can call me daddy.”
You scoffed. A group-sex kink and a daddy kink all in one day? “Wow, you’re just going all out, aren’t you?”
“Oh, you think this is my fantasy? You said a lot the other night.”
“You could have woken me up. That is such an invasion of privacy.”
“If I had woken you up, this wouldn’t be happening. I have no regrets, doll.” He climbed onto the table, hands settling on your hips. On his knees, he briefly leaned over you as he pulled your hips up off the table, slowly sliding his cock inside you.
You tossed your head back, pulling on the ropes around your wrists. “Fuck.”
“Fuck?” he promoted, voice thick and gravelly.
You laughed breathily, still adjusting around him. “Fuck, daddy.”
He hummed. “Such a good girl.”
“Are you going to make me come for being so good?”
“You’re not entirely good,” he countered. He reached up, hand closing around your jaw so he could turn your attention to the side.
Standing along the wall were several fictional characters that you had proclaimed your love for at least several hundred times to Steve. He was never huffy about it because he knew you loved him, but you figured that might change after this…
They were silent, simply watching. It was odd to think about how they were just there, how it felt so real even though you knew it wasn’t.
“The murderer, seriously?” he pressed.
There were two, in fact. Ransom Drysdale was the first one you noticed. You were weak, what could you say? Then Robert Pronge. That had to be a new low. He was a terrible man, you knew that.
“I’m…sorry?”
“You will be,” he promised.
“But there are also lawyers,” you pointed out.
“One of them is an addict.”
But today, you were the only thing that beautiful man was going to be addicted to. You spared Steve from hearing that, though.
“Let me look at you,” you requested, and he turned you back to him. “Make me come, daddy.”
He let his hand slide down to your neck, fingers curling just slightly as his hips began to steadily move. His cock drove in and out of your pussy, the wet noise of it echoing around the whole room.
Your head was already swimming, perhaps the concept that people were watching you get fucked. People, even if they weren’t real, were watching Steve play your body like an instrument he’d known his whole life.
Eyes locked on yours, he fucked you until you were both coming together. His hips were erratic as soon as you tightened around him. He pleaded with you to wait for him, and you held on for as long as you could.
He squeezed his hand tight as soon as you opened your mouth to scream. Your orgasm was built up by him choking you, and the strangled sounds you made went straight to his cock. You felt him spill into you and your eyes rolled back. That was a feeling you would never tire of.
He was still hard as he pulled out, some of his cum dripping down his length. He took himself in his hand and rubbed his cum all over your stomach, leaving your skin sticky.
You smiled. “Thank you, daddy.”
He leaned over you, reaching for your hands. “I’m gonna let you loose a little.” Your wrists were still wrapped together but you could now bring your arms down just a little. You could grab what you wanted and that was his intent.
“You still good?”
“Yes.”
“Remember…”
“Your name,” you confirmed.
“We’re gonna take it easy for a minute, okay? Two at a time sound good?”
“Yeah.” You’d never been fucked by two men at one time, and you had been sure it was never going to happen. When you met Steve, you knew you were done. You knew that you could never again touch another man or let them touch you. But there you were, and he wanted this almost as much as you. He wanted to watch you enjoy yourself and you just had to remember that.
He stepped off the table and moved off to the side. “We’re going to start with the lawyers.”
You turned your head as Mike Weiss and Andy Barber moved from their places against the wall. Mike was more confident; he went straight to the end of the table and began moving his pants out of the way.
Andy was less confident, unsure of what to do. You grabbed his belt and pulled him toward you. Mike got up on the table, his hands sliding up your thighs as neared your pussy. You turned down to watch him, shivering. He didn’t feel like Steve and you couldn’t help but notice.
“It’s okay, baby,” Steve promised. “Just let it happen. It’ll stop being so weird soon enough.”
You looked at him briefly and he nodded reassuringly. Your hands began working Andy’s belt open, but you turned back to Mike. He had one hand around his thick cock as he moved it closer to your entrance. You watched as he slipped into you, mouth dropped as you reveled in every inch that filled you up.
You impatiently yanked Andy’s pants down when you could and turned up as he pulled himself out of his boxers. It was big enough that your mouth instinctively fell open, desperate to choke on him. He was so slow about sliding in, eyes never leaving your face.
Mike pulled out until just the head of his cock was inside you and thrust back in quickly. You moaned around Andy’s cock and he let out a shaky breath. His hands closed around your breasts just as Mike’s fingers found your clit.
You were whining and whimpering already, bobbing your head up and down Andy’s length while Mike touched the most sensitive part of you. His cock felt like it was getting deeper and deeper, hitting a spot inside you that was making your vision blur each time.
Andy’s fingers began pinching at your nipples until it was painful. That was all Steve, he always loved doing that to you. Then one of his hands whipped across your breast sharply, noisily. You whined around him and so he did it again.
Mike angled his hand so he could slap his fingers against your cunt, an unbearable amount of pressure on your clit. Your eyes filled with tears, your body shaking with your approaching orgasm.
Andy alternated between squeezing and slapping your skin, never moving his hips. He let you work his cock freely, sighing when you took him down your throat, grunting when you teased him by sucking just the tip of him between your lips.
Mike moaned shamelessly as your cunt tightened around him. He fucked you faster, hitting you harder until you were practically sobbing. He timed it correctly, smacking your clit each time he wanted your hips to jerk so he could slide in even deeper.
You finished while you were choking on Andy’s cock, your overwhelmed cries of pleasure an added sensation for him. Mike followed soon after, keeping himself buried in you as he rubbed his fingers around your clit. You shuddered the entire time, aftershocks wracking your whole body.
Andy was next, pulling out of your mouth and stroking himself until his cum painted your breasts. He quickly gathered some of it on the tips of his fingers, leaning down as he shoved them into your mouth.
And before you could even gain your composure, they were switching positions. Andy took your hips carefully, slipping into you with consideration for how sensitive he knew you would be.
You threw your head back, whining.
“Do you need a moment?” Steve wondered.
“No, no. I’m okay,” you promised. It took you a moment to adjust to Andy, but he was patient. You turned your head and Mike touched your face. He moved your hair away from your eyes and traced your features until you looked up at him.
“Open up, sweetheart.”
You did so immediately.
He pressed the head of his cock against your tongue and slid in until you gagged. You could easily identify the taste of Steve’s cum that had been left in your pussy.
Andy reached under your body and held your ass for leverage, pounding into you. Your core ached but you craved so much more. Steve knew how to fuck you all night, he knew how to pace himself. These men had no idea about your body at all, they were just using you. Though you didn’t want this often, you enjoyed being objectified like this.
Mike rocked his hips but never too hard, never enough to choke you. If you wanted that, you had to take as much of him as you could. He hissed curses each time, brushing his fingers through your hair and touching your cheek. “Just like, sweetheart. You’re doing so well.”
You stared up at him until he was coming down your throat. He held a handful of your hair, but you moved up and down, despite the pull you felt on your scalp. Of course, he didn’t taste like Steve, but you didn’t dwell on that. He was the one who pulled away and began getting redressed as you turned down to Andy.
He pulled his hands out from under you and set them higher up on the table. His body hovered over yours and you longed to be able to touch him. You figured that was what Steve wanted to avoid in tying you up. Regardless of this, he was such a possessive man.
His hips moved sharply, always making it hurt at least a little. As you neared your end, you arched your back and he sat up once more to grab your breasts. He squeezed them tight, smacked them now and then, yanked on your nipples incessantly until you were screaming and coming.
This time he finished inside you and you shivered. The thought of every single man in the room leaving their cum inside was filthy and you wanted it so badly it hurt. Your gaze followed him as he pulled out and readjusted his clothing, head turning to see him take his place at the wall again.
“Oh, I’m sorry, did you want some alone time with that one?” Steve asked.
Smirking, you turned back to him. “Jealous yet, daddy?”
“Not at all.” He made his way to your side, leaning down to kiss your forehead. “And are you still okay?”
You nodded.
“Ready for another round?”
“Yes, please.”
He hummed, glancing over the wall as he moved back. “I guess the psychopaths are up.”
“Don’t call them that,” you feigned offense.
He rolled his eyes. “We need to talk about your sexual interests later.”
Ransom walked right up to you, one hand grabbing your jaw and the other pulling his cock out. He pulled you onto him immediately, groaning as he felt your throat struggling around him.
Robert did the same with your pussy, with no hesitation or sensitivity. He was slow enough about it, but you knew that we because he was teasing you not because he wanted to let you get used to him.
They kept you full for a moment, completely buried in your mouth and cunt. You were choking loudly, hips squirming at the sting, and just when you thought you couldn’t take it anymore, they both pulled out. You laid there, gasping and shaking, and they simply watched. You briefly wondered how much of this was you and how much of it was Steve. Did he want to watch you get used by two cruel, violent men?
Together, they fucked your mouth and pussy. They thrust in together, pulled out together, and both decided when soft and slow weren’t working anymore. They were merciless and neither one finished until you were crying and sweating. Tears stained your face, drool was everywhere, and every time Robert let you down on the table, you felt how wet you’d managed to get it.
Ransom was first. He held you down until you swallowed all his cum, and then pulled out and moved down to your breasts. He had to wait until Robert was done, but that didn’t mean he wasn’t going to have fun. He jerked himself off, tapping the head of his cock against your breasts.
You had come twice when Robert finally finished. He pulled out and leaned down just to firmly lick over your clit. You shuddered, a surprised squeal tearing from your throat. You were exhausted and it was clear, but that didn’t stop either of them.
“Baby?” Steve checked.
“No,” was all you said before you opened your mouth for Robert. He placed his hand on the back of your head, pulling you down onto him roughly. You gagged hard enough that your entire body moved. It was something that made his eyes light up, something he would make you do again.
Ransom rubbed his fingers over your clit until you were just about to finish then completely backed off. Since your mouth was full, you couldn’t even complain. Not when he did it the second time or the third time. And your scream was muffled when he took you so close that fourth time and instead of making you come, shoved his cock into your clenching center.
“Fuck,” he groaned. “You are so tight, gorgeous.” He set his hand to your stomach and fucked you hard. Your body was sliding against the leather, constantly pulled down by the ropes at your ankles. You were never able to get too far from Ransom.
Robert was harsher as his finish approached. He had you gagging and choking, drooling all over his cock. “Keep your mouth wide for me, honey.”
You did so, staying as open as you could. He would pull out all the way just to shove back in until your nose was pressing into his pelvis. The wet noises of your throat filled the room, even louder than your soaking cunt Ransom was pounding into.
Robert pulled out of your mouth and walked around the table until he reached your hands. You knew what he wanted right away and circled both hands around his length. He grabbed your face, forcing you to look at him. “Open.”
You did even though you knew Steve wouldn’t like what was coming next. He spit into your mouth and you eagerly swallowed. Then you rolled your head back and kept your mouth open for his cum as he fucked your hands. His cum poured out from his cock, most landing in your mouth or on your jaw.
Ransom was close but insisted on dragging it out. He would pull his cock out and smack it against your clit before thrusting back in completely, over and over, until both of you were orgasming.
At this time, Robert was licking your face to gather up all of his cum. Again, he spit all of it into your open mouth. Once both men left you to return to their spots at the wall, Steve was at your side.
“Are you serious?”
You scoffed weakly. “Who next?”
“So, can I spit it your mouth or is that just a thing you let murderers do?”
You opened your mouth instead of offering a spoken answer.
He sighed. “Doesn’t count after he did it. I’ll try it later.”
“Who next? I do have a preference. Like, if you wanted any suggestions.”
He merely rolled his eyes and moved away as Ari Levinson and Colin Shea came closer to you. Ari moved to the foot of the table, but Colin leaned over you in your side, lips crashing down on yours.
Steve was stunned silent for a moment before he cleared his throat. Not that that stopped the man from shoving his tongue down your throat. “Okay, that stops now, or this entire thing stops.”
Colin pulled back, smirking smugly.
You couldn’t help but giggle.
“Doll,” Steve scolded.
“I didn’t know he was going to kiss me!” you defended. Before the conversation could get much further, Colin had his cock out. He tapped it along your jaw until you stuck your tongue out.
Ari had climbed onto the table, but he wasn’t inside you. Not yet. Instead, he leaned over you, starting with kissing your neck and moving down your throat to your collarbone, your breasts, paying special attention to your nipples and then the curve of your breasts, your ribs, down the center of your stomach, under your navel, all around your cunt, but never right there.
Finally, he pressed his cock into you, and you hummed around Colin. “Fuck,” they both sighed. You would have had the same reaction if you could have.
Ari didn’t want to waste time, he wanted to see you come. As his hips moved, he massaged gentle circles around your clit. You were already sensitive because of your last orgasms but this man knew just how to touch you. He was using the right pace and pressure, so you figured that was Steve’s doing, not yours.
But any time Ari was close, his hips would still, and he would use his fingers to get you off. He liked feeling your pussy coming around him, and his goal was to make it happen as many times as he possibly could.
Colin was enjoying your mouth, letting you bob your head back and forth on your own. He liked watching your eyes, they moved between his cock and his face. “You’re doing so well, babe.” And when your eyes flickered up to him in surprise, he knew he’d caught something. “Your mouth feels so fucking good, and you’re taking my cock so well. Such a good girl.”
Ari used all the time he could, paying attention to Colin as well. He wasn’t moving until Colin needed to fuck you, and both men seemed happy making this last as long as they could. He made you come so many times you lost count, but you figured Steve would let you know later.
You wondered how many good-girl points you’d lost. He would undoubtedly be bending you over his knee and smacking your ass until it was sore, but how many times did he plan on doing it? You were guessing at least three situations he would feel it was warranted.
When Ari was coming, he grabbed onto your hips desperately. You felt his eyes on your face even though you couldn’t look at him. He held you tight as he was coming down, slowly thrusting his hips, making sure to reach that deep spot inside you.
Colin only grabbed your hair when he was finishing. He yanked you back, angling your head, and fucked your mouth until he had come back down. The entire time, Ari thumbed at your clit gently.
When they switched positions, you had the overwhelming desire to kiss Ari. Steve had shaved his beard off so long ago and if you sent him the right puppy-eyes look…
“Fine,” he sighed. “Never shaving again,” but he muttered that to himself.
Ari dropped down to his knees and kissed you eagerly. You felt his beard pricking at your skin and couldn’t help but smile. Damn. You missed Steve’s beard.
Colin used his fingers to spread your cunt wide open, groaning as he watched his cock disappear inside you. Relentlessly, he fucked you, and you were pathetically loud because there wasn’t a cock in your mouth shutting you up.
Ari touched your face and your breasts, and you reveled in how rough his hands felt against your skin. He pulled away and kissed all over your face before he stood up.
You took in as much of him as you could, which was a lot since you’d had your throat stretched impossibly the entire night. But you still gagged and because Ari was much sweeter than the rest, he took it slow after that. He didn’t necessarily want to hear you gag, he liked it of course, but he wanted you to enjoy sucking his cock.
And you did. You had your lips wrapped around him the whole time, pulling back slow, dripping back down the same way. Your eyes were locked on his and this man looked wrecked. His fingertips ran along your face and he whispered curses and nonsense about your beauty.
Colin set his fingers to your clit when he was close. It took you there almost instantly and he didn’t care. He continued fucking you, the noise of it louder with his cum added into the mix. You were overflowing with it by now, and you still wanted so much more. He didn’t mind that you were shuddering and whining, and Ari liked the vibrations of it, too. Colin just kept moving until Ari finished with a soft moan.
Nick Vaughn and Frank Adler were next. You were shivering over the mere thought of these soft men. As soon as Colin and Ari had left your side, they were right there.
Frank started at your mouth. He lifted his cock, and you showered his sac with attention. He used his free hand to fondle your breasts. Nick was kissing your legs. He had his hands settled on your knees before he let them slide up, along with his lips. He let them graze your skin until he reached your core. He kissed all around your sensitive skin, but never right there.
You hadn’t noticed at first, but he untied your legs and brought them up as he got on the table. He bent your knees, setting your feet flat on the leather and gently sunk into you. Your legs pressed against his sides before winding around him and hooking at the ankles.
Only when Frank finally let you have his cock did he also start untying you. As you struggled to hold his entire length in your mouth, he was pulling your arms down, but kept your wrists tied. He kissed your hands and arms all over as he used your mouth.
They let their hands wander your entire body. You didn’t know which one was where, but your breasts were never neglected, your clit was constantly stimulated, and your finish happened in record time.
They were so unlike the rest, even unlike Steve, they finished so quietly, so slowly. It was the gentlest you had ever been fucked and you liked it, of course, but when this was all over, you were going to beg Steve to give it to you hard until you were crying and couldn’t walk straight.
They traded places and you swallowed Nick’s cock eagerly, still high on your orgasm. You reached for him blindly and he took your hands in his. He kissed your fingers as you worked.
Frank slammed into you painfully and you moaned loudly. He carefully pulled you down to the edge of the table and Nick followed, his cock never once leaving your mouth. Frank pulled your calves over his shoulders, grabbed your thighs, and fucked you hard and loud and desperately. Slapping skin, your soaking cunt, they were both softly groaning, and you were certain you were fucking dying. You couldn’t take it anymore, you had been fucked too many times, you couldn’t handle another orgasm.
But Frank tore it out of you and all the noise you made coaxed Nick to an easy finish, was then they both started to kiss you again. Frank pulled out of you first, then Nick, and you dipped your fingers into your cunt, cum just poured out of you.
“Put them in your mouth,” Steve ordered, and you did so instantly. You hummed, noisily sucking your fingers clean. It tasted weird, so many unfamiliar men, but you could still pick out Steve’s taste. His cum still lingered inside you and you loved that.
Frank began picking you up off the table. You were confused for a moment before he sat down where you had been and pulled you back down on his cock.
“Daddy?” you called out. Was he okay with this next part?
“It’s okay, angel. Unless you need a minute.”
“No, I’m okay.”
Frank laid back and you began to unbutton his shirt. It was a hard task with bound hands, so he eventually took pity on you and did it himself.
You heard Nick getting undressed as well but until he was behind you, you had not put two and two together.
“This is okay?” Steve checked again, just to be safe.
“Yes,” you squeaked. The head of Nick’s cock touched your asshole and you stilled completely. Almost effortlessly, he pushed into you, unrealistic, but the feeling was too good to complain. God, you would never be able to adequately repay Wanda.
Nick grabbed one side of your hip, Frank the other, and they pulled down hard, away from the other. It was like they were fighting, struggling to keep you closer to them and only them.
You couldn’t process anything other than how full you felt. You were aching and overused, but you couldn’t even attempt to form the words that you needed a break. Your mind wanted one, but your body was still painfully desperate for more.
You finished hard, your entire body tensing, and something just snapped. It felt just like any other orgasm, but as you settled on Frank’s lap, you felt how wet he was. Everything was a blur as they pulled out of you and you were waiting for the next pair.
Ari was already naked when he carefully urged you off the table. You let your hands touch his stomach first and he let you have your fun as he set his ass just on the edge of the table. His cock was still hard, and he easily worked your legs over his hips until you were standing on your toes, trying to stay there because it already hurt how deep inside you he was.
He took pity on you, grasping your ass and spreading you open. You leaned forward just slightly and he kissed you. That was not your plan, you simply needed to place your hands on the table for balance, but you had zero complaints.
Of course, Colin, practically a frat bro, wanted to fuck your ass. You swore he was harder than before as you felt him shoving his cock inside you. You moaned into Ari’s mouth and his hips jumped up just a little. You cried out but he continued to do it several more times before Colin’s pelvis was pressed flush to your ass.
They held you in place as they fucked you. It wasn’t like the last time, slow, aching, fucking passionate. This was torture, they were using you and you couldn’t get away, not that you could make yourself want to, not that these sensations weren’t driving you insane.
Colin grabbed your hair and pulled you back, turning your head to him so he could stare into your eyes. “Your ass is so tight, baby.”
All you could do is whimper.
“Is he making you feel good?” Steve questioned.
“Yes.”
“Tell him. Tell him how much you like his cock.”
“Your cock feels so good,” you blurted out.
Colin kissed the side of your face. “I know.”
“It’s so fucking big,” you asserted, very much sounding like you were pouting about it.
“What about the other one?” Steve encouraged.
You faced Ari again, his eyes were washing over your whole body hungrily. You touched his torso again, his chest and his abs. “You feel so good.”
“Yeah?”
You nodded quickly. “Like having you in my pussy.”
Your next orgasm was no gentler than the last. It was numbing and overwhelming, but you knew that you were nowhere near done. You were on your knees on the table, waiting for the next two men. Your cunt was dripping with all the cum that had been poured into you and you were sweating and shaking.
“Want a break now?”
“No.”
“The psychopaths are next,” he pointed out.
“No,” you insisted.
Ransom grabbed you first, turning you over so that you were sitting again. “You should probably listen to him.”
You shook your head.
He smirked and pulled you off, forcing you to stand. He never let you go because he worried you would fall, but he enjoyed seeing how shaky your legs were. He sat down and turned you away from him. “Sit on my cock, baby girl.”
You carefully situated yourself over his lap and despite his directions, he helped you a lot. He pressed into you initially but reveled in you sliding down the rest of the way until you were flat against him. He spread your legs and Robert immediately moved in. He filled you up quickly, and you were suddenly so impossibly full again. It didn’t matter that this was the third time, it was devastating, and you were exhausted and aching.
Ransom stood with you, forcing you closer to Robert. You started at his hair, grabbing handfuls, and yanking him in for a kiss. Ransom moved your hair out of his way and began biting one side of your neck and the shoulder nearest. They fucked you without rhythm or cohesion, they fucked you like they were competing.
“Tell them you’re enjoying yourself, doll,” Steve reminded.
Ransom pulled you back against his chest, hands grabbing at your breasts again. “Yeah, am I big?”
You whimpered and nodded.
He slammed into you harder. “Yeah?”
“Yeah. So big. I don’t think anything else could fit.”
“Oh, we’ll see about that,” he muttered.
You didn’t have the mind to question him. You simply turned forward.
Robert smirked. “You like my cock, princess?”
You nodded fast, grabbing his hand to bring his fingers to your clit. “Make me come around your cock. Please make me come.”
Both men became even more unhinged. You hadn’t thought that was possible. They trapped you between their bodies and all you could do was take it. You had to take Ransom mercilessly fucking your ass, Robert rubbing your clit and cruelly fucking your pussy even as it got tighter. You screamed so loud that by the time you all finished, your voice was hoarse.
But oh, they were not done with you. Ransom pulled you onto the table with him, Robert’s cock slipping out. Both men were amused by your sad whimper. Ransom yanked legs open for Robert. “You heard her. She thinks nothing else can fit.”
Holy fuck, he did not mean…
Robert stepped closer, hand resting against your cunt as he began forcing his cock into your ass, next to Ransom’s.
“Relax, baby,” Steve said. “It’ll feel good, I promise.”
You were on fire as soon as the tip of his cock was inside you. You were shaking and panting, and you felt possessed. It was horrifying how badly you wanted him to keep going, until he was buried in you. With every push forward, every additional inch he fed you, you thought you would pass out. You’d never felt pleasure so intense.
As soon as his cock was settled deep inside you, they were moving. They were thrusting in and out of you and you were coming almost immediately. Your cunt was clenching around nothing, so desperate for a cock. Both Ransom and Robert were abruptly happy your pussy had been neglected because on one particularly good thrust, your pussy wept, leaving both men drenched.
“Fuck, baby,” Robert muttered, reaching out to touch your face. You touched his body, hands grazing his stomach, his ass, up his back, down his shoulders.
“Think you can do that again?” Ransom inquired.
You shook your head, unable to form words.
He hummed. “Don’t sell yourself short, I think you can.” He moved you up by the hips and you cried out when you were suddenly left empty. Ransom quickly replaced three of his fingers in your ass, shushing you as you squeaked and whined unintelligibly. He took his cock in his other hand and shoved it into your pussy.
Your eyes widened as Robert stepped in again. Oh fuck, you were already shivering and throbbing with the desire to have your cunt as full as they just had your ass.
He wasn’t slow about this, and you were wet enough that it didn’t hurt as much as the last time. Again, their cocks moved in and out of your hole, and with Ransom’s fingers still working you, you knew he was going to make it happen.
You’d squirted several times and Steve fucking loved it, but it was a mystery to you both how it happened. He never could quite master controlling it. But you felt that familiar pressure in your stomach just piling up so high until you burst, and your pussy once again made a huge mess everywhere.
Ransom laid you out carefully on the table as they were departing. He kissed your face all over and told you how much he liked fucking all three of your holes. You suddenly realized that Steve had taken this over long ago and his fake jealousy was just an act so you wouldn’t suspect him. You only had so long to plot revenge before you were occupied once more.
Andy picked you up gently, making sure he had you held tightly as he situated himself under you. You were straddling his cock when Mike grabbed your hips and shoved himself into your ass. One hand settled around your neck and he used the other to press you down onto Andy’s length.
Andy lifted onto his elbows to watch your breasts bounce as they both drove their cocks in fast. Mike held you against him but that didn’t stop you from reaching out to Andy. You just wanted to touch him.
“This one is so fucking pretty,” you whined to Steve.
He rolled his eyes.
It wasn’t until the three of you had come that you had a brilliant idea. “Can I ride his beautiful face, daddy?”
“Yes.”
You hurriedly climbed up the table and Andy yanked you down by your hips. You screamed, throwing your head back as his tongue met your throbbing clit.
Steve quickly made his way to your side to make sure you stayed up. You kissed him as soon as he was in your reach. You thrust your hips over Andy’s face, moaning loudly into Steve’s mouth.
He grabbed one of your hands and wrapped it around his cock. You pulled away to turn down, wanting to watch as he finished. He took your opposite hand and directed it to Mike’s cock.
Mike leaned in, kissing the side of your face and grunting against your skin.
“On your back,” Steve told you.
Slowly, he helped you lean down until you were laid out on top of Andy. That gorgeous man with his gorgeous mouth and beard was still eating you out like his life depended on it.
With your hands full, Steve had to take over just a little. He turned your head and worked Andy’s cock into your mouth. As you grew closer to your end, you became aware of all the men surrounding you, stroking their cocks, all wanting to paint your skin with their cum.
When you came back to reality, you were aching, your skin was wet, and your center was throbbing.
“Baby?” Steve called out.
You turned your body to the sound of his voice and instinctively reached out to him. You whimpered as soon as your hand found his face. What the fuck was this? You were surprised to feel him hard against your stomach.
He sat up, looking around until he found Wanda.
She was looking everywhere but the two of you. “So yeah, this kind of happens. Your mind felt all of that and that’s why your body thinks it felt all of it…but it didn’t and now she just needs to be fucked.”
You laid flat on your back, reaching out to Steve again. He took your hand, but he hesitated in moving any closer.
“So, my work is done, I’ll be going now.” She moved to the door quickly.
“You don’t have to,” Steve claimed.
She froze, eyes wide as she looked back at him.
He gestured to you. “You could taste the mess you made. She honestly does have the sweetest pussy.”
Her mouth opened to respond but quickly shut. She glanced down at you, eyebrows pulling together.
You had never discussed adding anyone else in the bedroom but fuck, Wanda? She was beautiful… Maybe Steve knew about more of your fantasies than he told you about. It hurt like hell, but you lifted your hips and tore your underwear down.
Wanda only contemplated for several more seconds before she was charging back to the bed. She threw herself over you immediately, arms wrapping under and over your thighs so she could spread you wide.
You screamed as soon as her lips touched you. This was what it felt like when Steve edged you after you misbehaved, but he’d only ever held out for an hour. This felt like a god damn year.
Your hands buried in her hair and you pulled her in as close as you could get her. Your hips bucked desperately and all she did was lap and suck at your cunt until you were coming.
All Steve could do was admire the scene. Even though it was a very short scene.
She pulled away as you were coming down, wiping her mouth and not meeting your eye.
“You want to fuck her?” Steve asked.
She looked at him with her wide eyes again. “Oh, I don’t know…”
You sat up and she turned to you. “I want you to. If you want to.”
She looked surprised for a moment. “I…I haven’t been like this with anyone since…yeah.”
You crawled down the bed until you could set yourself on her lap. She wrapped her arms around you, and you suddenly fell in love with Steve even more. He must have known how badly Wanda was craving intimacy and knew just the way to get her to a position where she felt safe with the two of you.
“We don’t have to do anything you don’t want to do,” you said.
She stared at you for a moment before she leaned in. She wasn’t just moving slow, she was moving slow, and all you could do was sit there and wait until her lips were finally touching yours.
You tasted yourself in the kiss and maybe that made you just a little less patient. You grabbed her hair again and used your body to push hers down. With you on top, you never broke the kiss, but you did begin to undress her.
She helped with her pants and underwear, and you settled your center against hers. She cried out, hands grabbing hard at your ass. She let her head fall back and you kissed and bit at her neck.
Steve sat down next to the two of you and moved your bra out of his way.
She was the one that started moving first. She pinned you against her and her hips began to angle upward against you.
“You’re so wet,” you gasped.
She smiled briefly before she moaned. “Think that’s you, babe.”
Okay, probably. You used your forearms for balance, staring down at her as she continued rubbing her pussy against yours. “You’re beautiful.”
She stopped for a moment, surprised once again, before smiling appreciatively. “You are beautiful.”
You scoffed. “No, Steve is beautiful.”
She snorted. “Guess we’re gonna have to let him in soon, huh?”
“Yeah, probably,” you said, pretending it was such a painful idea. “But you can finish first.”
She hummed and then she was moving again. It took a few minutes, you were sure you were the first woman Wanda had ever been with, but eventually, she found the correct position to get stimulation for her clit and yours.
She finished first, her eyes filling with tears as she stared up at you. You couldn’t imagine her pain, the idea of losing Steve… You thought Wanda was the strongest person alive because if you had lost your soul mate, you would have given up. She was so strong, and she was still here, still trying her best.
“Wanda, I love you.”
She smiled between her heaving breaths. “I love you, too.” She hummed before she leaned up to kiss you for just a moment. “Wanna come?”
You shook your head. “Nope, not yet.”
Her eyebrows pulled together but she understood as soon as you started kissing down her body. She parted her legs for you, closing her eyes and allowing herself to be swept up in all the sensations as soon as your mouth was working her cunt.
“Did you need a mailed invitation, Rogers?” she wondered.
Steve snapped into action then. “Excuse me, it looked like you two had it handled.”
You knew what was coming, but even that couldn’t prepare you for the sheer relief of finally being full of Steve’s cock.
He groaned. “Jesus, baby, you already going to come?”
You hummed back, not intending to give a real answer.
Wanda liked you moaning into her folds, sighing, whimpering, licking as you tried to regain composure. And she loved you staring up at her as you did it all.
Steve fucked you slow. Yes, he wanted to please you like he never had before, especially after having to watch different men touch you. But he knew you. He knew how kindhearted you were and how much you loved your friends, and this was about Wanda. He could fuck you until you couldn’t remember your name tomorrow.
So, he paid attention. He touched you just enough to keep you on the edge of pleasure but didn’t make you come until you had given Wanda so many orgasms that she was shaking. The sweet girl would never be able to push you away, so it was Steve that had to call it a night. After making you come, he pulled out and settled down on the bed by Wanda.
You arched an eyebrow at him once you’d come down.
He crooked his finger at you.
Smiling, you quickly dove between Steve and Wanda. He wrapped an arm around your shoulders, and you threw one of your legs between his because you liked when he ended up wrapped around you in his sleep. You reached out to Wanda and she rolled onto her side facing you. She looked unsure for a moment, but you were just so damn loving, how could she possibly leave? She laid her head on your stomach, an arm curling around your hips. You let one of your hands brush through her hair, smiling when you felt her lay a small kiss against your abdomen.
You turned up to Steve, it felt wrong to say the words given that Wanda was here still in pain from her loss, but he knew. He had seen that look on your face many times, of course, he knew that you loved him.
He nodded.
You smiled at him before turning back down to take his hand that was hovering over your chest and kissed his knuckles.
chris tags:
@onetwo3000 @donutloverxo @chris-evans-indian-fanfic @kleohoneyao3 @cevans-fics @gotnofucks @sweet-pieces-of-nothing
560 notes
·
View notes