#like im not perm killing Star in this version I love them too much for that. But I think taking away Star at first would be more likely for

[doctor-who-war-doctor]

Anyways I think if someone with a more ambitious, ambiguous wish somehow turned Asha in I don't think Magnifico would have granted that. I also don't think he would have a wish ceremony ever again since he no longer views them as the people's wishes but his own. He would still require everyone give their wish to him under false promises or face banishment because he would form a dependency on the power of the wishes ultimately becoming a tyrant, absorbing Star and locking up Asha & co for treason before they get a chance to inspire the people of Rosas.

Or maybe their able to go in to hiding for a long time as they hatch a plan to overthorw Magnifico. Maybe Asha would spend this time becoming very skillful in magic to be able to face the king.

Furthermore, I think he would ultimately end up locking away Amaya. I don't think he would be able to bare the thought of her leaving, rejecting his corruption & tyranny, so he would take that chance away from her. Which really upsets me but I think he would. I dont think he'd want to take away the person that loves him the most and despite his narcissism he still loves her. I'd imagine Amaya's hate for him would grow she would still continue to love him deep down perhaps in hopes the person she knew before this would still be inside him. I don't think she would kill him if given the chance.

Also he definitely seeked out Simon knowing he was most likely to cave under the pressure as the only Teen to have given his wish, learning that he was becoming insecure not knowing if he'd ever achieve his goals. It definitely helped that Simon's was to be a knight it was too perfect for him (Magnifico). Like the night Asha that questions his authority, unauthorized magic happens. I would wanna question her friends too lol.