#like i don't think factories need to have bosses who can threaten people with unemployment into doing whatever they want.
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
the anarchist position isn't a principled stance against unjustifiable hierarchies, it's just a lawless state where everyone sits around doing whatever they want and there is no more infrastructure or manufacturing of anything. when left to their own devices, people famously just completely lose all motivation to do anything, and dismantling the state, the entity that enforces law through violence, would be akin to loading up a game of The Sims and just leaving it running idly with no input, the titular sims wandering around aimlessly until they starve.
without a central authority maintaining law and order through threat of violence, society completely collapses! no one has ever or will ever do anything for anyone without the implict threat of jackbooted thugs shooting them in the head if they don't. there is no conceivable mode of society where this *isn't* the case.
"how would this part of society be run without a small group of people exerting their unquestionable will over a large group of people?" is a question you need to constantly ask to remind anarchists that their worldview just doesn't make sense!
if you can't *make* someone do something, then there's just no way to get them to do it!
asking nicely? using convincing arguments to persuade? just accepting "no" for an answer? (because if someone just doesn't wanna do something, they're probably being lazy, there's never any good reason for them to not wanna do it) all entirely unheard of. How will we govern if we are all equal?!?!
#juney.txt#anarchism is lack of rulers not lack of rules you dummies#believe it or not things can actually be organized without being hierarchical#people would be quite happy to continue manufacturing medicine and distributing it to those who need it#without implicit threats of violence direct and indirect#the question ''how would x work under anarchism'' is basically a complete non-sequitur in a lot of cases i think#like are you completely incapable of imagining factories and distribution networks and so on#running without someone somewhere coercing people into doing those things through use of force#like i don't think factories need to have bosses who can threaten people with unemployment into doing whatever they want.#that part seems pretty unnecessary to the whole manufacturing of goods thing
24 notes
·
View notes