#jfc foreigners really like to use the worst examples for voodoo huh
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Once again I appreciate OP bringing the inaccuracies with Sam's designs to light. After my initial post, I did some more digging to how many things I missed to talk about because I only watched TPATF twice when I was younger and I found an article describing all the inaccurate/inappropriate choices filmmakers did in The Princess and the Frog and....there's so much to unpacking here.
This brings be back to Sam's design in the JP TWST version. Considering how filmmakers were mixing other Afro cultures within Haitian vodou (Ex: using African masks to represent Haitian lwa), Sam's face paint was probably less inspired by the actual voodoo markings and moreso West African tribal face paint. Which would probably explain why his face paint was so out of place in a voodoo point of view because they're probably not even voodoo markings in the first place (unsurprising how there was little actual research done within the JP TWST team 🙄). NA Disney probably remembered the backlash they got for mixing cultures and took them out in local TWST to avoid controversy.
Alright so ive been seeing this going around, the lack of paint on Sam in ENG . I dont want to start shit though, im saying this as a disclaimer. And i want to say this as controversial as it may be: it was for the best probably.
Voodoo has a history of being portrayed as dark magic which is horrible. Voodoo is a religion not satanic not dark magic. It is as much of a religon as Islam, Christianity, Hinduism, Judaism, etc. Respect it. I like the bone paint too, it looked cool, but clearly its more cultural appropriation rather than appreciation on Sam (voodoo practicers if you can please tell me if ive said something wrong).
"Cancel culture" isnt just an "sjw" thing, its used to talk about problems. Saying "twst shouldve just stayed in jp" bc of the problematic aspect isnt good. We have to address problematic issues with culture and racism. Twst has racist aspects you cannot deny that. It doesnt mean you cant enjoy twst at all, but stay openminded and listen to minorities when they speak. Cultures arent "aesthetics" :/
#funny how the filmmakers had in mind to initially name him after papa doc....a haitian dictator....#who got my great grandfather killed under his rule....#my mother says he was a very strict man during his ruling and the premise of the justice system was basically#if someone says you did something wrong there was no trial or anything you just got thrown in jail and/or killed#ultimately leading to little to no crimes for the wrong reasons#not to mention filmmakers probably got inspired because of how papa doc was using vodou#jfc foreigners really like to use the worst examples for voodoo huh#also also Afro cultures are NOT exclusive they are each their own thing#Similarities? Yes. Ultimately the same? Absolutely not#you can't mix them like that thats so disrespectful#listen i love Sam and his design was unique to look at and TPATF was enjoyable to watch but you have to acknowledge his design wasn't right#so uh everyone say thank you local twst#they also took out the African mask pin as well but considering it wasn't as noticeable yall will live#twisted wonderland
285 notes
·
View notes