#it lessened my confidence in stating strong opinions on characters xD
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Note
by the way thank you thank you THANK YOU for your takes on nanaya ER, you have no idea how many people see her as some sort of agent for the FF or something like that and i feel like i'm taking crazy pills every time because........ the whole point is that she is the reason midra hasn't given into the FF despite the pain?? if she wanted him to inherit the flame why did she tell him to hold on? the main argument is that suffering enhances it, but it's clear he would have turned regardless, enduring was a way to prevent it. so thank you so much for an actually positive read of her character!!!
(also you pointing out that she seems to have survived the initial inquisition purge and that she might have been the one to call them there was such a smart observation and i totlaly get behind it now)
Aww.. Sorry for the delay with responses (busy busy), but thank YOU for thanking ME I guess gfhfhdhggv The last part made me melt a little, and it is not Frenzied Flame exposure, it is joy of knowing that I might have helped someone with the ideas on the character!! AND YEAH SMALL DETAILS!! Like 'the last reasonable person left despite all that happened with their people' vibe!
As for the takes.. to be honest, I have not much to say here because whereas I've been checking the tag often, the only post on the topic I've seen was someone also addressing strange abundance of evil Nanaya takes.... so now I am just left to wonder whether I was completely clueless about this sort of disco horse because 1) all these takes are on Twitter, Reddit or YouTube which I don't check 2) the takes come from a blog or blogs that I've blocked / blocked me or 3) Rom from BB concealed these posts from me XD
"Suffering nurtures it" is not a bad idea, there are just too many factors for me to include into the whole picture vs a headcanon I can't base on anything besides 'it could be'! Granted, after how badly I stepped on the rake with my conclusion on """more likely""" Miq and Mohg portrayals, I can no longer speak of characters personalities with confidence for a while :') What if in Miyazaki's mind, EVERY 'this is obvious vibe' should be taken in reverse?
Guess we should not overthink that man's enigma of a mind and instead should take it as a lesson of more free interpretations instead of placing too much meaning on justifications in canon! Not that I can due to my autism but I can TRY hfghgg I'll just say her having been spared by Inquisitors and lore being that harassing of Inquisitors was the reason Midra's Manse succumbed to Frenzied Flame to begin with sold it for ME! Him feeling guilty that he potentially doomed everyone (starting with their son?) because he quite literally played with fire is so sad.. I like to think Nanaya still loved him, but had to call people who were actually guilty because "I hate you, you hate me and it's your fault more than his but Frenzied Flame might end not just us but the WHOLE world so could y'all seal him before he explodes, I have grief to cling onto until it kills me 😔"
#ask replies#elden ring#nanaya#elden ring headcanons#you have no idea how iron my confidence that mohg was written with SA themes was ghhhhg#it lessened my confidence in stating strong opinions on characters xD#but again I should reclaim it later because otherwise no discussions are possible#this is how truth is found! one person states strong opinion and another strongly disagrees!#with 95% of the things miyazaki wont give such clear info so... ingame clues there are#like I said that nanaya idea isnt bad in isolation#but I can't connect all the dots into that nor I like discarding any dots
5 notes
·
View notes