#istg y’all have got to lean what bashing is and how to start tagging it
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
look. as much as i support fic writers doing their thing and writing whatever they want. it’s important that there still be some resemblance to the original characters. like if you didn’t have the names, you should still generally be able to tell who’s who—characters’ personalities and histories should be enough to give us an idea
so like. as an example. consider a completely hypothetical mdzs modern AU.
it’s about a single father working multiple jobs to make ends meet…after struggling financially for quite some time…who is subjected to a fair amount of classism and abuse…and still works harder than all the others without a single complaint…despite having seemingly wealthy family…(including a brother who gives well meaning lip service about caring but ultimately doesn’t offer any kind of substantial help)…who initially rejects a wealthy prospective romantic partner out of pride, because he doesn’t want to be seen as a gold digger or a charity case…
…where a fair amount of narrative tension stems from a cheating, absentee father who had zero qualms abandoning his kid to near-poverty…who hid the true extent of his wealth because he never had any intention of sharing what wasn’t absolutely required…who accuses others of being gold diggers or trying to sleep their way to a better position…who also appears to regularly mistreat staff, among other classist habits…who goes out of his way to be cruel, and is generally an all around scumbag…
this is clearly describing two very specific mdzs characters, right?
based on canon, the context surrounding them and the interactions they have with others give us enough information to tell who these characters are—
—lan xichen and jin guangyao, of course. OBVIOUSLY.
#jgy tag#mdzs talk#moi#brb tearing my hair out#look anyone can write whatever they want. more power to you. l#but please for the love of god just tell me you don’t actually think this is accurate characterization#if you can take out the names and mistake jgy for jin fucking GUANGSHAN????#istg y’all have got to lean what bashing is and how to start tagging it#JUST TAG BASHING PLEASE IM BEGGING YOU#I CANT FUCKING TAKE TI#look i’ll even give you the benefit of the doubt: you wanted to write a fic about jgy and accidentally mixed up all of the names horribly#like. can we address that.#like what is going on here that you wrote about a situation that nearly mirror’s jgy’s.#and yet manage to vilify the ACTUAL jgy to the point he becomes his father.#like we were talking about classism and protagonism re: wwx vs jgy the other day#and like what airplane says about shen jiu!!!#this is exactly it!!!#they recognize that something is bad when it happens to the protagonist#(or someone they consider ‘good’)#but short circuit at the thought that the Big Bad Evil Villain might actually be sympathetic!!!#so you wind up with shit like this where they abandon everything that ACTUALLY made that villain ‘villainous’ in favor of a cardboard cutout#and one that ALREADY EXISTS no less!!#there are already cheap cardboard villains in the jin!! you can grab any of them!!!#WHY did you think it was a good idea to cast the rejected bastard raised by a single mother in near poverty#AS A WEALTHY ABSENTEE FATHER WHO CHEATS ON HIS SPOUSE????#WHAT IS WROKG WITH YOU#AARRRRHRHHHHGGGGRRHHAAAAAAA#ok i’m done#consider my yayas out
15 notes
·
View notes