#is this a side effect of all the mormons in ya fantasy? MAYBE
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
one thing i have been finding with books recently (especially fantasy, and especially YA fantasy, i think) is that so many of them treat life so cheaply. characters die and others immediately move on, skim past it, even if they were responsible or even if they cared about the person. the depth of grief isn't there, and because death is not given the weight it feels like it should have, all of the other emotions also seem... hollowed out, shallow somehow. like, if life is not precious and if these characters are not grievable, why does any of it matter?
and i guess. not every book has to be About Grief™. but books that treat death casually run the risk of making me not care about anything, because the lives of the characters are not valued, are not seen as worth grieving, and so therefore they are not worth my emotional investment, either. it's like they've told me i don't need to care if these people live or die, because none of the other characters will
on the flip side, it means when books DO dig deep into grief and death and the absolute profound awfulness of irreversible endings, i get a lot MORE emotionally affected than i would otherwise because i've got so used to skimming over the surface of characters and never being dragged down into caring, so it catches me out a bit more
#you may have noticed i write about grief quite a lot#i guess for me death just seems like the absolute most awful thing that can ever happen#and i struggle to engage with narratives that don't seem to also see it like that#is this a side effect of all the mormons in ya fantasy? MAYBE#i never thought of it before but if your authors all believe in an afterlife then maybe they don't see death as Super Awful#but more likely some of these people just aren't that good at writing death scenes...#anyway idk. have read a few books recently that Did Grief Properly#but am also reading one right now where NONE of the emotions are hitting#and the cheapness of death seems to underpin a lot of it#néide has opinions about books
21 notes
·
View notes