#im still not 100% convinced but it would be the funniest possible outcome

[deevotee]

So i don't personally subscribe to the o!ciel finnian name theory (tho I DO believe the phantomhives are celtic!) but ive been thinking about it as a possibility and what it would mean for his relationship with finny, cuz even though it would mean that he's trying to take his brothers role and force his own role to someone else

WAIT POST PAUSED CAUSE IF ITS TRUE THEN WTF DOES HIS FAMILY THINK???

like??? how uncomfortable are they all everytime finny shows up? what was their reaction upon learning his name? do they know he was named by ciel or do they think its a coincidence??

like i can imagine frances reading her nephews letters like "Oh he got a new servant how lovely :) oh he named him finnian..? His dead little brothers name...? That's...sweet?"

also tanaka?! him meeting finny for the first time, fully being aware that o!ciel is the younger twin and just being like "😬 welcome to the belowstairs i guess"