#i ran discussions with tas about equitable and research-based teaching practices for two years
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
As educator and philosopher Nel Noddings put it, "The student is infinitely more important than the subject matter." Noddings pioneered the idea of an "Ethics of care" in education, i.e. the responsibility of recognizing the needs of others and addressing those needs with competence, responsiveness, and respect.
It seems obvious to say, but the goal of education and educational structures should be learning. Used responsibly, attendance can be a tool to support equity-- if students are repeatedly missing class, that's an opportunity to reach out to them, ask if there are unseen obstacles to their learning (cf. Devon Price's Laziness Does Not Exist), and work with students to help address them if so.
When attendance itself becomes the goal, rather than a structure to support learning, something's gone wrong.
When I say “school should be disability accessible”, I don’t just mean we need handicap rails and EAs. Kids should be able to miss a day without failing out of school. You shouldn’t be dismissed from clubs because your attendance record is “spotty” (true story). I once missed an entire week of school because of a terrible, unending migraine. I was expected to keep up with my studies despite the blinding pain that came with working on my computer. When I heard my teachers say that you couldn’t miss exams, I asked what I would have to do to be excused from them. Their response? “Either get a doctor’s note an hour before the exam or death of an immediate family member.”
I cannot express how rigid this expectation was. First of all, with my condition, I wouldn’t have enough warning about my sickness to go to the doctor and request a note. For many people, this is exceptionally difficult, especially with the current shortage of medical professionals. Next, it ignores the fact that my schedule may not line with theirs because of my medical needs. Once, I had to visit a hospital a province away (which I was on the waiting list of for over a year) on the same day as an exam. I begged my mother not to take me because I was so nervous that I would be marked as an automatic fail. I was lucky enough to make it work, but that’s only because of my spectacular support system consisting of family members and wonderful doctors.
Disabilities aren’t always about needing a bus that can accommodate wheelchairs. It’s already difficult enough for many of us to maintain school attendance without the harsh punishments involved for skipping a day. We need to be able to miss school without being punished. Only than can you claim that the school is “accessible”
#there is a 102-level discussion here about what an ethics of care asks of the carer#offering meaningful and individualized support is work! it is important and impactful work but work nonetheless#one can ask how much of this falls to the individual and how much of it should be structural and systematic#that we don't just rely on individuals to provide exceptional care#but we build safety nets and institutions centered on care#so that this labor is shared and doesn't just fall on individual educators (who especially if they are junior are vulnerable themselves)#you're extremely right op. there is no inclusion without accessibility#what might an educational system look like that centered care over punishment? i argue it's closer than we think#i ran discussions with tas about equitable and research-based teaching practices for two years#there is a growing vision of education that is progressive and compassionate (and more effective than the conservative dogma!)#but it is inchoate and often held to a higher standard than the 'old ways'#we need administrators who share this vision and support staff to make it possible#we need parents and students onboard#and we need inspired and progressive educators who are willing to prioritize care#i see it coming. it's closer than you think. but there's still much work to be done#for additional reading see: radical hope (gannon); pedagogy of the oppressed (freire); inclusive teaching (hogan and sathy)
40K notes
·
View notes