#he’s both the very obvious rat/villain of the game and mysterious and evasive

[locowolf]

i wish the more popular theory was when micah became a rat and not if there’s a second rat.

of course he started working as a mole for the pinkertons when he returned from guarma, but was he ratting to the o’driscolls before that? if so, when did that start? before the game, during chapter 1, or after? was he in cahoots with anyone else?

related to that idea, what were his intentions when he joined the gang? was it always to steal dutch’s money, or did he think to steal it later in the game? did he sabotage the blackwater ferry job? were all of his reckless plans done to destroy the gang and/or steal dutch’s money? where does he sleep at night?

the game gives us a great character to analyze and theorize about yet people only focus on a second rat :(