#given that and given the way ashton interpreted the convo
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Honestly, a part of why I'm giving the earth talk the benefit of the doubt is that Matt was improvising the shit out of that conversation
he was pulling stuff out of his ass that hes never really considered before and it kinda showed?
bc matt is not giving ANYONE in the party a bone. theyre gonna get a mess of conflicting ulterior motives and opinions. and its up to them to figure out what to do. there is NO higher power here, at the end of it all, when a decision must be made, it's gonna be up to them
and thats why i think matt... didnt want to give ashton a direct order, a direct bid - he wanted to give ashton room to interpret their desires as they see fit
i cant read ka'mort et al as yet another party with a conflict of interest - which is why Im like yeah, that sure is a thing fucking rock and stone would say. if mountains could talk etc.
it was circle talking, it was the bagua of conversations, it was a nothing burger of a statement - matt through ka'mort saying "you are my memory" feels like a very big implicit push for ashton to make up their own damn mind
(and they did which ha i see that part took off)
the survival of the fittest is a big red flag on the bullshit meter, but idk man, given how much matt was working to make that convo work, ill give the really bad cliche the benefit of the doubt
#critical role#cr spoilers#i dont know what to tell ya guys#sometimes the actors on screen dont improv cleanly which is to be expected#plus matt already has a record of Not Getting Through to Taleisin specifically#taleisin famously misinterpreted matts warnings as a dare and thought this was thematically correct for ashton to do#given that and given the way ashton interpreted the convo#i will give kamort et al the benefit of the doubt#and say that they dont want to be invited to this party
8 notes
·
View notes