#galuro

[isabellafoster13]

This was requested on AO3 by Westerngoddess.

This was a birthday request. So, happy birthday to Westerngoddess! I hope that you have a fantastic birthday! I also hope that this oneshot is to your liking! 

I think you all know what I think about Gajeel x Lucy x Rogue. I love RoLu. I love GaLu. Putting them together would just make it better. 

Also, as you can probably tell by the title, I am basing this oneshot off of the song "Jenny" by Studio Killers. I've been itching to write a fic based on it, so why not this one?

I hope you enjoy!

We Wanna Ruin our Friendship! (Gajeel x Lucy x Rogue)

Gajeel was in love with Lucy. 

That was pretty obvious to anybody that wasn't the blonde in question. It was a known fact in the guild that wherever Lucy was, Gajeel wasn't too far away. He sat with her in the guild, went on jobs with her, and protected her from creeps. He was clearly besotted. 

The dragon slayer had surprised everybody by worming his way into Lucy's life and becoming one of her closest friends. And Lucy didn't seem to mind at all. The pair knew a lot about each other, having even had several sleepovers at each other's places, gone on countless jobs together, and spent time together outside of the guild. 

It became apparent that Black Steel Gajeel was in love whenever he heard her voice and laughter, saw her smile, or even looked at her. The red blush that would spread across his cheeks and the small smile that would make its way onto his face were more than enough to know that his feelings for the celestial wizard were more than platonic. 

However, despite the entire guild knowing about his feelings for her, he would vehemently deny such a thing. It didn't matter how much Levy and Mira would tease him and encourage him to ask her out, he would claim that his feelings for her weren't romantic and stick to the claim. 

Truth was, he was aware of his feelings for Lucy. He wasn't an idiot. He knew that he wanted to make the kind and beautiful woman his girlfriend. He loved everything about her. Her strawberry and vanilla scent was intoxicating. Her blonde hair looked as though it was weaved from the sun's golden rays. Her voice and laughter were like a melody he could listen to on end. Her eyes were a deep, chocolatey brown that he would oftentimes find himself getting lost in. 

He knew that he was smitten with her. Hell, he was even using one of her shirts that she didn't want anymore as a pillowcase. How could he not be aware of how he felt about her? The problem was though, how could he tell her? He didn't know if she felt the same way, nor did he want to scare her off. Even if she didn't return his feelings, he still wanted to be her friend. 

He had been tempted to ask Mira for help, but then he would shudder at the thought of whatever over-the-top plot that she would come up with and quickly decide against it. He had asked Levy a few times for advice, but as she would say to simply tell Lucy. That wasn't much help. So, he was stuck. 

Like any other dragon slayer, he wasn't keen on the opposite sex flirting with Lucy. Simply seeing another man eye his Bunny Girl with clearly less than chaste intentions was enough to make him punch the bastard halfway across Magnolia. So, imagine the rage that he felt when he saw Sabertooth's Shadow Dragon Slayer walk into the guild with a smiling Lucy by his side.

Rogue was enamored with Lucy.

He didn't make attempts to hide that fact. Whenever one of his guildmates would ask him if he was in love with her, he would give them a simple 'yes.' This had resulted in constant teasing from Sting and Orga while Yukino, Minerva, and Rufus would encourage him to confess to her. However, he wasn't sure about that. He only ever saw her when she visited Sabertooth, which was an occurrence that wasn't nearly as frequent as he wished it was. 

He always knew when Lucy was visiting before she stepped through the guildhall doors, having long ago memorized her scent to the point that he was able to smell it when she hadn't even reached the entrance to Sabertooth. 

He had managed to form a close friendship with her, much to even his own surprise. Every time she visited, the two of them and Frosch would go shopping and have lunch together. It was something that they both clearly enjoyed doing. Rogue has even tagged along with her on jobs. 

The dragon slayer wasn't the type to flirt or make attempts to make his feelings for the Fairy Tail mage known. He simply didn't hide it. He was often tempted to tell her how he felt, but every time he tried, he would become suddenly tongue-tied and divert his attention to something else. He had never guessed that having a crush would be this trying. He wasn't even able to put into words what he liked about her or why he loved her. He simply did.

She was kind, beautiful, forgiving, supportive, and strong. How could he not love her? The fact that Frosch adored her and she loved the exceed just as much was definitely a factor. He loved everything about her. He simply loved her. The mere thought of her would send his heartbeat into an erratic pace and his cheeks would burn with the redness of a blush. He even had a small collection of some of her things. Just a hair tie, a tube of lip gloss, and a book she was planning to get rid of. Things that she wouldn't miss but reminded him of her. 

It wasn't lost on him that there would be some other men that had feelings for her, after all, this was Lucy we're talking about. However, he never expected his main rival to be none other than Gajeel Redfox, the man that he had looked up to for years. 

Gajeel and Rogue were not fond of each other. 

That was evident from the way that they would glare at each other whenever they were in the presence of the woman that they were practically having a silent war over, Lucy. Each of them would glare at the other, try to hog her attention, and would frequently argue over which of them she liked more. Their guilds were concerned that eventually, the two dragon slayers would end up getting into an all-out fight over her. 

The conflict that Lucy was somehow unaware of went on for some time until one day, Rogue came up with a solution. The pair had been visiting Lucy at her apartment and were waiting for her return after she had stepped out to deal with Natsu's sudden visit. 

Rogue had looked up from the book he was reading and cleared his throat, getting the attention of the dragon slayer across from him, who sneered in response. The Shadow Dragon Slayer bypassed all unnecessary talk and got right to the point, saying that they should bite the bullet and confess their feelings to Lucy. If she chose one of them, then the other would be happy with her decision. If she chose neither of them, then they would both accept it and remain her friends. And, if on the off chance that she loved both of them, then they would agree to share her, if that was what she desired. 

Gajeel had simply glared at the other black-haired man, thinking over the proposal. After a long stretch of silence, he finally nodded in response, accepting the terms. They then resigned themselves to waiting for Lucy to return to where they were sitting in the main room of her apartment. They wanted to ruin their friendship with her and become her lovers instead. 

After getting Natsu to leave, Lucy had walked back into the main room when and found her two close friends sitting across from each other, Gajeel on one side and Rogue on the other. She had smiled at them and asked what they wanted to do. Rogue had answered that they first had something to tell her. 

Lucy had watched as the dragon slayers stood up and walked toward her before they confessed to her that they both loved her. They encouraged her to be honest about her feelings for them, assuring her that they would be satisfied with whatever her decision would be. The two men had been expecting a few different reactions, but what they weren't expecting was for Lucy to kiss each of them and confess that she loved them both and didn't want to choose between them. The dragon slayers, following through with what they had agreed upon, accepted this and proposed that she date both of them.

This was how Gajeel, Lucy, and Rogue surprise both Fairy Tail and Sabertooth by entering into a polyamorous relationship.