#gale and karlach at the very least shouldve been difficult to keep

[stayatsam]

i do think for bg3 the dark urge should've had to make a persuasion (or deception) check to keep wyll, karlach, and gale after killing alfira

i know durge doesn't get a choice in killing alfira or not but you're already playing on the game on weird mode and have to make a check to not murder your lover, killing them on a failure, so i wish they just committed to having the good characters threaten to leave entirely after you killing her

i mean, if you fail the check of shadowheart attacking laezel at night you may have to kill one of them, so it's not like losing a companion or two is something they're afraid of doing? you could lose gale if you fail to pull him from the rock, it's easy to miss minsc, most people kill minthara, etc....