#gabenette

[fernsnouveau]

I actually disliked the direction where I'd recently seen a bunch of the more reasonable S5-critical ML fandom people going. Those discussions and analyses were spiraling increasingly towards demonising Marinette over time, as we were left hanging with the s5 ending for a long time, and the fandom had nothing new to talk about.

I actually liked her flaws.

But then the canon does... this...

And I do admit, it's an in-character way to push Marinette towards a villain arc. Like, if I had to construct a darkfic scenario where Marinette goes evil and try to keep it as close to her canon personality as possible, it would look something like this. Which, I guess, means that it's theoretically easier for me to accept than, for example, S5's occasional incidents of Edgy Murderboy Chat Noir (how is that the same character who had TWO guilt-based mental breakdowns about accidentally cataclysming someone completely out of his control, including the main villain??!). I'm sure there are in-character ways to turn Adrien (or anyone else) into a villain, but Murder-Noir was Not It.

Of course another reason why the writing of Murder-Noir gives me extra heebie jeebies, was how it felt like an abuse apologia excuse, validating Gabriel's accusations for Adrien to not "deserve" autonomy, nor to experience or express any negative, inconvenient emotions. Murder-Noir feels like it's a writing choice directed at child abuse victims in the audience, who related to Adrien. "See, your abuser was right, you're horrible and overly emotional and out of control, so you NEED to be rigidly controlled for your own and everyone else's good!

Anyway.

While I admit that Marinette taking up Gabriel's mantle this way is technically in character, I cannot claim to enjoy the writing choice at all. I liked Marinette's flaws. I wanted to explore them. I did not want her demonised to this extent. She could have been meaningfully flawed without becoming better at being Gabriel, than Gabriel himself was!

After this, the only justification for the lovesquare to stay together, would be as a wish-fulfillment or "reward" for Marinette, and that's not enough for me. When I think about, if there was a real-life abuse victim in Adrien's position (minus the supernatural elements), and then they were friends with, and/orstarted dating someone who repeatedly treated them the way Maribug has been doing (and "repeatedly" is important here, it demonstrates unwillingness to learn from mistakes and be sincere about apologies – S4 was brushed under a rug as soon as Chat Noir superficially forgave!), ESPECIALLY but not only siding with the abusive parent and lying to the victim that the abuse they experienced was "not really abuse" and For Their Own Good, and demonstrated this complete infantilisation and lack of respect for the abuse victim, wanting to see them only as a palatable, innocent fairytale being who's not allowed to be inconvenient, express negative emotions, make informed choices mor generally be a complete person...

Obviously the right thing to do, for the abuse victim, would be to get the hell away from that person.

It does NOT mean that the person is irredeemable. They're just... not owed the abuse victim's forgiveness and continued presence in their life.

And I can't ignore that anymore.

We failed to get an arc about Adrien surviving and escaping Gabriel and healing. He has now been put into a position where, in order to ever be okay, he would have to survive and escape Marinette in order to heal.

I don't like this. It feels very hopeless and bleak and unenjoyable. I don't even think the story is gonna go there and free/heal Adrien (Astruc made it clear that Adrien isn't supposed to be his own character or have agency, he's supposed to be Marinette's accessory and that's never gonna change).

But as far as I'm concerned, any excuse for the lovesquare relationship to get back together after this, would have the unpalatable aftertaste of propaganda to make victims return to their abusers.

I don't like this trajectory!!!

[chikorra]

Like, we can constantly learn from each other, and sometimes, when they are in the most vulnerable state in their life, the minors need adults's composure and clarity to listen to them and be there for them if needed. Isn't that also the point of parenting? By the logic "adults cannot talk to minors," then parents are not allowed to teach their children when they are still below 18 lmao.

This logic is so flawed sometimes for good people; this happens so much on Miraculous Twitter that it drives me crazy. I guess the minors I helped will sue me someday for dragging them away from suic*de and lending them money at hard times. One day, I will draw Gabenette to scare them off my pages lmao

Sometimes when people on the Internet are like "ADULTS CAN NEVER INTERACT WITH MINORS IT'S CREEPY" I remember how, at 12, back in 1997, I was on the Witchvox forums with people ranging from me to people in at least their 50s, and no one there was ever a creep to me, no one ever made me feel uncomfortable or asked for my personal info, and when I finally broke down after a particularly brutal day of bullying at school and posted about it they were the first adults I'd ever met in my entire life who told me the bullies were the problem and it was okay to be angry about it.

Kids need to interact with adults who will listen to them.

[gale-gentlepenguin]

Why does gabenette exist?-

And why would someone even ship it-

I couldn't tell ya anon, and quite frankly I am too scared to ask

[soap-lady]

Fanfic recs

I’m looking for some good MLB recs. I’ve re-read all my old faves and I want to read something new to me.

What I will read:

Lila/Bustier/Damocles salt or a combo of all three

Crossovers

Crack fics

Humor fics

Rare pairs. Hey, do you have a Marc/Mari/Nath fic? Lay it on me. Do you think Marinette could find love with Jean DuParc? I’ll check it out.

I’ll even read angst if it’s well-written

What I’m not interested in: 

Bashing fics. Except maybe the trio listed above. No fics where the whole class bullies Mari, no fics where Sabine and Tom are awful parents to make Bruce Wayne look like a better dad, no fics where Alya is an iredeemable as*hole.

No Daminette. Here me out! It’s been done and done well but if you want to write Maribat, why not Tim or Duke? Maybe Cass? Maybe Tim/Cass?

No torture fics. No, not even Lila.

No underage smut. I know the Age of Consent is 15 in France but I don’t live there. 18+ please.

No Gabenette. I don’t care if you age her up. No. Just. NO.