#for the record I'm quite fond of the egg option

[meeeeeeese]

Question for you thief mains out there, what's the funniest thing a thief can steal from enemies in your opinion?

For those who don't play thief, these are all actual things you can steal from your enemies.

[drakothedragon55]

Drako’s Top 10 Underrated "Creepy and/or Cozy" Roblox Games

That’s right. I’ve been wanting to do this for a while, and as 2024 is drawing to a close, I thought that this would be a good send-off.

For a game to be included, it must have under a thousand current players (at the time of me writing this, which started in October 2024. I'm aware that #4 has over a thousand current players now, but it didn't at the time, so it stays)

I chose to purposely exclude some more well-known games to give smaller ones a chance to be noticed. Sorry, Jim’s Computer, The Smiles Family/any Roblox myth place, and other similar games. You're all still awesome!

Also please keep in mind that this list is quite subjective. It’s literally my opinion lol. What you and I consider a good game might be quite different.

Without further ado, let’s begin!

#1: Expedition by hyuno_ooo

(second image courtesy of Josh Plays)

Interesting plot? Check. Well scripted? Check. Isn’t even close to being finished? Check. The Expedition is a tale about mental health, and about growing up. Despite it only having a prologue, it seems really promising. Yeah, it goes for the "here's the ending of the story. But how do we get here? Let's rewind." trope (which I don't typically like), but this time around it was actually quite interesting. I could relate to the main character in more ways than one, the dream sequences were neat, and...I'm going to stop there to avoid further spoilers. Hopefully more people notice Expedition soon. It deserves the attention 100%.

#2: Star Creator Simulator by funny fire ant games

I stumbled across this game after discovering another one (cart ride around a used car battery or something along those lines) by the same group. It seems to be heavily inspired by Squirrel Stapler, which is already a good game. I won’t spoil the story since I really want people to give this game a shot (and also because it's really short. Like, 10 minutes maximum), but I was consistently tense during my first playthrough. I genuinely didn't feel safe in the little house, and it's crazy that this joke-game-treated-seriously made me feel that way.

#3: Train to the Unknown by Master Games Corporation

A cozy and creepy exploration game where you can travel between different worlds on the titular train. There’s easter eggs, minigames/small tasks that you can do, a lot of cosmetic options, and other neat things to find. Also the lore is quite interesting if you take the time to find it. If you'd rather figure it out for yourself, then you can just skip ahead to #4. Now for those who want to know, the entire game is essentially purgatory, and each world is composed of memories iirc. Pretty neat! And it explains the ominous messages you see each time the train goes between worlds.

#4: The Intruder by Official_Bulderme

Sorry for the bad screenshots. I recorded a video in case I messed up the shot.

The Mandela Catalogue meets FNAF. Despite being a bit of a chicken when it comes to horror games (ironic, since I love them), I enjoy The Intruder. I have fond memories of trying to piece together the lore back when Satan’s Lodge was the most recent released map. Good times. I appreciate the eventual straying (and subsequent returning) from the FNAF formula, just so each multiplayer level doesn't feel like a reskin of the last one. Oh, and the singleplayer campaign is a whole different beast entirely. I recommend the entirety of multiplayer, and all of the singleplayer tapes. They're short but sweet :)

#5: Warm Isolation by Steven_Scripts

Does this count as a bait and switch experience? Regardless, props to the dev for making a singular bedroom so fun to chill in. But once you find a way to leave the bedroom there’s a whole house to (kinda) explore. So get a lighter or two, and venture out into the long dark hallway. I swear- every last inch of this game was put there with a purpose in mind. Sit down anywhere in the bedroom, then sit down anywhere in the rest of the house and see what I mean. There's also a notebook that you can write in, and I'm pretty sure it only erases once the server closes. It's cool to read both the silly and the in-character messages written by all sorts of different players.

#6: Pepper’s Playhouse by kippwire

A weirdcore/circuscore hangout game. You're gonna see a few other hangout games on this list, I'm sure. Anyways, it's a real shame that no one really plays this game anymore. I liked it so much, I even made my own PPH OC once upon a time. It's still getting updates every now and then, and it even has some custom music tracks. If you like weirdcore, then you're gonna like PPH. Here's hoping you like clowns, too...

#7: Tearose Library by * Tearose Library *

I first discovered this game back when it was called Teafuls' Library, and I gotta say that I'm a fan. I actually used to work as a book restocker here once upon a time, but I'd still recommend this game regardless of my past affiliations. It's just so cozy! All of the books are player-submitted, and despite the low active userbase, it's still getting new book submissions each week.

#8: Cookie Cookie Funtime by Draggyy

(both images courtesy of Josh Plays)

Upon first glance, Cookie Cookie Funtime seems to be yet another FNAF clone. And you’d be right! But CCF does something most of the other clones don’t: it makes fun of itself. CCF is a shockingly-well-made experience that’s also short but sweet (ba-dum tish 🥁 ). Just like all the other games on this list, I recommend it!

#9: Journey to the Sun by nextReality Games

A relaxing (and sometimes challenging) platforming adventure! Journey to the Sun tasks you to collect seven sacred flames, before finally venturing into the sun in order to prevent an ancient evil from escaping. You speed and jump height increases with each flame, allowing you to access areas that you otherwise couldn't before. Plus there's a whole lot of bonus content as well. The vibes this game gives off is hard to describe, but it's definitely cozy.

#10: a dream youve had before by 4slug

What first appears to be a simple "leave your mark" game where you can leave notes for other players to read is actually quite the strange experience if you take the time to delve deeper. There's many badges to collect, but the atmosphere alone is probably enough for some to want to play it. I won't spoil the events that can occur on each floor, but I will warn you about the clocks. Any floor with a clock on it is bad news...

——————————————————————————————————

Honourable Mentions

Write a Letter by Free Hashbrowns. It's a cozy hangout spot with multiple different locations, such as an abandoned bakery, an overgrown convenience store, and more. It gets a spot on the honourable mentions list due to it not really having anything going on besides that. Once you see all there is to see, there isn't really any incentive to go back. Though the letter writing/saving is executed well, and its fun to read what others have written :)

JOVIAL Playground by ROSKAA123. I didn't want two different weirdcore hangout games on the list, so I chose Pepper's Playhouse over this one (due to me liking it just a little bit more.) But that doesn't mean that JP is a bad game. Quite the opposite, in fact! It has a lot of areas to explore and NPCs to meet. It feels like a place kid-me would have loved to visit.

Stupid Idiot Cafe by Funny Fire Ant Games. These people also made Star Creator Simulator, which already has a spot on this list. Stupid Idiot Cafe is both a mockery and improvement to the dime-a-dozen cafe games you'll find all over Roblox. The baristas get guns, for pete's sake! But not just for unruly patrons, oh no no. For the SCP-style cryptids that will periodically escape, of course. There's even a Star Creator Simulator reference. It's cool.

Scary Sushi by Evil Twin Games. Any longtime followers of mine know that I love this game. Unfortunately, it’s a bit too popular to qualify for the main list. But the gameplay loop is just the right amount of difficult and fun to keep you interested, and chapter 2 is going to allegedly release in December. Also SS got featured in The Haunt, so uh. Yeah. At least it’s getting acknowledged?

Edit: Chapter 2 is indeed out. Lol.