#cacoëthes ask

[ambrosialdesire]

Okok. I know I have asked many questions but I beg for this one. What if instead of Marco overheard Reiner and Bertholdt, it was reader who overheard them? Thus, Marco lives AU. What will Reiner do with reader? Can u elaborate a bit longer btw.

reiner’s attached to her already during trost, so either the og plan is forced to speed up/get rushed or he’s kidnapping her and locking her away while faking her death until he’s able to take her out of paradis (aka like the normal canon). i think that both his “soldier” and “warrior” personas agree that reader is very special to reiner and they don’t want much harm coming towards her, though the “soldier” part of him is much more homely and gentle (still manipulative and conniving, but not as bad as the “warrior” persona). so the option of killing her is out of the question, and even annie and bertolt knows that.

tbh there’s not really much i can say about it?? reader would hate him regardless of what happens and how it happens; he’s still the armored titan that killed her family, he’s still the reiner that kidnapped her and took her away from everything she known, he’s still the reiner that kills the fisherman that would’ve taken her back to paradis, and he’s still the reiner that coerced her into having his kid.

[ambrosialdesire]

I enjoy asking questions and you kindly answer them. After part 3 of reader and Reiner lose their virginity, do you think that’s what Reiner will do to her every night ( except periods ) and buy suggestive clothes for him to rip it off.

of course! any questions asked about fics (esp cacoëthes) i enjoy trying to answer!

yeah pretty much, i think i also answered a question similar to this one idk tho lol but reiner’s trying to get her pregnant + make up for lost time due to reader’s restraint on not trying to fuck him HAHA reiner might buy lingerie for reader to wear and for him to take off right after, but i think he prefers seeing her in the skimpy nightgowns (that he also buys her constantly lmao) with just her panties on cause he thinks she’s at her most attractive with those on.

[ambrosialdesire]

Dude… if reader did survive from that persons ask and went back to the survey corps and reiner saw them during battle… oh bro its soo joever for them

-🌷

i fear the poor reader will have to relive the absolute sheer carnage and speed that reiner would have back in his prime armored titan days trying to get to her 😭🙏 he’d be insanely upset and angry, but at the same time, he missed her so much that he can probably forgive her of those transgressions against him (also she’s so fucking hot in the new survey corps uniform, if he was able to pop one out in the titan form, it definitely would’ve made itself know 💀💀)

[ambrosialdesire]

Time for my monthly read of cacoëthes 😼

thank you for your service mekla 🤭🤭 i fr need to do that epilogue and porco side story lmao

[ambrosialdesire]

I read the part three of yandere Reiner and I wanna know what will Reiner do as soon as he shoot your sailor, you took his place and drive the boat straight to the border? After reader succeed reaching the border…

to be fair, that’s up to interpretation! i did mention somewhere in the 2nd part of cacoëthes that the reader would either: die at sea from the lack of resources/getting lost, die from the titans if she managed to land back on paradis, or actually make it back home safe and sound.

reiner would turn into the actual canonical reiner where he’s much more prone to pew pewing himself due to the fact that he finally lost the one person that he devoted his whole life and heart to, so at this point in his life, he’s got nothing left to lose. basically it’s just the entirety of s4 normally until they possibly reunite (which i don’t think would happen since i think the reader wouldn’t join back into the survey corps due to the risk of meeting reiner again, though she really wants to be back on the field again like before + she’s a liability due to her rusty skills and the attachment to reiner).

if she did rejoin them in the final battle, it gives reiner a boost of energy upon seeing her to give it his all as much as he possibly can. he has to apologize to her for scaring her away, embrace her as tightly as he can and to never let her slip through his fingers ever again; and in his mind, she also has to apologize to him, even if it’s literally not her fault for doing what she needed to do to escape lol

reiner wants reader to give him another chance, even if he doesn’t deserve it, but he’s willing to try over and over again just to be in her arms once more. so he fights his hardest when he knows he’s likely to die trying, cause even then, she’ll know how much he loved her enough to save the world for her.

[ambrosialdesire]

TQF answering about Marcel AU lives. May I ask another thing. After post rumbling, where miraculously every Warriors survived, including Bertholdt, what will they do about Reader? I mean Marley no longer have power soo….

i sorta answered the same thing before so please refer to this post with the included links! all in all, they basically feel bad but have bigger issues to worry about themselves (aka their mental health, making peace with both marley and paradis after the rumbling, things like that)

[ambrosialdesire]

Hello. I know u said your inbox request is closed but may I know if u can make some respond of what if Marcel survived and how did he feel about the girl Yandere Reiner fell in love with?

well my fic requests are closed but my asks about certain fics are really never closed lol, and i’m assuming you’re talking about cacoëthes since that’s the only reiner fic within the canon universe

idk if marcel still lived, then reiner really wouldn’t have that reliable big brother kinda vibe that drew reader in the first place, and he’d be more of the pining type if that had occurred. BUT if he still had the same personality (highly unlikely but we’ll roll with it lmao) while marcel was still alive, he’d definitely would try to reason out to reiner why he shouldn’t be with this paradisian girl and definitely why it’s a completely terrible idea when they’re trying to complete their mission. i feel like if he was in the scouts with them, he’d definitely would have developed the same caring attitude he has with the warriors, even if he knows it’s “wrong” to even show an ounce of compassion towards these devils.

how he feels towards reader, probably just like an actual older brother since he misses porco deeply and she sorta reminds him of his little brother. if reiner did go throughout his plan, he finds devastation in it since he feels horrible about having her dragged into this mess when she’s completely innocent, tbh he’d probably fist fight reiner for going against his word. back in marley, marcel would watch over her, making sure she’s acclimating well in the new country and if reiner’s not messing with her too much. he’s the one that makes porco be nice to her and could definitely tell that his little brother has a soft spot for reader once they start hanging out more. he’s not completely thrilled at the idea of his little brother having a crush on his mentally adopted little sister, but it’s material to tease him more than ever!

i think he really would’ve prevented reiner from doing a lot of what he did to reader in the original fic story since reiner holds a lot of respect towards marcel, promising him to never lift a finger towards her nor to force her to do anything she doesn’t want since he already forced her to come to a strange new world. reader would cling onto marcel like he’s the only one she has left (he basically is since bertolt is still dead and gone and annie’s left behind in paradis), and though it irritates reiner to no ends, he can’t do anything about it.

it’s kinda sad how one person could’ve changed everything, but that’s how life is fr

[ambrosialdesire]

Hey, i just finished reading cacoethes and wanna ask will there be a part 4??? And also i saw bloodsport on your incoming fic and wanna ask when is it gonna get publish. Just wanna ask, sorry for sounding rude and demanding though<33

hiiii, thank you for your support! nah cacoëthes won’t have a pt 4, i planned to have it only 3 parts when i made it. i did though, plan to have an epilogue and some what-if kinda spinoffs for cacoëthes, but i haven’t gotten to it lol cause of my college classes, sorta writing block, and i want to finish all my requests and others fics prior to starting new ones 🙂‍↕️

bloodsports is mostly finished, but i don’t really have a set date for when i’ll post it unfortunately. i just usually post whenever i have the energy to keep writing for it, i kinda struggle with smut writing and it’s my first abo fic so i’ve been trying to overcome that mental hurdle 💀💀 i feel like it’s not abo enough atm either, i’m sorta particular when the reader is like super submissive immediately cause that’s not my style tbh LMAO

[ambrosialdesire]

I always wonder how annie or their paradisian friends would react finding out reader is alive or is in marley 🤔

How do you think Cacoëthes Reiner would handle the situation?

Btw, LOVE YOUR WORKS!❤

hi anon! i kinda already answered this question here (for annie at least): https://www.tumblr.com/ambrosialdesire/726886528146653184/im-the-same-anon-who-was-asking-all-those

and here is sorta the others perspective: https://www.tumblr.com/ambrosialdesire/746583876522196992/so-idk-if-u-answered-this-in-like-another-ask-but

all in all, it’s basically indifference since they’ve gone through so much that finding out reader has been kidnapped into reiner’s war wife is pretty minute 💀 like omg thank god you’re somehow still alive but i have trauma to deal with, so let’s talk about this later

and i’ve think i’ve said before that reiner harbors a little guilt about it and lets her speak to them without much restrictions since he already knows who they are, but it’s usually somewhat brief cause reader feels unsure that she should be talking to them for very long. if you wanna see some similar answered asks, the #cacoëthes ask tag has all you need to know hopefully 🤞

[ambrosialdesire]

Quick, who would win in a fight—

Cacoëthes Reiner vs Desiderate Bertholdt?

Oooh and to make things spicer what if they’re fighting over Y/N 🥰

WAIT OMFG THIS IS GOOD QUESTION FUCK I DON’T WANT TO SOUND BIASED EITHER ABOUT IT TOO

TBH i feel like desiderate bertolt is more stronger than cacoëthes reiner, cause even in the canon storyline, bertolt was the one who was picked over reiner for the titan holder (we all know bro did NOT get chosen at all) and has the considerably strongest Titan before eren’s attack titan/founding titan form. but bert’s pretty lanky and reiner is much more beefier than him, even when he was going through it, BUT ALSO BERT IS MUCH TALLER THAN HIM SO?????

BUT THEN AGAIN reiner did amazing in the training scouts as he came in second place, over both annie and bertolt, two of the holders that were also chosen for their titans before reiner was swapped and reiner is also the one alive compared to bert (isayama tysm LMAO) 😭 but given that, i feel like cacoëthes reiner is more powerful strategically since desiderate bertolt wasn’t even the one that planned the entire kidnapping for his reader, he just asked reiner if he could so reiner could plan how to sneak her away from the others along with them LOL reiner in his story was already locked in from the beginning stages on how to bring her back to marley too and how to break her in slowly to have a family with him 💀

i think also in terms of scuffling, we know that reiner in s4 struggled really mentally to win any fights bc of his guilt towards his paradisian friends and from his struggle of his identity of being a warrior and a scout, so he also has that handicap, cause i think bertolt has less guilt about it since his dad came before all of them (he’s also the one without a mental disorder so 💀😭)

IF CACOËTHES REINER AND DESIDERATE BERTOLT FOUGHT FOR READER, guys they’ll literally either be the death of each other or a stalemate cause they can’t just die and leave reader alone 😭 plus reiner’s too stubborn to let himself die and bert’s just gonna become too horny HAHA in another stupid ass scenario, if they fought, reiner might win simply bc beat came during it LMFAOOOOO

"bro did… did you just cum?" "… no." as reiner is choking him out, bertolt’s literally doubling over trying to hide that he actually did 😭😭😭 LORD SAVE THE READER FROM THESE MEN 💀💀

it also depends on which reader too since they’re kinda a little different (the only thing they can agree on is hating their partner LMAO) so imagine them being plopped right into each other’s worlds

reiner with desiderate reader, she’s more tolerable with him rather than his reader since desiderate reader works for them and he’s her boss technically, so she has some respect towards him. she may hold hate for him too, but it’s not as much as with cacoëthes reader. also constant office fucking from the both of them, it’s probably is now part of her job if cacoëthes reiner was there, though he’d prefer her to be a housewife rather than working for him, but when he sees her knelt under the desk sucking him off, his mind kinda changes teehee

desiderate reader is not getting a break from both her home and the workplace 😖

bertolt with cacoëthes reader, she also technically hates him since it was very well stated in the second part BUT i feel like she tolerates him better than reiner 😭 THEY SHOULD SWITCH READERS TBH /j and even if he’s more masochistic and pretty fucking scary overall when he’s near knives, he’s more obedient to her demands and starts to enjoy the thought of coming home to a wife. plus reiner may be onto something when he sees the swell of her pregnant belly and her breasts, the desire to impregnate her next latching onto his mind.

again, cacoëthes reader is NOT getting a break either LMFAOOOOO

THAT’S MY TWO CENTS ON IT THOUGH, I THINK DESIDERATE BERTOLT ROCKS CACOËTHES REINER IN STRENGTH BUT CACOËTHES REINER ROCKS DESIDERATE BERTOLT IN STRATEGY IDK 😭😭 i actually loved answering this question, ty anon!

[ambrosialdesire]

im feeling a little silly think abt cacoëthes reiner and what if the reader was or had become mute? (Idk why i love mute characters because they are so expressive in body language)

ooo this is an interesting idea anon!

reiner would be frustrated at first if reader became mute, not completely understanding why she started to do this, contemplating if it was because out of spite, anger, or a combination of both. he'd get mad cause he expects verbal communication to be reciprocated (it's like expecting eren to join forces with him and bert back when he confessed that they were the armored and colossal 💀), forcing her to try and speak again but since it's only harming their relationship, he stopped and started to adapt to her new "habit" rather than try to change it. reiner started paying even more attention to very small details in her expressions and movements, now causing him to fall even deeper in love with her LMAO cause nothing can really make bro stop loving reader, we appreciate our delusional king here ‼️

since she's not talking, she thinks that he can't read her anymore but it's becomes the opposite effect. like the smallest twitch of her mouth downwards indicates that she obviously doesn't like something, the shifting glances towards a particular object constantly during shopping means that she likes it and wants to get it, closing her eyes with slight scowl means that she wants to be left alone (he gets that a lot haha), etc. even during sex, reiner's attentive towards what she likes and what'll get her off quicker, even if it's just from her sounds. you can blindfold bro and he'll still manage to make reader cum like crazy LMFAO

and then let's say she was born mute (like her vocal cords were never properly developed) or she's been mute since reiner met her (like they were damaged from something WAIT OMFG IMAGINE SHE SCREAMED SO MUCH AND SO LOUDLY WHEN HER FAMILY DIED THAT IT LITERALLY SHREDED HER VOCAL CORDS TO THE POINT OF NOT BEING ABLE TO BE FIXED/USED ANYMORE THE GUILT REINER WOULD HAVE OVER THAT BC IT WOULD ESSENTIALLY BE HIS FAULT), he adapts much faster than if she started to become mute during their married life. if the reader knows sign language, he'll learn it just for her and during this time (since they're still cadets), she appreciates his willingness to communicate with her like this and actually will start to have a genuine crush with him since he's the only one that's talking to her in the way she likes/knows best (canon cacoëthes reader did like reiner and thought he was attractive from time to time, but never had a long-lasting/actual crush on him). everyone else either just talks to her and lets her only listen, or she uses a notepad to respond, but with reiner, she doesn't have to do that. it's pretty cute since they're the only ones that know what they're saying to one another, and reiner sees this communication as something special between them, like he's the only one that listens to her yk. just like in the other paragraph, he learns what her expressions and movements mean as the days go on and when he kidnaps her, he could never forget that look of fear and hatred and betrayal sewn onto every detail on her face.

first few months, she'd close her eyes and put her hands over her ears to ignore him and he understands why, but gets so frustrated to the point where he rips her hands away from her ears and threatens her that if she keeps on doing this, he might as well take her hearing and sight away since she likes doing that so much. that's the only time he'd actually threaten to severely harm her to the point of disability (cause i'm gonna be so fr, i don't remember if i ever wrote reiner threatening reader like that in the entire three parts besides him telling her he would A. unalive her (he won't and ik i said that in the third part, but reader constantly assumes he's gonna moider her) B. impregnate her C. slap/hit/choke her D. shoot her and well, we can see which ones he chose without even saying it 💀💀) and safe to say, she immediately stopped and was forced to start communicating with him again.

sorry i made this hella long LMAO but i found this really fun to think about, thanks for your ask anon!!

[ambrosialdesire]

So idk if u answered this in like another ask but would the s4 plotline still continue w/ cacoëthes reiner?

yup! i think i did answer some similar questions about it a few months ago lol

if you need help finding the answers, every cacoëthes series related ask is under the tag #cacoëthes ask in the blog 😁

AOT S4 FINAL PART SPOILERS JUST IN CASE

but in short, reiner does go off into the same plotline (he’s just a little less self-deprecating since he has a family to live for now) and does get released from the titan holder curse. i think i did also say that reader was with his mom at the time of the rumbling (still pregnant) so yk how they turn into titans for like a bit? she turns into one BUT DW THE BABY IS NOT AFFECTED OR HARMED DURING THIS PROCESS 😭‼️ and bc he now is able to live longer, both him and reader are still together and they’re working it out (not really, reiner’s still pretty controlling but becomes more lenient for reader since his paradisian friends are back and he knows how much reader missed them, and he’s still feels sorta guilty about the whole circumstance). she knows that he doesn’t like her talking to others for too long (and bc he molded her to be that way after the escape attempt/pt 3 of the series) so unfortunately she kinda hesitates bonding with her old friends bc it’s crazy awkward to talk about her time and relationship with reiner, and it’s been forever since she’s seen them.

reiner and reader after the rumbling become more like an old couple that bickers towards one another but they still love each other; kinda like when reader was at the braun family home to celebrate in pt 2 if y’all remember that, but it’s genuine, no more pretending.

the scout squad think its a pretty weird to see her and him being in a relationship (esp cause reiner literally kidnapped her) but they don’t really question it too hard, cause quite literally everyone there is traumatized and trying to do their own thing to heal. plus everyone there has done their own war crimes, so reiner kidnapping and having a family? unfortunately pretty tame compared to murder tbh 😭😭

[ambrosialdesire]

Imagining Reiner just snatching up a random baby reminds me of this one scene in the movie School Dance. Just imagining reader being like who’s baby is that is makin me lose it

This clip:

https://youtu.be/prIDNfcsdiw?feature=shared

HELP MEEEEE

im gonna be so fr with you anon, that’s exactly what i was thinking about when i was making that answer to the other anon 😭😭 but i didn’t know where the audio originated from, i just know it from tiktok 💀

[ambrosialdesire]

REINER SNATCHED UP A RANDOM BABY IF THE READER COULDNT HAVE ONE OH MH GOD

YESSIR AND HES TOTALLY CONVINCED THAT IT CAME FROM THE TWO OF YOU TOO LMAOOO like babe wym you obviously gave birth to them, don’t you remember how many times i nutted in you 🙄

there’s a possibility that the child is probably from an eldian dad that’s very down on his luck, maybe bc the woman he loved was a marleyan who basically dumped the child on him and left and he can’t stand looking at this horrid baby. he found them in a cardboard box with tattered pieces of cloth wrapped around them in a makeshift blanket, stained inked words jotted down with crude insults and reiner took pity on this poor lil baby bc their background was just like his. how fascinating it was that they were nearly similar in appearance to both reader and him, so he swooped it up in his arms and took them home.

at least… that’s what he said when you kept asking where they came from and you felt like you had no choice but to believe him.

and you may be wondering, ambro, since the baby isn’t technically reader’s, she wouldn’t care to leave them right? well yeah, she could very well still up and leave reiner, but the whispered threats of implying murder to a innocent child doesn’t settle very well in anyone’s stomach, especially hers.

reiner reminds you he’s killed thousands, no matter the age or the gender. what’s another to his already lengthy repertoire? so stay and watch our child like a good mother would, okay?

[ambrosialdesire]

I had a thought what if cacoae (however tf u spell it) reiner’s reader was like infertile/sterile. Would the home boy be devastated and like reader be like idk relieved

yea reiner would be in shambles but it fr doesn’t mean that he’ll love reader any less bc of it and yes omg the reader is extremely relieved that she can’t bear a child for him, but i feel like bro still fucks her like he’s trying to put in a baby in her and is in denial about the whole thing 😭

so reader’s doing pretty well mentally despite the constant fucking, she can’t get pregnant which means that he can’t hold anything against her and there’s nothing binding her to him and preventing another escape attempt. she’s now planning it mentally as best as she can so reiner can’t do anything about it or find out.

it’s not until one night when she was going to escape to a different internment zone, reiner comes back with a crying baby in his arms.

“reiner, who’s baby is that?”

“ours of course.”

that’s when she realizes that he really is never letting her go. no matter what it’s going to take.