#but for actual dialogue i like to add the subject dropping mid sentence or repetition of words and pauses and rewording
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Ok I know there's the whole thing about writing a novel like a script for television, in that you omit "ums" and "uhs" and have people clearly say what they mean to "justice is for those fortunate enough to consider what to do" (some character making a clear theme related statement) or if a character says a lie it's unclear Because it's a lie not because they talked unclearly "I don't know where he went, I think he mentioned going to see Seph" when character did see where he went, and wants Seph to be blamed even though "he" didn't go to Seph.
I get that it's this kind of dramatized way of speaking that isn't realistic. In reality, people often change words midway through a sentence, change topics or full on halt one statement and just drop it. Stuff like "I was going to the store and - hey Richard why didn't you come with me yesterday. I needed you. It. It really hurt you didn't show." The first part about some store would be unimportant in a tight script but it's realistic. The pausing on It is not necessarily a strong sounding line carried though. But a woman starting to cry, scared to say the next portion, might repeat it or you. You- trying to work up her courage to completely voice the sentence. It reads more choppy yes, but it also reads more like a real conversation. For me personally I like when dialogues in stories sometimes are written this way. I get the reason for the other way, but I think leaving in the natural messiness of regular everyday speech sometimes adds something of its own.
#rant#................................................................................................................................#i feel like ive seen some writers Heavily biased toward one or the other writing style for dialogue wording#so like. haruki murakami i have not read in a while#but in particular i think his writing dtyle tends to do it in the narration not just the dialogue#which is probably jarring for some people. i absolutely love it though it feels like stream of conciousnes#like im IN the author or characters mind as the situations happen#some of my favorite writers do this a bit and its fantastic to me#i personally like to tighten my narration a la dramatic clear wording#but for actual dialogue i like to add the subject dropping mid sentence or repetition of words and pauses and rewording#because i like my scenes to feel like you walked in on some real moment between people#and just saw them actually interacting. a private moment#and in real life people dont always know what theyre saying right away. ppl reword and clarify#and conclude as they realize their point#like. i do get avoiding uh and um#but the pauses? the repeating words and reqording sentences mid way through?#thats part of the tension of a conflict. is u desperate to tell someone what u mean#byt they cant understand you or refuse to no matter how you reword and explain#in real life that is a tense point of conflict as much as the topic itself
0 notes