#basira was a hypocrite but thats genuinely not the worst thing someone can be | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

pmpknsoup · 5 months ago

Text

i actually am a defender of georgie and melanie and basira being mean or rude to jon bc that man really needed to be put in his place sometimes. like i understand that they were also wrong sometimes— basira is hypocritical and the other two could be nastier than necessary, but i literally cannot blame them at all. jon was so out of line sometimes

#WAYY more thoughts in the tags ->#its like people forgive jon for how needlessly dickish he was in s1 #and tim gets forgiven for his outbursts in s3 because he was going through a lot #despite the situation being relatively low stakes #but the girls get villainized to hell and back for honestly some very reasonable points of anger #georgie shut down jon coming back to her apartment to talk to Melanie because as far as shes aware #melanie mutilated herself to get away from the institute and jon was attempting to drag her back #mind you jon didnt give her a reason to believe he was doing otherwise #basira was a hypocrite but thats genuinely not the worst thing someone can be #and its part of what makes her character so fascinating to me #yes shes a hypocrite. yes she still gets shit done #and melanies anger is very akin to tims yet she seems to receive the brunt of the hate for it #and while i do think sometimes they were unreasonable with jon #jon was also unreasonable with them at times too #its a two way street and it really bothers me to see people act like these girls are the worst characters because they dared to be mean #pmpkn tma liveblog #the magnus archives #tma #sorry i yap a lot

62 notes · View notes