#at this point im pretty sure he kinda ignores script directions for reactions and just vibes w the character

[clairenatural]

re: the gifset w/ the script that you just reblogged + your tags

i also agree i don’t think it was shock at all i think dean knew what he was going to say and he was so desperate for him to not say it not now please not now cas please don’t leave me

yeah!! that’s exactly what I took from it--that doesn’t look like shock/not reciprocating/caught off guard. That was “not right now,” “don’t do this right now,” not “wait hold on I don’t feel the same way oh no”

Idk I just think it’s interesting that Jensen might claim to play Dean as straight and not in love with Cas but then, even when the script tells him to be shocked and caught off guard....he instead plays it like he’s in love with Cas.