#Now they've thrown out a huge thematic portion of their source material | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

thefollow-spot · 2 years ago

Text

I think the writers of Rings of Power really fucked up when they decided to make Galadriel the only elf with substantial trauma about the War of Wrath/the war in Beleriand in general. This was a long war in a culture with a long memory, and so much of the Second Age can be read as a direct (traumatically influenced) response to those wars. To make Galadriel out as not only unusual, but unreasonable for holding onto this trauma is a massive blunder.

#Now they've thrown out a huge thematic portion of their source material #Not to mention how little this makes sense logic-wise.#I can adaptation decisions that don't quite make sense if it's a sacrifice to strengthen other story elements #but this is a sacrifice for no reason.#It literally makes the story worse #This would all be fixed if they made Halbrand take his shirt off more of course #rop crit #rop critical #rings of power critical #rings of power tv show #amazon rings of power #rings of power #anti rings of power #anti rop

62 notes · View notes