#Luffy’s struggle is more external while Aang’s is internal. Luffy’s always known who he is while Aang is still trying to fighter that out
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
As someone that loves ATLA and is recently getting back into the fandom and has also been spending alot of time in the One Piece fandom as off late
Luffy and Aang have a very similar energy that I enjoy. They are just both so precious oh my god 😭. They are so different but they have very similar narrative functions in how they inspire the people around them to embrace silliness and childlike joy.
But also I love the way they move their powers are fun and they love using them. They are constantly using it's ungrained in the way they move Aang loves airbending he's never not jumping around with it and Luffy loves being rubber
Which makes their differences all the more exciting and seeing how that same scale of personality
they both deal with inherited will Aang more literally and directly that Luffy (as of yet) and they interact with that differently. Aang's inherited will is a weight on his shoulders a burden he has to bear while Luffy's is a pleasant surprise to those around, and the source of his desire for freedom. And this comes through in how they interact with the ultimate version of their powers the literal embodiment of these inherited wills. The avatar state and gear 5
The avatar state for Aang represents a destiny he is still to young to bear, it is unpredictable, overwhelming, uncontrollable, it is something to be feared and worried about, it represents a loss of control for him and he struggles to reconcile that kind of destructive power with himself and his values. It scares him, and That’s why it remains lost to him for much of the series till he makes it his own.
Meanwhile for Luffy Gear 5 represents freedom, he is literally being freed from the constraints of reality. It is the culmination of everything he’s ever been. It’s everything we love about luffy turned up to a 100. Gear 5 is silly, goofy, cartoonish, unserious, fun loving, filled with laughter, insanely power and lowkey a little scary. Even tho Luffy is technically transforming into another person (or god) but god it is still him it is everything that has ever embodied him. And Luffy loves to be in it he has so much because as he said it’s him at his freest.
Aang and Luffy have very different character philosophies, priorities and move through the world differently. Aang is very much concern about the people in the general sense while Luffy is very much focused on helping his friends which then spirals to helping the general population, it just so happens that he is very good at making friends
But at their core they are just both fun loving little boys refusing to let their tragedies define them as they and their rag tag group of walking disasters rove the world like criminals, freeing the people from oppression.
#they both have a strong relationship to freedom as well except freedom means two drastically different things#god I feel like I had a better ending written out but I waited to long and tumbler deleted it#but yeah this is me rambling#hope some sense can be made out of this#I love Aang and luffy so much and it’s so sad and interesting#that Luffy is generally adored through out the fandom while Aang has become so polarizing#they are obviously not going through the same character journey#Luffy’s journey is more about becoming outworks strong so he can carry out his will (freedom protecting those he loves)#and Aangs journey is more strengthing his will to match his physical power#Luffy’s struggle is more external while Aang’s is internal. Luffy’s always known who he is while Aang is still trying to fighter that out#luffy is a lot more soef assured as to who he is than Aang is I would say it’s because he’s older but he’s always been that way.#it’s interesting they’re interesting I love these boys so much#throwing thoughts to the void#one piece#op#atla analysis#atla aang#aang#avatar aang#monkey d. luffy#luffy#straw hat luffy#one piece meta#atla meta#avatar the last airbender#one piece analysis#character study#pro aang#still kills me that that is a tag 😭
33 notes
·
View notes