#Batman stopped adding evidence to the theory or say anything against it they JL think he knows it is true

[bwabbitv3s]

I think it would be a tie between Bruce and Diana for who figures it out first. Bruce says nothing about it as he wants to see how long it takes the others to realize they are tailoring the evidence to fit the theory. The Batkids has a betting pool going about it.

Diana is upset for just a moment before she realizes that not once has Phantom or his sister lied or even implied his sister is an Amazon. She finds a way to drop hints that she is always interested in meeting more Amazons that have left Themysicra and welcome them to the family.

*Oops set this to queue instead of draft, let me finish that though.

Danny does not question the way the League seems to ask him questions about his family. He is just glad for a way to change the topic when he needs an out. It is all fine and good till he mentions his aunt that hates men and lives far away from everyone. "Its not really that bad and honestly she is pretty nice once you get past it. I think she blames Dad for why mom lives so far away."

Ancient Siblings (dpxdc thought)

So y'all know the trope where Danny, as Phantom, is perceived as thousands of years old due to time traveling shenanigans?

During an interaction with another hero (could be the Batfam, could be the JL, who knows), Danny lets it slip that he has a living sister. He doesn't mention her by name, but in just a couple sentences makes it clear that he has a sister that he has known for much of his life. The thing about this prompt is that there are two people that it could lead to.

The easy solution is Danielle, Phantom's little sister. Similar looks, similar power set, could probably fake being fairly old with some help from the ghosts in the zone.

The hard solution is Jazz, his big sister.

Jazz with her towering figure (due to her Dad's genetics), great physical strength (due to her liminality), skill in combat (due to training from her mother and perhaps some swordsmanship from Pandora), and strong sense of justice (due to being on a vigilante team) and human psychology.

Jazz who, through a series of coincidences and matching aspects, could feasibly be mistaken for an Amazon that left Themysicra in favor of Man's World.

The heroes are scrambling to figure out how an undead, interdimensional being at least three millennia old ended up meeting an Amazon and when they decided to call themselves brother and sister. How did these two decide to find family in each other, of all people?!

For her part, Jazz thinks it's hilarious, and would love to get a set of armor to fully commit to the bit.