#*sobs* malmal im sorry.. for thinking of putting u thru all ths... | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

lvminisciel · 7 months ago

Text

🤗🤗

ive just spent the last 6hrs goin thru every piece of media from 'the phantom of the opera' and all i can say is

WHY IS IT LIKE THATTT

why's the ending like that??? be it the one from broadway theatre dated back in 1988, or the musical in 1986, the movie from 2004, even in the original novel by Leroux himself, none of them ends with a closure of the phantom's acceptance..

i hvnt watch the 1925 silent film version tho; but so far i think i like the og novel version best

personally i spite the 2004 version so much as in tht one, christine clearly stated tht she's afraid of the phantom (as uttered in the song 'Twisted Every Way') while it's never been told that way in the novel/broadway/other versions

on the og novel tho, despite christine still married raoul in the end, he still returned to bury the phantom during his passing, the last thing phantom had asked before they parted. she fulfilled her promise, and put the ring(?) he gave her to be buried w/ him.. truly the best ending of all version me thinks

overall i loved the parallels of night & daylight imagery. of heaven & hell, beast & beauty. also the part where she said 'he sings inside my mind'? imo it can be interpreted in many ways

#the whole media was a blast but i think the phantom deserves more closure #like what happened!! to those pain & suffering!! that years of longing & yearning human compassion!!#all that just to be resolved with one kiss???#then he bow down and cried?? weep even??#then what?? what about all his life works?? what his wishes and dreams of normal life??#do we not get that issue resolved; or at least the phantom goin thru acceptance or forgo the path of spite??#did the moment christine kissed him he jst accept the fact that. that myb love & compassion aren't meant for him??#DO YOU WANT ME TO BELIEVE IT ENDED LIKE THAT???#THERE'S STILL SO MUCH TO TALK ABOUT COMBACK HERE YA AUTHORRRRR #I WANNA KNOW WHAT'S INSIDE THE PHANTOM'S MIND AFTER THT FINAL SCENE RRRAAAAAAAHHHH #I NEED MOREEEEEEEEE #*sobs* malmal im sorry.. for thinking of putting u thru all ths...#.... yknow what imma jst alter the story in my fic #😈😈 dw malmal ur in safe hands #miè fic refs #miè rambles

4 notes · View notes