#(idk if tumblr fob fans would do that but ive had twitter fob fans come at me for saying slightly critical things)
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
i listened to the fall out boy version of we didn’t start the first (listing 1989-2023 world events) and can i just say. first of all the original song is silly and not that deep in its commentary but at least it was like an original idea. there’s a reason your 11th grade history teacher played it in your class in the cold war unit, right? it sets a scene and a mood without even having to do anything but listing a bunch of pop culture and political iconography. but there’s also like, a sequence of events. fob’s really just throws events and names of things together sloppily in no particular order other than if they kinda rhyme. it has a lot less impact when thinking about the recent historical or present moment bc it’s just like “thing you remember, other thing you remember, other thing you remember” but from one object to the next they have no particular connection to each other in space or time. it’s poorly associated.
#i'm not a huge fan of the original but i do like billy joel as a songwriter... though we didn't start the fire is not his best#it's fine. it's got a point but not a very deep one.#it's more just like an *interesting* song to *think* about and feel#that's kinda why remaking it is also weird in the first place? make your own song about recent history#bc there's actually SO LITTLE said in the original we didn't start the fire. the only commentary is in the chorus and it's not that deep#i'm not mad that it exists but it's kinda like. why#idk this is some shit pete wentz would find deep and powerful that's all i can say#text post#sorry fob fans if you find this text post bc i'm not censoring the band's name. we used to have a tumblr tagging system#that was great where i could simply not tag the name of your favorite band and you wouldn't find it in a search but now tumblr's broken#im not here to start drama ive actually liked a lot of fall out boy's music in my life i'm just not impressed by their new stuff#but by the looks of it neither are a lot of you so. idk i come in peace.#leave me alone don't send me hate#(idk if tumblr fob fans would do that but ive had twitter fob fans come at me for saying slightly critical things)#(that's why i dont use twitter anymore among several other great reasons)
3 notes
·
View notes