entrepreneurdesigners

[entrepreneurdesigners]

Teaching Entrepreneurship through In-Public Experiential Learning

Insights from the Teach the 1K Workshop

In February 2019, @xuhulk​ and I convened Teach the 1K — a multi-event gathering of over 40 entrepreneurship educators and activators from a variety of backgrounds—academic, community-based, for-profit, non-profit—to teach them how to teach the $1K Challenge:

Design, launch and complete a crowdfunding campaign that benefits a community you’ve worked with over the course of the semester. The campaign should raise at least $1,000 from 50 different backers.

We ran this workshop because after collectively teaching for 7 years, we were at a crossroads with our work.

We’d seen how transformational the $1K Challenge could be as a teaching tool, and that the lessons the students learned through that experience were only becoming more and more important for the broader public.

There was tremendous potential, but it wasn’t clear how to scale it beyond ourselves. So, we decided to convene a gathering of relevant folks to see if we could teach them how to teach the $1K Challenge.

Here’s what we learned.

Teach the 1K Insights

1. There is a burgeoning interest in teaching people to confront uncertainty.

When we launched the Teach the 1K Workshop, we decided to frame it as an opportunity for teachers to learn how to teach people to confront uncertainty.

We were concerned this framing might be too abstract and thus fail to attract sufficiently qualified participants.

As it turns out, that concern was unsupported. The response was so strong and clear that we created a second event to accommodate the demand.

In retrospect, this shouldn’t have been a surprise. We’re not the only ones to recognize the need for a different, more equitable, approach that is relevant to a broad range of creators, whether they’re optimizing for economic value or social value.

2. The heart of entrepreneurship is exploration, which is rarely taught.

The heart of entrepreneurship — no matter which flavor — is about navigating and confronting uncertainty. We refer to this as exploring, and it is distinct from training the labor force to work in the venture industrial complex.

Many of the existing approaches we have for fostering entrepreneurship are selection mechanisms intended to surface investment opportunities, not opportunities to teach people to explore. While there are efforts to coach and mentor entrepreneurs, the stakes are either too high, or the experience is conflated with the separate challenge of raising capital.

Generally speaking, people aren’t being taught to explore. Our current educational system is optimized for training people to climb ladders rather than to sail the open seas.

The fundamentals of how to explore can be taught in a consistent and repeatable fashion, but doing so is a distinctly different practice from teaching skill acquisition (especially at scale). Everything from the interaction model to the economics of what sustains such an effort needs to be carefully considered.

3. What makes the $1K Challenge an effective teaching tool is that it takes place in public.

Many lessons are best learned through experience rather than lectures, and this requires that the students pursue real projects with real consequences.

Unequivocally, we have found that it is this decision — that the students pursue a challenge with real-life outcomes outside of their control — that is the most critical enabler in teaching people to explore and confront uncertainty.

The $1K Challenge is an example of what we call In-Public Experiential Learning.

4. Online public spaces create new opportunities for In-Public Experiential Learning

The rise of online public platforms like Kickstarter and Twitter has resulted in an exciting arena for In-Public Experiential Learning.

By leveraging Kickstarter, for example, we inherit the constraints of the platform, which make it easier for someone to launch something as audacious as an original idea. We also benefit from the resources Kickstarter provides to any creator, not to mention the collective wisdom of past creators. Twitter creates a space where by the students’ projects can be discovered (or not) by a receptive audience.

In essence, Kickstarter is the boat, Twitter is the open sea, and our 16-week course provides the prompt (the $1K Challenge), the training, and a safe harbor.

Once the student launches, the outcomes are out of everyone’s control — which is a valuable lesson in itself. As a class, they’re going out to sea together and coming back with personalized lessons which inevitably benefit everyone.

This is just one example of an educational experience that is built on this new terrain. Done well, there’s a huge unrealized opportunity to create similar educational experiences across all online public space.

The hard part is figuring out how to craft the right challenge with a clear success or failure mode that encourages the student to willingly jump in, and the necessary safeguards for guiding participants to the endpoint with minimal risk.

5. In-Public Experiential Learning requires resilient instructional systems.

The experience of teaching an in-public challenge introduces an additional layer of chaos and complexity in the form of unpredictable student outcomes and obstacles.

This can be overwhelming for both the student and the teacher. By taking the students out of carefully controlled conditions, you are subjecting them to the entropy of the world, which can surface many irrational fears and reflexes. Similarly, as instructors, it’s inordinately expensive to support a whole cohort of students working in this manner.

The key to managing this is to build resilient systems in lieu of defaulting to “hero mode”, where student challenges are resolved solely through increased individual effort by the teacher.

Such systems include things like:

leveraging our own personal and professional networks for student project feedback,

building software tools to automate mundane tasks, and

establishing rituals where the students share some responsibility.

Thinking of teaching as a set of systems means that we can do more than just react; we can pre-empt problems, point out inefficiencies, and continually iterate.

6. The $1K Challenge is a specific implementation, not an adaptable framework.

Our hypothesis going into the workshop was that the $1K Challenge was one of the best ways to actually teach people to explore and confront uncertainty, and that other educators could potentially modify it to fit their contexts.

In reality, it would be more effective to teach other instructors at the level of abstraction right above that.

The $1K Challenge has worked well for us because over the years, we tailored it precisely to our context — teaching first-year graduate students in the SVA MFA in Interaction Design program. We built a precise obstacle course that accounts for our students’ strengths and weaknesses — as well as our own — and considers the constraints and the institutional context in which we operated. The process we have shared here is the outcome of seven years of optimization.

While there are many components of the $1K Challenge that can be borrowed or adapted, it’s ultimately too custom-built to serve as a starting point for other educators and activators, especially those working in very different contexts.

Rather than teach the $1K Challenge, the more impactful (and scalable) approach may be to share what we know about designing and operating In-Public Experiential Learning programs, and to help people create programs customized to their context — whether they’re coming from academia, government, non-profits or for-profits.

Hot Takes

No blog post is complete without some hot-takes. Here are a mix of trends and insights, all of which are worthy of longer posts in themselves. Each of these represent opportunities for further exploration.

1. We will see new a whole bunch of educational experiences that take place in the new networked public. 

The $1K Challenge is but one example of what can be done. However, most of what we see in online education is skill acquisition or a straight port of offline classrooms to an online container. There’s a huge opportunity to create fun and powerful experiential educational experiences, akin to Pokemon Go. This doesn’t mean that classrooms are irrelevant—in fact, quite the opposite. Classrooms provide space for cohorts to support and learn from each other—which is key for experiential programs—and IRL will always be more compelling than virtual. Related, we’ll also see a fair amount of innovation in networked teaching models.

2. Teaching is a horizontal practice that’s increasingly relevant outside of academia. 

For a certain class of companies, Education will graduate from being a Support or Marketing activity, to being a core function that reports into the CEO. It’ll be the most effective way to grow and retain customers/users while simultaneously becoming a powerful input into the product development process.

3. Build (or join) a community before you begin to build a product. 

The first “product” you attempt to build should be the thing that either coalesces the community you want to serve, or grants you trusted access to an existing community. In most cases, it should notbe an MVP of your idea. Done right, you’ll have less guesswork on the road to product market fit, lower user acquisition costs, and a built-in group of advocates—if not customers—you can build for and with. Or, you may discover they’re not who you should be building for at all. If you fail to coalesce a community, it’s a non-starter. Start over. (Note: this idea is the undercurrent of the most recent version of the course.)

4. Mission-driven entrepreneurship is a different process from what’s been popularized. 

There are many flavors of entrepreneurship, and they all optimize for different outcomes—wealth creation, agency, impact, are some examples. In all cases, you can’t escape the laws of physics—at some point you will need to figure out how to financially sustain your work. Often, the biggest hurdle is the mindset shift from “what you can dream up” to “what will actually work”. If you are optimizing for a mission over wealth creation—meaning you’d rather shut everything down than pivot to a completely unrelated random business—you have an added level of difficulty in that you will need to figure all of this out as early as possible. Otherwise, things may get really complicated. Furthermore, you may need ignore the majority of the advice, programs, and support infrastructure out there, simply because they just don’t apply to you. Honestly, the best approach you can probably take is #3.

The Teach the 1K Insights were co-written with Christina Xu and can be found on our website Post-Industrial Design School along with an archive of the Teach the 1K Workshop, our course materials, student blogposts and much more. Hot Takes are written entirely by Gary.

Post-Industrial Design School is an experiential learning lab run by Christina Xu and Gary Chou.

[entrepreneurdesigners]

Sharing your work in public is scary, but it is an essential step to build trust and credibility within your own network.

Lessons Learned From Successfully Running a Kickstarter Campaign by Margarita Yong

[entrepreneurdesigners]

It is definitely out of my comfort zone. However, friends, families, and people have truly surprised me.

Asking for help empowers you by Wen Chun Wei

[entrepreneurdesigners]

Stay within your target audience (somewhat) to get the appropriate feedback. You don’t need to please everyone.

What I learned from launching Reflect, a guided journaling club by Andrea Kang

[entrepreneurdesigners]

...you need not always polish your offering to bring it out to people, it is OK to bring the idea out in its inception stage and keep improving upon it as you move along.

My understanding of KICKSTARTER by Abhinav Sircar

[entrepreneurdesigners]

it helped me to do all of the above and realize that our networks and our fellow designers — the company we keep — shapes who we are and helps us to grow.

The Company We Keep: A Kickstarter Journey by Crystal Wang

[entrepreneurdesigners]

I don’t know what role design and technology can play in solving the problems I care about, and whether they even should.

Learn/Unlearn by Kate Styer

[entrepreneurdesigners]

The successful project is one which the world gets to see, the designer keeps iterating on and remains a constructive work in progress for as long as the idea keeps getting better.

Lessons on ‘First Created’ for Kickstarter by Kinza Kasher

[entrepreneurdesigners]

That is the most powerful thing about sharing the unfinished, about being open and raw with the world, is that others can recognize themselves in you.

Breaking the Golden Record by Rachel Balma

[entrepreneurdesigners]

When you send something good to the world, it will come back in the most lovely form of surprise. So be kind to others and always choose to pay it forward.

I got kickstarted and here’s what I learned by Angie Ngoc Tran

[entrepreneurdesigners]

Ask for feedback, but most importantly know when [it] is time to use the feedback and when [it] is time to trash it.

This is just the beginning… by Paula Daneze

[entrepreneurdesigners]

I will post my design work regularly on social media…Also, I need to invest time and energy to accumulate my community slowly.

What I learn from my Kickstarter project by Xiaoxi Yuan

[entrepreneurdesigners]

In fact, the process of finding the correlation and realizing the original cause is the process of healing themselves. Once they realized the reason, they can let go their pain somehow.

Reflection on my Kickstarter project by Yumeng Ji

[entrepreneurdesigners]

This was a wild rollercoaster of anxiety throughout the entire process, but very rewarding and taught me lots about how to make noise about our passions and drive an idea into the world.

What I Learned from Kickstarter by Mia Darling

[entrepreneurdesigners]

Am I just complaining about the current education system, or public shaming a culture or country? The 'problems' I’m trying to uncover is not something Chinese feel comfortable with knowing.

Update 1: Shutter - A New Beginning · Shutter, Part 1: Ten conversations on Chinese Art Education by Ke Hu

[entrepreneurdesigners]

I learned that you have to be very scrappy and relentless in your outreach, almost to the point of annoyance which I am sure was the case for some of the people I continuously sent reminders to.

Lessons Learned from My 1st Kickstarter by Addi Hou

[entrepreneurdesigners]

$1,000 Projects from the 2018 Entrepreneurial Design Class

Hello Entrepreneurial Design Tumblr Followers!

We’ve taken a bit of a hiatus from blogging this year (here’s the syllabus), but we’re posting when it counts.  

We’re in the final hours of the students’ campaigns and there are some lovely projects, which we encourage you to check out and back and share if you are so inclined. You hold the key to making a grad student happy today:

temporary tattoos based on traditional Chinese culture

a participatory art project about childhood verbal abuse

an art/therapy/feast day for people with tinnitus

a collection of conversations about art education reform in China

a nudibranch photobook

a popup art gallery for homeless artists

a workshop for designers getting into AR/VR

a collection of stories by people who love their libraries

a postcard campaign highlighting small campaigns of social change in Brazil

a documentary about high school volunteers in Vietnam

a publication showcasing contemporary Peruvian art

a collaborative magnetic calendaring system for parents and kids

an art empowerment kit for kids experiencing bullying

a guided journaling club

an animated story about restorative justice

Each project is clearly tied to a community of relevance for the student, and if you click through and read the projects and watch the videos, you’ll see that there is a tremendous amount of heart carried through in the work.

For background, here’s how some of the students arrived at their respective projects — this will also give you a glimpse into some of our teaching changes:

The designer will see you now. by Rachel Balma

Egos and Answers by Kate Styer

Making a community offering and what I learned from it by Jason Branch

An Anonymous Letter by Yumeng Ji

Traditional culture view of mine by Xiaoxi Yuan

Things I learnt from my first offering to a community by Abhinav Sircar

What I have learned from designing a community offering by Angie Ngoc Tran

Lessons Learned From Creating My First Community Offering by Margarita Yong

What I learned from the Brazilian Community living in the U.S. by Paula Daneze

Kickstarter Explosions by Mia Darling

How might we support those who support loved ones dealing with alcoholism? by Andrea Kang

Lessons Learned From My Initial Offering by Addi Hou

This year, we actually scrapped everything and redesigned the course from scratch. We’re looking forward to writing up the process, the lessons learned, and frameworks and principles we’ve developed, but in the meantime, all I’ll say is that it feels like the course has grown up, and we’re excited to share the results with you all.