american-pandora - Tumblr blog

[american-pandora]

Son of The Clan Supreme Chapters Masterpost

disclaimer: this post will be edited to reflect the current standing of the story. please be aware that there is also a ‘Reblogged’ Masterpost that is not edited.

story summary

Ayla has left after being cursed to death once more- this time, by Broud. Forced to leave her son behind, Durc must battle for standing in a Clan where tradition and conformity is everything. Named for the figure in a fable, Durc has to decide what he wants in his story- will he stay with Broud’s Clan, forever looked down upon by the leader, or will he take inspiration from his name and become his own legend?

Part I: Aftershocks

Chapter 1: Changes

published July 4, 2019

In the face of catastrophe, Brun’s Clan must move forward. Except they’re not Brun’s Clan anymore, they’re Broud’s. Faced with the daunting prospect of untested leadership, the Clan scrambles to pull themselves together after upheaval.

Chapter 2: Advice, Allies & Introspection

published July 11, 2019

Goov, Brun and Zoug talk about recent events; Goov makes a discovery with terrifying implications. Meanwhile, Vorn struggles to find his footing amidst all this change.

Chapter 3: the bones of Ursus

published July 18, 2019

Goov brings his need of an acolyte to Broud. In the meanwhile, Ursus intervenes.

[american-pandora]

Chapter 4: Tradition

published August 1, 2019

Borg asks a favor of Goov; meanwhile, Goov and Broud make an announcement to the Clan

Son of The Clan Reblogged Chapters Masterpost

disclaimer: this post has been reblogged to reflect the current standing of Son of The Clan. chapters have likely been added.

story summary

Ayla has left after being cursed to death once more- this time, by Broud. Forced to leave her son behind, Durc must battle for standing in a Clan where tradition and conformity is everything. Named for the figure in a fable, Durc has to decide what he wants in his story- will he stay with Broud’s Clan, forever looked down upon by the leader, or will he take inspiration from his name and become his own legend?

Part I: Aftershocks

Chapter 1: Changes

published July 4, 2019

In the face of catastrophe, Brun’s Clan must move forward. Except they’re not Brun’s Clan anymore, they’re Broud’s. Faced with the daunting prospect of untested leadership, the Clan scrambles to pull themselves together after upheaval.

Chapter 2: Advice, Allies & Introspection

published July 11, 2019

Goov, Brun and Zoug talk about recent events; Goov makes a discovery with terrifying implications. Meanwhile, Vorn struggles to find his footing amidst all this change.

[american-pandora]

Okay guys! Chapter 4 of my WIP Son of The Clan is up! I’m late updating, but work has been crazy, and my best friend is getting married and WHY ARE WEDDINGS SO COMPLICATED?!?! Anyway, here’s Chapter 4!

Chapter 4: Tradition

Previous Chapter

[american-pandora]

understanding terms used in Son of The Clan

the Clan = Brun/Broud’s clan, the group of characters we are all familiar with

The Clan = all of the Clan peoples, including other caves

The Mog-ur = Creb specially

Mog-ur (capital M) = used as a sort of honorific. When capitalized, it is being used specifically as a title

mog-ur (lowercase m) = refers to the position when lowercased. It is never directed at a specific person, but more as a broader concept

the Cave (capital C) = the specific cave that is home to the Clan

cave (lowercase c) = any cave

[american-pandora]

Chapter 3 of my WIP Son of The Clan is up! I’ve actually uploaded consistently for like three weeks now, I’m kind of proud of myself!

If you’re interested in becoming a beta reader, please slide in to my DMs either here or on AO3!

Let me know what you think!l

Chapter 3: the bones of Ursus

Previous Chapter

[american-pandora]

Chapter 3: the bones of Ursus

published July 18, 2019

Goov brings his need of an acolyte to Broud. In the meanwhile, Ursus intervenes.

Son of The Clan Reblogged Chapters Masterpost

disclaimer: this post has been reblogged to reflect the current standing of Son of The Clan. chapters have likely been added.

story summary

Ayla has left after being cursed to death once more- this time, by Broud. Forced to leave her son behind, Durc must battle for standing in a Clan where tradition and conformity is everything. Named for the figure in a fable, Durc has to decide what he wants in his story- will he stay with Broud’s Clan, forever looked down upon by the leader, or will he take inspiration from his name and become his own legend?

Part I: Aftershocks

Chapter 1: Changes

published July 4, 2019

In the face of catastrophe, Brun’s Clan must move forward. Except they’re not Brun’s Clan anymore, they’re Broud’s. Faced with the daunting prospect of untested leadership, the Clan scrambles to pull themselves together after upheaval.

Chapter 2: Advice, Allies & Introspection

published July 11, 2019

Goov, Brun and Zoug talk about recent events; Goov makes a discovery with terrifying implications. Meanwhile, Vorn struggles to find his footing amidst all this change.

[american-pandora]

Chapter 4: Tradition

published August 1, 2019

Borg asks a favor of Goov; meanwhile, Goov and Broud make an announcement to the Clan

Son of The Clan Supreme Chapters Masterpost

disclaimer: this post will be edited to reflect the current standing of the story. please be aware that there is also a ‘Reblogged’ Masterpost that is not edited.

story summary

Ayla has left after being cursed to death once more- this time, by Broud. Forced to leave her son behind, Durc must battle for standing in a Clan where tradition and conformity is everything. Named for the figure in a fable, Durc has to decide what he wants in his story- will he stay with Broud’s Clan, forever looked down upon by the leader, or will he take inspiration from his name and become his own legend?

Part I: Aftershocks

Chapter 1: Changes

published July 4, 2019

In the face of catastrophe, Brun’s Clan must move forward. Except they’re not Brun’s Clan anymore, they’re Broud’s. Faced with the daunting prospect of untested leadership, the Clan scrambles to pull themselves together after upheaval.

Chapter 2: Advice, Allies & Introspection

published July 11, 2019

Goov, Brun and Zoug talk about recent events; Goov makes a discovery with terrifying implications. Meanwhile, Vorn struggles to find his footing amidst all this change.

Chapter 3: the bones of Ursus

published July 18, 2019

Goov brings his need of an acolyte to Broud. In the meanwhile, Ursus intervenes.

[american-pandora]

Chapter 2 of my Clan of the Cave Bear WIP Son of The Clan is now up! Let me know what you think, y’all! I’ve also started tracking the tag #apsotc

Chapter 2: Advice, Allies & Introspection

Previous Chapter

[american-pandora]

Son of The Clan Reblogged Chapters Masterpost

disclaimer: this post has been reblogged to reflect the current standing of Son of The Clan. chapters have likely been added.

story summary

Ayla has left after being cursed to death once more- this time, by Broud. Forced to leave her son behind, Durc must battle for standing in a Clan where tradition and conformity is everything. Named for the figure in a fable, Durc has to decide what he wants in his story- will he stay with Broud’s Clan, forever looked down upon by the leader, or will he take inspiration from his name and become his own legend?

Part I: Aftershocks

Chapter 1: Changes

published July 4, 2019

In the face of catastrophe, Brun’s Clan must move forward. Except they’re not Brun’s Clan anymore, they’re Broud’s. Faced with the daunting prospect of untested leadership, the Clan scrambles to pull themselves together after upheaval.

Chapter 2: Advice, Allies & Introspection

published July 11, 2019

Goov, Brun and Zoug talk about recent events; Goov makes a discovery with terrifying implications. Meanwhile, Vorn struggles to find his footing amidst all this change.

[american-pandora]

Son of The Clan Supreme Chapters Masterpost

disclaimer: this post will be edited to reflect the current standing of the story. please be aware that there is also a ‘Reblogged’ Masterpost that is not edited.

story summary

Ayla has left after being cursed to death once more- this time, by Broud. Forced to leave her son behind, Durc must battle for standing in a Clan where tradition and conformity is everything. Named for the figure in a fable, Durc has to decide what he wants in his story- will he stay with Broud’s Clan, forever looked down upon by the leader, or will he take inspiration from his name and become his own legend?

Part I: Aftershocks

Chapter 1: Changes

published July 4, 2019

In the face of catastrophe, Brun’s Clan must move forward. Except they’re not Brun’s Clan anymore, they’re Broud’s. Faced with the daunting prospect of untested leadership, the Clan scrambles to pull themselves together after upheaval.

Chapter 2: Advice, Allies & Introspection

published July 11, 2019

Goov, Brun and Zoug talk about recent events; Goov makes a discovery with terrifying implications. Meanwhile, Vorn struggles to find his footing amidst all this change.

Chapter 3: the bones of Ursus

published July 18, 2019

Goov brings his need of an acolyte to Broud. In the meanwhile, Ursus intervenes.

[american-pandora]

ALSO I am highkey looking for beta readers

Alright everyone- Chapter 1 of my WIP Son of The Clan is up! It tells the story of Durc after Ayla leaves. Please read it and let me know what you think! Summary below:

Ayla has left after being cursed to death once more- this time, by Broud. Forced to leave her son behind, Durc must battle for standing in a Clan where tradition and conformity is everything. Named for the figure in a fable, Durc has to decide what he wants in his story- will he stay with Broud’s Clan, forever looked down upon by the leader, or will he take inspiration from his name and become his own legend?

[american-pandora]

Alright everyone- Chapter 1 of my WIP Son of The Clan is up! It tells the story of Durc after Ayla leaves. Please read it and let me know what you think! Summary below:

Ayla has left after being cursed to death once more- this time, by Broud. Forced to leave her son behind, Durc must battle for standing in a Clan where tradition and conformity is everything. Named for the figure in a fable, Durc has to decide what he wants in his story- will he stay with Broud’s Clan, forever looked down upon by the leader, or will he take inspiration from his name and become his own legend?

[american-pandora]

[american-pandora]

other writers: plan out their stories, have their characters figured out and know how they’re going to grow. write every day, keep hydrated.

me, a goblin: jump in headfirst with only a vague plan and a feeling. who are these characters?????? fuck if i know, we find out as we go! plot what plot? i’m just as surprised at this development as you are. writes only on full moons. only ingests caffeine. 

[american-pandora]

Sorry for bothering you, I just wanted to ask if you've seen that post about the 'original version of Persephone's kidnapping' myth going around, where she doesn't actually get kidnapped but just sort of... wanders into the underworld? Is that even a little accurate as far as you know or another made-up tumblr retelling?

It’s a load of WANK

I have actually added this to the original post, but obviously there are about 780 versions of that post floating around at this point and nearly all of them are like ‘omg i’m so glad that this 100% unverified post about persephone proves that everyone has been wrong about the myth for the past hundreds of years… thank god for no sources

But anyway, here are my thoughts on the matter. It would probably help to have the original post open at the same time, as this response does make some close references to it: 

A disclaimer, first of all: any post that says THIS IS THE ORIGINAL MYTH is going to be wank, because we don’t know what the original myth was - we only have the first written sources, but without a time machine there’s just no way of finding out how the myth developed in an oral tradition. So already, we can debunk about 80% of that post. Groovy.

The first source we have for Persephone being carried away is in Hesiod’s Theogony, written in the 8th or 7th century BC. We also have the Homeric Hymn to Demeter, written in the 7th or 6th century BC, which is explicitly about her being taken away by Hades.

Hesiod is one of the oldest Greek sources that we have, roughly contemporaneous with Homer. We don’t have any earlier sources than this which say ‘hey, Persephone went to Hades because she thought it would be cool’. A lot of people have theorised that this could have been an original, or at least an earlier tradition, but it’s about 60% wishful thinking, 20% misinterpreting evidence (i.e. assuming that Persephone and Demeter used to be aspects of a great mother goddess, which they weren’t) and about 20% conjecture based on actual rational thought (i.e. the fact that the oldest written source we have is about an abduction doesn’t mean that it is the original source; there could be older non-extant written sources or just oral tales which pre-dated writing). It’s not fact.

It’s true that Homer himself never explicitly says that Persephone was abducted - he just describes her as Hades’ wife - but he also doesn’t say that she wasn’t abducted; it could well be that the myth of her abduction was so well known that he had no need to recount it.

It is true that Persephone’s name was Kore, which means ‘maiden’; however, this could be an epithet because she was unmarried. It’s also theorised that it was a euphemism of sorts for when people didn’t want to name Persephone outright; again, this is a theory. Lots of gods had epithets - basically cooler names which underlined some of their core attributes, e.g. Apollo = Loxias, which highlights Apollo’s powers of prophecy. Unlike the post claims, the name ‘Persephone’ does not definitively mean death / destroyer; the etymology is unknown. The ‘death / destroyer’ theory is just one of many, and others are based around ideas of harvest and grain.

The reason Zeus got involved wasn’t just because he was tasked with sorting out justice - it was because he had told Hades ‘hey, you want a wife? Cool! Abduct my daughter, Persephone. Her mum totally won’t mind,’ and then when Persephone’s mother did mind, Zeus was like ‘I fucked up real bad, I should sort this shit out.’ In Ancient Greece, women didn’t have to consent in the same way as we do now. Abduction marriages were actually illegal (or at least very very naughty) but the bride’s consent basically took the form of her father saying ‘you’ll marry this dude, right? Yeah, cool. She’ll marry you, dude.’ Here, Zeus gives Persephone’s consent to Hades by telling Hades that he can marry her - this is why technically she wasn’t exactly abducted, because the necessary consent - her father’s - was given. HOWEVER, let’s not get into Greek law here. She was abducted by our standards.

It is also true that Persephone became a very feared goddess and basically had a great time in the Underworld. She wasn’t exactly more terrible than Hades, though; there are certain myths (e.g. Sisyphus and Orpheus) where she’s the one who says ‘Hades, babe, shall we give this guy a chance to make his way out of the Underworld alive?’ HOWEVER, she did usually do this with the implementation of specific terms, meaning that she had a level of control in proceedings which a lot of other wife goddesses didn’t have over their respective spouses’ spheres. Most mythological canons also give her and Hades a very healthy and monogamous relationship (with the exception of Orphism, which is a bit more iffy on that front) so, disregarding the abduction part of her myth, their marriage was really relatively healthy, even by modern standards. Also, Persephone did not ‘lay the smack down on sinners’, as quoted in the original post - the whole idea of sinners is basically a Christian concept. The Underworld was not Hell. It wasn’t a place for bad people. It was just where the dead went. Tartarus was the place where the really bad guys went to be tortured and shit, and is more indicative of Christian notions of Hell. People weren’t punished in the Underworld. They just went there.

I love the idea of Persephone as a consenting wife of Hades. I am a fan of modern reinterpretations in which she chooses to eat the pomegranate seeds willingly, or where she falls in love with Hades and goes to the Underworld of her own accord. However, these are modern interpretations, based on modern gender politics and ideas of reclamation and representation. I will forever fight for people’s right to reinterpret myths however they like, but this whole idea of the ‘original myth’ of Persephone being devoid of any misogynistic undertones really needs to die. 

I think it also speaks to a worrying argument that in order to empower Persephone, some people need to remove her trauma. Why can’t Persephone be a terrible dread queen of the Underworld and a survivor? Why should her experiences need to be erased in order to make her into a strong woman? If you ask me, she’s already stronger than Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson. I don’t think that the modern need to reframe Persephone as architect of her own descent into the Underworld is necessarily as progressive as others think it is. I think it sends the message that a strong woman always has agency, and I actually think that a better message to send would be that it’s totally possible to lose your agency and still retain your strength, because you define yourself through your own actions, not what is done to you.

tl;dr any post that makes a broad sweeping claim like ‘hey this greek myth was originally like this and u r all wrong’ without any sources is what my tutor would call ‘specious’ and what I call ‘bollocks’.