#while it's definitely a significant tonal shift I don't think it's entirely negative
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
One criticism I saw about Dragon Age Veilguard was that everything in the game was kind of sanitized compared to past titles, making for overall weaker and less impactful writing.
And I would agree that Veilguard feels more "family friendly", which comes with both pros and cons. There's definitely a thoughtful critique to be made.
But the specific example used in this post was the Lords of Fortune and how they have scholarly experts examine their acquisitions to avoid stealing objects of significance from other cultures. And how this effort to avoid being problematic makes the entire faction seem more shallowly presented.
I think that ignores the fact that the Lords of Faction is led by Isabela. Isabela, who in Dragon Age 2 stole the Tomb of Koslun not really realizing what its value was to the Qunari people. Her ignorance directly led to so much conflict and literally hundreds of deaths in Kirkwall. It makes perfect character and narrative sense for her to have learned from the experience and to take pains not to repeat that kind of mistake in the future.
Isabela was always the kind of person who wants to make money with a minimum of effort and have fun. But even in her more selfish days, she never wanted to hurt vulnerable people to do it. I think her relationships with Hawke and Merrill helped her grow into a more thoughtful person, and the way she runs the Lords of Fortune is a reflection of that. It actually makes perfect sense.
#Dragon Age#DA Veilguard#DA Veilguard spoilers#there are so many critiques of this game that are upset that it isn't as miserable and and dark and grim as past titles#while it's definitely a significant tonal shift I don't think it's entirely negative#focusing on the extremes of things like fantasy racism doesn't always make a title more mature and thoughtful#sometimes it's actually less mature in the sense that it presents these behaviors as cartoonishly evil#when in reality oppression and discrimination are often far more banal#I do think it went too far in the other direction#but that doesn't mean the past titles got the balance right either
115 notes
·
View notes