#this is also why Strong Female Character type fantasy books are a plague on society if they're not aware of the tropes
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
infinitelystrangemachinex · 2 months ago
Text
if a writer insists that the best written female characters in existence are stoic and for all intents and purposes could be replaced by a male doppelganger without changing anything material about the story, ie """androgynous""" roles that just so happen to be played by a girl/woman, then that writer will face the same criticisms over and over forever that they only know how to write at most 2 women, and will ultimately never be someone who can write a variety of characters from a place of originality or honesty
and any reader who insists the same will forever feel threatened or disgusted by any characters who don't fit or don't reassure their expectations of gender-essentialism
#ISMtext#i have once again been subjected to Literary Analysis#by my brother and stepfather lol#no matter how much I love them sometimes I feel like characters like Daenerys and Arya are plagues on society#and by society I mean literary analysis but really just the reading world in general#and as much as I love Alien the same goes triple for Ripley#like there's no way Dany or Arya could ever be replaced by men and have the same story but there are fans who THINK so#partly because of Game of Thrones but mostly because even in ASOIAF they display traditionally male traits in fantasy and that's on purpose#if they were the only female characters in the story then that reinforces the argument that the best female characters#are female characters who play the role that men have always played in stories#meaning: men are the default and any role counter to that is either a side character or a villain or a prize/object#ASOIAF has more female characters and more roles for them than you can shake a stick at#but there are Certain Fans (men AND women) who love Dany and Arya for example and then hate or ignore every other woman in the books#it is the perfect litmus test in my opinion lol#this is also why Strong Female Character type fantasy books are a plague on society if they're not aware of the tropes#and tbh most fantasy books are not aware of the tropes. the Deep Tropes if you will#going back to movies if you can't even sit through either Little Women or Mad Max Fury Road without getting uncomfortable#then that says everything about you
5 notes · View notes