#the implication of the “it's mean to be against the gods in front of orym” take is that their feelings should not be shared at all!
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
ultimately the thing about the, "how dare the rest of Bells Hells debate whether to save the gods or not when Orym's family was killed by the people trying to kill the gods" take is that a personal tragedy is not a determinative argument, especially wrt an issue this fundamentally world-altering. its completely understandable that Orym finds the deaths of Will and Derrig inextricable from this topic. what's being demanded of him emotionally is enormous. but nothing about being in opposition to the gods requires that someone take the actions Ludinus and the Ruby Vanguard have taken, and they are far from the sole representatives of this ideology. and Will and Derrig's actual feelings regarding the gods had very little to do with their deaths.
(and, really: if the deaths of Orym's family makes questioning the gods' place unconscionable, than what does Aeor make of supporting them?)
beyond that: the discomfort of a single individual does not disallow a topic from discussion. it's an indication to tread lightly, with care and patience for that individual. but it is not grounds to consider a conversation as vast and complex as this one decided. especially given that Orym is far from the only member of the Hells who has intense emotions and traumas tied up in this; Orym's feelings should not take precedent over, for example, the negative experiences Ashton and Laudna have had with gods and their followers.
but also, like, even if you truly believe that anyone being ambivalent or antagonistic towards the gods in this situation is self-centered and wrong, unconditional support is simply not where the Hells are at. and if they don't talk about it now, they're gonna have to talk about it later, when they're being asked to put their hand on the scale and there's mere moments left to act.
#critical role#cr3#posting this now so i don't rewrite it entirely again hey#bells hells#crposting#anyways this talking point has been rearing its ugly head again. died down for a while there#and after watching ashton and laudna's completely understandable and highly emotional reasons for distrusting the gods#get diminished and invalidated and turned into their own fault at the same time as people were. dare i say. coddling Orym. well#(ultimately i think this is as much about how insistent a lot of fans are that unconditional support of the gods is the Only Good Take)#(as it is any particular bias towards Orym. although I think Orym's normativity is absolutely germane with that perspective)#(there's probably some dead body calculus you could do to justify Aeor and condemn the attack on Zephrah. if you wanted to miss the point)#conversely this is not saying ashton and laudna's feelings on the topic should take precedence over oryms.#the implication of the “it's mean to be against the gods in front of orym” take is that their feelings should not be shared at all!#or else they're being bad friends to him. hope this helps
55 notes
·
View notes