#the closest it's come is TMATL (jane is actually...kind of...passive aggressive towards mary?
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Note
☕️ do YOU have any about the tudors, showtime?
Unpopular opinions?
I think the common one is that JS was really rewritten between S2 and S3 to the point where she's basically a different character (although...I don't think that theory floating around that they wanted viewers to separate Jane wrt the Boleyn downfall and Jane as Queen is true, lol, it does really seem like it was just a casting availability issue and unfortunately it did have that effect, doubtful they had that intention, though); but I actually find the writing of Princess Mary to have been fairly inconsistent as well. I do understand why this is glossed over, before BE arrived it's arguably the best portrayal of Mary I we've ever had, and Bolger killed, but if you look at the actual text and subtext of the show the writing for her character was glaringly inconsistent (particularly between S3 and S4), almost to the point where, like Jane, it's like she's either a completely different character or somewhere in the space of time between events, developed amnesia.
#it's interesting that novels do this too. i mean. i overall liked adrienne dillard's keeper of the queen's jewels . but#i did hmmmm that it began may 20 and not before#anon#maybe i'll show the specific gap i'm talking about later#i'm mentioning jane bcus it is actually in relation to jane that i noticed this inconsistency wrt to mary#how she allows chapuys to speak about her would suggest that the show had a cynical approach to their relationship#but they didn't; they had a sentimental one#that would be compelling but tudor productions are never brave enough (the cynical approach i mean)#the closest it's come is TMATL (jane is actually...kind of...passive aggressive towards mary?#like it gives stereotypical AB as stepmother vibes . petty is maybe a better word)#i won't be watching the series in full but maybe if that scene floats on YT i'll watch#bcus i am curious if they'll keep that and sort of hope they don't bcus i found the way mantel wrote about mary kind of. hm. gross?
7 notes
·
View notes