#side note: I kinda wish Nanako's valentine scene wasn't a “the girls suck at cooking” joke- but I liked the first part.

[taldigi]

You have any feelings on the p4 valentines? Either the valentines dates themselves or the rejection scenes

Not particularly, nah. I'm not a huge fan of the available romances. I know the protags are supposed to be heartbreakers to an extent, but almost none of the girls feel truly close enough to them to really make me interested in a romance between them and their protag. (Aigis, mmmaybe Yukari, and... Yoshizawa are the only characters I feel had particularly appealing chemistry.) (which is double odd because almost all of femc's romance options are really nice? I digress, back to p4-)

I guess it's interesting to hear a bit about how the some of girls envision themselves in the future (with Yu)(rise's is interesting because she talks about wanting to go to college and get married on an island one day and thats cool of her) and if you held me at gunpoint I'd say Yukiko's is overall charming with the big box and the "welcome" banter. the idea of "Yu Amagi" seems fitting tbh (the way things work with ryokan families is very interesting!) even if it's not my ship of choice (for her or yu)

On the other end, Naoto's romance overall feels weird and not great to me. mondo bad vibes. I dont like a lot of the choices made for their route and the valentine scenes even moreso.

as for the rejection scenes? They're not bad on a writing scale, but I reeeeallllyyy dont like Asshole Yu simulator. It feels awful- and I only watched the video! LMAO!