#my relationship with antipsych also has a family resemblance (hehe) to both of these
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
I know i've expressed this before but "family abolition" as a concept vexes me because I don't know how exactly I'm supposed to relate to it. there is clearly something that both I and self-proclaimed family abolitionists both want to abolish and we at least partly agree wrt many specific approaches to this but I don't recognize and in fact reject their identification of this thing-in-need-of-abolition with anything called "The Family". and then sometimes they will haul off and say shit that I'm actually strongly against on principle and claim it as core to "family abolition". there seems to be some private concept of family as distinct from kinship itself that doesn't really feel useful or even available to me; it just gets no traction in my brain. so it really feels like they're just saying "abolish [kinship systems I don't like] now!" which is fair, but like.
#pol.txt#txt#my problem with prison abolition is similar on the surface but actually completely different. i KNOW how i relate to prison abolition#in that i think its really always either prison reform or state abolition in disguise depending on how they understand the word prison#and i ofc have separate positions on each of those different things#my relationship with antipsych also has a family resemblance (hehe) to both of these#in that i actually kind of am antipsych in that i both despise psychiatry as an invasive pernicious and illegitimate state-within-a-state#(and therefore also hate the associated ideology and their cowboy prisons called psych wards)#and think we need to find and build radical alternatives for a system of mental and spiritual care#but I also feel awkward calling myself antipsych because I'm fully aware that if i had state power#the 'prisons' i would build would way more resemble inpatient than the slavery and torture system we have now#just obvs hopefully more humane/less abusive and with a different polemic informing what does and does not constitute a mental disorder#even though in practice i may as well be one it feels weird to id as antipsych and then believe that#sometimes society really should have a right to say e.g. I diagnose you with Delusional Racist Bitch Disorder I sentence you to treatment#provided due process of law ofc. which psych as such is incapable of providing because only The State can truly attempt to do that
1 note
·
View note