#missing my fav polycule this fine evening……

[coff-in]

AAAAHHHH I'm the devious baby sis requester and coff-in you make my heart flutter :))) Your thoughts on Decay route fed my thoughts oh my god you genIUS 1. All I can think of is baby sis reader finding her siblings dead (or at least close to dying) in the murder-suicide route and being like "D: Why didn't you take me with you????" Which kind of brings me to an interesting question, do you think either sibling would ever be compelled to kill her? Like for example Andrew clearly meant to go meet Ashley in the afterlife, does he ever have "ah hell just bring the whole family" thoughts and goes to find baby sis reader? I just think of him gently comforting her, talking her down with a knife to her throat because it's for their own good, he promises. 2. Alternatively, baby sis reader *pretending* to lose it when she loses her -not- favorite sibling because, yk, that's what normal people do when the lose their siblings. It's still a plan though because if she freaks out about it, whatever sibling left will freak out that this will cause reader to leave > they become even more possessive > yeah that's exactly what reader wants. In the case of Ashley, reader's crying over Andrew while Ashley is half-insane herself and frantically telling her that "I'm good enough for you, right? You don't need him, WE don't need him (coping very hard right now)! You have me, you have me!" and she completely misses the look on reader's face when she finally gives into Ashley's embrace. If it's Andrew, reader backs away from his knife and bumps into Ashley's body and screams, trying to run, but he catches her (as always) and tells her that "I'll take such good care of you, it'll be like she was never there. Isn't that fine? I've always been your favorite older sibling...and now you can have all my attention. It'll be better with just the two of us... (he is also coping very hard right now)" and reader "reluctantly" gives into him because of the knife, but she's secretly delighted. She hopes he doesn't put a hand over her heart, because it's fluttering. Sorry I feel like I just word vomited all over the place, I just wanted you to know that your thoughts are so DELICIOUS mwah I love you too :DDD

notes from coff-in: I JUST SAW THIS!!! i'm at work rn but i can't wait, i'm just too impulsive. and omg "devious baby sis" that's so good! we should actually kiss each other /j

[fem] reader-insert, follow up to "younger sister [reader] who just as bad as the graves", talks/mentions of incest, murder and suicide

i would think that andrew would most likely kill baby sis [reader] in the decay route. he killed ashley out of his resentment for her (but he joins her later because he still loves her you know?) but he also loves [reader] too, so he'd kill her too so they're all together forever. in an afterlife where there are no consequences their actions! there's also the possibility that he doesn't kill her and GRRR THAT'D BE SO ANGSTY!!! [reader] coming across their dead bodies and trying to cope with the fact that her siblings ("soulmates" because we're delulu) are dead and they didn't invite her to go with them. she'd have a full mental breakdown before killing herself.

(this is completely unnecessary but i see devious baby sis [reader]'s weapon being a pair of scissors, the blades are supposed to be symbolic of her siblings. every precise cut and stab is made with her love for them ♡)

oh oh oh!! her getting to live with her favorite sibling would be fucking hectic. i definitely see the siblings loving each other like a cute little incestuous polycule but having [reader] live with her fav sibling would be sorta chaotic. ashley would maybe use [reader], not as a replacement for andrew, but maybe some sort of stand in? [reader] for the most part does everything ashley wants her to do and only really choosing to step in and veto ashley's feelings when they (or ashley specifically) are in danger. there's also hella toxic yuri incest, you gotta trust me on this

"i'll take such good care of you" GOD I WANT ANDREW!!! I WANT ANDREW TO BE REAL!!! THE DEVIOUS ONE HERE IS YOU NONNIE FOR WRITING THAT LINE 🔥 ✍️ i think andrew would try to put all that happened in the past but he's coping and [reader] can see that. they'll leave ashley's body buried somewhere and ditch town and try to live a normal life... as boyfriend and girlfriend :3 but sometimes andrew slips up, you know? maybe he almost calls [reader] ashley or maybe he's brushing her hair one night and puts it up in a ponytail like ashley did. but [reader] doesn't mind, of course, but she has andrew with her :)

or maybe andrew and [reader] continue going about their murder and cannibalism after ashley dies when they steal her dream talisman, who knows, who knows.

i'm curious about what would happen if her favorite sibling died but she couldn't kill the survivor. would she leave? would the living sibling be mad at her? i'm like growling and barking in excitement in my mind I LOVE THIS!!!

you and your wonderfully devious brain, 'nonnie, thank you!!! ur like a head chef in the kitchen, just know that i'll always eat your cooking ♡

----

coff-in

[clintbeifong]

hi Rachel!! it’s your sanctuary holiday exchange partner!!! as I start to piece together an outline for your gift, I have a few more specific questions about your preferences…

- are there any OTPs or NOTPs you’d particularly like to see? (thoughts on John/James/Helen? or any combination thereof?)

- thinking about different historical periods I could play with, any events/decades you’d like or prefer to avoid?

- what is your fav dynamic between any of The Five?

- especially thinking about a fic set in the past, would you be okay with canon divergence or would you rather just missing scene type fic that could fit in canon?

- what is your favorite historical flashback plot in the show?

appreciate you letting me badger you with questions! I’m hoping to use this exchange to flesh out one of my many plot bunnies - but only if it fits your desires of course 💗

Happy Holidays!

~ 🎁📝

Hi exchange buddy!

Thank you for the questions! I know my request was pretty vague. The short answer is I write a lot more than I read so I'm not sure exactly what my preferences are? Largely anything goes. I'm as interested in what you, random internet stranger, see in the show as anything else.

And you have a plot bunny already cooking that more or less aligns here go for it!

That said, I'll do my best to answer your questions:

No NOTPs other than Will/Helen I guess? Is that a thing? It must be. Not in my house lol

Very fond of any pairing or combo among the Five. My personal headcanon/interpretation is that they were all in a polycule at Oxford (except for Watson, who is the Lone Straight Man and literally just came for the science) and that's why they all treat each other like bickering exes. But I'd be happy to see any combination thereof.

Fav Five dynamic is therefore bickering exes/4 way divorce but nobody's over it

No strong preferences on time period--which is wildly unhelpful! So either something that piques your interest, or, if you're looking for a prompt I'll throw out "Great Boston Molasses Flood of 1919."

Have at it with canon divergence if that's your bag

Again, I think it's really cool that this exchange even exists so don't sweat it too much please!

But I know too much "oh anything's fine with me" is also hard to work with (Just pick a restaurant! At least a cuisine! I'm begging you!)

I hope this was slightly helpful! Looking forward to it, and let me know if you have any more questions!

Happy holidays!

[maxmayfieldirl]

I posted 5,102 times in 2022

That's 5,102 more posts than 2021!

607 posts created (12%)

4,495 posts reblogged (88%)

Blogs I reblogged the most:

@blueeandyellowmakesgreen

@wibble-wobbegong

@paladin-n-cleric

@japplejottomjeans

I tagged 2,238 of my posts in 2022

#st4 spoilers - 416 posts

#stranger things - 405 posts

#mike wheeler - 177 posts

#stranger things 4 - 172 posts

#byler - 144 posts

#robin's chatter - 116 posts

#will byers - 113 posts

#st4 - 90 posts

#nancy wheeler - 57 posts

#robin's favs - 51 posts

Longest Tag: 140 characters

#in 2019 my mom wouldn't let me stay up long enough to watch it as soon as it came out so i set an alarm for 6am and it pissed her off sm lol

My Top Posts in 2022:

#5

Nancy Wheeler has two hands, Jonathan and Steve just share one and Robin gets the other one to herself

646 notes - Posted May 10, 2022

#4

I think it's so sad how Mike would try to be himself around El and it would get shut down. And the one time he tried to be vulnerable for once, talk about something that he doesn't talk about because it hurts he's told "you don't understand". And how he gets invalidated by everyone. And how his older sister is more of an older sister to literally everybody else.

It feels like he's expected to fit how everyone wants him to be and when he doesn't he's an asshole. And not just by the fandom because I kinda get that vibe in show too, especially from El and his family.

677 notes - Posted October 1, 2022

#3

The stranger teens polycule

778 notes - Posted May 30, 2022

#2

Giggling and kicking my feet thinking about Hopper's reaction to his son dating the very kid he tried to get rid of aka his daughter's ex boyfriend Mike Wheeler

947 notes - Posted June 2, 2022

My #1 post of 2022

"Mike isn't in love with Will!"

You mean the Mike who disobeyed the chief of police's orders to not look for his missing friend, who he's totally not in love with?

You mean the Mike who told his friend, who he's not in love with, that meeting him was the best thing he's ever done?

Maybe you mean the Mike who chased his friend, who he's not in love with, in the pouring rain just to apologize and treating that far more seriously than when he was broken up with the day prior?

Perhaps you meant the Mike who couldn't hug his friend, who he's not in love with, because his girlfriend, the girlfriend he can't say "I love you" to, told him he might have a crush even though he was perfectly fine hugging his other friend who does have a girlfriend the day prior?

Yeah you're right, he's totally not in love

1,369 notes - Posted June 1, 2022

Get your Tumblr 2022 Year in Review →