#it makes even less sense if you accept the 'he got with nightcloud to prove loyalty and she got with him for kits' explanation | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

cryptideye · 2 years ago

Text

still baffled at the onestars confession retcon that implied crowfeather knew about three as early as when breezekit was still a baby when jayfeather LITERALLY looks inside of his head to know that he didn't in Sunset 😭

#like??? what was the purpose of that #and yeah I guess it was more implied than outright confirmed but #it makes literally zero sense for him to A. know about the three and B. be sneaking around to see leafpool #while he was actively with nightcloud since he was super pissed at leaf after their breakup AND the fact that #he can't have been with her at the same time and also not know about the three. he would've had to see her pregnant???#him cheating doesn't make ANY sense not because he's particularly virtuous or kind but because of what we KNOW he knew about the three #and how he acts around leafpool. you cannot tell me that crow 'you chose your clan remember' feather would be #sneaking off to go cuddle with leafpool after she broke up with him #it makes even less sense if you accept the 'he got with nightcloud to prove loyalty and she got with him for kits' explanation #(which I do)#because okay he decides to prove his loyalty by rebounding into nightcloud because leafpool said it wasn't gonna work but then he just goes #'lol nevermind'??? it doesn't line up with his future or previous actions at all #also are you really telling me leafpool would agree to meet up with him while he had breezekit in the nursery??? come on lmao #maybe I'm misreading the scene and it wasn't an attempted retcon #but the fact it was compared to onestars 'secrets being kept for the good of everyone thing"#definitely implies to me that they were trying to say he was cheating on nightcloud and aware of the three #and again. this doesn't make any sense at all. already explained why #I can accept he maybe snuck off to like. creepy observe her but since he was being compared to ONE STAR here #the implication was definitely more than that so I'm just like. okay are you retconning him cheating or is this just a weird line #crowfeather sneaking off to check on leafpool bc he's not over it even though he isn't aware of his kits and the relationship is over #especially on her end: believable #crowfeather meeting up with her and being aware of the three: no fucking way.#I'll accept that he was probably internally pining even if he was outwardly aggressive and cold towards her #but I do not accept this idea that he was still openly pursuing her. does not make sense

4 notes · View notes