#if we go with 1 or 3 than the idea of firelizards going back to where they were laid to clutch doesn't make sense
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
kariachi · 2 years ago
Text
You just wanna take McCaffrey and shake her. They’ve got a perfectly viable strategy going on- lay many eggs and leave them to their fate is a wonderful concept for a prey animal specifically, especially since they likely breed year-round on Southern given the climate seems to be very accommodating, like at most I could see firelizards not breeding during hurricane season but otherwise things seem suitable for year-round breeding- but no, no they have to be going with it because they’re the stupidest things to ever grace the planet. Full 50% of firelizards apparently have absolute fluff for brains, amazing the species has survived.
Because somehow it never occurred to Anne that if only 1% of your population is making babies, and you are a wild animal, your species isn’t going to last. But somehow, those firelizards~ Just, every green egg is nonviable or not even worth looking at because it make, greens, and blues, but mostly because they make greens horror of horrors.
The worst part is, the greens’ ‘lay ‘em and leave ‘em’ strategy is extra effective for their species, because we’ve already seen that firelizards can tell when eggs are going to hatch or babies are going to be born and that they flock to join in and help. So it’s low care while they’re egg with all but a guarantee that if they survive to hatch they’ll be immediately made part of one fair or another. They’re a social species for whom leaving their eggs alone doesn’t stop the young from being raised in safety of the fair from hatching! So the best case scenario is that your eggs survive and get taken in by a fair, and the worst case scenario is they get eaten in which case they’re still acting as a distraction from the eggs of the other dams in your fair to whom you’re probably related! Plus, the constant egg loss helps prevent overpopulation! It fucking works!
But no, Anne couldn’t have with that, she had to keep her Super Special critters super special, and just wasn’t capable of doing that without tearing other fuckers down. Which, having read her heroes, I can see how she got into the habit, but still.
Anne McCaffrey's classism and misogyny are almost indescribable. Specifically in regards to green fire lizards. It's like a perfect combination of classism and misogyny and it just becomes so fucking absurd. Like rich people staring in offended horror and clutching their pearls because a poor person has an iphone or something. but more absurd.
#also completely unrelated but i just remembered it#the whole 'they go back to where they were laid to lay their eggs' thing annoys me#for multiple reasons#okay here's the thing for the firelizards to have remembered the eruption at landing we have three options#1) firelizards actively pass down this sort of knowledge (which would be really cool)#2) firelizards have instinctual and ancestral memory (would not be the first time in fiction)#3) firelizards don't die of age or live a *severely* long time if they don't get injured eaten sick or have a betweening accident#(my personal favorite just because i think it's fun and can be adjusted for ecologically by actually- you know- giving pern some ecology)#if we go with 1 or 3 than the idea of firelizards going back to where they were laid to clutch doesn't make sense#how would they know?#i mean i know how the ones who hatch in the wild know but how do fuckers who hatch in captivity know?#(yes i know it's just there so anne can keep the firelizards a status symbol rather than everyone and their mother having one)#but even with that#the concept pisses me off because *there would already be a fair nesting there*#these aren't sea turtles where they go to tone specific spot to clutch and then live their lives elsewhere#we've seen that firelizards clutch where they live#we've also seen that they live in fairs that seem to only have one gold naturally#and that golds guard their nests#so our theoretical gold would be having to go back to her mother's territory#and bring her fair because somebody needs to help her guard her nest#so she'd have to share her mother's territory while she's nesting#without her and her fair being driven off#i can see it maybe working with greens (it still wouldn't but it'd make more sense than the golds)#but how the fuck is that supposed to work with golds?#it doesn't#why would you even split off at that point and again wild fairs don't seem to have more than one adult gold at a time#fuck they *can't* have more than one adult gold at a time because they'd fucking kill each other the first time one of them Rose#it makes no sense it drives me up the wall it's only there to perpetuate this classist shit i refuse to accept it#sorry let me amend- it's only there to perpetuate this classist shit without any of our noble good guys having to eat firelizard eggs#to keep numbers low
15 notes · View notes