#if miyeon has 4 lines total in a song but it's just 2 lines repeated at a different point in the song. then she only has 2 lines.
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
🫠
i do wish soyeon would shuffle the order in which members sing for the title tracks. they usually change things up a bit on the bsides but i wish she would do it for the songs they actually get to promote. it’s just a little annoying that miyeon is pretty much always just singing part of the chorus (or pre chorus). and i can really only use rv as an example of what i mean bc they’re the only other gg that i stan so i know their songs well enough to remember the orders, but in queendom and fmr each member had a part that wasn’t part of the chorus or singing the same exact line twice. and idle has their own sound right i don’t want that to change i’m not saying they need to change that much but i just wish soyeon would mix it up. and i love her i really do but sometimes it really does feel like ‘soyeon and friends’ when she has a significant part of the first verse, and then a rap (which is usually a significant part of the song as well). tomboy and nxde are pretty similar so based off that it just feels like a bit of a waste to have soyeon singing part of the first verse when there are 2 members who could being singing something other than the chorus. and the places where she would usually put soojin just feel like they’ve just become part of whoever was singing before then (minnie usually, and/or soyeon) yuqi’s been getting an extra line in between minnie and soyeon in the first verse but she also tends to be delegated to just the chorus. even shuhua has had verses outside of the chorus. and truly truly truly this is no shade to any of them, i’m miyeon biased yes but i really do love soyeon so much, i just want some variety in the title track structure. let yuqi open the song! let miyeon do more of those little bits (adlibs?) that are sprinkled throughout songs! put a bridge that’s not just instrumental or non-lexical vocables (yes i looked up the term for it) back in the songs! let her sing something other than the chorus. tomboy and nxde are on the shorter side so make them a little longer to let the vocalists sing!
#sorry#i just#for me it's not about how many lines they have. it's about what lines they have.#if miyeon has 4 lines total in a song but it's just 2 lines repeated at a different point in the song. then she only has 2 lines.#it doesn't matter that i'm hearing her sing at two different points in the song if both points sound exactly the same#and don't get me wrong that amount of lines is important i don't want them to go backwards in terms of line distribution...#i just want some variety in the words that are being sung by a specific member throughout a song#and also none of their songs really flex what miyeon is capable of#and i get it right it's miyeon's voice vs. idle's overall concept#i mean the reason we got you were my breath is bc that person thought her voice didn't have many chances to shine within the group sound#but idle doesn't really have one sound do they#and maze exists!#maze really has it all#/sigh#anyways#i love (g)i-dle regardless of my personal miyeon biased grievences#and i really love nxde#i think i like it more than tomboy gyhjkghj#just wish it was a little longer
8 notes
·
View notes