#i'm so sorry i keep posting starter calls i have NO impulse control
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
shadowedresolve Ā· 11 months ago
Text
Tumblr media
And while I work on other replies, like this post for an Ann starter! I have a lot of muse for her right now so I want to take advantage of it while I can <33
6 notes Ā· View notes
thinkingisadangerouspastime Ā· 4 years ago
Note
(pt 1) i really enjoy all your atla analyses & you've done a great job breaking down the usual arguments re how eip shows that kataang shouldn't have happened. i'm curious about your take on one specific argument that i just saw today, in an analysis of the show by a zker that was otherwise quite good and respectful (i know you've already talked about eip a lot, so no problem if you don't feel like rehashing). the premise: aang didn't just pressure katara in eip, he threatened her.
(pt 2) they point to when katara joins aang & asks if heā€™s alright: ā€œaang: no, iā€™m not! i hate this play! katara: i know itā€™s upsetting, but it sounds like youā€™re overreacting. aang: overreacting? if i hadnā€™t blocked my chakra, iā€™d probably be in the avatar state right now!ā€ the suggestion is heā€™s threatening her when he says ā€˜iā€™d probably be in the avatar state right nowā€™ to describe his anger. i think this take exaggerates and oversimplifies it, but interested in your thoughts on it.
Hello my friend!! It is true I am Old inside and donā€™t like rehashing dhdlksjslks BUT your comments on my posts are always incredibly kind and insightful so I am more than willing to do a bit of rehashing for you šŸ„° Besides! Iā€™ve seen this general take before a few times and itā€™s always irked me for the exact reason you point out - it simultaneously exaggerates and oversimplifies the situation (and honestly thatā€™s an impressive duality since itā€™s seemingly contradictory, so hats off to them lmaooo) - and now is as good a time as any to address it. So, for starters, letā€™s go ahead and get the excerpt they love to focus on so much:
Cut to Aang standing alone on a balcony. Katara enters and walks up to him.
Katara: Are you all right?
Aang: [Angered.] No, Iā€™m not! I hate this play! [Yanks his hat off and throws it on the ground.]
Katara: I know itā€™s upsetting, but it sounds like youā€™re overreacting.
Aang: Overreacting? If I hadnā€™t blocked my chakra, Iā€™d probably be in the Avatar State right now!
Hereā€™s the thing about so-called analyses of this excerpt: in a manner extremely convenient to the poster, they never seek to contextualize this moment. (I mean, to do so would deplatform their entire ā€œargumentā€ - perhaps thatā€™s why they avoid performing a full analysis?) So letā€™s avoid that pitfall from the start.
Firstly, below are some links to related posts; Iā€™m going to do my best to summarize the most relevant parts, but for anyone who desires greater detail, I gotchu šŸ˜¤
This post explains why EIP (the play, lol) is imperialist propaganda and is intended to belittle the entire Gaang.
This post explains how Aang never acted ā€œentitledā€ to Kataraā€™s affections, particularly in regard to EIP.
This post breaks down the infamous EIP kiss like Snopes Fact Checker, covering common misconceptions, important perspectives to consider, etc.
Alright. With that out the way, itā€™s time for some context.
Aang and Katara have this conversation on the balcony after watching 95% of ā€œThe Boy in the Iceberg,ā€ a play chock-full of Fire Nation propaganda that demeans the entire Gaang in order to prop up the Fire Nation as superior (hence why the play ends with Ozaiā€™s victory). Here is my general breakdown of Aang and Kataraā€™s treatment in particular from a previous post:
- katara, an indigenous woman, is highly sexualized and portrayed as overly dramatic and tearful, because the fire nation objectifies women not of their own people and views them as less intelligent and less emotionally stable
- aang, the avatar, the sole survivor of the fire nationā€™s genocide of the air nomads who is incredibly in-touch with his spirituality and femininity, is portrayed as an overly-airy and immature woman. the fire nation portrays him with a female actor to demean him (like, thatā€™s classic imperialistic propagandist tactics) and furthermore writing his character as a childish airhead reinforces the fire nation sentiment that the air nomads were weak, foolish people who did not deserve to exist in their world
In other words, these kids have just watched almost an entire play that preys upon their insecurities and depicts them using racist and sexist stereotypes about their respective nations. It is completely understandable that tensions might run a little high and that their interactions would not be as balanced as usual (Katara and Aang have a great track record of communicating well with each other, as it happens!).
So we have to keep that in mind when examining the aforementioned excerpt. But there are other factors to consider, too! Namely: they are kids. Children. Teens. Aang is 12, Katara is 14.
If we want to be scientific, a personā€™s brain doesnā€™t finish developing until they are 25, lmao, and the preteen/teen years are when the prefrontal cortex that controls ā€œrationality,ā€ ā€œjudgement,ā€ ā€œforethought,ā€ etc. is still developing. This doesnā€™t mean Aang and Katara are irrational and make poor decisions 24/7 (obviously not), but it does mean that in an intense, highly emotional situation, like after watching a play that intentionally demeans them and depicts them as inferior, they are more likely to overreact, more likely to be emotional, and more likely to make mistakes. Like, Iā€™m serious, lol. ā€œTeens process information with the amygdala.ā€ Thatā€™s part of the brain that helps control emotions! Itā€™s why teens sometimes struggle to articulate what weā€™re thinking, especially in situations that require instinct/impulse and quick decisions, because weā€™re really feeling whenever we make those choices. Acting more on emotion. Our brains simply havenā€™t finished developing the decision-making parts, lmao.
In sum: Aang and Katara are both kids, not adults, and should be interpreted as such. This doesnā€™t negate their intelligence, because they are both incredibly smart and Aang is arguably the wisest of the Gaang, but they are human. Young humans. They have emotions, and we should not be so cruel as to assume theyā€™d never act on them.
So taking that all together, we can now acknowledge the high stress Aang and Katara are under, understand why they might be upset (*cough* imperialist propaganda is hurtful *cough*), and examine how their youth might play into their emotional reactions. And funny thing - all analyses that come to the conclusion of Aang ā€œthreateningā€ Katara here do not usually bother with this context. I canā€™t imagine why!
And you know what, letā€™s add one more piece of context: Sokka states that Aang left the theater ā€œlike, ten minutes ago,ā€ which is what cues Katara to go look for him on the balcony. The reason I mention this line is because to me, it suggests Aang knew he was more worked up than usual! He chose to separate himself from his friends so he could process his frustration! He did not take his anger at the play out on them; instead, he purposefully took time and space to be alone.
With that in mind, I donā€™t understand at all how Aangā€™s Avatar state quote could be interpreted as a threat? Canonly, Aang is someone who was aware enough of his frustration to separate himself from the others - yet the logical next step is him threatening Katara as a result? He knew his intense emotions were because of the play (which he says himself), so the logical conclusion is that he then pinned the fault on Katara? What?? Sorry, that interpretation has no textual basis, lmao. But I digress!
Aang tells Katara, ā€œIf I hadnā€™t blocked my chakra, Iā€™d probably be in the Avatar State right now!ā€ As you said, this is the line people point to in an attempt to justify their (baseless) conclusion that Aang is ā€œthreateningā€ Katara. So letā€™s bring in the two key pieces of context: imperialist propaganda and age. Given that Aang is 12, and given that Aang has just watched almost a full play that demeans him and everything his people stood for (and letā€™s not forget it also mocks his and Kataraā€™s love for each other)ā€¦
His reaction is understandable. An exaggeration and needlessly dramatic, but understandable. He feels vulnerable and insecure and Aang is human. He is human and flawed and he overreacts here and I love that A:TLA shows how even our heroes, even people who are truly good at heart and in soul, can get overly upset (especially given the aforementioned circumstances!). Would Aang actually be in the Avatar state at that moment, had it been possible? Of course not! Heā€™s young and heā€™s hurt and as such he says something dramatic to convey his anxieties and frustrations. The line is not meant to be taken literally, and seeing people do so despite all the factors that should be taken into consideration when analyzing itā€¦ Cue a long, tired sigh from me and so many other A:TLA fans.
And to be honest? I cannot fathom how people watch this episode and come to the conclusion that Aang is ā€œthreateningā€ Katara. To me, this episode - besides being a recap episode - is one that humanizes our cast even further. Aang snaps at Katara, kisses her when he shouldnā€™t (which the story appropriately treats as wrong). Katara pushes down her true feelings and retreats into herself, afraid to start a relationship with the boy she loves because sheā€™s already lost him once before and canā€™t bear to do so again. Zuko further confronts the hurt heā€™s enacted upon others, especially upon Iroh. Toph practices being vulnerable and accepting vulnerability from others by conversing with Zuko. Sokka witnesses how others have erased his contributions and labelled him as nothing more than the token nonbender in the group. Even Suki learns that she is not the only person who holds a place in Sokkaā€™s heart and that she can never replace what he has lost.
To watch this episode where our heroes must come to terms with how the Fire Nation deems them inherently inferior, with how they have more fights to overcome in the future with the Fire Nation than a single war, and to come to the conclusion thatā€¦ that what, Aang is abusive? A monster? Irredeemable? That he would threaten his best friend, someone he loves in every way?
Wow. That says more than enough about the viewer, doesnā€™t it?
112 notes Ā· View notes