#i think the marital discontent and burnout and 'holy fuck i'm exhausted' of it all is much more realistic
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Note
One of the biggest book crimes is Harry naming his son "Albus Severus". I feel like the Marauders were done so dirty and it makes no sense to me. I hope you right this wrong in Lionheart!
I've never seen any fandom come together so unanimously to reject a writing decision with the same vehemence that they have Albus Severus (save, like, the ending of Game of Thrones). Everyone looked at it and went "weird, no thank you." Beautiful moment of unity for the fandom.
It might be realistic for the first generation after a major war, but naming all the kids after their grandparents seemed cliché to me. Rose and Hugo and Scorpius were much better, and seemed more like real names that you might pick out because you liked them. Harry doing that to honor his parents specifically because they never got to have normal and long lives is a nice gesture, but it's then weird to use the name "Albus," who lived a very long and successful life, tragic as it was. (I've sometimes tossed around the idea that Harry gives Albus II that name because he wants one of his kids to have a proper "wizarding" name, i.e. something that ties them unimpeachably to the wizarding world, rather than the muggle names given to James II and Lily II — almost an effort to cement his family as being Magic.)
But I was never going to be the right audience for the Potterlets, anyway. I'm not a fan of timeskip epilogues — they work when it's a short jump, but years (or decades) stretches it too far. Either the characters feel like strangers, or they feel the same, which is almost weirder. Which is why I've been on EWE copium since I read the books.
#greenteacup asks#one of the precious few things that the cursed child gets *right* imo#is that the epilogue is a fantastically improbable projection of what life would be like 17 years after the war#specifically everyone being business-as-usual at king's cross#i think the marital discontent and burnout and 'holy fuck i'm exhausted' of it all is much more realistic#which you could say. is not a fun ending for a fantasy epic#and you'd be RIGHT! which is a great reason not to end your fantasy epic SEVENTEEN YEARS after the climax#unless you want to actually flesh out what happens in those seventeen years!
23 notes
·
View notes