#i am once again mad at the concept of 'mulan-ing it'
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
"This historical figure who was born as a woman and lived the rest of her life as a man isnt transgender and shes not a man she was an oppressed woman who pretended to be a man in order to pursue her dreams under intense patriarchy" listen i understand what the line of logic here is and i know that applying modern labels to figures who lived and died before these words and concepts were invented or popularized is a dangerous game but if this dude not only lived his life as a man but insisted that he be referred to as a man and went off on people who misgendered him and had an entire love life where all of his lovers would also refer to him as a man and was adamant that his body not be examined postmortem as so not to be retroactively defined by his genitals and wished to still be recognized as a man after his death i feel like at the very least you could respect his wishes to be referred to and seen as a man and leave the 'born female' thing to be an interesting tidbit at most instead of the fact about him you parade around
#spitblaze says things#i am once again mad at the concept of 'mulan-ing it'#not because nobody who ever did that was cis#but because people assume everyone who did it WAS cis and wouldve been the womanest woman to ever woman if they didnt have to#which if im going to be honest i do not think most of the women who crossdressed to join the military wouldve been high femme so.#anyway whether or not they were trans is unknowable but if they WANTED to be known as a man you should probably just refer to them as one#instead of erasing proof that people like us have existed historically in favor of your cultural feminist narratives#transphobia tw#yes the stupid guardian article abt dr. james barry crossed my dash again lmao
108 notes
·
View notes