#but also they do a very very bad job of showing us why Gridania's issues cant be like. dealt with.
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Ok also it's something that I've been thinking about and I think something that would have helped Gridania a lot is a rival faction. Like Ul'dah, you instantly have two factions that function pretty effective as good guys and bad guys. Limsa is less clear cut, but its made clear that while the Admiral is the leader, there's a bunch of pirate crews and trying to get them all to work together is like herding cats, because they all have their own priorities and rivalries and such. Gridania has...Kan-E-Senna, who's the boss, and then....nothing. Nobody for her to play off, nobody for us to contrast her against and go "oh, so this is what she's dealing with and why she can't just solve every issue." Like if there was some kinda powerful, entrenched Hearer community that was opposing her, or a faction propping someone else up as Elder Seedseer, or just any kind of force that makes us go "oh no! we're in your corner, Kan-E-Senna!" instead she's just the figurehead for a system where Bad Things Happen- and unlike everywhere else, where we can point to causes or reasons why solutions wouldn't work so easily, the takeaway from most of Gridania's issues has to be "Kan-E-Senna is just bad at doing her job."
#ffxiv#like I guess. I like the Elementals in theory and I think making them evil makes for a more boring story#but also they do a very very bad job of showing us why Gridania's issues cant be like. dealt with.#Like if the primary issue is prejudice against Duskwrights and Mooncats and Ixal and stuff leading to a negative spiral#of 'marginalized group needs resources' to 'elementals get angry that they're overstepping the treaties' to 'gridanians treat them worse'#then maybe like. address that.#and I just think if we had a face for more conservative gridanians#to say 'we should just drive those people out of the black shroud! the elementals will it!"#then we could have Kan-E trying to argue against them and find a more peaceful solution for everyone#and go 'oh! she sees the issues in her community and she's trying!'
10 notes
·
View notes