#both benjamin byron davis and curzon dobell said that hosea is dutch's enabler as much as his deterrent

[oldstormyy]

rdr2 fans need to accept the fact that hosea is a flawed character whose morality is just as complex as dutch or arthur's. he's got you all fooled. the bank job was entirely hosea's idea from start to finish. he was excited by it as he's excited by danger every time you're out doing something with him, from the bear hunt (which is his idea + he explicitly prefers the most dangerous approach to said idea) to the braithwaites-grays scheme. in ch4 he hypes up the tahiti/paradise "plan" just as much as dutch (he does so to arthur, to pearson, in speeches at least twice) but you all are too busy projecting the stereotype of the ~old wise father on him to see that. if hosea was "always right" he'd be a boring character