#and the answer to dealing with corruption or upset nobles can't singularly be appeasement bcuz look how that turned out
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
I think it was a mistake for s2 of Arcane to gloss over the implications of Amara and the Black Rose's deception in Mel's story because it fundamentally unmoors her perspective. Mel believed that violence like war could be avoided through diplomacy, and she applies that philosophy by maintaining the complex political environment in Piltover where every house is in some way content.
In the face of the nobility's discontent with Jayce's anti-corruption measures, Mel sought to appease them to stave off retaliation. Through her lesson to Jayce, Mell didn't just help potentially enrich her colleagues but also the woman and by extension the organization that KILLED HER BROTHER AND STOLE HER FAMILY'S ASSETS.
Can you imagine the horror and disgust she would feel at having trusted Piltover to be different? Mel thought she understood the game but she wildly underestimated the machinations of the nobility in Piltover. Mel accepted Piltover's corruption as a means to avoid violent conflict, only to indirectly enable the recent violence harped upon her own family. And the worst irony is that even though politics and corruption have largely been viewed as a cynicism game, for Mel this was an avenue she genuinely believed conflict could be avoided but in fact it was just more insidious.
The opera scene was a lesson for Jayce in politics, but the effects should be the real education for Mel as she heads to Noxus. From what I can tell Noxus is in its pre-Trifarix but post-First Invasion of Ionia, which means Swain has his demon powers but he hasn't overthrown the emperor yet. She will probably ally with him as they're both opporpsed to the Black Rose's existence, however once he's in power he will alienate a large portion of the nobility as they root out the Black Rose's influence.
The challenge for Mel (possibly as Guile) is to deal with these disgruntled nobles because as Piltover proved, you can appease them through corruption all you want, but once their ideology is truly set against you, diplomacy becomes a far more complicated balancing act.
#arcane#mel medarda#arcane meta#league of legends#lol#we can talk about how Piltover's political system is predicated on violence til the cows come home#as well as how Mel's traumatic experiences impacted her persoective to see piltover as preferable to noxus#but like i said before it's all more insidious than she understood#and the answer to dealing with corruption or upset nobles can't singularly be appeasement bcuz look how that turned out#obviously accruing political capital to do ANYTHING is complicated but the situation calls for a shrewder eye#it really was a missed opportunity for mel to understand what she's up against and indirectly enabled#bcuz now she's going to noxus and her family is financially worse off and she really doesn't know the SCOPE of things
163 notes
·
View notes