#and she tells amity about her dad dying. but the whole time she's minimizing her own pain and saying it's not a big deal
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Note
yeah, i feel like the above comment gets to the root of the issue a little more directly than the original post
cuz sometimes a conversation/conflict in fiction doesn't NEED to be drawn out very long and doesn't need to be full intensity. sometimes it should just be a one-chapter storyline. sometimes it makes more sense with the narrative and characterization to have the characters just communicate healthily and adding unnecessary miscommunication and drama just for the sake of "interesting" ends up being ooc and irritating to the reader
but as the above commenter said, rushing through the conflict and forcing a resolution at the expense of both characterization and narrative pacing is bad as well.
in both cases, you need to let the narrative move at its own natural pace and let the characters' voices and personalities shine through
https://at.tumblr.com/luimnigh/694651481588105216/byylgx19hiad
I seen at least one other post talking about stuff like this and i really don't get what exactly is the problem with it. You would think characters actually listening to each other would be a good thing. (I don't know if the post is a joke or not but i really don't know how to put the concept into words so link it anyway)
It's the good thing to do in real life, but good communication where you immediately solve the issues you have with other people and their behaviour doesn't make for good stories. These problems exist to be problems, and to take effort to solve, and the criticism being made is that they're being solved effortlessly.
You wouldn't want to see the adventures of a superhero who tells the villain what they're doing is morally wrong, and the villain immediately agrees, halts their plan, and apologizes.
#relatedly: i recently rewatched reaching out and that episode is SUCH a good example of how to write healthy communication WELL#the writers know their own characters and knew the story they wanted to tell and how big of A Thing they wanted the conflict to be#like. both the cause of the conflict and the resolution are very in character#it starts because luz is avoiding talking about her problems and tries to use helping amity as a distraction but just causes more problems#this is something that we've seen her do REPEATEDLY throughout the show especially in season 2#and amity is initially concerned bc she sees that luz is definitely avoiding something#but she doesn't force luz to talk. part bc she's busy w her own issues part bc she canonically strongly respects privacy#and then when luz's actions cause issues for amity she is understandably upset bc this day was important to her and bc she values honesty#and then she tells luz bluntly why she's upset and asks for an explanation which luz doesn't give#and amity isn't all ''come on let's handle this right now''. she instead physically runs away#which. she has physically run away in multiple previous episodes when she's been hurt or overwhelmed#and luz follows her and finds her at their tree and i was like ''jesus fucking christ they better not break up''#not for 'oh nooo my ship' reasons but for 'their relationship's vibe thus far has been healthy and low-drama. that would be shit writing.'#and then amity yet again opens up about why she is upset in more detail and in a more calm manner and then asks luz again to open up#which fits well with amity's development. like in s1 she would have gotten defensive or freaked out and refused to show how she was hurt#but it is very fitting for s2 amity after all her character development#and luz reluctantly opens up. not so much for her own sake but because she feels like she owes an explanation#and she tells amity about her dad dying. but the whole time she's minimizing her own pain and saying it's not a big deal#and amity doesn't suddenly become some well-spoken grief counselor.#she sits there in stunned silence before stammering out that that the two of them should go pick some flowers in honor of him#it's not the voice of a therapist. it's the voice of a teenaged girl who has been through a lot of growth and loves her gf so much
793 notes
·
View notes