#I can’t believe this was before jodio!

[crashdevlin]

Secret

Author’s Note: This is part one of my second card for @spnskinnyballs‘s 500 Follower Challenge. The prompts for this were Jody and ‘What are you wearing?’ 

Summary: Y/n is missing her girlfriend because she doesn’t get out to Sioux Falls very often.

Pairing: Jody Mills x Reader

Word Count: 1643

Story Warnings: Biting kink, exhibitionism, femslash 18+ HERE BE SEX, DON’T READ IF YOU’RE A YOUNG’UN!!!

The phone rang twice before she picked up. “Mills.”

“Hey, baby.”

“Hey, y/n.” You could hear her smile and you loved it. “You're calling? You always text.”

“You know, I don't like how my voice sounds through the phone but I love hearing yours, so I decided to suck it up.” She chuckled and you could imagine the skin on her neck turning ever-so-slightly pink like it always did when you complimented her. “So… what are you wearing?”

Now you imagined her rolling her eyes at you. “My uniform. I'm at work.”

“I love you in your uniform, Jodio.”

“You aren't Donna. Don't call me ‘Jodio’. Did you call for a reason or are you just bored and trying to get a rise out of me?”

“Baby, if I'm calling ‘cause I'm bored, it's not to get a rise out of you. It's because I'm lonely and I miss you.”

You could hear a car door shut and knew she'd climbed into her truck to talk to you in private. “You're lonely, huh?” Her voice had taken on that husky quality that she usually left to the bedroom and it sent a thrill straight to your core.

“Uh-huh. Haven't seen my girlfriend in a few weeks ‘cause she won't let me tell my best friends and travelling companions about us, and we don't find a lot of time to just hang out in Sioux Falls.”

She sighed and you heard the engine of her truck rumble to life. “Oh, this is one of those conversations, then?”

“Yes, it's one of those conversations. I just don't understand why it's okay for your girls to know, but we can't tell my boys.”

“Because it was good for Claire to know, y/n. It was good for her to see that there wasn't a problem with it. Can you imagine how those guys would react?”

“Yes, I can, because I'm with them all the time and they know I'm bi, Jo. They watch me every time we go into a bar to see if I'm gonna try to pick up the same quality of roadhouse pussy they do and every time I go back to the motel alone, they make backhanded comments about how they think I'm lying about my own sexuality because they've never seen me with a woman before. I’m sure you don’t understand what that kind of erasure feels like, ‘cause you’re still half in the closet, but it hurts. More than they think and more than you know. I have endured that pain, and I will continue to endure, for you because I love you. But these conversations aren’t gonna stop just ‘cause you don’t like ‘em.” A familiar rumble outside caught your attention. “Hey, I gotta go. Talk to you later. Bye, Jody.”

You bit your lip and waited for the door to open. Jody appeared in the doorway of the Sioux Falls Sheriff’s Department, completely bundled against the South Dakota winter. Your teeth pressed into your bottom lip harder as you watched her unbundle, taking off her beanie, coat and gloves. She really was gorgeous, and you were so damn lucky.

You smirked and moved to lean against her office doorjamb. “Hey, Sheriff. Is this where I report a stolen heart?”

Bright hazel orbs jumped to your face and she gasped, dropping her gloves on her deputy’s desk and rushing for you. “You’re here?!” She exclaimed, ignoring your cheesy line as she wrapped cold fingers around the back of your neck and pulled you into a kiss.You moaned as she bit your lip and tugged it with her teeth.

You wrapped your hands around her wrists and pulled back. “The guys are here, too. They’re in the break room raiding your vending machines.” You whispered.

“So, we got a few minutes, then.” She said, smirking as she pushed you into her office and kicked the door closed. As soon as she had you on the edge of her desk, she pulled the collar of your V-neck thermal out of the way and started to lick and suck at your neck and shoulder. Her teeth came down hard on your shoulder and you moaned, loudly, as wetness dripped out of you.

Your eyes rolled back and closed as she continued to scrape her teeth at the bite and she slipped her a right hand into the front of your jeans to rub at your clit through your soaked panties. “Oh, god, Jo.” You whined. Jody just bit you again and increased the pressure on your clit. When you opened your eyes, Sam and Dean were standing at the door, arms laden down with snacks and eyes wide. “Jody. Sam and Dean, they’re-”

“Let ‘em watch.” She whispered in your ear. “They might learn somethin’.”

Now, exhibitionism was not usually your thing, and you didn’t really want the Winchesters to know what your ‘O’ face looked like, but with Jody’s voice in your ear, her fingers working you hard, her teeth digging into your earlobe, you didn’t really have a chance against the climax that crashed over you.

She smiled and licked her fingers before waving at the guys to enter. “See somethin’ you like, boys?” She asked, leaning against her desk next to you.

Dean smirked, dropping his snacks on Jody’s desk and turning to Sam. “Yup. Ten bucks, in my palm right now, Sam.” Sam rolled his eyes as he pulled out his wallet.

“Why is money being exchanged?” You asked.

“I told Sammy you had a secret girlfriend in Sioux Falls. He didn’t believe me.”

“You thought it was Claire!” Sam argued, but he still handed the money over.

“Doesn’t matter. Bet was that y/n had a secret Sapphic relationship in Sioux Falls, which she did.”

“Ew! Claire is jailbait.”

“Not technically.” Sam and Dean said, together.

“Still way too young for anyone in this room to even consider sexually.” Jody said in her very best Mom voice.

“Oh, yeah, totally.” Dean agreed. “‘sides, she’s a brat. But she digs chicks, y/n digs chicks, you never said you did, so I thought she was keepin’ it secret ‘cause Claire’s so young.”

You shrugged. It made an amount of sense. “You know, I’m surprised you know the word ‘Sapphic’, Dean.”

He scoffed and smirked. “You kiddin’ me? The amount of pornography I consume? Course I know that word, as well as a few other choice words for what just went down.”

“So, uh, how’d this start?” Sam asked, gesturing between you and Jody, who took your hand in hers. You smiled down at your fingers entwining with hers.

“Remember, uh, couple years ago, when Amara tried to eat me and I ended up bedridden with depression?” You bit your lip. Having your soul ripped from your body and almost eaten by God’s sister had taken a toll on your will to live. “Jo got me through it.”

Jody brought your hands up to her lips and kissed the back of your hand. “She got herself through it. I just didn't let her give up.” She squeezed your hand and gave it another kiss, before turning her attention back to Sam and Dean. “Anyway, she fell asleep in my arms watching Dirty Dancing and I knew that I wanted that to happen again, as many times as I could get it to happen.”

“And when did it, uh, get fun?” Dean asked, a suggestive twitch to his eyebrows.

You looked to Jody, not sure if she wanted to answer such an invasive question. She chuckled. “Soon as I came to grips with the fact that I wanted it to get fun.”

Dean seemed satisfied with that answer, nodding. “Okay, so… now that we know about y’all, no more lying and making excuses to come to South Da-fuckin’-kota, right? From now on, just say ‘I miss my girlfriend and I wanna go get laid’ and you can borrow one of the Letters’ cars. Okay?”

You nodded. You pressed your lips to Jody’s cheek. “How long ‘til you can take me home, baby?”

“I’m on call ‘til 3am, but I can do a patrol over near the house, take lunch.” Her tone was suggestive and it made you bite your lip.

“It’s gonna need to be a long lunch. This one’s been sexually frustrated for weeks.” Dean chuckled.

“Thank you so much, dude. Jerk.”

“Just callin’ it how I see it.” Dean picked up his snacks and ripped open a Snickers bar with his teeth. “Come on, Sam. Let’s let the ladies have their together time.”

Sam shook his head as Dean walked out. “I’m happy for you. You deserve it.” He smiled and followed his brother out of the office.

You turned to Jody with a smile and squeezed her hand. “Why’d you do that? You didn’t want them to know.”

“But you did.” She pulled her hand from yours and turned flush with you, fingers moving to curl around your hips. “The only pain I want you to endure for me, honey, is the good kind.” She leaned forward and scraped her teeth against your neck. You let out a breathy moan and wrapped your arms around her. “Come on. Take me to lunch.” You pressed your lips to hers and grabbed your coats, before following her out to her truck.

“The girls in?” You asked, sliding as close to her as you could.

She smirked. “Nope. Some music festival in Colorado. I can make you scream as loud as I want.”

You shuddered at the thought. “I know you’re supposed to uphold the law, baby, but maybe lean on that pedal a bit.” You requested before leaning back to bask in your current situation.

“Patience.” She scolded, but you noticed a definite increase in the truck’s velocity.

Hunters- @mrswhozeewhatsis, @adoptdontshoppets, @letsby, @spnskinnyballs

Everything tags- @heyitscam99