#in the 7th division therefore the implication is they fought in ww2... guys i get why the implication is uncomfy as hell
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
A particular painpoint for me aside from what I commented in the tags of the og post is Siraishi both not saying goodbye and getting the gold. I think getting the gold was on brand with him and the final wink to fulfilling Boutarous' wishes is cute. However he does not get a dream of his own so to speak. On the other hand, he doesn't properly say goodbye to Sugimoto and Asirpa because he's not one for goodbyes or whatever. I see where this is coming from, this is all good old Siraishi, nevertheless I do think doing both things kind of fumbles his arc and growth which is a shame because his character growth was one of the things that had me most impressed in the latter half of the manga
Oh ok. I get now why a lot of people didn't vibe with the ending.
All and all: excellent manga, overall very good final act, too rushed final 2-3 chapters but weak and honestly mediocre epilogue, which makes the high of the ending kind of leave a bitter taste. I think Noda had a good steed and suddenly he had to finish and had to rush all. So the ending in the sense of the final arc was good but the ending proper (final couple chapters) + epilogue......... Not so much
#either say goodbye or get the gold. both of them is like 'ok you didn't grow at all did you π€¦ββοΈ' which i get!! but it also kinda makes#me sad. though come think of it i get why he didn't say goodbye#with the final letter and all. i also think it's not fair that none of the hijitaka guys get any of the gold at all#nagakura i get that but the other guys could have used a bit of gold kinda like the dust that sugimoto gave ume#headcanon that siraishi got out the gold with their help lmao. i want a whole anthology with all the 'but#that is a story for another time' bits that noda throws in#I've also seen ppl on reddit feeling uncomfortable/unhappy about koito and tsukishima because they remain#in the 7th division therefore the implication is they fought in ww2... guys i get why the implication is uncomfy as hell#but be serious. none of them were uncomfortable AT ALL with the entirely imperialistic project that tsurumi proposed#in fact they were entirely on biard with it all (tsukishima in particular imo given how he reacted to the possibility that tsurumi was doing#all for simple grief and vengeance and how absolutely relieved tsukishima was aftear hearing it was not the case. he put his faith back in#the man and stronger than ever). also some ppl commented on how tsukishima basically doesn't grow because he goes from following tsurumi to#to following koito and i see the point but listen. that's just how he is. choosing to follow koito who has never lied to him and is a person#with whom he has formed an entirely genuinely personal connection is absolutely on brand with him and koito taking the lead does show his#own growth. (btw i never commented on it but i really like his relationship to his dad too)#laura reads#golden kamuy
9 notes
Β·
View notes